Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 4, Lesson 22Sefer Even ShelemaPart 77Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:006:18Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:06בן שלמה, פרק ד', אות י״ז. כל דרכי האדם נמשכין אחר הרצון הראשון. All the ways of a person are, they follow, or basically it just follows through with the original ratzon that he has.0:18What does it mean by the ratzon? The original thing that he sets out that he wants to do, that sets the pace for everything to come. We'll explain.0:30כמו שעולה ברצון הראשון, הוא זך וישר בעיניו. And just as when the beginning, if the original ratzon, that means the original kavanah, the intent of something was pure and straight,0:47right? וה׳ בתוכן רוחות ה׳. The pasuk says Hashem examines the spirits of a person, the mind of a person.0:56ויודע אם לא היה כלל פנייה ברצון הראשון מזה יומא, זה כי תל לבי, אם הוא חלם היה כלל. And Hashem really knows the person's real, real intentions in something.1:01That means we're all used to the actions. We speak so much about1:05actions. We're especially, I mean, I don't know the people listening, but in our kehillah, we're a big kehillah of action because we're a kehillah of halacha.1:15I once went to a certain community, and there were Sefardim and Ashkenazim.1:20And, excuse me, there were Sefardim people, members of the community, and there was a lot of Ashkenazim teaching the community,1:27right? And it's just very interesting to see.1:29I said, I'm going to make a question-and-answer session,1:32okay? And I told the Ashkenazi rabbis, I said, you know, they're like, Yeah, what are you going to talk about this?1:37I said, Watch. You know, I said, You want to know Sefardim? Sefardim are all about halacha.1:44Watch. I'm going to get up, I'm going to ask anybody one question-and-answer, and they're all going to ask me questions on halacha.1:50So, first question, I got up, somebody asked about a certain midrash, very neat. It turned out to be an Ashkenazi guy.1:57But the next one, all this Sephardim were all asking halacha.2:01Oh, wait, what do you do this? What do you do this?2:03And if you notice, most of the questions that Sephardim have are usually about halacha.2:07They're very interested in halacha. We're very into lemaaseh, making2:11maaseh. Ideas, all these things. Sometimes I even try to introduce it, especially to a more traditional community that has sources from other countries.2:19All these things don't interest them.2:21So because of that, there is a negative part of it, and that is that we focus so much on the action that we forget also the ratzonot.2:29So we look at the action and we define, and the final mark is given based only on the action and not the ratzon, and not the2:37kavanah, not the intention. Now what does that mean, kavanah? You have to have kavanot? That's not what I mean.2:40I mean to say, why are we doing certain things?2:42Why are we doing certain things?2:45Just an extreme example, but a good example of this, right?2:48So you come at night to class and you see certain people, they always come, and there's certain people that pop in here and there.2:54So somebody will ask you, you know, what do you say about this guy?2:57You know, how is he with his commitment to Torah?2:59So, well, based on what I see, being that we have class twice a week, he doesn't come every night, but sometimes he pops in.3:06So you say that this guy is not so committed, but he has a certain commitment to Torah, right?3:11Do you know why he is coming? No.3:15Pashut, I just judge what I see, right?3:18But how can you say that he's committed to Torah? All you see is that he's coming or he's not coming.3:21I know more. I know that when this guy comes to class, I know, and this is a true story of a certain person, right?3:28I know that he had a fight with his wife and he doesn't want to be home, so he's going to be here, right?3:32He's not a friendly guy with other people that he could go hang out with them in the bar, so he comes to class,3:37Baruch Hashem, right?3:38But does that show commitment to Torah? Right?3:41So it doesn't show commitment to Torah. It just shows a commitment to staying away from the wife,3:45okay, so he doesn't want to get beat up.3:47So the idea here is that we're dealing with kavanot, the ratzon, right?3:53What's your true intention to something?3:56Sometimes it can have a major, major effect.3:58Certain people that come to certain shuls. Why?4:01Because there's a certain rich guy they want to be close to.4:03There's a certain, you know, group of people they want to be close to.4:06And there's nothing wrong with being social.4:09There's nothing wrong with being with your friends in a certain shul.4:11Of course, that's the idea of building a community, and that's good because we all support each other.4:16But when that's only your kavanah, then that could taint a lot of the mitzvot.4:23And then, yes, he did the mitzvah; you get a check for the4:25maaseh. But what's the ratzon? Where's the4:28ratzon? Now, that's what he's telling you.4:29The original ratzon of something is everything else follows the original, how you started off.4:37Good? Now what are you going to tell me?4:39What are you going to tell me? You know, I could say whatever I want.4:42I know what. So he says,4:45V'tochen ruchot Hashem. Tochen, like from the word tochen, inside, content.4:48Hashem examines the insides, the ruchot of a person,4:52and He can really tell you what your real kavanah is.4:56Are you really doing it for that reason?4:58Are you really, you know—there's people say,5:01I'm l'shem shamayim.5:02This is mamash l'shem shamayim,5:04has v'shalom, and have anything, right?5:05Sometimes, and it's more so, I'll tell you, even more so for people who are always involved in mitzvot,5:10like rabbis. They're always involved in learning and teaching and everything else.5:13So you really have to always examine yourself:5:16am I really doing it because that's the right thing to do?5:19That's what they need to hear?5:20Let's give a very good example.5:23Could you remember—I know it might be5:25hard—could you remember the last time you got angry and yelled at your children?5:29Might be very hard, you know, but you have to, like, dig deep in your memory, right?5:33Do you remember the last time you yelled at them?5:35So now, did you yell at them l'shem shamayim?5:38What does that mean, l'shem shamayim?5:39It means to say, well, why did you yell at them?5:41Because there's a mitzvah of5:43chanoch lanaar al pi darko. I have to train the child, right?5:46Now, do you think yelling and screaming actually5:49works? Do you think making your child feel dumb or putting him down really works?5:54Or does that actually hinder, ruins his5:59self-esteem, and actually it's backwards because he gets upset and he yells back,6:02and the proof is how many times we say it doesn't work.6:05I did it a thousand times and I'm not doing this, right?6:08Obviously it's not working, right?6:09There's something wrong here.6:10Would you do something in your business a thousand times and it doesn't work?