Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 4, Lesson 9Sefer Even ShelemaPart 64Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:50Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:04Eben Shelema, perek dalet, ot zayin. יש עוונות שבאים באונס ושוגג, ואף על פי כן נענש עליהם. There are sins that come to a person by accident, I guess you call that shogeg, and by ones, even against his will, and still a person is judged on them and is punished on them.0:25Whoa, you're still punished on them? What do you want from the guy? He was ones. Somebody bumped him. He's patur from a korban. There's nothing for him to do.0:34Still he gets judged on him. Listen to this powerful statement. You know why?0:49כי העבירה גוררת עבירה, ואדם מטמא את עצמו מעט, מטמאים אותו מלמעלה. Excuse me. ואדם מטמא עצמו מעט למטה, מטמאים אותו מלמעלה. We don't understand that there's another effect. We always think of aveirot in one effect,0:56that every sin that I do has an effect on me eventually, in Olam HaEmet, where I will be judged or punished on it.1:06And sometimes we know there's certain aveirot that get judged or punished on it in this world.1:12For example, a person eats pig. So what happens when a person eats pig?1:16So you're going to say, Whoa, that's going to be malkut, 39 lashes for a person who eats pig.1:22Oh, without the beit din today, son shamayim, they'll zap you. How will they zap you?1:27I don't know which level of Gehenna, but you're going to get into Gehenna and they're going to burn you to get rid of that bili'ot of the pig from your neshama.1:36Good? Or sometimes, even in this world where we don't have 39 lashes, you will still get some sort of punishment in your parnasa. Right?1:47Where you're gonna have to pay so much food for kosher food, and then all of a sudden it goes to waste because of the food.1:54I don't know, but there's some sort of punishment. We always look at the effect of an aveirah on the punishment.2:01But comes the Ibn Shlama and tells us from the Gra that you only, like, you know, you haven't seen the full picture, really. You're only looking at part of the story.2:09The effects on aveirah are—there's more than that. There's other effects that... Chazal tell us that a person who does one aveirah, you open the door to another2:20aveirah. You allow, or you give yourself a chance for another aveirah. You go to a certain website that you're not supposed to go to.2:27You've now put yourself in a situation where you can link yourself to another site,2:32and that can link you to another thing, and that can link you to another thing, right?2:36The worldwide web has taught us that lesson,2:43that aveirah גוררת עבירה, מצווה גוררת מצווה. What kind of advertisements would you see on certain websites? Well, it depends what the website is.2:49There are certain websites where you see all types of smutty advertisements.2:53There are certain websites where you go to their websites and you'll see advertisements for2:57sefarim. You see advertisements for Jewish bookstores, for Jewish vacations, right?3:03It all depends which website it is. And that's the same idea when we do a mitzvah3:11or an aveirah. מצווה גוררת מצווה, ועבירה גוררת עבירה. So another effect, and it's also part of the picture because there's still more,3:15another effect of when you do a sin is that now you set yourself up for another sin.3:20There's another effect yet, and that is a sin by itself is3:26metameh, and that metameh itself, למטה מטמאים אותו מלמעלה, right?3:29You bring tumah within yourself, and that right away—tumah means stuffing, clogging up or clogging up.3:35So once you clog up already the arteries of spirituality, even though it was by ones, it's not a punishment, it's just a reality:3:42you're dirty. You're a dirty person. A dirty person cannot get into a lot of places.3:48Your neshama becomes dirty. She says,3:52כי מסתמא נהיה מטומאה פתח ליצר הרע לכנוס. Or because in order for this a lot, for this to be able to come,3:55how did it come? Even b'ones or b'shogeg.3:57How did the aveirah even come b'ones, b'shogeg?4:00The answer is, it allowed it to come in.4:02There's a very, very, what's it called, there's amazing things.4:07I don't think that God is going to bring all of them, but before we just see that,4:10look at the bottom over here where he quotes a4:13Sifri. Everybody see it?4:15There's a Sifri. It's a Midrash on Parashat