Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 3, Lesson 8Sefer Even ShelemaPart 51Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:38Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Yesterday we did part one of Eben Shelema,0:06perek gimmel, ot hei, and today we're going to do part0:08two. Part two today is basically we're going inside the words of the actual,0:11the פירוש of the0:13Gra, and yesterday was a summary, which is the Eben Shelema brings it down.0:17What was yesterday's summary?0:18We said that sometimes people, they might be great0:21tzaddikim and they're doing everything that they're supposed to be doing,0:23yet the mazal looks horrible.0:25And the answer is, like we said, they have some old debts that they have to pay0:28in this world because of, from their previous gilgulim, and Hashem puts them in here.0:34So, you know, even though he does everything right and he's doing whatever he's supposed to do,0:39it's still, that's the way it is.0:40And based on the Zohar, that's what it means, tzaddik v'ra lo,0:43right?0:44And then what happens is that the yetzer hara comes and he plays on the guy,0:48and he tells him, he convinces him to, you know, drop his learning,0:51drop his bitachon Hashem, go do some things either not in the straight way0:55or even get out of kollel and go work. You need to earn parnassah.0:59And then he sees that even though he's working and everything else, he still doesn't have it,1:02and it has nothing to do with his effort.1:04It's only because he's not doing right.1:06So it kind of matches ot dalet, because in ot dalet we were saying1:10how a person puts his full trust in Hashem, Hashem will take care of him.1:14Hashem will send him somebody that needs to take care of him.1:17And you mamash see it in the world. There's some people, even rabbanim,1:19even people, some people have it better than others,1:23where Hashem always has an answer.1:25Yeah, because he married—he came from a poor family.1:28How did he end up marrying a rich family?1:30Hashem took care of him. The guy was serious about his learning.1:32Or you can see other things where you can say,1:34yeah, of course the guy, you know, he could dedicate his full life to Torah1:38because this guy has1:39his schar, has his reward. But how did the schar, his reward, come through?1:42And the answer is, like the Gra says, when a guy dedicates himself1:45and he gets to that level, then Hashem sends him someone.1:48We want to see those words now inside over here in the1:53Gra. And he brings it from his פירוש on Sefer Yonah.1:57We all know the story of Yonah, which we read by Mincha on Yom Kippur.2:01So it says, what's it called, about Yonah,2:06towards the end, he was sitting under a tree, and the tree kind of goes away.2:12Means to say Hashem makes the tree move away, and it was a very hot day,2:15and it was very, very hot for Yonah, and Yonah prays because the sun is hitting2:19him. It was very, very hot for him.2:21It says in the pasuk,2:23וַיְמָן... וַיְהִי לְיוֹנָה, and he got...2:27וַיִתְפַלֵּל אֶל ה'... Comes the Gra, brings a deeper explanation of it.2:30He says, וְהָעִנְיָן, the idea of this is like what the Gemara says in2:39מועד קטן: בני חיי ומזוני לא בזכותא תליא מילתא, אלא במזלא תליא מילתא. The Gemara says that children, a person's children, a person's life, and his mezonot and his2:49parnassah, it's not תלוי on זכות, it's תלוי on his mazal.2:53You see, some people are big tzaddikim, they don't have children,2:56and some people are big reshaim, they have a lot of children,2:58right? You see a person's3:00parnassah. You see people who live long life, short life.3:02You know the classic case is the Arizal,3:05right? Arizal. How old was he when he died?3:11Thirty-nine. The3:14Rama, forty-two, forty-one, right?3:15There's big tzaddikim who died very young.3:17Magen Avraham in his3:19fifties. The Rambam in his sixties, early3:22sixties, right? You see, what do you mean big3:24tzaddikim? I'm telling you huge names over here,3:26huge, big, huge names,3:28and he died so young.3:28The Shach al HaTorah, the Shach—excuse me—the Shach al Shulchan Aruch,3:32in his thirties he died.3:34And first of all, it shocks us,3:36like how could they do so much at such a young age,3:38right?3:38We read their3:39פירושים and we think they were like a hundred when they wrote them,3:42right? But it's not.3:43They died very, very young.3:45How can that be?3:45And the answer is,3:48לא בזכותא תליא מילתא. It's not because of זכות, chas v'shalom, they had any3:50aveirot. It's because these people,3:51Hashem was3:53גוזר. This is3:55במזל תליא מילתא, right?3:59ואמרו: צדיק וטוב לו, וצדיק בן צדיק. And the Gemara also says in4:02Masechet Berachot, how do you find a tzaddik v'tov lo, tzaddik4:04v'ra lo? He says the idea is like this.4:07Kemo shekatuv b'Zohar, ki mi shehaya begilgul rishon ra.4:09Tzaddik v'tov lo, according to the Zohar,4:12doesn't literally mean that the guy's father is actually also a tzaddik.4:15It means, ben tzaddik means previous gilgul.4:19The tzaddik, the father