Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 3, Lesson 3Sefer Even ShelemaPart 46Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:40Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Perek gimel, ot bet, part0:30two. Now, if you're listening to the recording, you won't necessarily know what's going on, but it happens to be we're very late in our regular morning class in doing Eben Shelema, so it happens to work out. So today might be a little bit shorter because it's a small paragraph for part two. It works out for us over here in the shul, and that listening live, but those who are not listening live, so it may not work out exactly. So we said yesterday that everything comes from the aveirah of chemdah. All the sins, all the sins come from the desires.0:36But if a person has true bitachon, and he really has0:41middat hishtapkut, which means being happy and being satisfied with just what he has,0:44interesting, hishtapkut and satisfied is almost a lot of letters are,0:49hishtapkut, peh, a lot of letters are connected with it,0:53same letters. Anyway, a person who has it, it's, what's it called, exact opposite.0:58He won't bring him all these bad middot.1:00But if a person could do all the mitzvot, but he has the chemdah, it leads him to all the terrible1:06aveirot, as we see. Unfortunately, people also, it's unbelievable.1:09When you know about kashrut and you know the insides of kashrut,1:13and I've seen it plenty of times, as good as a guy is, and the guy is mamash,1:17he never did an aveirah in his life,1:18but once you put the guy in a position where it's money, it's based on money,1:24you know, why do I mention kashrut?1:25Because we live in a community which values kashrut so much.1:29No matter how off the guy is, kashrut is very, very, very important.1:33Yet you see those people, when because of the, I don't want to say chemdah, whatever you want to call it, but pressure of money.1:41Now why is there pressure of money?1:42It's a1:43difference, but because of pressure of money, when they're put in positions,1:45they're ready to break their values.1:49They're ready to break1:50the vows, and not only that has to do with the kashrut, but we see other things.1:53We value family very much in our community,1:57right? And when you put family together to work with each other,2:02and now the money comes in, again because of2:05the emunah, people are ready to break these important values that they grew up with.2:08Every single family in our community will tell you the importance of family.2:12But if you do a little bit of research, somebody was just telling me,2:14he knows of an 85-year-old man, a very dignified man,2:17and he says for the last 30 years he hasn't spoken to his2:23brother. Why? Because they were partners, and one felt that he, what's it called, robbed the other.2:28And, you know, each one felt that each one was robbing each other.2:30For 30 years they don't speak to each other.2:34And by the way, each one of these brothers has a very important family,2:39he stresses family so much.2:42It's a makhloket. And as we see, it's crazy.2:44When it comes, all aveirot come from that.2:45All aveirot come from the chemdah, the desire of money.2:48Had there been plenty of money for everybody, it wouldn't be that way.2:52When people feel that pressure, they need more and they need to have more,2:55so unfortunately it breaks even the greatest value.2:57And that's mamash what we learned yesterday in the3:00Gra. The Gra says all aveirot come from it,3:03and the answer is you're ready to transgress every sin.3:05Look, we just showed you how values that people really, really value,3:10and we know a lot of people like that, that really value family and they value kashrut,3:15but when it comes to money, they break these values.3:19You know that famous story with the chickens and Muncie, right?3:22The man was giving daf yomi.3:26What do you mean? He was feeding people taref and he's giving daf yomi?3:28He was selling to all3:29the yeshivot. How can that be? And the answer is, for him it's not a contradiction,3:34right? The chemdah makes a person transgress everything.3:38That's why a person has to be careful.3:39We saw in the Gra that these words stem from—he connects it to the four animals that are not kosher,3:47and he says based on the simanim, look at the kosher animals.3:50The kosher animals have a siman called3:54ma'aleh gerah. It eats, goes into its digestive system, comes back to its mouth, it eats it again.3:59It's good; it has what it has. It's fine, it's satisfying.4:02It doesn't have to knock. It doesn't have to break others to eat.4:05Now, let's look now at the continuation of that.4:08This is where we left off yesterday.4:14U'ba gamal ve'arnevet ve'shafan. By the camel, the arnevet, and the shafan, these animals, whether you translate it as rabbits,4:19whatever you want to translate them, are the famous four animals that the Torah lists that they're not kosher.4:24He doesn't mention right now chazir, right?4:27The three, they have one thing in common,4:29and that is4:31siman taharah shelahem ma'aleh gerah. The siman that they're kosher is that inside of—they do have ma'aleh gerah. They do chew their cud.4:37Ve'siman tum'ah