Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 5, Lesson 10Sefer Even ShelemaPart 93Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:009:23Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:03Eben shel mafarekeh, ot tet. This is the last piece in0:07perek hei, and we move on to the next subject, which is a subject that everybody is going to be interested in,0:14and that is the subject of chinuch ha-yeladim, raising children, which is, ah, on everybody's mind,0:20unless you don't have kids, then, and, or you mean to say your kids are already older, then it's not on your mind.0:28Anyway, let's come back to0:34ot tet. Meni'at kiyum mitzvat aseh hu merubeh ma she'adam over al lo ta'aseh. Now we know there's two types of mitzvot.0:37The mitzvot can be broken up basically into two categories.0:39Category number one is mitzvat aseh, where Torah commands you to do something.0:43Category number two is mitzvat lo ta'aseh. Torah warns you, don't do an averah, don't do what we call a mitzvah and0:49averah. Mitzvah is doing it, and averah is staying away, don't do the0:53averah. Good? If you tell somebody, okay, listen, the guy didn't put on tefillin. Did he do an1:00averah? So we call averah, but really, in fact, it's not called averah; it's called meni'at or bitul mitzvat aseh.1:05He didn't do mitzvat aseh. He didn't sit in the sukkah. He didn't shake the lulav.1:10Good? He didn't light menorat Chanukah, which is deRabbanan, but it's a mitzvat aseh1:16deRabbanan. Now, there's lo ta'aseh deOraita, which is, for example, the guy etaref. Torah says don't eat taref; he ate1:22taref, right? Which one would you say is worse, a guy who didn't put on tefillin or a guy who ate1:27taref? You naturally, like the way we saw from the Rambam, is that we know that a guy who doesn't an averah, a lo ta'aseh is worse.1:34He did an averah; he's1:38chayav malkut, therefore he's chayav malkut, right? So look what he says over here, based on the Gra, he says,1:41Meni'at kiyum mitzvat aseh1:45hu merubeh ma she'adam over al lo ta'aseh. He doesn't say which is worse, but look what he says is it's more.1:47Not doing a mitzvat aseh is, it seems like it has more ramifications than a person who transgresses1:58a lo ta'aseh. Kemo she'amru Chazal, like Chazal tell us,2:01What do Chazal tell us? Yashav adam u'vitel mitzvat aseh,2:04over aleha bechol rega. A person who sits and, meaning to say, he has the ability to do a mitzvat aseh2:09and he doesn't do it, he transgresses every moment.2:12Wow. Every moment? Yeah.2:17But by lo ta'aseh, over ela b'sha'at ma'aseh. But think about it, the aveirah, you ate that taref, it's over.2:21Once you've done eating taref, Chazal tell us,2:23if a guy didn't do an aveirah, he did a2:27mitzvah, right? But the aveirah takes—if we never thought about it from this angle,2:31and the Gemara is pointing out something very2:34interesting—there's more involved, or there's more of you involved2:39in the not doing the mitzvat aseh than in the2:42mitzvat lo ta'aseh. Let's come back to our two cases.2:44You're right,2:46in punishment, in Beit Din, they're not going to punish a guy2:50for not doing a mitzvat, not putting on tefillin.2:54They're not going to punish him. Maybe they'll force him to,2:56they'll hit him to force him to,2:58but they're not going to punish him for not putting it on.3:01Let's say it's even one day,3:03and the guy who ate taref, he's going to get malkut.3:05But he's telling you, think about the following idea.3:07Every day the guy doesn't want to put on tefillin,3:09at every moment from the time in the morning3:11that—what time is alot? I think3:146:30, 6:35—so from 6:30 in the morning until 53:18o'clock, which is when shkiah is, the guy is transgressing,3:21or he's over, basically, as Chazal tell us,3:24if you didn't do, you have to—come on, you have to tefillin, tefillin,3:27you're on vacation.3:28No, he doesn't want to do mitzvat tefillin.3:30He's over every moment.3:32Yet you come back to3:36aveirah, at night he wants to go out and eat taref.3:39They bring him the food. He didn't do an aveirah yet.3:42Here comes the food, comes in front of him.3:44He eats the meal. He was over3:46aveirah. How long did it take him?3:47How long does it take to eat3:48talef, a kezayit? It has to be within seven minutes, right?3:51How long does it take?3:52Half an hour he's eating taref, and that's it.3:55The aveirah, the length of the aveirah was only half an hour,3:58where the bitul mitzvat aseh was for close to twelve hours.4:03That's what the4:04Gra is saying. If you think about it, it's much more this way.4:07The guy is really, who's4:09mevatel aseh, he's involved more in the wrong act4:12than the guy who's eating the taref.4:15So look on the bottom over here,4:19where he brings it from.4:20He brings it from the pasuk in4:23Yeshayahu. It's a famous pasuk. It says,4:25Hoy, Yeshayahu says,4:27Woe