Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 4, Lesson 19Sefer Even ShelemaPart 74Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:11Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:05Perek daled, ot tet-vav. Ha'adam nichshal ba'aveirah mipnei shnei devarim. A person usually stumbles in the sin because of two reasons.0:11Number one, shehu kaves ha'aveirot asher dimeh lo aveirah lifa'amim sheheim mitzvah. That what happens is that he's blinded, that he thinks sometimes that what he's doing is actually a mitzvah, when in fact it's really an0:26aveirah. Or, again, the same idea, he's misled that, you know, he's been doing it for so long and so often that he thinks what he's doing is really mutar,0:39but he doesn't know that it's just an aveirah that's repeated over and over and over again.0:43Kind of like, I had a friend one time, he was once saying a story, and one of the stories, like, wow, wow, like really, like hard to0:52believe. So one of the guys, you know, a bunch of guys are listening to him saying this story, it's very interesting, the way he's saying it.0:57So the one guy goes, Really? That really happened to you? He says, Yeah.1:00Then he stops, and he says, You know, I'm not sure actually, but I've been saying this for so long, you know, that I believe it now.1:10Right? It can be even with a story. Maybe it was shaken the first time he said it,1:14right? And you know you're exaggerating, but after you say it for so long, you really believe that this is really what happened.1:19Kav hachomer when things happen, what people now refer to as minhag.1:24Chas v'shalom, I'm not against minhagim, but I am going to tell you, though, that a lot of minhagim are, you know, based on nothing,1:33right? Not a lot, but there's enough out there.1:35And certainly some minhagim that are aveirot, and people will come tell you, It's our minhag.1:39Why do people think it's our way? Because like we just said, people are doing it. That's what the Gemara says.1:42You do it often, often, often again, you think it's mutar.1:45Not chas v'shalom that you know that's wrong and I'm repeating it.1:48You've just been doing it so often, you must, it's got to be1:51emet. Next, number two. Why do people do1:55aveirot? Pa'amim sheha'adam yodea shehi aveirah chamurah. A person knows this is a terrible sin,1:59v'harita mara kel'anah, and I know I'm going to suffer tremendously for this,2:01not only in olam haba but even2:05in olam hazeh. Rak she'i efshar lo leparen mechibat po'alei aven. I just can't leave alone the2:12aveirah. Hi azah k'mavet ahavatam. Now why can't I leave2:13the aveirah? Because the people that push me towards the aveirah... Or, I can't leave them.2:19I'm part of a group. I'm part of a society. I'm part of people like that,2:23and I can't leave it.2:25And the love and the attachment that he has towards them is very strong.2:31Or, shekasheh lo lenazem et ha'aveton, or you can't leave the taava. This is what we call addictions.2:34Every addiction is the same thing. You can't leave it.2:36You know it's damaging. You know it's2:38damaging. One of the biggest problems when you speak to people addicts is trying to convince them.2:44They know. They know.2:46It's very, very difficult to leave.2:48And that's, you know, something I've been researching now about internet and the digital world,2:52and if you think about it so much, how much we're really attached to all these things.2:57And whatever, there's a lot to talk about in this area.3:00This is like an area I've been researching for hours and hours and hours for months at a3:05time. So, b'ezrat Hashem, it's a different discussion.3:07But that's exactly what he's telling over here.3:09Very, very difficult to leave because you're attached, you're locked into it.3:14V'zehu shekatuv, and that's why David HaMelech says, what does he say?3:21Lev tahor bera li Elokim, Hashem, create for me a heart that's pure,3:28v'ruach nachon chadesh b'kirbi, and a correct spirit renew within me.3:32What's going on over here?3:33Why is he asking for two things?3:35Why is he asking for a pure