over here4:21that's mentioned,4:22is not talking about, you know, his physical, actual biological father.4:25It's talking about his gilgul4:26rishon. If his gilgul rishon was ra,4:28was a tzaddik ben rasha,4:30and now he's a tzaddik ben rasha,4:33why? The son of a rasha means4:34not that his father was evil,4:35but it means his first gilgul he was a rasha.4:39Therefore Hashem brings him into this world,4:40He brings him in a time when there's a4:44chesaron lebana, when he's born in a certain time of the year4:46where it's under the way down,4:50sheein Hashemesh zoreachat nekdah, where the sun is not shining towards it.4:57Ki kol ma'aseh ha'olam hazeh, hakol meshemesh vare'ach b'kabalatam mehashemesh. All is based on, everything in this world is all based on the sun and the moon5:00and how the moon receives from the sun.5:05Ve'az hu b'chesron kol yamav af al pi shehu tzaddik gamur. And then he's always lacking his whole life,5:07even though right now he's a tzaddik5:10gamur. That's the way it works.5:12Vayechal lo, and the pasuk says about Yonah that he was very upset.5:17Shekina b'anshei Ninveh shezachu l'shnei shulchanot b'chayeihem. He got very upset, Yonah.5:19So let's have to do with Yonah. He says like this:5:21Yonah got very upset.5:22How can it be?5:23These people, the anshei Ninveh,5:25they were zocheh to do teshuvah,5:27and they also had a lot of money and wealth,5:29and they were living, they were having a good life.5:31Vayitpalel Hashem, therefore he prayed to Hashem, because he was5:42lacking. Ki otam shemazlam kasheh vehem dochakim mitasha'ah, v'i efshar sheyeshaneh Hashem et mazalam, notel Hashem mechelko, v'ganazimo v'notel ba'olam hazeh. People who have a certain mazal5:45and they're trying to push Hashem,5:48they're trying to, Come5:48on, I want, I want to push Hashem,5:50so Hashem says,5:50Okay, listen, if you push, you push,5:52you'll get your part.5:53But what are you going to do?5:54I have to borrow from5:55somewhere. There's only a certain thing.5:56So I take from what you actually earned,6:00l'olam haba, in Gan Eden, and I give it over to you6:04in olam hazeh. V'sameach me'od shehigialta avato, and he got very happy6:05that he got what he wanted.6:11V'achar kach notel oshro, v'hu piresh min haTorah, v'oshro lo amad lo, v'nish'ar keriach, mikam v'kam. But unfortunately,6:12what happens is he takes his part,6:14he loses his part.6:15And what happens when he loses his6:17spot? He wants6:18to ta'avot. Guess what?6:19He ends up getting these6:21ta'avot that actually pull him away more from the Torah,6:23so he ends up losing in this world, the Torah,6:26and he gets6:26Olam Haba. He already ate it up6:28because he wasn't supposed to get it,6:29and he just got it6:30because he kept on pressing Hashem for it.6:37איתא בגמרא, ואמר רבא בר בר חנה: זמנא חדא הוה קא אזיל במדברא, ואתלוי בהדיה נחשא. The Gemara says6:38that Rabba bar bar Chana says,6:39one time I went,6:40I was traveling in the midbar,6:42in the desert,6:45and ויתלוי בהדיה נחשא. And there's this Arab,6:47or this, I guess you could say this Arab,6:49that came along with us.6:51You know, people who traveled in the desert,6:53there's nobody there,6:54so whenever people need to travel,6:55they saw a group of people6:56going, they always traveled together out of safety.6:58You know, they're always good to be with a group.7:00So people were7:01traveling, and this Arab came along with them.7:06אמר לי: תא חוי לך היכא דנשקי ארעא ורקיעא אהדדי. She tells Rabba bar bar Chana, you know,7:09I travel here all the time.7:10Let me show you a place where7:12the earth and the sky meet.7:19אזל וחזאי דעבית כווי כווי. He saw that the place that he showed him7:22was like windows.7:30שקלתא לסלתא, ותנחתא בכוותא, דרקיעא, ומצלינא בעיתא ולא אשכחתיה. So he says he took his basket7:35and he put it in one of the windows of the sky,7:39and then he went to pray.7:42After he prayed,7:44בעיתא, I looked for him, ולא אשכחתיה, and I couldn't find him.7:48אמר לי: איכא גנבי הכא? She says,7:49Is there any robbers over here?7:53אמר לי: האי גלגלא דרקיעא הוא דהדר. No,7:54this is what we're seeing over here7:55is because...8:01The galgal means the roundness of the sky that's coming back.8:08Nata ad lemachar, like wait till tomorrow and you'll find him. This is very weird, this whole Gemara.8:11He found this Arab, he showed him windows where the earth and the sky meet, and he put his basket,8:16he prayed, he found. What's going on?8:20Ketav Rabbeinu, פירוש, כי יצא הרא. He's going to tell you the depth of this Gemara over here.8:27Hayatza hara, sochen da'asan לגופה בזינין בשין. The yetzer hara keeps on going around, he's trying to give bad advice to the person.8:41He says, והוא מסיתו לפרוש מדרכי תורה, מפאת שמא ילא אדם פני הרעות טוב ומחמדת עולם ומלואו. How is he trying to deceive the person?8:43He shows him all the good about this world and how, you know, it's very alluring.8:47You know, that could be you if you think about it,8:50you know. That's exactly what the lottery is.8:51That could be you. Anybody can be a