Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 4, Lesson 21Sefer Even ShelemaPart 76Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:32Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Even Shlema, perek dalet, ot zayin.0:04Just a small little note for the ones who are following us.0:08I know I said yesterday that we're going to spend more time on the Gra's own words in0:15peirush, on the explanation of tet-vav, being that it was a big letter.0:19But like yesterday, we picked up certain parts, the gist of it.0:23There is a lot more that he writes over here,0:25but it's all pretty much the same idea, just taken from different places.0:29So we're going straight to tet-zayin today,0:33a short piece. Let's see how long we spend on it.0:36Hayetzer hara — oh, the Even Shlema over here says,0:40Hayetzer hara ba0:42la'adam bishtei ta'anot. Yetzer hara, when he comes to a person, he's trying to convince him in one of two ways.0:47One is, or sometimes both,0:48shebliad Hashem yefshar la'amod bo.0:50Either that this is very difficult to do. You can't do it.0:54You can't be religious, you know, even if you're convinced, you can't be religious.0:59You can't do this.1:00You know how many times we go to class and we get inspired, and it sounds great,1:04and it's really, really the right thing,1:06but we just — you can't do this. It's not realistic.1:10You just can't do it, right?1:11Number two is sheha'elo heterim.1:13The second way is that the yetzer hara shows a person heterim.1:19He shows him, you know, listen, yes, you can do it,1:23but why do you need to be so machmir, right?1:27It's a hashkafic issue over here.1:29It's not a halachic issue.1:30There's heterim for this kind of thing,1:33and that's the way.1:34Now, and then there's what, what's it called,1:37the Even Shlema doesn't bring over here,1:39the Gra doesn't bring over here,1:40is that there's a third way, which is really the third way.1:43That's a1:44ma'aritz. That's the1:46yetzer hara's customary. He doesn't even have to make a meeting.1:47You know, the yetzer hara is busy.1:49He's busy with a lot of people,1:50and to make a special meeting with each person to convince him,1:53it's not an easy job.1:55The am haaretz is the yetzer hara guy.1:57He works for him.1:58He's doing the1:59aveirot. In fact, he himself, this2:01am haaretz, goes to other people to try to convince them of the yetzer hara's ideas,2:05right?2:06So we're dealing here with a person who learns and sees the halacha in front of him.2:11He sees the right thing to do.2:13What does the yetzer hara come and tell him?2:15Yashan is not doable.2:17Yes, wow, that was a great class.2:19Wow, the rabbi is really good.2:21Very hard to argue.2:22I mean, it's Shulchan Aruch,2:23and we're all convinced of the heterim of Shulchan Aruch.2:25But there's a2:28heter, spek-sfeka. But the spek-sfeka, who is—2:30but the rabbi said a2:31heter. But he said the heter is like only one in a million,2:34and it's very, very far,2:36and so— no, there's a2:38heter. All the other way is that,2:40come on, you keep2:42yashan? You can't do that.2:43Tell me I can't eat Entenmann's anymore?2:46You tell me I can't have Arnold's—2:50By the way, I think Arnold's, just a side point,2:52as we're speaking right now from the recording,2:54I think they took off the OU from them.2:57They don't have a hechsher anymore,2:58but that's a side point.2:59But anyway,3:00but you tell me I can't have all these things?3:03Come on,3:04it's not doable.3:05You know, you're not speaking logic.3:07These are the two ways,3:08and we've all heard these3:10ta'anot. We've all thought that way3:12for many things that we know we want to perhaps start doing.3:17But here, the Gra already told3:21the talmid, this is not an old thing.3:22You're just fooled by the yetzer hara.3:23This is an old trick of the yetzer hara.3:25It's great,3:26we're learning this book3:26and we're learning all the tricks of the yetzer hara.3:29Don't be fooled,3:29right?3:30It's kind of like a3:31guy—we said this3:32yesterday—a guy goes into business.3:33You want to teach him,3:34don't be fooled,3:35don't be3:35scared. The guy comes in, he says,3:37Please, you know, I'll pay you for the item.3:38I'm going to give you the deposit.3:39I'll come back to it.3:40Don't be3:41fooled. Make