Shelach. It says,4:22וְכִפֶּר הַכֹּהֵן עַל הַנֶּפֶשׁ הַשֹּׁגֶגֶת בְּחֶטְאָה. The pasuk says that when a person does a4:26shegagah, on the bottom, all the way on the4:28bottom, ha'arot b'biurim, when the person does an4:32aveirah b'shegagah, then it says over there,4:34וְכִפֶּר הַכֹּהֵן, the kohen is mechaper on the person who does4:39aveirah b'shegagah. Now let me explain. Shegagah means by accident. He didn't know.4:42He didn't do it on purpose. He did it by accident.4:44That's when you're allowed to bring a korban.4:45The Alshich writes over there,4:48so, excuse me, the beraita says over there,4:53חטאים שבידו הם גרמו לו שיבוא לידי חטאת. We think the sin that caused me to bring the korban chatat is, you know, the sin itself.5:00Comes the beraita, comes the Midrash and says,5:03the sins that you've done in other areas5:05caused you to come to this point to bring a5:08chatat. Don't think it's an accident5:10that comes. Look at the Alshich. The Alshich on the Torah writes over there,5:18להשים אל לב בני אדם העולה על רוחם כי קל מאוד שיחטא בשגגה, ממש שלא מלבם נעשית הטעייה. This Midrash comes to tell us a very important rule.5:22I think in psychology also it has a very, very deep meaning.5:24We'll get to that later on. But first he's telling you that5:28the Alshich, the Alshich who lived in the time of the Beit Yosef and the Arizal also.5:32So the Alshich says that people think,5:35when I do a sin by accident, by mistake,5:37he said, listen, I didn't do it on purpose. What?5:40I can't make an accident? You can't do, you can't make an accident?5:44וְלֹא כֵן הוּא, that's not so. That's not so,5:49כי גם בלא דעת נפש לא טוב. It says, even without daat, nefesh lo5:53tov. The nefesh at the end day is also not good,5:55even if it's done without6:01daat. She'il maleh nafsho lo6:04metumaa me'avera b'techilah, lo hayta takalah shegagah yotzet mitachat yado. Powerful. This needs a highlight.6:07Underline. It's not our book, so don't do it.6:10But it says that if it wasn't for the fact6:13that his nefesh was tamei from previous6:18averot, he would not come to6:21a shegagah. Uvizeh bi'er hapasuk. And now you can understand what the pasuk, the connection of6:24the pasuk. What does the pasuk say?6:25V'im nefesh achat techeta bishgagah,6:28ba'asotah achat mimitzvot Hashem asher lo6:30te'asenah. Look at the order6:32the pasuk says. If a person should sin bishgagah6:34by doing one of the mitzvot of Hashem asher lo6:37te'asenah. The Ashich explains the pasuk to mean like this:6:39V'im nefesh achat techeta bishgagah.6:42If a person sins bishgagah,6:43you want to know why a person sins bishgagah?6:46Because asotah.6:47Because it did a previous6:50aveirah, achat mimitzvot Hashem asher lo6:52te'asenah. It did one of the mitzvot that never was supposed to be done,6:56and that led him to do this current sin bishgagah.7:01There's no such a thing as an accident.7:04Why does an accident only happen to certain people?7:07If you're a boss over many employees, right,7:10and you see people that come late, right,7:14and don't you notice that the same type,7:17the same guys are always having the problem with timing,7:20whether it's here, it's there?7:21How come it doesn't happen to other people?7:23Why is this7:24person—and he's right,7:25he missed the bus,7:26and he's right,7:27there was traffic,7:28and he's right,7:28he got stuck behind the garbage7:30truck—why is it the same people?7:32Why is it always happening to the same people?7:34The guys are always... The guys should always be late?7:36And the answer is, you could see, not from this,7:39but you could see in other areas that usually those type of people that are late7:42are people who don't really care about their work.7:46And therefore, coming late is not a big deal for them.7:47So they're always thinking,7:49ah, okay, a few minutes late is not a big deal.7:51Could there be maybe a garbage truck?7:54Don't you know it's Thursday and Monday,7:56and when there's garbage collection, there's going to be, you know, things?7:59It's not the—8:00He doesn't care so much. Doesn't even think about it. When you care about something, you care in any area, you won't come to that mistake.8:07You know, in big places. Let's say you work for Trump. There's no room for mistakes.8:11There's absolutely no room for mistakes.8:14And this one said, the guy fired. You see, you think he only did it like when he was a regular