Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 4, Lesson 15Sefer Even ShelemaPart 70Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:23Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:03Perek dalet ot yud bet. I'm scared to say it's a short piece,0:05but anyway, from the look of the source of the Gra,0:10as we know that when it's otiyot in Rashi, it means it comes from Kabbalah, from Zohar.0:15So let's see what we can do today and how to simplify it and make it, you know, very, very practical on the earth.0:22This is easy. This first part is easy.0:28The Emet L'Yaakov says, Pa'amim yesh tzaddik she'oseh chet gadol. Sometimes we find a tzaddik that does a big, big sin,0:33v'hu bishvil she'musharshet ra'ot b'ma'aseh avotav. Where does that come from?0:34And the answer is, it could be that it's rooted in him from what his ancestors did.0:41You hear that? Actions that we take could be rooted inside of us, and it could pass down to our children.0:47Not that it forces somebody to do something like that,0:50but he has a netiyah more towards that.0:55Or it could be for other reasons,0:57that he himself personally was in a previous gilgul in that same situation,1:03and that's why he's more leaning towards it.1:04This is a famous Gra, which we'll discuss probably later,1:07perekim, we'll talk more about gilgulei neshamot and everything else,1:12that there's a famous Gra that we're going to see,1:15that a person who wants to know what he used to be in his previous gilgul,1:20watch what you're leaning towards to more,1:24right? If you have a certain aveirah that's pulling you, or a certain thing, a certain yetzer hara that you're battling with constantly,1:30you know, wherever you turn, you're always confronting that.1:33You know, I remember a person that had a social issue, couldn't get along with people1:39from when he was a kid until even much later on,1:44and it always resurfaced. No matter what situation he found himself in,1:47and he changed many, many times, and it always resurfaced.1:50He get married, it comes up again and again.1:53Wherever you turn, it's always there.1:54That's a very clear indication of something that you came to be1:58metaken, which the Gra says that was what you had an issue with in your previous gilgul.2:02Let's see the Gra, which comes really from the Tikkunei Zohar.2:08Ready? Says the Tikun says the following words:2:11Amar lei, im ken dekorbana d'Hebel itkabal, if you want to tell me that the korban of Hevel was accepted,2:21if Hevel's korban was duly accepted, as it says in the pasuk,2:25why did Kayin have the ability to kill2:30Hevel? Amar lei, he answers, in Zohar it says, hacha vadai raza ila'a. This is a very big secret.2:42D'ihu hava darga d'etz hadaat tov v'ra, d'havei. He was on the level of etz hadaat tov v'ra, where he is chayav in it.2:51Uv'ma d'have, kabil onshei b'hai alma, and since he is chayav in it, that's why he received this punishment in this world.2:58Uvahu korbana itkabil minei, histezim onshei d'hu alma. However, his korban allowed Hevel to be saved from the onesh of the future world,3:06the trei onshei, because a person when he does aveirah, he's really chayav in two punishments:3:12חד לעילא, one in olam haba, which is called Gan Eden really,3:16or all these things, v'chad l'tata, and one in this world.3:18Had hu d'chtiv, this is what it means,3:22'ki v'yom acholcha mimenu mot tamut.' That's why there's a double language,3:25mot and tamut. There's mita in this world and mita also in the world of Gan Eden.3:31Amar lei, v'ha Adam d'have hai ilana. He says, whoa, whoa, what are you bringing Hevel and3:34Kayin? Hevel and Kayin didn't do anything, right?3:36It was really Adam. How do you show it was3:41chayav? Amar lei, obda d'abuha valei umet. It's because of what his father did, and that's why he died from it.3:46Amar lei, ki b'yom acholcha mimenu ketiv. What do you mean? The pasuk says—3:49The conversation was between Hashem and Adam,3:52and He told Adam, the day you eat from it, you'll die.3:55On that day he looked and he died.3:59What does that mean? We can see this soon,4:02but just keep that in mind. This is what the Zohar says.4:03Now keep in mind, whoever is listening to this4:06and you're not familiar with the Zohar,4:08the Zohar is very, very deep.4:09You need to really understand what he really means,4:11and you can't bring contradictions from the Zohar to Gemara and things,4:15because they really, they both are saying different,4:18you know, they're giving you different angles.4:20And this is a Kabbalistic angle,4:22which needs really, really... And if this