Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 4, Lesson 16Sefer Even ShelemaPart 71Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:44Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:02Eben Shelema, perek dalet, ot yud gimel. Now we're going to see something amazing. It's always amazing. I always begin like that,0:07amazing, but he said, no, I'm really—this is becoming one of my favorite, favorite books,0:12especially a lot of these things I've heard also as I was starting to become more and more learned,0:19and I've heard a lot of these things randomly from different people,0:21and it's so nice to see the source of all these things, and most of them are accurate.0:26Okay, let's begin. Perek dalet, ot yud gimel. He says over here0:33in the Eben Shelema, רוב המינים והחוטאים בן אדם למקום. Most of the minim—minim are the people who don't believe,0:38like we could say kofrim. There's different explanations of what a min is,0:42but pashut pshat is kofer either b'Torah shebe'al peh or kofer b'divrei chachamim, right?0:47But people who are0:50non-believers, v'hachot'im, or any sinners, ben adam laMakom. As we all know, you could steal from people, right? You could rob people,0:57you could hate people, and you could do aveirot that are ben adam1:04lachaveiro. And then there's aveirot ben adam laMakom, which means kefirah, like this is what we're talking about.1:09Most of these people that are in the category of ben adam laMakom, listen to this powerful, amazing statement:1:17הם לפי הנראה טובים בטבע. When you see them to the regular naked eye, they're good-natured people.1:23They're good people.1:28וזו היא אחת מתחבולות היצר. And why are they good people, then such nice people? He's the best guy.1:33He gives you help. He helps you. Why?1:36This is one of the ways of the1:44yetzer hara, לפרוש רשת לפני תועה רוח למשוך אחריהם. He puts out his trap. For people to go and pulled after them.1:50It's an amazing statement. You hear that? That,1:53you know how many times you talk about people, this guy is a rasha, he's kofer, he's mechalel Shabbat2:00b'farhesia. But he's the nicest guy. Anybody goes to him, he helps them out with money.2:05He's baal chesed, harbeh, right? And he's the sweetest, the kindest person.2:12He won't hurt a fly, literally. I killed a fly today. It was annoying us.2:16He won't do that. He'll take the fly, feed it, and send it outside,2:20right? That's an amazing thing.2:23But says the Gra, you know why? Because that's part of the yetzer hara also.2:28And it's amazing, we find that, and people always complain,2:31the more the religious people are, there's always more fighting.2:34They always complain, but there's always arguments.2:37And the reason is because the yetzer hara knows how to play his game in every single one.2:41And being that people get impressed by, you know, how you behave towards them2:48on an emotional level, on a personal level, and the kefirah is not something so visible,2:53that's why the yetzer hara knows how to get them.2:56And that's why the Nimshach after those people. Wow, it's a powerful2:59statement. You want to see it now inside.3:05You know what, before we continue, before we continue, sorry,3:08this is just like a runoff on the last3:09statement. Look at chav zayin all the way on the bottom,3:17Ha'arot b'iurim. Ha'arat haRav haMechaber. However, now this is what the Gra says.3:20Now, the Even Shelemah, the author of the Even Shelemah, who was, we said his name from the3:25beginning, Rabbi Maltzan, okay, this is the person who organized everything together.3:32On the bottom, he doesn't stick on top anything that's his personal.3:36He only quotes the Gra. He summarizes the Gra,3:38but he doesn't stick his own personal opinion. But he writes on the bottom his own personal opinion.3:42He writes the following words:3:45ולהפך מתלמידי חכמים. But we were just saying right now,3:47but תלמידי חכמים is the exact opposite.3:53היצר מתגרה יותר. But the תלמידי חכמים, the yetzer hara is always instigating fights.3:56כדי להרחיק מהם. Why? Because he wants you to go away from3:59them. He wants you to stay away from4:00them. So a guy goes to a talmid... I know a lot of people, they go