Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 4, Lesson 23Sefer Even ShelemaPart 78Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:14Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:02Perek dalet, yud-zayin, part two. Yesterday we started speaking, and like we said, it's a deeper concept, right?0:06It's a deeper concept of what the Emes Shelva brings down over here0:12about understanding why you do things and what's really pushing you and driving you to do something.0:18So before we get to the things, to the actual words from the0:22Gra, I want you to look down over here in0:25the ha'arot u'biurim. You see that?0:30אות ח'. Okay.0:37דברי רבינו בספר זה וכן העלם בפרק ה' סעיף א' מכוונים לעניין העבודה הפנימית של האדם. What the Gra is talking about over here, and later on, which we'll see eventually0:43also—not eventually, but not so long, maybe like two weeks.0:47In seif alef, are talking about the same idea, and that is the internal0:52avodah. We have avodah. Most of the avodah that we know0:56is the avodat Hashem is like, you know, like the famous avodah in Beit HaMikdash, korban,1:01shechitah, and we have also the regular halachot that are in Shulchan Aruch, right?1:06Putting on tefillin and waking up for Shacharit and learning Torah and being nice to others1:09and being mechabed av va'em, and even things are in1:13machshavah, but there's still avodah, meaning to say like,1:18Lo taturu acharei levavchem v'acharei eineichem. Am I really looking or not looking? That's within me, but still more of an external.1:23Avodah penimit is the internal struggle that a person has with his1:28thought, what we'd call basically his thoughts, in Torah language, with his1:33yetzer hara, because really the battle that goes on in a person's mind,1:36you know, like the internal conflict, what we would call.1:40L'tikun nafsho b'yirat v'ahavat Hashem, to really fix even the inside with fear of Hashem and love of Hashem.1:53U'baal mechaber sefer Nachlat David, he elaborated on it, and he said the following:1:59K'shayu nevi'im v'ruach hakodesh b'Yisrael. When we had prophets at one point, and there was ruach hakodesh2:03that was, you know, you had an app called Ruach HaKodesh, right,2:05when we used to have such a thing.2:12Hayah yachol ha'adam lada'at b'eizeh devarim yeched et avodato hapenimit l'ahavat Hashem yitbarach. A person was able to really, really know how was he,2:18the internal kavanot, the intentions that he has,2:22the real drive that's driving him in avodat Hashem.2:26A person would go to a navi or would go to the Arizal,2:29and the Arizal would tell him exactly why he's doing what he's doing.2:39אבל עכשיו שאין נבואה... Not by the Jewish nation, because neviut was also not by everybody.2:44No, not each one. You had to go to certain people.2:51אבל עכשיו שאין נבואה ורוח הקודש. But nowadays, we lost both these levels.2:54We don't have prophecy anymore, and we don't have really ruach hakodesh anymore.3:00אין לסמוך על מחשבתו. A person cannot rely on what he thinks he thinks,3:06right? You can't really depend and say, you know what,3:09the reason why I'm doing this is because I think this is the reason.3:15You have to be careful to do every single mitzvah in the Torah,3:20and this way you're completing your3:29avodah. וזהו עיקר החסידות... בהגהות רב חיים מוולאז'ין. And this is the real level of chassidut, which is doing it.3:34עיקר החסידות means, says Rav Chaim of Volozhin, who was a student of the3:42Gra, גודל הזריזות במצוות... That person has to be very, very careful and very meticulous3:47in keeping the mitzvot to the fullest detail.3:53אפילו מה שהוא מדת חסידות, ידקדק. Even what's considered chassidut, you have to be3:58medakdek. Meaning that we shouldn't, you know, it's not like once upon a time4:01where you could have done mitzvot and just be yotzei dechovah minimum,4:07but your kavanah was great on such a high level,4:09and you say, Hey, you know, a guy is great.4:12Nowadays we don't have that. We don't really know4:15what's driving us really to do mitzvot.4:17So we have to be careful that every mitzvah we do to the fullest detail,4:20we yotzei every4:22shittah. Why? Because we don't really even know what's driving us.4:25Am I really posek this way because, am I holding like this opinion because4:29I know that this is the right way,4:32or really because inside of me there's a little bit of laziness4:35that I don't want to be machmir like the other shita?4:39So why am I really posek this way?4:41What's making me go like this opinion?4:44All right, and we could see clearly because we know there's a great,4:47you know, there's a lot of people—I'm going to use the Rambam for4:50a second—a lot of people say, Rambam! The Rambam!4:53You shakran. You're not going like the Rambam,4:56because you're just using the Rambam as an excuse, right?4:59The Rambam says you can do this.5:01You