Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 3, Lesson 4Sefer Even ShelemaPart 47Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:32Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Even Shelema, perek gimmel, ot0:03gimmel. In today's Even Shelema, he discusses again a concept of chemdah and0:10taavah. So one of the people who was listening on the chat told me something very interesting.0:14He said that, you know, so I thought it was going to be too much.0:18You know, as I'm learning this, it was too much.0:20I was surprised when they said, I like this whole thing about chemdah and0:24taavah. I said, Really? I thought it was going to be too much.0:26And he said, No. You know why? Because we live in such a world of0:31taavah, where the whole society is founded and built on0:36taavah, right? The dream of everybody is always vacation and to, you know, to basically just have it the way you like.0:42So it's very good to have a reality check of what the world is supposed to be about and what it is.0:47Yes, like we said a few times, we pointed out, if a person needs it,0:50so it's not a case of taavah anymore; it needs it to survive.0:53But it's a good reality check. We need it from the0:57Gra, baruch Hashem. We have these sefarim that can put our head in the right place where we're supposed to be.1:03In ot gimmel, he comes and he discusses something very interesting.1:06He says1:10over here, Until now we're always thinking, Oh, people are lost in1:14taavot. That's, you know, people are off the1:17derech. People don't keep Shabbat. They don't have Torah.1:18He says, No. Sometimes doesn't mean all the time.1:21You know, I want to emphasize that.1:23Doesn't mean all the time.1:24So don't go around and say, All that ... I've been in1:26taavah. No, no.1:26I said sometimes people who are mamash even bnei Torah,1:30people full of yirat Shamayim and Torah,1:33they could get trapped in the trap of1:37chemdah. Why?1:40Because in the beginning, chemdah, not taavah again1:42over here, we're talking about1:43chemdah, the guy who, you know, trying to make money and everything.1:45In the beginning, look, it shows, it fools the guy.1:48It shows him, Look, you need to pay your1:50bills. You have mortgage to pay,1:52you have debts to pay,1:53you have credit cards to pay.1:54Right? You need to.1:57Torah1:57... is not very good.2:00Okay. U'misham nimshach achar2:01ha-motarot, and from there2:02it takes and pulls him after the extras.2:04Then he says, you know, what's I'm making?2:05You know, it's like, I got to tell you2:09a story. Motarot, motarot, the extras.2:10Ve'omesh ha-kol tzorech lo.2:11Then becomes, now even the luxuries become a necessity,2:16because ... because, Baruch Hashem, I can make it,2:18so if I can make it2:18now, I'm gonna get the money2:21so now, Baruch Hashem, I can learn without any worries.2:24What a difference.2:24Now that I can pay my bills. Beforehand2:26I was just in a headache.2:27Now I can pay my bills,2:28I'll be calm.2:30Ve'ahbi telech beito, and this way I can save my house with dignity.2:34Ve'hashba sigul, and fine,2:34you got it.2:35No,2:38what's gonna be,2:38who knows what's gonna be later on.2:40If Trump takes away right now,2:41he took away the health insurance,2:43who knows,2:43he might take away also the benefits of the old,2:45and the next president will go crazy and say even more and take away even more.2:49So what's gonna be later on?2:54But, rabot machshavot b'lev ish, but, you know, there's a lot of2:56machshavot b'lev ish. People have so many plans,2:59and it could be really the advice of the3:02yetzer hara. Now on this point, I want to mention, before I get to the ground on the bottom,3:06before I forget, I want to tell you. Two things.3:11Number one is, it's interesting.3:12I'm reading in this book. This book,3:14it's a secular book.3:15It's not a Jewish book.3:16It's a book of how to run things and how to do things3:19and how to prioritize family,3:21and a real practical, systematic way of how to prioritize your family.3:26Okay?3:26So now you can learn a lot of things from that book.3:29It's a very easy read.3:30Just yesterday I got to the3:32part—I read it,3:33you know, attached,3:34whatever.3:34So just yesterday I got to the part where he says,3:36he quotes an article, which I want to look at.3:38It's in 1997.3:40He says,3:41The five lies that parents lie to themselves3:45about going to work and not spending enough time with their kids.3:48And he brings out the craziest thing.3:50I said, Wow, this is exactly how it is.3:51We talk about dedicating more time to learn Torah,3:54spending more time with your family, right?3:56And we always speak about it.3:58No, everybody's answer always,3:59We're busy at work, busy at work.4:00So this is like back then,4:01and it's telling you all these things that people claim that,4:04No, we need to go to work.4:05We need to do that extra thing because of, you4:08know. He brings down the five lies,4:10and he brings down things like, you know,4:11Oh, because, listen, my wife also