Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 5, Lesson 3Sefer Even ShelemaPart 86Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:59Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:05Okay, Even Shelema, perek hei, ot bet. Hamarbim la'asot mitzvot ve'einam shetulim al palgei mei haYirah vehaTorah, alehem ne'emar, lama li rov zivcheichem. Very,0:09very strong statement. Let me translate slowly, and you'll see how strong this statement is.0:18It says like this: People who do a lot of mitzvot, but they're not rooted into Torah and Yirat0:24Shamayim, regarding them the pasuk says in Yeshayahu, What do I need all your many korbanot?0:33That's a lot of— that's a very strong statement. So now, just to give you a little background of that pasuk,0:39the pasuk is in Sefer Yeshayahu, perek rishon, which we read on Shabbat0:46Chazon, Chazon Yeshayahu ben Amoz, right? So over there, the pasuk, the simple meaning of the pasuk was talking about when the Jewish people used to come to the Beit HaMikdash0:53and bring korbanot in the times of Yeshayahu, which is in the times of the first Beit HaMikdash,0:59and when they brought the korbanot, they were sinning anyway.1:03They were doing all these different things. They were stealing from people.1:06They were twisting the law, taking advantage of the weak.1:10They were doing all different types of aveirot, and then they would come and bring a korban.1:14So Hashem says, Lama li rov zivcheichem, right? What do I need all your1:18zevachim? You think you can do whatever you want and just bring me a korban?1:20Ah, make Him happy, you know, give Him a korban, so I don't need it.1:24The Gra is using or applying that pasuk to people who do mitzvot, even though they do a lot of1:30mitzvot, but they're not rooted on the riverbanks of the Torah and Yirat1:37Shamayim, and therefore he says this will apply to them. That's a strong, strong statement.1:42Look on the bottom over here in Ha'arot u'Biurim. He brings something very interesting.1:49He says, u'mistabra, right? This is the ha'ara of the Eben Shelema himself,1:55which is the author of the one who compiled all this together,1:58not from the Gra; this is from himself. He says,2:01why would Hashem not want—at the end of the day, the Chaim are doing a mitzvah. Why not?2:05They're doing a mitzvah. What's so bad about it, right?2:07Why would Hashem not want it?2:08He says, hainu dafka mitzvot she'ein bahem kol2:12kach chiyuv la'asotam kegon mata korbanot. We're talking about not mitzvot that they have to do.2:13If it's a Rasha, he says, you know, I'm not keeping Shabbat anymore. Why?2:16The Gra said, I'm not in Torah. I'm not going to keep Shabbat.2:19I'm not going to do this. He says, no.2:21We're talking about korbanot and the like,2:24which means these are certain things that you didn't have an obligation to bring,2:30right?2:33Kemo she katuv, lama leiv zivcheichem... daika. V'im lo ken, vechi mi she'achal shum2:37v'rechono, דף יעזוב ויאכל שום, kemo she katuv, zevach resha'im to'eva, daika, right?2:38So we know the famous statement of2:42Chazal: a guy who eats garlic, should eat more garlic,2:43right? A guy's doing2:45an aveirah, you tell him, no, do more2:47aveirot? Oh, you're not in Torah, you can't do any2:49mitzvot? No. We're talking about voluntary2:52mitzvot, voluntary mitzvot, right?2:54And you're not rooted into Torah.2:56On that Hashem says, what do I need all that for?2:58V'shama'ti shepa'am achat nasa Rabbeinu b'derech v'nichnas b'malon, v'haya sham Yisrael3:02pokeid, hechan natal yayin shelaf lishtot bifnei Rabbeinu, v'amar lo Rabbeinu, barech.3:06One time, he says, he's like,3:07I heard one time that the Gra was traveling3:09and he came to an inn,3:11and the owner of the3:13inn—now, excuse3:14me—and in the inn there was another Jew, right,3:17who was off the3:20derech, and he took a,3:22what do you call it,3:24a beer or scotch or whatever it is,3:25or whiskey.3:26He took something called vodka probably in those days,3:29okay, and he wanted to drink.3:30So the Gra sees him, doesn't make a3:35beracha, v'shiblo... he says— Well, what do I need this for?3:36What do I gain by making3:39bracha? Look, כבר פרקתי מעלי עול הדת. I'm off the derech, man.3:41I don't keep anything.3:42I'm a chiloni, as they say.3:47No.3:48Even if you're off the3:48derech, you still have to make a3:50bracha. And if you don't make a3:51bracha, you get punished on it.3:54כי על כל עבירה יקבל עונש בפני עצמו. Every aveirah, you get another3:57punishment. He