sometimes to4:04תלמידי חכמים. He wasn't nice to me.4:06He didn't give me kavod,4:08and they get so offended.4:09I go to this other guy that you claim is not religious,4:13he's, you know, all hefker and everything else,4:15and he's so sweet.4:17Tefadel, how are you? How's everything?4:19How's your family? How's your wife? How are your kids?4:22And what about your grandchildren? He knows their names.4:26And then you go to the gadol,4:27okay, gives me4:29mussar, right? Why? That's it. It's not awesome.4:32He wants them to distance each other. He distances them from each other.4:36Now, we'll stop over here.4:38Ad kan. We'll come back and we'll see it more later,4:41im yirtzeh Hashem, we'll come back. I want to show you now, let's go to the4:43Gra and see the source and the words of the Gra.4:46The pasuk,4:49the Gra's פירוש is from the pasuk in4:52Mishlei. The pasuk says like this:5:00בְּפֶה חָנֵף יְשַׁחִת רֵעֵהוּ, וּבְדַעַת צַדִּיקִים יֵחָלֵצוּ. With a mouth that's5:02chanef. Chanef is usually a hypocrite.5:04A hypocrite, a chanef by definition is not a5:07chanifu. The sort of chanifah means that you show approval of something5:12when inside you don't approve of something.5:14That means basically you're5:15two-faced. A person who's chanuf is you're thinking one way,5:19but you're speaking something else,5:21right?5:21So for us, when, for example,5:23if Rasha comes and tells you,5:25all of a sudden he starts making fun of5:28all takanot Chazal, all this,5:29you know, once had such a thing, right?5:32I went to some random doctor for something,5:34to check up something.5:34It was like a specialist or whatever.5:37So he's Jewish,5:38and he found out, I guess he's like,5:40so what do you do?5:41He found out that I learn5:42in kollel. I usually don't reveal that I'm a rabbi.5:43I just say, you know, I learn5:45in kollel. Oh, you're one of those.5:46All of a sudden he closes the door.5:49His face turns.5:50He starts giving me a whole5:52mussar against the takanot of5:54chachamim. He says, If Moshe Rabbeinu would have been around,5:57he would go crazy on them.5:59He knows what Moshe Rabbeinu would have wanted,6:01you know what I'm saying?6:03So then I asked him one simple question.6:05He didn't know how to answer.6:05He got all nervous and upset.6:08He started yelling at me.6:09I said, Okay, I'm gonna keep my mouth shut.6:10I was tired6:12of that. I said, I just want to get out of here.6:13I don't6:15have time for this.6:17But it's funny,6:18like, they all contradict themselves,6:20you know, within the same... that's a different class.6:21But anyway, so6:23he started to give me a whole different thing, right?6:26So if I would have heard it from the beginning,6:28and I say, you know, listen,6:29this is my doctor.6:30I don't go to him.6:30Happens I don't go to him all the time.6:31I just went to him one time in my life.6:32But let's say I go to him all the time.6:33All of a sudden I hear these6:35kefirah, and I say, Yeah, you're right,6:36you're right.6:36That's6:38asur. That's6:38asur. That's asur of6:40hanifah. For I don't want to get involved.6:42Say, Okay, whatever you like.6:44That's6:46not hanifah. Whatever you like.6:47I'm not agreeing with6:48him. Whatever you like.6:49First I say, Yeah, you're right.6:50I agree with you 100%.6:52Yeah, and then I,6:53Yeah, the terrible those rabbis.6:55Oh, the Gemara is full of nonsense.6:57Now meanwhile, inside, the guy is an idiot.6:58He doesn't know what he's talking about.7:00That's7:01asur. That's7:03asur hanifah. So, but we got the idea of what the definition of hanifah is.7:05So pasuk says,7:07With the mouth that's7:10chanef, you destroy your friend.7:12A guy destroys his friend.7:15With the knowledge of the7:17tzaddikim, they get saved.7:18Comes the Gra, and we always know in his7:20peirush, it's amazing that every verb7:22has a specific kavanah why it was used.7:25So he says, What's7:29mashhit? Mashchit nikra ba'averot shebein adam laMakom. Mashchit refers to averot7:32between Hashem and between adam7:34laMakom. Between adam7:34laMakom, the category is between man and Hashem.7:37How do we know?7:37Pasuk says,7:40Shishchit et Yisrael avihem shebashamayim. When it talks about the famous