to4:29moshchei he'avon, the people who pull the sin,4:30b'chavlei ha-shav, with the ropes of nothingness,4:38v'cha'avot ha'agalah chatta'ah. And agalah is a wagon.4:41Wagon also has ropes,4:42but the ropes of the wagon are like4:44a few ropes together. Right?4:47If you look at every rope,4:49it's many small strings that are stranded together.4:52A thick rope,4:54like let's say the ones for the ship4:55or the ones they used to tie the wagon with,4:56it's really a bunch of ropes knotted, you know, twisted together.5:00So that's called a abot,5:02the word thick.5:04Vechabota agalah, and she made sins like the thickness5:09of the wagon's ropes.5:11What does that mean?5:12He says, Moshchei avon5:14hu she'over lo ta'aseh. Moshchei avon is referring,5:16when the pasuk, when Yeshayahu is yelling,5:18he's yelling about two types of people.5:20One who is moshchei avon,5:22the ones who do5:24mitzvat lo ta'aseh, the guy who eats5:25treif, the guy who speaks lashon hara,5:26the guy who's, you know,5:28doing all different types of5:33aveirot. Vechataa she'over mitzvat aseh. That's a person who is transgressing5:36mitzvat aseh, like he's not putting on tefillin,5:38he's not praying,5:39he's not mekayem mitzvat ve'ahavta et Hashem Elokecha.5:43That's that type of guy.5:46VeMuchazal, Chazal tell us something very interesting,5:48says5:54the Gra: Yoshev adam u'vatel mitzvat aseh, over alav bechol shaah. If you're sinning5:55and you have the ability to do5:57mitzvat aseh and you're not doing it,5:58you're over every moment.6:01Vhu shemarbeh lachto. So it comes out that your sins are really much more.6:07Vzehu shekatuv kaabot ha'agalah. And now you can understand when the pasuk says6:09that when it comes to6:13mitzvat aseh, the aveirot are like the ropes of a wagon,6:16which are much thicker6:17than the people who pull with the small rope,6:20right?6:20Because every time you're not doing it,6:22it's like another strand,6:23it's another layer of the6:26rope. It becomes so thick.6:30But by lo ta'aseh, אינו אלא עוון אחד לשעה שעשה. But the mitzvat aseh is only for a moment of time.6:34Another source from Mishlei.6:36Pasuk says,6:38Avonotav yilkeduno et harasha.6:40The sins of the wicked person trap him,6:46uvchavlei chattato yitamech, and with the ropes of his sin6:49he is supported.6:50What does that mean?6:51He says,6:54like we said above,6:56that although we don't give a punishment6:59for people who transgress7:03a mitzvat aseh, ach be'idna d'reitcha, Chazal tell us in the Gemara7:05that when there's a sha'at din,7:07when7:09Hashem—sometimes a sha'at din,7:10like the machloket, the halachos was sha'at din.7:12Sometimes when there's,7:13you know, we have a wave of terror in7:15Eretz Yisrael, that's called sha'at din.7:17In sha'at din, Chazal tell us,7:19however,7:21ma'anishinin gemaseh; in Shamayim they punish even a person7:26who's over on an aseh. V'hainu, k'sheyesh bo aveirot lo7:28ta'aseh uma'anishin lo aveirot. So, pashut pshat, we understand,7:30like the examples we just gave,7:31when there's a sha'at din in the world,7:34that let's say, like we said,7:35there's a wave of terror7:37and there's7:39etzarah l'Yaakov, that's when in Shamayim7:41they punish7:42on aseh. The Gra is telling us something amazing.7:43The Gra is saying,7:44when a person has7:48aveirot, that they're going to start punishing him now7:51on the aveirot, right,7:55as ma'anishin lo gemaseh. Oh, you made7:56it—you know, it's like imagine a guy7:57who has criminal acts.8:00Small things here and there, they don't do anything to you.8:03Yeah, okay, you transgress here and there, you know,8:06they don't. Once you're brought to court for something that they're gonna try you for,8:11for example, you were, you know, shipping fake goods from China,8:16and they realize, oh, you're bringing now things which are not really yours.8:20Now you're in court,8:22they're gonna pull up everything.8:23Now they're gonna say, oh, you pay taxes here.8:26Oh, you have illegal cars.8:28You have illegal gambling in your basement.8:31Whoa, where are all these things coming up from?8:33Because once they caught you on something big, they're gonna bring up everything.8:37And that's the same thing over here also, says the8:39Gra. A guy who has bitel mitzvat aseh, so they're not punishing him in shamayim, right?8:45But they're not punishing him on it because they don't punish.8:48But when they're gonna come to punish him for mitzvat lo8:51ta'aseh, he was mechalel Shabbat, mechalel Shabbat, yalla, right?8:55Send the malach to punish him.8:57But once we're opening up the guy's case, we say, hey,9:01true, he's mechalel Shabbat, but he's also what?9:04He's also not putting on tefillin,9:07and so he gets punished also for the other ones.9:12And now you can understand the pasuk.9:14Pasuk says, da'avonot trap the person9:21to Gehenna, ve'achar kach, bechevlei chatato yitamech. And then what happens?