sure he pays you everything,3:43right?3:43It's only when you get burnt once or twice,3:45then we learn our lesson.3:45Unfortunately, we get burnt left and right,3:48and, whoo,3:49there's a lot of fire waiting for us also, unfortunately,3:52right?3:52And we keep on falling for the yetzer hara.3:55Don't fall for him.3:56This is3:57the ta'ana. Now, where does it come from?3:58It comes from the original,4:00the original incident in the4:02Torah where the yetzer hara came and attacked.4:04The pasuk introduces us to the snake.4:07And the snake, Chazal tell us, is the yetzer hara,4:10represents the yetzer hara. And it says about the snake in the pasuk,4:16V'hanachash hayah arum mikol chayat hasadeh. The nachash was sharper than all the other creatures in that field.4:22Vayomer el ha'ishah — the nachash came and spoke to the woman.4:24He told her,4:28Af ki amar Elokim lo toklu mikol etz hagan. Even if God said,4:30Don't eat from all the trees in the garden, in the Gan Eden,4:35good?4:36So comes the Gra and says,4:43גילא לנו התורה כל טענות היצר הם משניים למשפחותם. When the Torah tells us this incident4:46of how Adam and Chava, or I want to say Adam and Eve, came and sinned,4:51or how really the nachash was able to convince Chava to sin,4:56it's not stam talking.4:58The Torah is coming to tell us exactly how the yetzer hara works.5:10First approach that the yetzer hara always tries with a person is by telling him,5:14You can't do it.5:16It's not for you.5:18Your wife won't let you.5:19Your kids — how are you going to do it?5:21Your family, your parents won't agree.5:24Your community doesn't agree with you.5:25It's impossible.5:26You're going to be an outcast.5:28You have much more things to lose.5:30It's not good, man.5:32You can't do it.5:33And that's why the pasuk says,5:35what does the nachash tell5:37Chava? He tells her,5:39Hashem said,5:42Lo toklu mikol etz hagan. That's a sheker v'chazav. That's a lie.5:44We all read the Torah and we saw clearly what Hashem told Adam.5:47Hashem told Adam the opposite:5:49Eat from all the trees except for this tree.5:52Look how the nachash presents it to5:55Chava. Maybe we paid attention to this pasuk,5:57maybe we didn't,5:57but look how he presents it.5:58What does he tell her?6:00Yeah, I understand Hashem said you can't eat from all the trees,6:05right?6:07Shoof. That's6:08something—you changed the words.6:09But Chavah didn't realize that.6:11You can do it, basically.6:12It's impossible.6:13How are you going to live without eating any of the trees?6:20Ulay hayta kavanat haBorei shelo tochal me'uma, v'hu davar shemshalamon bo. That's what Nachash is telling her.6:22Yeah, it's one tree, but maybe it's all the trees,6:25because that's what really he meant.6:26This is just an example of all the trees.6:28You can't do that.6:29You can't live your life without eating from any of the trees.6:32You can't live your life without a cell phone.6:34You can't live your life without, you know, just keeping yashan.6:38You can't do that.6:39You can't live your life without covering your hair.6:42You can't live your life with going to classes.6:45You can't live your life with Shabbat,6:47whatever you want, rabotai.6:48You can't live your life without6:51blank—you fill it in.6:52That is the yetzer hara's tactic.6:56V'tomer ha'ishah, p'ri ha'etz hagan nochal. No, no, no, no, no.6:58The woman was sharper,7:00Baruch Hashem. Chavah was sharper than that.7:01She caught his lie right away.7:03But she made the mistake7:06of—when you see a guy is a liar, dump him right away.7:09You caught his lie.7:09But you see, the problem is7:11the yetzer hara doesn't come as a liar,7:13right?7:13Again, it could be in the form of another human being, the7:16yetzer hara, right? So7:16when we know a guy is lying,7:19we drop him right away.7:19Get out of here.7:20You're trying to sketch me.7:20I know you're trying to sketch me.7:21Leave me alone.7:22You're trying to, you know, convince me out against the truth.7:25But over here, the yetzer hara came so innocent.7:28Oh, is that what Hashem said?7:29You can't eat any of the trees?7:31So Chavah took it very innocent.7:34She said, No, that's not what He meant.7:36What Hashem said is7:38that—well, we start defending now, right?7:40We got to defend Hashem, right?7:41What Hashem