she'eino mefris parsah, the siman tum'ah is that they don't have split hooves.4:41U'ba chazir, lehefech. But we know by the pig, it's exact opposite.4:45By the pig, the siman's on the outside. Look at the pig's feet; it looks 100% kosher.4:49On the inside, it's not.4:51Ve'ha'inyan, what's the idea?4:53Kemo shekatuv baMidrash. Midrash brings down,4:55interestingly, we have four animals, we have four4:56galuyot. Comes the Midrash and says the four animals are corresponding to the four5:01galuyot. How?5:02Gamal zu malchut5:04Bavel. Camel, that's malchut of5:06Bavel. Arnevet zu malchut Yavan.5:07The arnevet represents malchut Yavan.5:10Chazir zu malchut Edom,5:13and chazir is malchut Edom.5:15We know those are the four5:17galuyot. And the Gemara says5:20in Masechet Yoma, the Churban Beit HaMikdash, there was one and there was a second one.5:25Which one is worse?5:27Says the Gemara, well, look at the results.5:31What happened after the first Beit HaMikdash was destroyed?5:34Seventy years later, they came back.5:35What happened after the second Beit HaMikdash was destroyed?5:41Vusalam galut, right? It's over 1,900 years already.5:43I forgot, I think we're up to 1950 since the5:48Churban Beit HaMikdash. Vusalam galut, right? So the Gemara says, No. Isn't it better that the second5:52Beit HaMikdash, on the people that are greater from the second5:56Beit HaMikdash? Why? Because they are5:58osek baTorah. So the Gemara answers, Tenu anachem babirah. Look at the6:02Beit HaMikdash. Is it around or it's not around?6:04What does that mean? What's the meaning of the Midrash? I mean,6:04what's the meaning of the Gemara?6:07Says the Gemara,6:13V'anian Chidushim she'nigla avonam, nigla kitzam; acharonim she'lo nigla avonam, lo nigla kitzam. The Gemara says that the Rishonim, their sin was revealed,6:18and therefore their end also was revealed to them.6:20But the Acharonim, their sin was not revealed,6:25and therefore their end was not revealed.6:27What does that mean?6:31HaYu ma'aseihem ha-tovim temunim v'amumatim, geluyim ki libam hayah tov. The early generations, their good deeds were deep within them.6:37They were really good people.6:39The aveirah was something external,6:41right?6:42Yeah?6:44V'haAcharonim lehefech. And the Acharonim were the exact opposite.6:47That means6:49their inside was crooked,6:51and on the outside they did everything good.6:53But deep inside they had a deep hate.6:56V'Rachmana liba ba'i. Hashem cares about the heart.6:59What does it mean He cares about the heart?6:59Not that you should only be in the heart,7:01but the idea is that the heart will get you to last longer.7:08Kemo she-katuv, Rabuta lemeba'ei ba'ei b'shnei d'Rabbi Yehuda. What is a big deal for a person to pray in the yeshiva of Rabbi Yehuda?7:12What does that mean,7:12in the yeshiva of Rabbi Yehuda?7:14It says the Gemara that everybody7:17was—the Gemara says, famous Gemara,7:21Masechet Berachot—you know, Rabbi Yehuda, when they needed rain,7:23he would bend down to untie his shoes so he could pray7:25and rain would fall.7:27And the Gemara says,7:28we are much more learned, much more learned than the generation of Rabbi Yehuda.7:34And we pray and we pray and we pray,7:35the Gemara says,7:36it's Abaye and Rava, right? And we pray and we pray, and nothing happens,7:40right?7:40So what's the pshat?7:42And the answer is7:43because HaKadosh7:46Baruch Hu, leva ba'idech divrei Hashem, ela levav. V'amru. And the Gemara continues,7:52Rishonim shehayah bahem avodah zarah gdolah, shefuchei damim, ela shetlu bitchonam baKadosh Baruch Hu. They had terrible7:53aveiros, but they put their trust in Hashem. Nimtza ki ma'aseihem ra'im.8:00עוד שכולם בהרג ועל יעבור, עבירות חמורות שבתורה. It comes out that really they were chayei mita,8:05right? The all the aveirot that a person is supposed to give up his life on.8:10ולבם היה טוב מאוד שמעלתם בטחון על כולם. But the heart, the heart was very good,8:13because they had full trust in Hashem. That means it was above everything else.8:18However,8:20האחרונים עסקו בתורה וגמילות חסדים. The Acharonim were occupied in Torah8:23and gemilut chasadim. ומפני מה חרבם? מפני שנאת חנם. Why was it destroyed? Because of sinat8:27chinam. The Gemara says, the8:30Masechet Yoma, sinat chinam is equal as all the three aveirot together.8:33But, says the Gra, the real over there is8:38מחוסר הביטחון. They're missing this midah of8:41bitachon. What made them do all—what made them have this terrible inside?8:44What made them be so jealous and hatred?8:46And the answer is8:49מחוסר ביטחון. They lacked the trait of trust in Hashem.8:51Why is a person jealous of somebody else?8:53He's doing better than you. Why are you jealous?8:55Don't you trust in Hashem that everything will be good?8:57No, you don't trust in Hashem.8:59That's why you get jealous of others, and that's why you come to hate others.9:05ולכן נענשו, הוגלו שלוש מלכויות. That's why,9:06now you can understand the punishment,9:08the exile of the first generation,9:11which means the people from Beit HaMikdash, they went to9:14Bavel, they went to Paras, and eventually they were in Yavan.9:17All those are represented by the three animals.9:22ששמנת ה' להם בבפנים. Their kosher signs were not inside,9:24right? The camel has—he