rasha,7:43Yeravam ben7:45Nevat, that was considered the worst of the worst,7:47ein lo chelek l'olam haba. Why?7:48Chazal use the word,7:51shishchit et Yisrael avihem shebashamayim. He destroyed the Jewish people from their Father.7:54What's destroyed?7:55Destroyed means7:56he killed. No,7:57hashchit is used, v'tashchit ha'aretz lifnei Elokim.8:01Right? Ben adam laMakom, averot specifically bein Hashem to Makom, that is the word8:11mashchit. What's written, Noef ishah, chaser lev, mashchit nafsho hu ya'asenah. A person who goes and he's noef ishah, he's with a woman — that's not his wife, obviously8:17— is chaser lev, mashchit nafsho hu ya'asenah, a person who wants to destroy his soul, right?8:23What does it mean, destroy soul? It's the same idea.8:25Mashchit is used to disconnect between Hashem and the human being,8:32and the people, whatever it may be.8:33So now, let's come back to the8:34pasuk. The pasuk says,8:37Befeh hanef yashchit re'ehu. We're talking about disconnecting between Hashem and a human being.8:44Says the Gra, habaladiachu bepeh hanef. A person who comes to push away a guy from Hashem,8:47it's done usually bepeh hanef. What does it mean? With a mouth that's hypocrite,8:55right? He's not coming to tell him,8:56Stay away from Hashem, He's terrible.8:58No, that's not how9:00he does it.9:01He does it calm. He brings him, he's a nice guy,9:03he draws him close to him,9:05because he knows that if he doesn't do it this way,9:08he's not going to be able to be successful.9:12Lachen, rov haminim tovim beteva. It's an amazing statement.9:14Most of the apikorsim are good-natured people.9:17They're good people at heart,9:20at least people — they call them,9:21I don't want to say good people at9:22heart, they're not good people at heart,9:22they're terrible9:23resha'im — but they're nice people.9:24They try to help,9:27right? I mean, we look at even in our own times,9:30the people who are, you know, like always,9:34you know, pro-Jewish, whether it's in Congress or in the Senate9:37or even the Israeli Knesset,9:39all these people, and they are, you know, they're fighting for the Jews.9:43Meanwhile, look how they treat Shabbat.9:45Look how they talk about Torah.9:47Look how they talk about all these things.9:52V'lachen rov haminim tovim b'lev, ki gonev lev re'ehu u'mashchit oto, because that's part of the trick.9:54I don't know if they realize that this is why they're doing it.9:59It's yetzer hara making them extra nice,10:02so this way people can't figure out the true colors.10:12וְזֶהוּ בְּפֶה חֲנֵפוּת שֶׁהִתְרָאֲהוּ, עַל יְדֵי פֶּה חֲנֵפוּת שֶׁהִתְרָאֲהוּ. רַק הַצַּדִּיקִים שֶׁעוֹסְקִים תָּמִיד בְּעֶבְדוַת ה' וְיודְעִים דַּרְכֵי ה'. But the pasuk, what does it say?10:17וְדַע צַדִּיקִים יַחֲלֵצוּ. With tzaddikim, the people are always saying10:18dvar Hashem, and they know exactly clear what's right and what's wrong.10:26הֵם מַכִּירִים פִּתּוּיו שֶׁדִּבְרֵי הַשָּׂרִים מִדִּבְרֵי ה'. They recognize right away what the guy is all about,10:29and they realize they could catch the guy,10:31that he's not going away from divrei Hashem,10:35and they could save themselves.10:41וּמְבִינִים שֶׁמַּה שֶּׁמְּדַבֵּר דְּבָרִים טוֹבִים, מוּחָנֵף וּמַחְמַד זֶה יַחֲלֵצוּ. And they realize the fact is extra nice,10:46yetzer hara over here. Wow. Yetzer hara. It's amazing, by the way.10:48I don't have time to go through stories of gedolim,10:50and sometimes when you hear people,10:52they come out and it sounds so impressive.10:54Things—gedolim came out and said, No, stay away.10:57One particular story that sticks to mind:10:58I was young and foolish.11:00Now I'm just old and foolish,11:01so one thing changed, baruch Hashem.11:02Hopefully we'll get to the second part.11:04So one time when I was in yeshiva,11:06they made a big march in Washington,11:09D.C. There was things going on in11:11Israel, and they made a big march,11:13good,11:13and they said, We're going to make a big march.11:15We want all people to attend,11:17everybody to attend this big march,11:19and we're going to go there11:20and we're going to march in Washington,11:22D.C., so this way we show approval to our brethren in Eretz Yisrael,11:26and hopefully the government