says, You listen to him,4:00right?4:01And he made the4:03bracha, and eventually the guy was4:05chozer b'teshuva. I, what's it called,4:07I remember hearing the same story about a4:09gadol who passed away a few years ago.4:11It was Moshe Shapiro.4:12So one of his students, Rabbi Mordechai4:15Becher, who, when I was4:17in yeshiva, he used to give a class4:19once a week.4:20He's a very, very big intellectual.4:21He said this story. He was once sitting in the car4:24with, what do you call it,4:25with Rabbi Moshe Shapiro. They took a taxi.4:28So they, you know, you stop a taxi,4:30and all the drivers are Jewish,4:32so they stop a taxi, they're driving.4:35They come to a red light, like it just turned red.4:38All of a sudden the guy puts his car4:39in park.4:40He says, I'm going to run out and get a falafel, please.4:43Okay, if somebody comes, you know,4:45just tell them to wait for me to go.4:47What? You know,4:48he rode the taxi. The guy says,4:50One second, running to get a falafel, okay?4:52Listen, you know, these guys, they got to figure it out.4:55He runs inside, he comes back in like three4:56minutes, you know, with a falafel sandwich,4:58boiling hot. You can smell it in the car.5:00It's all boiling hot, okay?5:02So finally he drives.5:04The guy takes it out, and he's like5:06smelling, he's waiting for the next red light.5:08Next red light comes, he takes the thing out of the bag,5:11he takes it out, and ah,5:12the aroma. He's waiting, like5:14this, it's so juicy. He's about to take a5:16bite into it, and Rabbi Moshe Shapiro,5:18I mean Rabbi Moshe Shapiro,5:20alav hashalom, was a man with a long beard. I met him personally.5:22He had like a5:24stature. You looked at him, you know, Rosh5:26Yeshiva, big talmid chacham. But he had a look, you know,5:28like it could be a scary look.5:30He tells him,5:33מה אתה עושה? אני רוצה לאכול, I want to eat.5:35I mean, change5:37the thing, it's nice and Hebrew, change the thing because it's like,5:43מילתא דלא ידעים. So no, אני לא דתי. מה זה אתה לא דתי? חייבים לברך ונטילת ידיים, אסור לך לאכול. Must be5:45the guy was so5:47dati. The guy just put it down.5:49He went back to driving.5:51The whole way, keeps on looking5:54at it,5:54looks at the driver, nothing, no budging.5:58He didn't eat the sandwich.6:00What do you mean, אני לא דתי? You still have to make6:02a bracha, okay? Dati or not, call yourself religious or not, or dati, call yourself6:05whatever you like.6:06At the end of the day, you're a Jew,6:07you have to do a beracha. So what do you mean when it6:11says, למה לי רוב זבחיכם? No, voluntary things.6:13Things are voluntary,6:14you're not chayuv doing it,6:15like a korban. Now, korban,6:17you didn't have to bring,6:19so Hashem says, what, you don't need to bring it.6:20So those kind of mitzvot is what we're talking about.6:22That's a point that you have to make6:24out. Let's come back and see the words of the Gra inside.6:26The words of the Gra, guess where they come from?6:28From that same pasuk in6:32Yeshayahu. Right? He says,6:41הדרך מה שכתוב, המתפלל וטעה, פלא שנית תפילת נדבה. אבל אם יכול לכוון גם בתורת חובה, אך למותר. Okay, this is the same6:43halacha, Shulchan Aruch, Berachot also.6:44And we know6:47when you pray the Amidah,6:48you're supposed to have kavanah, minimum,6:50minimum, minimum, minimum6:53— I'm going with the more in the shita — the first6:54beracha, minimum.6:55What happens if a guy prays Amidah6:57and he gets up to מחיה המתים, he realizes, hey, I wasn't6:59mechaven by the first7:01beracha. I was completely spaced out.7:03What should he do?7:04So the halacha should be that you should pray another one,7:07right? And the second one7:08should be that — I can say you should do that7:09— but if you can't be7:11mechaven, right, then there's no point.7:13Don't bother.7:15And that's a psak Shulchan Aruch.7:17Says, אנחנו לא מכוון. We don't want you to pray a second Amidah7:19because we're scared you're not going to be7:21mechaven the second one also is going to be a problem,7:23right? And if you're not mechaven, it's really what's the point of it?7:29ואמר כאן עולות חלב ודם. And the pasuk says over here,7:36laminchotzachem, olot, elim, vechelev meriim, vedam parim. And the pasuk specifies7:39the types of things Hashem doesn't want.7:40He doesn't want7:42olot, which is a korban that completely is burnt on the7:45mizbeach. He doesn't want7:46chelev. He doesn't want the dam.7:47He doesn't want the fat of the animal or the blood.7:51Ramaz b'zeh al ha-lomdim