is ma'aleh gerah, he does chew the cud,9:29right? Which means the inside was kosher, and the outside was not.9:33ואחרונים, however, us, were in the galut of Edom.9:38And our galut in Edom נמשלה, חזיר. We're compared to9:41chazir. Why? Because a chazir is the opposite.9:43He shows you that he's kosher on the outside, but inside he's not.9:45And that's what we are right now.9:47We're in the galut9:49where on the outside we look great,9:51but the inside is rotten.9:55וכן הוא בגלות זה מדתו של הערב רב. And this is exactly what the whole idea,9:58whenever you hear about ערב רב that the Zohar talks about, that10:02נעשה לנו שם, right?10:02ערב רב wanted to make a name for themselves.10:05But the Gemara concludes and says,10:10טובה ציפורנן של ראשונים מכרסן של אחרונים. The ציפורן, the nails of the ראשונים, is greater than the stomach of the10:15אחרונים. Well, on a simple level,10:17we can understand it to mean that the nail, which is something very small,10:21is greater than the big belly of a person,10:24right? That means their small deeds were much greater than our big deeds.10:27But now you understand on a deeper level.10:29The ציפורן is the outside,10:31and the כרסן, there is the inside.10:34The סימן טומאה of the ראשונים was what?10:38On the outside,10:40right?10:41But the inside they were kosher.10:43On the outside they were not mefarsem, but the inside was kosher.10:47They were good on the inside;10:48they had10:50midat habitachon. The other ones, כרסן, on the10:53inside—on the outside they showed that they were kosher,10:55but not the inside.10:57And that's the difference.10:58The Gra comes on and he says11:00that's exactly the depth of the difference between us and the generation of the First11:05Beit HaMikdash. They, on the inside, were really good people.11:08Yetzer hara got to them,11:09so he made them do some things,11:11but the aveirot were external; they're not part of them.11:13Where the later generation, on the inside they were11:15rotten. Even though they did a great11:16mitzvot, but eventually it came to rot and destroy everything.11:20What do you mean?11:21It's only סאת התנם, and the answer is, when you have סאת התנם, you can do everything.11:24When you have that hate,11:26when you don't have that—and according to the Gra, where does it stem from?11:28It stems from the fact of lack of11:30bitachon. We don't have that trust in11:32Hashem. So who are you trusting in?11:34Trusting your power, you're trusting everything else.11:36So then that person could ruin your11:38parnassah, so we're gonna knock out that person.11:39Now, you know,11:41you could easily understand how some people11:43will see competition11:45and will do whatever they can to knock out their competition.11:48What about11:50parnassah? Chayei, my life comes first.11:52Chayecha kodmin, they always quote to you,11:54chayecha kodmin, right?11:56Well, we're talking about small people.11:57Big people will knock out bigger people.12:00And sometimes bigger people12:02will knock out, literally will kill other people12:04to get their ways.12:05And again, everybody with this power.12:07That's most of the time.12:08Most of the time.12:10Big people, they smash the small. Yeah, I'm not talking about just in12:11parnassah. I'm talking about literally. They hire men,12:13they hire people to destroy.12:15And lo aleinu, sometimes you see the ugliest thing in the world,12:18the ugliest thing,12:19the most disgusting thing in the world12:21is Israeli politics.12:23The most disgusting thing in the world.12:25Why? I'm sorry to say,12:27because... and everybody should try to stay away from it.12:30In the certain yeshivot, they pay people not to listen to the news12:32when it comes around the elections.12:33Why? Because instead of everybody12:35promoting themselves, what they're doing,12:37the opposite. So in America, you see,12:39you know, my kids are like,12:41Abba, who are you voting for, Dan Donovan or Max12:43Rose? I said, I don't know, the difference. Like, we keep on getting mail12:45that this guy is no good. I don't know which one of them.12:47But they keep on getting...12:48nobody, we never got mail, you know, they send you the flyers12:51about what the other guy is doing.12:52Always got that the other guy is bad,12:54right? So guess what's stuck in my head?12:56That this guy's name, so when I vote,12:57I vote for that guy's name,12:58right?13:01I don't know who anybody is.13:03I sit there, right? But think about it.13:05CNN, knock out Trump all day.13:06Trump, knock out CNN all day.13:08All they're doing is knocking. Nobody's showing13:10what's good about... they're all doing knocking.13:12Now somebody going, who cares?13:13But not take that and put it by Jews.13:15It becomes really, really sad.13:17It's really, really sad.13:19So, no, but... and you ask13:23every... we're all doing... because if we don't do it this way,13:26then that... there's a lot of things.13:27But unfortunately, again,13:29who's really right, who's13:30not, I don't know. I can tell you one thing13:31is that we have to put our full trust in13:33HaKadosh Baruch Hu.13:36We have to work on our midat bitachon and not let these things drag us away.13:38I said it's gonna be five minutes.13:39It took a little longer, sorry.