will, you know, do more for the land of Israel.11:30Great, sounds like a very good idea, right?11:32Our yeshiva wasn't going.11:34I was in yeshiva, and the yeshiva wasn't going.11:37So I personally, you know, it's not like we all had11:41smartphones—anybody had smartphones, right?11:42So I didn't really know the news and whatever.11:44I didn't know what's going on.11:44But there was another guy who happened to be learning in my shiur,11:49and... It's funny, whatever.11:50Okay, this other guy, he made a lot of noise about it,11:54and it made a lot of sense to me.11:56And he says, you know, how come we're not going as a yeshiva?11:59So we went to the Rosh Yeshiva.12:00He says, listen, we heard about this march,12:02but the reason why we're not going is because this march is set up by Reform and Conservative.12:08It's not set up by one of our camps.12:10It's not set up by religious people.12:11So who cares? The reason is good.12:15So the rabbi tried to explain to us,12:17which was very, very immature, we couldn't understand.12:18He's like, there's going to be a lot of things that a yeshiva bachur should not see.12:24And the guy, the other guy, was insistent,12:26no, no, no, no, no, no, no.12:27He said, okay, we got to ask a gadol.12:28They asked a gadol,12:30and they asked Rav Shmuel Kamenetsky,12:32and he said, you know what?12:36Because they're making a lot of noise,12:37there's about two yeshivas12:38also, and they don't understand so much.12:39Okay, the yeshiva should rent a bus.12:42They'll pay for half,12:43and whoever wants to go will pay for the other half,12:46right?12:47And 50, no, 50 seats,12:48and that's it.12:49Whoever wants to go, go for the other half.12:50Good.12:51So I said, you know what?12:52As long as other people are going, I don't have to go because I don't have whatever.12:55They didn't even fill up the bus.12:56I had to end up going.12:57Okay, so I ended up going, whatever.12:58And this guy, of course, from my shiur also went,13:00and he went.13:01Okay, we went there.13:02It was really, you know, very sad to see.13:06I had been in yeshiva then for two years,13:08and I had been out of the community for two years,13:11and I have not seen pritzut for two years.13:14It was horrible.13:15It was the summer,13:16and a lot of girls were supposed to be coming from, you know, let's call them13:21yeshivot, but they're not, you know, mixed yeshivot or whatever.13:22They'll top in yeshivot, modern Orthodox13:24yeshivot, all taking off their shirts and sleeveless and things, dancing, singing.13:28It was really horrible for a yeshiva13:30bachur to see. It was definitely not a sight.13:32But the rabbi picked it up from before.13:34Before we went,13:35he didn't even know,13:36and this never happened before.13:38But he said from the beginning,13:39this is not a thing you should go to.13:41How is he able to read it?13:42Because it depends where he came from.13:43It sounds like it's all good,13:45but it depends where he came from.13:46When we came back,13:48now the guy who made the noise realized that the rabbi was right.13:50We went to the rabbi to speak to him,13:52and he said the following line.13:53He says, because the rabbi that we complained to,13:57he, you know, he came to show support, you know, just because the guys were going,14:01he went also.14:02He went for five minutes,14:03and then he jumped back on the train and went right back.14:07He didn't even go by bus.14:07He jumped on the train back.14:08He said when he was there, he said that he was crying.14:10He was tearing from all what he saw.14:12Like, it's so sad to see such a thing.14:14In any case, but you see the words of the guy,14:17amazing.14:19Tzadikim yachaletu. Tzadikim who know,14:20and they learn Torah, they know exactly how to differentiate between right and wrong.14:24They know also who's coming from.14:25If it's coming from this guy,14:27it can't be good.14:28And us who don't understand,14:30right, and we always look at it,14:31why not?14:32Why not?14:33We can't understand.14:34We can't get an idea.14:35We can't grasp it.14:36We have to know,14:38they can read.14:38They can see clearly between right and wrong.14:40Okay, we'll stop here. Continue.