bothers you,4:25stop the recording here, stop the audio here and go on.4:28But this is something deeper than the regular4:30pshat. We'll get to it, and Bezrat Hashem we'll explain.4:32Let's just finish the Zohar.4:35אמר רבי שמעון, בגין דא כתיב. Because of this it says, יש הבל אשר נעשה על הארץ. שלמה המלך says,4:40הבל. There's nonsense that we see that happens on the world, in this world,4:46אשר יש צדיקים שמגיע אליהם כמעשה הרשעים. We find tzaddikim that receive the same thing as the4:52reshaim. ואחרת רשע וטוב לו. Says the Zohar over here, is the remez of the famous, famous question4:56that bothered Moshe Rabbeinu4:58and bothers every single human being throughout all of history.5:01Why do we find that there's a righteous person5:05that his life is, he suffers in his life,5:08and why do we find that there's wicked people that have a good in their lives?5:15צדיק ורע לו, אחרת רשע וטוב לו. A person who's a tzaddik and goes through difficulty in his life,5:20we see it over here in this pasuk as a5:23remez, like it says,5:27צדיקים שמגיע אליהם כמעשה הרשעים. ודא רזא. And here's the secret:5:45דצדיק דא ארעא לקי כמעשה הרשעים, לאו דהוא רשע ולא בן רשע, אלא כמעשה הרשעים דחייבא עובדא דחייבא דינון, סמכמין מנחש עירא לעובדא דלהון, ואיהו רזא פוקד עוון אבות על בנים. The reason is because the5:49ma'aseh harsha'im, not that he's a rasha, but there was an action that was a5:52resha'ut, which means there was a sin that was done that he was guilty for it,5:56which came from his ancestors, and basically it caught up with him.6:05And because of the famous statement of6:09ma'aseh avothem bidehem, the ma'aseh of their parents is by them,6:12that's why it causes mita, v'katav Rabbeinu.6:14Comes now the Gra and explains what the Zohar really means.6:21And that's what it means.6:34Sometimes the parents are the ones who do the sin,6:37and it causes that this enclosing of a sin comes and encloses also on their children.6:47It's not that, chas v'shalom, that he has to sin that6:50way. It just6:52becomes—it's kind of like, you know how we inherit things from our parents.6:56We inherit the way we look from our parents.6:59We inherit their money.7:02We inherit a lot of things we inherit from our parents.7:05Same thing, the ma'asim that our parents do,7:07or the ma'asim that we do,7:09we also give it over to our children.7:13This is why,7:15hazal, you married a woman, before you want to marry a woman,7:18check out her brothers.7:20Why?7:22Because as we know,7:23you want to know where the fruit is,7:25look where it came from, which tree it came from.7:27So the same thing,7:28you want to know about the ladies,7:30you know, more7:32maris, they don't do things,7:32look at her brothers,7:34because what her brothers are,7:36it's a big indication of what she is also,7:38because they came from the same thing,7:40they came from the same father,7:41they came from the same parents.7:44So that's one way7:45where a person seems to do7:47aveirot. He says,7:49I'm such and such, I'm so careful.7:50Why am I being pulled towards7:52this aveirah? The answer is7:53because of your ancestors that had7:55this aveirah in their genes,7:56in their spiritual genes,7:57and it transferred.8:00Over to you. Again, I want to emphasize, even according to the Kabbalah and Zohar, and according to the8:04Gra, this does not mean a person is chayav to do the8:07aveirah. It just says he has more of a challenge in this area because of what his ancestors did.8:13But he has the ability and he has the choice to overcome it, which is harder than most regular people.8:18Next, it says also,8:22another reason why a person who maybe is a tzaddik,8:25that he finds himself, you know, a very, very difficult time overcoming8:30his yetzer hara is because in his original gilgul he was8:33nichshal. It's interesting that we're looking today in the days of baalei8:37teshuvah, and we see that people who lived a certain lifestyle,8:40even though they switch over and become religious,8:43they still have those challenges,8:46you know, when they come across them again8:48in their life. Let's say people are very, very into music, right?8:51So I used to be very, very into music and non-Jewish music also.8:54So you're not supposed to listen to8:56non-Jewish music; it leads you towards all those things.8:58So as much as, Baruch Hashem, I stopped for many, many years, I don't listen to it,9:01sometimes you walk into a store and they're playing those good old,9:05you know, the oldies, what they call them.9:07For me it was like, you know, that's the last song I've been listening to, right?9:10But boom, it takes you right back.9:12It's very