heart3:39and a ruach nachon and a correct spirit?3:42Right, what is he saying?3:45Says the Ibn Shlema, lev tahor, hu... lev tahor is the second type,3:48right?3:49Give me a pure heart because of the sin of3:51avirah. I can't let go of the3:52avirah. I can't let go of the people.3:53Give me a new heart.3:54Give me new desires.3:55A heart usually, we know, is always associated in Torah with desire.3:59Give me new desires.4:00I don't want these desires.4:01I don't want to be attached to my phone.4:03I don't want to be attached to...4:07I don't want to be attached to all the other addictions out there, to the cigarettes.4:11כמו שנאמר, טהור מקלדיקה טמא. Chazal tell us a famous statement: whenever you see4:13tahor, it is tamei. As it says,4:16... tahor. ... can become tamei, right?4:19And Chazal explain because it was moved,4:21right? So always tahor means there was4:23tamei. Lev tahor... Please, Hashem,4:26I don't want these desires.4:30V'ruach nachon hu hefech. What's ruach nachon?4:31Ruach nachon is a spirit.4:34Spirit is more spiritual,4:36right? That's the4:39de'ot hakozvot, the lies that we live with,4:41the lies that we live with,4:42that we think this is correct,4:44this is the right thing to do.4:45It's our minhag,4:46or I'm blinded by it,4:47I really think it's a mitzvah.4:50V'zehu she'omrim, and this is also what we say in our prayer,4:58v'taher libeinu l'ovdecha be'emet. Okay,5:00I'm sorry, sorry for just, you know, showing off my chazanut a little bit.5:04Purify our hearts5:05to serve You in truth.5:07Again, you see the double language over here.5:10Purify our hearts.5:11Once you purify hearts, obviously you're going to serve in truth.5:13Or, let us serve You5:15be'emet. What's purifying?5:16Right?5:17He explains,5:17ha-levenu hu neged lev tahor. Ha-levenu is the desires.5:21Give me desires.5:21Let me attach myself to good things.5:24U'la'avdecha be'emet, and to serve You truthfully,5:28hu hefech hada'atot. Again, it's truthfully,5:31right?5:31Don't live a lie,5:33and that's a very, very important thing.5:35V'zehu shekatuv, here we go,5:36another proof5:37from what it says5:40in Tehillim, Zivchei. Yes, that's how you read it,5:42zivchei, right?5:42There's a5:43ma'amid, and there's also a thing,5:45what's called the5:49ta'am. Zivchei Elokim ruach nishbarah. And here's another thing.5:50This is one of the hardest pesukim to read,5:52because you ever read it:5:55Zivchei Elokim ruach nishbarah. That's not5:56nishbarah, because the ta'am is also on the resh.5:58That's Sefardim; Ashkenazim can say whatever you want.6:07Zivchei Elokim ruach nishbarah, lev nishbar v'nikeh, Elokim lo tibzeh. The zivchei Elokim, the slaughterings of Hashem,6:10what's considered a korban6:12that a person, a sacrifice a person can bring to Hashem,6:15is ruach6:17nishbarah, is a spirit that's broken.6:21Lev nishbar v'nikeh, Elokim lo tibzeh. A heart that's broken, Hashem doesn't.6:23Again,6:24why two things?6:25There's a ruach6:26and there's a lev over here,6:27and it's exactly what we're saying.6:29The ruach is corresponding to the spirit of the time,6:33what people, you know, are into,6:35right?6:36And there are a lot of people that are into things,6:38and a lot of them think this is true,6:40and it's very hard to tell people,6:42Hey, wake up.6:43This is not6:44really—this is not emet. This is not the right way to live.6:47What do you mean?6:47Everybody's doing it.6:48It's got to be mutar.6:49And we get blind because everybody's doing it.6:52And then lev nishbar is, like we said,6:53is the desires.6:55It's the same idea.6:57U'lehishta'areh ani me'elu. We told you the problem.7:00We got to tell you a solution.7:04Says the Gra, for these two things,7:07the medicine for it,7:08or the surgery sometimes for some people that need it,7:12right, is what?7:13Musar and7:15tochachah. What does that mean?7:16What's musar and7:17tochachah? We assume always7:18musar is a study of musar,7:20and that is in itself,7:24mevakeach, it clarifies to us7:26what's right and what's wrong.7:27But that's not what it means in the literal sense.7:30Musar is from the