has to4:14work because we have to pay this bill and we have to pay that bill.4:16So everybody's got the yetzer hara; it's the same thing.4:19By the goyim, it's trying to distract them from their families,4:21which is supposed to be priority.4:22By us, it's distracting us from Talmud Torah and our families.4:25It's all the same4:27yetzer hara, but it's the idea of this culture that we live in4:29is always running after4:32chemdah. And when people see success,4:35and even though they got whatever they need,4:36now they're always thinking,4:38Yeah, but if I can do it now, I can do even more,4:40right?4:41Like, think about it.4:41Let's say you sell—you know,4:43I remember when we were young,4:44my sister one time made tuna fish.4:47Okay,4:48she made tuna fish.4:49It was, I think, she was having in the house.4:50It was still very, very young,4:51you know, like we were twenties, early4:54twenties, not even maybe4:55nineteen. So she made tuna fish,4:56and she put carrots inside,4:58and she put—it was like, Wow, very good.4:59We're like giving her all compliments, like,5:01Hey, you think I should open a store?5:04But think about it.5:05Eight times when he does something good,5:06you get a compliment?5:07You're not content with this.5:09So all of a sudden we take it5:10and we make it into a whole business.5:12And again, people need it.5:14It's something.5:15I'm just telling you the idea5:16that that's the culture we live in.5:18Everything could be turned into money,5:20could be turned into a business.5:21Now that's going to take up time.5:23It's a career,5:24and it's going to take up your time5:25and everything else.5:26But that's, unfortunately,5:28that's the answer that we live in.5:30Chacham Yosef has a story.5:31It's a funny story,5:32but he says it on5:34purpose to show you the nature of a person.5:36He says one time,5:37you know, he goes—he used to go,5:38I don't know if he does it anymore,5:39but he used to go collect for the yeshiva.5:41So he used to go to this guy5:42who was a big ashir.5:43He used to give him a hundred thousand dollars every time,5:46okay, for the yeshiva.5:47So he went to5:48this—you know, he goes over to the city,5:50he goes up the elevator, he goes.5:51So one time he went to him,5:53and the guy couldn't give.5:54Didn't give.5:55He says, I'm sorry,5:56Chacham, this year5:57I'm not able to do it.5:59Okay.6:00So he went, he traveled all the way, fine.6:02Very disappointed.6:03He gets into the elevator,6:05he's going down.6:05Somebody comes in,6:06and SY walks into the elevator.6:07He says, Rabbi, how are you?6:09He says, Everything okay?6:11So what happened?6:13He says, You6:14know, I come usually to somebody,6:15and he usually gives me6:16a hundred thousand for the yeshiva.6:17He didn't give me.6:18He says, Rabbi, come.6:21He says, What?6:22Come to my office.6:22Takes him to his office,6:23and he writes him a check,6:24a hundred thousand dollars for the yeshiva.6:28Chacham Yosef said, You know what was going through my head?6:29I could have had6:30two hundred thousand. He says, That's how we are,6:35you know. We don't say, Baruch Hashem,6:37we got the hundred. Right away,6:39what's6:39going— I could have had.6:41And if you think about it,6:42it's always like that.6:42I could have had more, right?6:45But, so okay, if it doesn't harm,6:47it's great.6:47But a lot of times it does harm,6:48because I could have done this6:49and that and that and6:50that. But who gets, at the end of the day,6:52what gets taken away?6:53It's taking away6:54the main things in life,6:55which is Talmud Torah,6:57time spending with our families,6:58time spending even ourselves,6:59time spending with our wives.7:01Very important.7:01I say7:02משפחה, I don't mean always with the kids.7:04Parents have to know7:05that's a very, very important thing,7:07to get a babysitter.7:08That babysitter could be your mother,7:10your7:10mother-in-law, or your neighbor,7:11or any girl, or whatever it is,7:13or it could be one of your kids.7:14Just you and her alone.7:15It's a very, very important thing7:17to not be less than once a month.7:18So not be less than once a month,7:20especially when your7:21kids are old enough to talk,7:22so you're not going to have7:23any time to really.7:24You sit by dinner,7:25you're always getting interrupted,7:26somebody pops in your face,7:27and there's always7:27a—you can never finish7:28something to somebody else,7:29and you're all the time saying,7:30Go, stop, do.7:32You never get that quality time7:34with your wife.7:34It's a very, very important thing,7:36because you and your wife7:38are really the foundation7:39of the whole family.7:40Everything is built on you.7:41And not only that,7:41the kids will get7:42older, get married,7:42they'll be out of the house.7:44Guess who you're stuck with?7:46So if you don't invest now,7:48right, then already.7:50So it all goes by the investment7:51that we do7:52now. So it's a very important thing.7:53But when we busy ourselves7:54with so many things,7:56that takes away from—8:00Real things. Let's come to the