winner.8:54America, anybody can be that. Anybody can be the president. Anybody can be the president,9:00right? And the guy in the beginning,9:05he's not going to listen to the yetzer hara. He knows,9:07עולם הבא. No comparison. What are you trying to fool me?9:09I know what's the real things.9:13Ah, but the yetzer hara tells him, listen, I'm not telling you to do anything asur.9:17I'm telling you what the rabbis say.9:22גדול הנהנה מיגיעו יותר מירא שמים. A person who earns his own parnassah is greater than even a yerei shamayim.9:29And then you get olam hazeh because you're going to earn the money,9:32and also you're listening to the words of the rabbis,9:37you're also zocheh olam haba. And this is the meaning of this taya, this Arab who came with9:42Rabban Yochanan. He tells him, come.9:43What does it mean, come?9:44It means leave where you are and come with me, right?9:46It means,9:48קום ועסק התורה, ואני... I'm going to show you something that's good for you.9:51I'm going to show you where shamayim and earth meet, where heavens and earth meet,9:58right? You think that, you know, he comes to the yetzer hara tells the person,10:01you think, no, it's got to be extreme.10:04You have to be extreme.10:05You have to be always your head is in the10:08world, Rasak belchet. Come,10:09you can have olam hazeh and olam10:11haba. I'm going to show you where earth, and this sky means the earth,10:15taavot olam hazeh, and at the same time go also. You know, that's always a big question.10:19Chacham, it's mutar. Why not?10:21Mutar, what's the problem?10:23Right? Now, Baruch Hashem, there's a book that's opening our eyes a little bit.10:26So he says, what happens,10:29and that's the meaning over here, that you'll be zocheh to this olam hazeh and olam10:34haba. So he says, Halachti berech min haTorah, ... he says,10:36the Baba ... he went.10:37That means he actually left the Torah.10:38He listened to his voice.10:44He says, I saw that, you know what?10:46It's not good for everybody to go out and to earn his own10:51parnassah. As it says,10:55Lo lachachamim lechem, lo lenevonim osher. As Shlomo HaMelech, what does he say? Not every wise man really has10:58parnassah, and not every smart person who knows how to ask advice is really the rich guy.11:06And we see it, all of us. The guy is writing this 200, over 200 years ago,11:11and we see it.11:12We see that not every smart person is really making it,11:15and not everybody is in control of his11:18parnassah. Some of the worst ideas in the world have become big,11:21and some of the best ideas in the world have crashed and made the people who invested in them go bankrupt.11:27Right?11:28Why?11:29Because,11:33Daltei shamayim patach. Pasuk says, Yiftach Hashem lecha et otzarot, it's all byad Hashem. All the parnassah clearly comes from Hashem.11:36And we pray,11:39Shaarei shamayim petach, ... Why?11:40What does that mean,11:40open up?11:41These are the windows.11:42These are the windows that this rabbi saw in the desert,11:45right? The windows are the window of opportunity Hashem gives,11:49and we pray that He should open the windows and give us the shefa.11:53Now, what does he do?11:55He says11:56he started praying.11:57It says in the Gemara,11:58Bar Bar Chanah started praying.11:59He put his basket there and he started praying.12:03And then he went back to the basket;12:05it was empty,12:06and he didn't even see the guy with him,12:09right?12:09And then the people, he asked around,12:12Did you guys see this guy?12:13Did you guys see where he is?12:13They told him,12:15Don't worry,12:16it's the galgal of the earth that turns around,12:18which means,12:19like the Gemara says,12:22Galgal chozer ba'olam, right?12:22The world is like this spinning wheel.12:25Some people are on top,12:26they become on the bottom.12:26People on the bottom go back on top,12:28which is the same thing that we said has nothing to do with the effort of the person.12:35Lo bizchutah talya milta ela b'mazala. It's not12:36in the zechut; it's12:38in the mazal. You're not getting your reward for12:41mitzvot in Olam Hazeh. The Gemara says,12:46Schar mitzvah b'hai alma leika. And the Gemara says also,12:51Hayom la'asotam u'machar lekabel secharam. You're not going to get your reward of12:55mitzvot in Olam Hazeh unless you want to trade it in,12:57and that's a very bad trade.12:59Therefore,13:00comes the Gra and concludes,13:01Don't listen to13:02yetzer hara. Don't listen, because that's his whole plan.13:06He tries to trick a person to leave his13:11arba amot shel halacha and to go into the world of13:14parnassah. You're going to make more if you work more,13:16and you're going to go become this big,13:18you know, and a lot of people,13:19yeah, they enter college13:21and they have careers13:22and all these things,13:22but most of13:23them, they're busy just paying for those things,13:25so we end up in the same place.13:27So that's exactly what the Gra is trying to emphasize over here.13:31We're a little bit on time.13:33We'll stop over here,13:34and then tomorrow we'll move on.