word7:33yissurin, sufferings,7:33right?7:34Now, sufferings doesn't have to be rolling in snow,7:37right,7:38or jumping in7:40or running on hot coals,7:42okay?7:43What suffering means,7:48in the beginning7:50a person has to inflict himself7:52with things that break his desires to completely—8:00To remove himself,8:02kind of like a diet.8:04Anybody who goes on a real, real diet8:06will know that in the beginning8:07it's so, so hard.8:08My wife was just telling me recently,8:10I said, you know,8:12shovevim, I'm gonna quit, I'm gonna stop.8:14I've been overeating.8:16I gained so much weight,8:17and I need to let it go, right?8:19And I always say, I'm gonna go exercise,8:21because when I was young, that's what I did.8:22I exercised, I was always in8:23shape, and I ate like crazy.8:25I didn't care what I ate, right?8:26We think the way we were when we were 148:29is the same way we're gonna be when we're 74.8:31It's always gonna be the same.8:32My body's always the same.8:33It's not true.8:34And one of the main reasons is because,8:35first of all, we're not as active as much,8:36and even if we do work out,8:38at the end of the day,8:39we're not, you8:40know, the body needs to eat.8:41We can't just eat whatever we8:42want. We have to cut down what we eat,8:44but that's very hard to do, right?8:46To stop eating the food that you're usually accustomed to,8:49it's very, very hard,8:49especially if you're taking less8:51and you need energy in the day,8:53it's very, very difficult, right?8:55So I tried it yesterday for a day.8:56I said, I can't, I'm fainting.8:58She's like, yeah, I went through the same stage8:59about a week or two later.9:02Not only would you get used to it,9:04but you'll have more energy than without it, right?9:08So that's even on a diet, a physical thing.9:11That's when you break any9:13taavah, right? Over there,9:13so you're doing it for whatever reason, for health reasons,9:15but when we do it for anything, any desire,9:17any aveirah that you're used to,9:18it's gonna be so difficult to let go.9:21I can't answer back that text.9:24I'm so used to it. I'm the news guy.9:26I'm the one who always forwards in the community news to everybody.9:30And I will have fans waiting for me, right?9:33People are addicted to, like, their Twitters,9:34and everybody's listening.9:35Everybody's waiting for me to say something, right?9:38It's gonna be very difficult to me.9:39That's called9:40mussar. That's a yisurim. It's a suffering, if you think about it.9:44It's a suffering to hold back.9:48Like it says,9:50Get the yetzer tov to go.9:51You take offense.9:53Don't wait for the yetzer hara to attack.9:54You take offense,9:55and you let him fight against the9:58yetzer hara. And that's what we mean9:59when we say musar.10:02V'achach, after that difficult period,10:04or the initial period10:06of fighting the yetzer hara, battling10:07and really going through, it's going to be hard.10:09Like we said to everybody,10:11you know, we always give the mashal of diets and everything,10:14because we know it's very, very—10:15that's a simple thing that we could all relate to.10:18We all tried it, and we know how difficult it is,10:20right?10:21But he says afterwards,10:26then you have to look into your10:28deeds and see what brings you to such10:30aveirot, and to see where,10:32you know—10:33we know what the problems are,10:34but now what's causing me to come to these problems?10:37And that's called10:40tokhachah. Because, ma shelo piresh megilui hara, lo ya'aleh lo tokhachah. If you don't stop the bad habits that you have,10:44all the tokhachah in the world10:45will not help you.10:46Oh, yeah, this is right.10:48No, you got to first stop. You got to first stop.10:51Yes, you can learn about it a lot.10:53Learning that Torah will help you,10:55will give you the energy to fight the10:56yetzer hara. But if you don't start— start,10:59excuse me— if you don't start pulling away11:01from the11:02yetzer hara, all the tokhachah will not help you,11:04because it's, you know it,11:06you know, you just need to start.11:07That's how you got to start working on it.