found a kula in the Rambam,5:03and that's why you want to go.5:04You're not quoting the5:07Rambam's chumrot. You're not figuring out.5:08You're not realizing that the Rambam, who says this halacha over here5:11and the other halacha over there,5:13the Rambam is clearly contradicting5:15himself according to the way you explain the Rambam.5:17So what happened to the Rambam?5:20Ela mai, you have a personal agenda5:23that either you want to put down the rabbi in your shul,5:26or you want to knock certain people,5:28or you're just stam lazy.5:30You don't want to do the right way of the5:32halacha. You know, you want to do like5:34this Shulchan Aruch, and you're running around like the5:35Rambam, but Shulchan Aruch didn't write the5:37halacha. So we know that.5:37We know that people will take quotations of certain gedolim,5:42right, and, you know, like the famous one is5:45Chacham Ovadia, right? Chacham Ovadia is a adam gadol,5:48and he was posek b'sakinah harifta a lot of times,5:51and even though, yes, I gotta deem this is a5:55halacha, right?5:58So people, Chacham Ovadia, Chacham Ovadia, you can't wear wigs,6:00Chacham Ovadia, right? Well, Chacham Ovadia also says about Beit Yosef.6:02Did you know that?6:03That he was the one who yelled Beit Yosef at the top of his lungs.6:05Why are you מקל in that?6:07What happened?6:08So what's really driving you now?6:10You gotta wonder.6:11Why are you going,6:13why are you flipping out6:14Chacham Ovadia? Why are you flipping out the Rambam?6:15Right?6:16We don't really know what's really driving us.6:18Because with that,6:19we can't be sure to say that we're really,6:22we're going6:23like Chabad because I really know the6:24sugya and I know it6:24clearly, and that's really the right way6:25it's supposed to be6:27halacha. Or maybe really I'm doing it for personal reasons.6:29Sometimes it could be because6:31I'm avoiding a certain level of guilt,6:34or sometimes I'm doing it because6:36I'm really,6:40I have a personal conflict with a certain group of Jews6:44or group of people,6:46and therefore6:47I can use now6:49Chabad or the Chazon Ish6:50as a weapon against them,6:52right?6:52In yeshiva,6:53I was in yeshiva in Baalei6:55Teshuva. I once overheard one of my6:57rabbis—he's a big adam gadol,7:01Rav Shor—and I overheard one of the guys coming to him,7:05and I forgot, not forgot,7:06I didn't hear the full conversation,7:08but I kind of like, you know,7:09eavesdropping after.7:10Yeah, I was eavesdropping,7:11not a good thing to do,7:12but anyway, I was eavesdropping.7:13But he basically7:14says, But the Chazon Ish7:15says not like that.7:16So Rav Shor smiled and says,7:19You have a Chazon Ish esrog?7:21You have an etrog the Chazon Ish size?7:24Do you do this like the Chazon Ish?7:26Do you do that like the Chazon Ish?7:28Oh, you don't.7:29So okay, so7:30not a big deal not to do that.7:31It's okay, the Chazon Ish7:32says, there's other opinions also,7:34right?7:34Why are you yelling,7:35Chazon Ish?7:36So that's exactly what we're talking about7:38in the subject.7:39What's really driving us,7:41we don't know.7:41We really don't know.7:42We really don't know.7:43We think7:44l'shem Shamayim. We don't know if we7:46really—that's because we believe that's right, or really7:48there's a yetzer hara that's driving us to do something.7:49So because of that,7:51we have to be careful.7:52We can't trust,7:52we can't rely on ourselves.7:53And therefore we have to try to be7:56yotzei every shita. We have to do7:57every—to the detail, okay? Now.8:00Now he says also over there,8:03V'ayin sham shericha .... But באמת, אחר מתן תורה אין לזה8:06זכר, ... ודברי8:08חזל. After8:09Matan Torah, chalas, this is what we're supposed to do.8:12We cannot rely on what the yetzer hara just tells us.8:18Now, interesting midrash.8:19The midrash tells us the Chanoch used to8:22stitch shoes.8:24ובכל תפירה כוון ייחודים8:26ופעל למעלה.8:26In every stitch as he made,8:28he had a tremendous amount level of kavanot.8:33And the same thing, we see Moshe was a shepherd.8:36We see that Abraham8:39dug wells.8:41Yitzchak dug wells. Yaakov8:42was a shepherd,8:45right? What's going on over here? What's going on over here?8:47And everybody uses that.8:49Look what people say:8:50Oh, look, you got to do shoes, you got to make shoes,8:52you got to dig wells, you got to sell8:54Poland Spring water,8:57right? No. Each one, they had a kavanah in it.9:07... וכל זה קודם מתן תורה. But that was only from Matan Torah,9:09where we didn't have specific plans9:12of how to serve Hashem.9:13You could serve Hashem by stitching shoes,9:17and a goy today9:18could be a great oved Hashem9:20by being either a9:21shepherd, a car salesman,9:23or a shoemaker.9:26Rak sheyishmor zayin mitzvot, but you got to make sure you don't, as a goy, you don't9:29transgress the9:34seven mitzvot. Aval lanu Bnei Yisrael, nitena Torah geder v'gbul. By