hard.9:13But I haven't been listening, but, you know, the lifestyle that I chose then,9:18it comes back and it affects you, right?9:20So the same thing, the lifestyle that we chose in our previous gilgul,9:25it may have went away with that person,9:27but the neshamah was affected from it,9:30and that's why when we come in this gilgul, it still affects us.9:32Where does that come from?9:33It comes from the following piece of the9:37Gra, and he says, he quotes it from the peirush on Yonah.9:40The Gemara says like this:9:45Is it better for a person to have been created or not?9:48Would have been better off for a human being to have not been created.9:51So the Gemara comes down and says,9:53really, it would have been preferable, preferable, excuse me, for a person that he should never have been created.9:59However, now that he has been created,10:04let him at least search his actions and, you know, do the best of what he can do.10:10So comes the Gemara and says,10:14How can the Gemara say that it's better a person should not have been created?10:17Why? Hashem didn't know that?10:19So if it's better that a person should never have been created,10:21why Hashem created him?10:23Also, the Gemara is saying like a10:25bediavad. Oh, now that he's created,10:27also it's very hard, asks the10:28Gra. Also, what does it mean,10:31yefashpesh, right?10:31It should have said10:33ya'avor Hashem. Now that he created, serve Hashem.10:34What does it mean,10:37yefashpesh ma'asav? Ela, comes the Gemara, comes the Gra and says a beautiful explanation that sheds so much light on this Gemara.10:45The nechloku b'shuv ela gilgul ha'sheni. The Gemara was not discussing if a person should be created or not.10:49Of course Hashem created human10:50beings. Of course that's v'ya Hashem ki tov. Of course that's a good thing for a human being to be created.10:55The machloket in the Gemara was regarding if a person comes back in gilgul,10:58is it better that person be created in the second gilgul or not,11:02or better off not?11:03So Gemara comes down and says,11:05well, if you say that it's good that he was created11:09because he keeps saying he can do more11:12mitzvot, but if you say that's not good because he's going to mess up again,11:15and then the Gemara comes down and says11:18better that he was not created because the yetzer11:20hara, referred to the Torah as11:24tushiya, matesh kocho shel adam. It takes away the power of a person. On a good way over here,11:29it takes away the power of the yetzer hara that drives him to do11:34aveirot. And that, he says, we can understand now11:37that Chazal tell us why this rabbi saw a field of11:41chardal, he saw a field of mustard.11:45Ramzu haKetuvim merirat hayetzer b'ol haTorah. It's coming to tell you,11:47you want to really be immersed in Torah,11:49you want to really get rid of the yetzer hara,11:51look at the field of the11:53chardal. What does the chardal represent?11:55The chardal, you can't eat it like that; it's bitter.11:56The only way is by grinding it,11:59completely breaking it.12:04And it says over there12:07that, what,12:08he saw this big field,12:10and he's telling you that the reason there's also in another Gemara that mentions12:15the arba'im, giruyei, the measurement of forty measurements,12:18because forty is also the number of the12:20mikveh, to tell you that the only way to get rid of the yetzer hara12:23is only when you're completely immersed.12:25So a person shouldn't think that we said,12:27you know, because we came off a statement that we said12:29to get rid of the yetzer hara,12:31you don't really need the tactics if you're fully immersed in Torah.12:34But this is what happens when people learn Torah12:37and they just start,12:38the yetzer hara tells them,12:39You got it.12:40You're the guy. You're the man.12:41Did you hear the12:42gra? The gra says,12:43You got Torah. You don't need to work on it.12:45It tells you, the12:47gra, Be careful. Don't let the yetzer hara do that to you.12:49That's how12:49he starts. So really, really be immersed, to be completely into it.12:53And it doesn't come because you're very smart12:55and you just started learning.12:57You can be very, very smart,12:58and you can grasp concepts of Torah very quickly,13:01and therefore you may be able to cover more pages.13:03It doesn't mean that he's fully immersed in Torah.13:05Fully immersed in Torah means13:06all you have in your life is Torah,13:08and you're completely busy with it,13:11and it doesn't come right away.13:12It comes after years and years and years,13:14and then you could be on that level. Halacha lamaaseh.