meant is that7:43we can eat from all the trees except for one tree,7:45and therefore,7:46im ken hu7:46davar shemshalamon bo. Yeah, it's possible.7:48I can live without eating one tree.7:49That's not a big deal.7:51So what does the yetzer hara now try to do?7:54Oof,7:55now he comes with the other...8:00Tactic. So pasuk later on says,8:05when Nachash tells Chava, lo mot temutun, you can eat from it, you won't die.8:07What are you talking about? You won't die.8:16Pirush, ki ein tavo aleha mit, rak retzon... borei... Hashem doesn't want to kill you.8:19God loves every Jew.8:22You know, you hear that from—you get that from a lot of religious people.8:25God is a good God.8:27God doesn't—He's not a mean God.8:28He doesn't want to harm me.8:30So why did He say don't do it?8:32Ah, He's just, you know, He's trying to protect me,8:34and I don't need protection over here. I'm8:37okay. God loves me,8:38and God loves me, there's no way8:40I'm going to get punished for it8:43because, you know.8:44So these people would rather say that8:47God is so loving,8:50but,8:50you know, He doesn't know what He's talking about.8:53All of a sudden we gave our own...8:54But that's exactly what the yetzer hara does also.8:57Look what he's telling her.9:00V'lachen efchid etchem. Yeah, God loves you. He doesn't want to kill you guys.9:03He's just scaring you.9:08V'zu hi ta'ana shenehsh yetzer hara latot ha'adam miderech hasechel bepirush haTorah, and that is to make a person mistake9:10in how to understand the Torah properly.9:12And therefore,9:16v'od lo heterim v'galuyot panim shelo kahalacha. That's the yetzer hara's other way,9:17is interpreting the Torah,9:18and it's unbelievable.9:20For those who are listening to us,9:22I mean, I don't know, Baruch Hashem, the link went to a bunch of people,9:24and I don't know where this recording is going to go,9:26but I'm assuming the9:28most people that listen to us are Orthodox9:30because they want to grow and they want to understand more.9:32I'm sure you've heard from people that are not religious9:34the statement of,9:36God doesn't care if you eat lard or not.9:39God loves you,9:41right?9:42But the Torah says He can't. No, that's not what it means.9:44You know,9:45I remember hearing from9:47a big kiruv guy, and he says9:50he once had a, you know, somebody once brought him head to head9:52against a Reform.9:53He doesn't want to talk with the Reform rabbi,9:56but the Reform rabbi was saying that,9:58yeah. No, there's no problem with homosexuality from the Torah.10:01Says, what do you mean? The Torah says10:03mefurash. No, Rabbi,10:04that's not what it means.10:05It means this.10:07This is crazy, right?10:09Who are you? You don't know how many10:12perushim there are in the Torah.10:14You don't know what the words of the Torah mean,10:15and you come tell me what Hashem means?10:17You tell me what the Torah shebaal peh means?10:19You don't know what a masechet looks like.10:21You tell me what it means?10:22But that's what happens.10:24And it's always the people who are less learned10:25that come and make their own interpretations.10:27But don't think the yetzer hara is only for10:29amei haaretz. Yetzer hara is for all gedolim, right?10:32For us, all of a sudden we start squeezing out heterim,10:35right?10:36No, we start coming out with different heterim.10:38We start coming to interpret the Torah10:40not the way it's meant to be interpreted.10:42We start to interpret the halacha10:47not10:51the way it's meant to be interpreted.10:53And that's exactly what the yetzer hara tells them.10:56Don't think when Hashem meant10:57that you're going to die,10:58it means you're going to die physically.11:00It means it's a spiritual weakening.11:02That's all,11:03and you're okay. You can handle it.11:04You don't need that.11:06And that is the second approach of the11:08yetzer hara. He starts to give us different commentaries11:11on our obligations.11:12So once we got the skills,11:15rabotai, go out and fight the war,11:17fight the battle.11:18You know the11:19yetzer hara. If you hear such a thing in your head,11:21understand where it's coming from11:22and know what you have to do.11:24Maybe you need some little more chizuk.11:26Come back and listen to this audio11:27when you get to such a position. Baruch... amen.