us, it doesn't—He can't do that anymore.9:36The Torah came and gave us clear directions9:38and clear boundaries9:39of what you should do9:41and what you should not do.9:45V'chol hama'aseh nichlal b'tzivui v'azharah, every action is included in those commands.9:50As we're doing what we're supposed to be9:53doing, we could do those9:54yichudim, if you're on a level,9:56which means, for those who don't understand,9:59certain ideas10:00you're supposed to have of combining10:02Hashem's names.10:05V'geder hasidut—You want to be a chasid, you want to do beyond10:07the letter of the10:08law, you want to do10:09extra, to be as precise as possible,10:11to an extreme in your precision10:14in keeping the10:19mitzvot. Excuse me.10:27And also, to run away10:30even from a10:33hair length between us and10:34issur, we have to make sure we don't even come too close10:36to an issur from whatever the Torah warned us about,10:39from whatever the10:41Chazal told us about,10:42and from whatever our Gedolim warned us from.10:47V'im lakach Yaakov beitah chayot, v'Amram nasa dodah Torah. In the Torah we see10:49Yaakov was able to marry two sisters.10:52Amram married his aunt.10:53Both these are listed in the arayot.10:57Zeh hayah kodem Matan Torah. That's because it was before Matan Torah;10:58they had the option.11:00Yaakov could still say, I kept all the mitzvot in11:02Torah, even though he married two sisters.11:04That's the biggest question everybody asks,11:06right? And there are many11:08different answers. And the way we're explaining over here,11:11because the11:12intent—11:14Which is to serve Hashem,11:17Yaakov was able to do11:18even by marrying two sisters,11:19but that was before Matan Torah.11:25But from the time Moshe HaTorah was given, there's no switching anymore,11:28and there's no switching11:30mitzvot, there's no switching commands,11:32there's no switching ideas.11:36And even though up until now11:37we've been talking11:39that you have a certain11:41neshama in your body,11:43and you need to come to this world to fix it,11:45and you11:47realized that the way you're going to fix it11:49is through doing a certain11:51aveirah, because that's the way11:52you're going to be metaken it, right?11:55No. We already have a clear boundary.11:57You know, one of the things, for example,11:59we have a zman of Kriat Shema.12:01We have to say Kriat Shema12:03in the morning before12:04three hours halachic hours of the morning.12:07Now you12:08need to mentally prepare yourself12:12to serve12:13Hashem, that you should be mechaven every word,12:15and from your preparation12:16you have to go to the mikveh, and you're really12:19l'shem shamayim. But you're missing this zman of12:21Kriat Shema. You can't do that anymore.12:23That was a big12:25machloket, as you understand that there's some people12:27who do that.12:29They're dochez man tefillah, they're docheh other things,12:30and that's what the Gra is coming to say,12:32and Rav Chaim of Volozhin expressing it more.12:34No, we have clear boundaries12:36of what is right, what is wrong,12:38and other things we have to worry12:40that it may come from the yetzer hara.12:46Kavahomer, anu shehasketenu hakol hevel v'haskafato gam ken hevel. Kavahomer us, right,12:48that we really—who says we're really mechaven12:50like the way we understand, like the way12:52Yaakov Avinu understood, like the way Amram understood,12:55right?12:56We don't have those12:58hasagot. We don't understand what they understand.13:00So therefore, we have the boundary,13:02we have to stick to those13:03boundaries, and when we13:05feel—you know, sometimes people say, I feel that13:08this is what Hashem...13:10Maybe not.13:12But I feel13:13someone. No, no, no. Even your feeling is correct,13:15he's telling you. Even if your feeling is 100% correct,13:18that's before Matan Torah.13:19After Matan Torah, you cannot stray from that.13:22Now, there's more about the subject,13:24but that's what we read yesterday,13:25and that's what we're clarifying today.13:27Whatever we have, and we're just going to go on to the next subject13:29already. I think we spoke about enough.13:31Whatever kavanah that we may have,13:33whatever good intention that we have,13:36doesn't apply anymore13:38once the Torah was given.13:39And once we have set rules13:41of who we go like,13:43like the Rishonim and the13:45Acharonim and the rabbis that we follow.13:47And I'll add even more. Even in machloket that we find today13:50between13:51Acharonim, don't be your own posek.13:53You don't know what's really driving you13:55to go after a13:56certain psak. Ask a rabbi that you trust13:59and tell him your situation.14:00Maybe there is room to be lenient for your situation,14:02but don't decide things on your own14:05when you really don't know14:06where the source of it from.14:08Maybe it's a14:10yetzer hara trying to dig a hole for you.