Gra over here on the bottom.8:03He quotes a pasuk,8:05Al tachmod yofyah8:07bilvavecha, pasuk in Mishlei, perek vav, pasuk8:10chaf hei. Don't desire her beauty in your heart.8:11And we said already, this lady that Shlomo HaMelech talks about in8:15Mishlei is referring either to ta'avot or to8:18chemdah. So he says, Ki8:22hachemdah ein lah pituiim v'chelkat peh.8:23The chemdah doesn't have—it's not seducing.8:27Rav8:29she'adam chomed me'atzmo. The ta'avot have to seduce you.8:32It's fattening, I don't want to eat it,8:33but no, it's delicious, right?8:36Come on, who cares, a little bit of oil.8:38No, but I don't want to, right?8:40But it has to seduce you.8:42But when it comes to money, the opposite.8:43We run after it.8:45That's why the word8:47kesef is from the lashon of nichsaf; it's desirable.8:49Everybody wants it.8:50Shekitsatam nitzrach8:53me'olef haneset, because we all know what we could do with the8:56money. Of course, we could give tzedakot,8:58but the basics, we need to sustain our family.9:03However, from that it pulls you towards extra things,9:07the luxuries that you don't need,9:09and therefore, v'lo yefteh mimenu mevakesh kol hu tzarich lo,9:12it becomes a sickening cycle9:14where a person is always running after, I need it, I need it.9:17It's always needed.9:19V'kedei sheyachol lilmod, and now he justified—the religious guy justifies9:21it—because I need to learn Torah better,9:25v'la'avod Hashem b'revach, v'lazon eshto v'banav, to sustain my family and my kids and my grandchildren.9:27V'lachen amar, Al9:30tachmod b'atzmecha yofyah. That's why he comes9:32to—says, you don't desire its beauty,9:35כלומר המותרות, don't run after luxuries.9:37And we stressed this so much when we spoke in Sefer9:43Sha'ar HaBitachon. We said, when a person has—don't you have to do9:47hishtadlut? According to Rabbeinu Bachya from a thousand years ago,9:50that has haskamah from9:51Shamayim, from the malachim Shamayim, as the Beit Yosef heard from9:54the malach. What does he say?9:56He says, you have to work for the minimum.9:59The minimum you need to survive.10:00If there's anything extra that will come,10:02will come to you from that.10:04Never ever work for extras.10:07Extras will come on their own.10:09Huh?10:09That's a very important line from10:12the ... You want to know how much10:13hishtadlut? That hishtadlut stops at the minimum that you need to survive.10:16All the extras will come10:17whether you do the hishtadlut or you don't do the10:19hishtadlut. How many people work so extra hard10:21in building a whole project and boom,10:22they get a loss and everything gets lost.10:24So you see that if you're going to get it,10:26you're going to get it either way in the10:28... But even we're talking about here, the Gra is saying,10:31if you do have the money, if you do get that10:34berachah, be careful not to live your life with the luxuries.10:37First of all, from a practical, psychological point of view,10:41it's not good for your children.10:43Why?10:43Not every child will grow up in such a house of luxury.10:47Maybe your daughters might marry somebody10:49who doesn't have the same luck as you.10:50And those rich people that say,10:51I'm going to make sure my kids always marry rich people,10:54we call it the cycle of life, right?10:55We always see people that are very wealthy10:57and they have brothers that are not so wealthy.10:59How can it be if they had the same father?11:01And the answer is, listen, each person's mazal.11:03But when they grow up accustomed and used to those luxuries,11:06they can't live without it.11:07It becomes a necessity,11:09and to have such a necessity, it's destructive in their life.11:12And then they forget about what they have to do to get it,11:14or they live that they're missing out.11:16How many women feel that they're missing out on life11:18because they grew up and they have father's house with luxuries11:20and their husband can't afford them,11:22so they go out through life. My husband is a nice guy,11:25but, you know, we don't have it.11:28So that's a very sad thing.11:29Your husband is a nice guy, that's a great thing.11:32Instead of looking at the good that you have,11:33you're always looking at what you don't have,11:35because that's what11:36you're used to. So that's from a practical.11:37But over here, it takes a person away,11:40pulls him away.11:40The ... pasuk says,11:44because you need the yetzer hara to serve Hashem,11:47but he shouldn't pull you to his side.11:50And then he tells you that afterwards, when you get it,11:54what happens? Then it just never ends.11:57The cycle never ends.11:58And for this, the Gra says it. Today12:00we see it in such... A clear way12:05how people, literally the whole lifestyle is12:08always trying to make more and more and more.12:10And as much as people have, you never see them.12:14They always, no, no, I can do more,12:15and it becomes a kavod issue,12:16and everything is always justified.12:18So that's why he's telling you, be careful,12:20don't fall into the trap of that topic.