shelo al menat la'asot. He's meramez with this7:53on people who learn Torah7:55not for the sake of8:00Keeping the Torah just for the sake of learning.8:04He says, Noach lo shelo נברא. The Gemara says that such a person who learns not to keep the mitzvot, better that he is not created.8:11Why?8:13והם כנגד מקרא, משנה, וגמרא. And these three things correspond to three levels of learning, which we know the three levels of learning, as the Rambam brings down from the Gemara,8:20that the three levels of learning are pesukim, Tanach, Mishnayot, and the analysis of the halachot, which is known as Gemara.8:31Dam,8:34sheha'avodah הראשונה כן לימוד המקרא. Dam is the first step that we do in the korban.8:38We take the blood, we sprinkle it on the mizbeach. That's the first step.8:41That corresponds to pesukim.8:46ולכן אמר אצל דם גמו מנים, פרים כבשים ועתודים. That's why, if you look when it talks about ... it says, What do I need dam, parim,8:54kevasim, ve'atudim? Right?8:56Why did he specify the blood? Just say, I don't want your9:00bloods. Why do you have to say the blood of the sheep, the blood of the goats, and the blood of the cows?9:04And the answer is corresponding to three levels of mikra, of Tanach, which is Torah, Nevi'im, and9:11Ketuvim. And then he says, olah, right?9:15Also olah. What I need the9:18olot zivcheichem. That corresponds to9:20the—first of all, what is olah? Olah is a korban that's completely burnt on9:24mizbeach. That refers to the Mishnah.9:26Why? Because the Mishnah is inclusive of all the halachot.9:29Good? All the halachot are in the Mishnah.9:33Next says9:35chelev. What's chelev? Chelev is the fats of the animal.9:36The chelev, we know,9:39אינו אלא מקצת הקרבן. It's not the whole korban; it's only part of the korban,9:42and yet it's the best.9:46הטוב והשמן. As we know, chelev is used also by other things.9:51Like, for example, when you separate terumah, it says chelev of your produce.9:56There's no fats by produce, but it means the best,9:59good, and that is corresponding to the Gemara,10:02because the Gemara, the best part of learning is the internalization,10:06the thinking and the analyzation of the learning,10:10where you process it and it becomes part of you.10:11Just to read superficial, a lot of people could read.10:15Even to understand simple memorization, people can understand.10:18But to work your mind and to internalize it, that's the best part of learning.10:21In fact, that's a newer study from Harvard.10:23That is the best way of learning critical thinking.10:26It's not how much, you know, most of our schooling is just10:30shoving information into our minds and trying to remember.10:33So if you have a good memory, you're good.10:34If you don't have a good memory, you're gone.10:35But the real learning is processing,10:38and that's why a lot of things that we learn when we're younger,10:39we actually don't remember unless you have a crazy memory.10:42What we do remember is the things that we worked through.10:45That's why you see a difference when you learn a Gemara,10:46when you learn halacha in depth and you understand the reasons,10:50then we just, I'll tell you plain, straightforward facts.10:53So he's telling you that's why the chelev corresponds to the learning of Gemara.10:59And there's a lot of people that learn Gemara,11:03but the purpose of learning Gemara is not why Hashem wants us to learn Gemara,11:05which is why they're learning Gemara,11:07to just show off that they know or to knock other people.11:10That's why Hashem says, Sabati, it's too much.11:14But when pesukim, he says, Lo chafatzti. I don't want it,11:17right?11:18Sabati means it's too much.11:19There's a lot of people doing11:20Gemara. Mikra, they're doing the lashma, it's very little.11:23Very little people are learning11:25Mikra lishma, right?11:25Because you don't get so much kavod for just simple pesukim.11:29But for knowledge,11:31ah, now you get11:32kavod. So a lot of people are doing that.11:33He says, I don't want it.11:34And that's from there. He wanted to point out that what,11:39that these things are giving, that people are giving.11:43Hashem says, I don't want these things.11:44What do you mean,11:44they're not in Torah?11:45I mean, what's it called?11:46He says, no.11:47When you're not learning Torah, you're doing all these11:49korbanot, and you're not founded in Torah,11:50you're not mebusas on Torah,11:52lo rotzeh these things.11:54And again, these are only things that are voluntary,11:57right?