businessman, right?8:18And on the show, The Apprentice.8:20But now, even the White House,8:21the guy has fired, I think he's gone in history as the guy with the most, you know,8:27he does—he cleans out more his cabinet more than Beor Hametz.8:31And he's always people not fired.8:34Next week, another guy, another guy fired.8:37He's firing people left and right. Why?8:39Small mistake. That means for him it shows that there's no room for—that means you don't care about it.8:44So in halacha also, not halacha, in Torah also, because an aveirah came by mistake, right?8:50It's a mistake. He didn't know.8:53There's no such thing as a mistake. Chazal tell us this in a very, very amazing way.8:57It says Lot slept with his daughters when they went to the cave, right?9:00Now, is it disgusting?9:03Yeah, it's disgusting.9:04Is it Lot's fault? He was drunk.9:06Chazal put a dot over the word9:10uvkumah. There's a dot in the Torah. There's a small dot.9:13And we have a klal: whenever there's a dot, it's a derashah there,9:17that it says that when he got drunk and he slept with the first daughter,9:22he didn't know when he was sleeping with his daughter that she was his daughter.9:24He was so drunk he didn't know, right?9:27But when he woke up, he realized.9:29The next night when he drank again,9:32what, are you crazy?9:34You saw what happened last night.9:36Wow. How do you get yourself drunk again?9:38The answer is because that shows us even the first night he didn't care.9:42No, Lot didn't make a mistake by one daughter.9:46And the other one he really wanted to.9:48He wanted to buy both daughters,9:50because such a mistake didn't happen to Abraham9:54Avinu. Such a mistake didn't happen to other people.9:56It happened to Lot,9:58because Chazal tell us,10:00Shatuf b'zimah. He's the same Lot that went to10:03Sedom. He chose to go to10:05Sedom, and said, Mistakes don't just happen.10:07Whenever we come across a mistake,10:09we always have to question ourselves:10:11why did we come to such a mistake?10:14And it's unbelievable how you see this all the time by many different things.10:19Shabbat. People made a mistake once in Shabbat,10:21and now they're very careful on Shabbat.10:24I have a relative10:26now who cares very much about Shabbat.10:27One time, by accident,10:29he put a tea bag in10:32kli sheini without turning it into10:33kli shelishi. That means he poured from the urn,10:35he put it in a cup,10:36he put a tea bag over there.10:38Shabbat, he forgot.10:39He stopped drinking tea on Shabbat.10:41He stopped making tea on Shabbat.10:43He wouldn't make tea anymore.10:44I don't know if he drinks even.10:46I don't even know if he drinks anymore,10:48right?10:49Why?10:50He cares very much.10:52Me, I made mistakes.10:53I do it again.10:54It happens again,10:55right?10:56If I really, really cared about something,10:58I would stay very far away from it.11:01Now, or I put other boundaries,11:03whatever it may be.11:04Rabbi11:06Twerski, Hashem should bless him,11:07he should live a long life.11:08He's already in his 80s, 90s,11:09probably in his 90s,11:10and he, in his 50s,11:12he had a center in Pittsburgh11:15for addiction.11:17It was the biggest center in the whole country,11:20biggest center in the whole country.11:21He's a rabbi also, Rabbi11:23Twerski, for the goyim also,11:24not for the Jews.11:25So it's the biggest center in all of America11:27for addictions.11:28So he knows about addiction,11:29he knows about different things.11:30So when I was in yeshiva,11:31he used to come every other week11:33to give a class on11:34Mesilat Yesharim, which he wrote a book on also.11:36He also wrote over 70 books, by the way.11:38So this is Rabbi11:39Twerski. So I heard it from him directly.11:41He said the following story.11:41He says,11:42when they had the center,11:44whenever people come in to recover,11:46they were11:47always, one more sip.11:49One more sip,11:50right back here.11:51So usually people who come to the center11:52are only people that hit rock bottom.11:54A lot of people have problems,11:55but when you hit rock bottom,11:56that's when you start to realize it's a problem11:58and you enter there.11:59And usually that happens12:00when people threaten you12:01that, you12:02know, the wife says,12:03I'm going to walk out,12:03and the business partner says,12:04I'm leaving,12:05and that's when it hits really rock bottom.12:07So it says12:08when they come out of the rehabs,12:10we always tell them,12:11One more sip,12:11you're back here.12:12Okay.12:13It says one time they get a call12:14on their emergency line,12:16emergency line,12:16you got to pick up.12:17What happened?12:17There's a guy,12:19he's frantic over the telephone.12:20He says,12:20I'm here at a party,12:21and they had alcohol12:22and didn't touch it,12:23and they had punch,12:25and I took a sip.12:26Later on,12:27somebody told me12:27that they spiked the punch.12:31So, okay, what's going on?12:31Why are you so nervous?12:32Why are the emergency line?12:33He says,12:34Are you drunk or not?12:35I don't know,12:35but he said,12:36One more sip.12:37He said,12:38One more sip,12:38I'm back here.12:39I don't want to come back.12:40Please help me.12:40What do I do?12:42That's a person.12:44So what he says,12:44That taught me12:47yiras Shamayim. This is his words,12:48you know.12:48That story12:50is yiras Shamayim. You realize.12:51So we don't realize.12:52We think everything12:53in reward,12:53every12:55aveirah is, oh, punished, right? I don't get punished.12:57Kind of like12:57we have to look at12:58shola. I did12:59aveirah. What's going to happen to me?13:00Next week went by,13:01no bad luck,13:02okay. But you don't realize13:02when we do13:04an aveirah, we're metamei our nefesh. We already put ourselves,13:05we took that sip,13:06we put ourselves13:07easier not to come back.13:09So let's see13:09from the words of the13:12Gaon of Vilna. It says over here,13:15Tnan, you see13:15on the bottom,13:23אות י'. החשבתי במקצת נזקו, חייבתי בתשלומי נזקו כאילו כל נזקו. Famous Mishnah in Bava Kamma, those who did Bava Kamma. If I prepared13:24part of the damage,13:27I'm13:29chayav to pay back13:30as if I paid13:31the complete damage.13:33Right? We all know13:34what that means13:34is that—13:35If I was a cause13:38of something13:39getting partially damaged,13:42even though13:43that partial damage13:44ended up causing13:45a major damage,13:46the whole damage13:47to the whole item,13:48I'm responsible13:48for the whole item.13:49What do you want,13:50my responsibility?13:50I only was,13:51you know,13:52I only forgot the screw,13:54right?13:55Or I only took out the screw.13:57I'm still responsible13:57for the whole thing.13:58Says the13:59Gra, amazing things.14:04יש עוונות שבאים באונס ושוגג ואף על פי כן נענש עליהם. There's sins that come14:06be'ones shogeg and still you get punished on them.14:08Why?14:13עבירה גוררת עבירה. אדם מטמא עצמו מעט מטמאין אותו הרבה. Because, like we said,14:14you open yourself up to another,14:16and that's the idea14:16over14:17here on a deeper level.14:21חטאתי במקצת נזקו, חטאתי בתשלומין נזקו, כשלי כל נזקו. When I do a little bit of an14:24aveirah, I do a little bit of damage spiritually,14:26I am responsible for the full damage,14:28because when that big aveirah later comes on,14:30I shouldn't wonder where it came from.14:31It came from that small14:33aveirah, and that's how it came from.14:34Now I can understand,14:35there's a story14:37that Rabbi Shor,14:39my rebbi, used to say14:40about his14:40mother,14:42aleha hashalom. He says one time,14:44Rabbi Shor's brother,14:45there was a little kid,14:46he was maybe14:48eleven. By mistake he bumped into the light,14:50and14:51his—oh, he just turned14:54bar mitzvah, or twelve, or right before his14:55bar mitzvah, whatever—and his mother started crying on Shabbat.14:58He says, Mom, why are you crying?14:59He says, You just turned15:00bar mitzvah and you mechalel Shabbat.15:01He says, It was an accident,15:03and she wouldn't stop crying,15:05right?15:05Maybe she read the15:06Gra and she understood.15:08Yes, it was an15:09ones. It was an15:10ones, but how can the ones come?15:12Why did the ones come?15:13Why did it happen?15:15Why did it happen to you?15:16Next,15:19there's a pasuk in15:20Mishlei that says,15:22רשעת תסלף חטאת. Cause15:23of—what does that mean?15:31כמו שכתוב, כי כשלת בעוונך. שובו ישראל כי כשלת בעוונך. כלומר מחמת העוון, שכבר עשה מתחילה, מחמת זה מביאים לידי חטא. It's because of the sin that we do,15:33unfortunately brings us to another sin.15:35So this is, again,15:36he says,15:38ורשעת תסלף חטאת. Our wickedness15:39brings about more15:42chatat. That's all we,15:42you know,15:42we got the point.15:43Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll continue15:45with the next piece tomorrow.15:46We already went over time.