Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 3, Lesson 13Sefer Even ShelemaPart 55Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:007:05Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Even shelema, perek gimel. I think we're going to finish today the last two pieces over here, yud alef and0:05yud bet, the small pieces, and bezrat Hashem we finish with this perek gimel.0:11Toblo le'adam, let's start with yud0:12alef. Toblo le'adam sheyikbot tzedakah, rak me'at mamon,0:19veya'aseh tzedakah. And he should just collect a little bit of money and do tzedakah with it,0:23she'az hu yotzei chovat tzedakah, because this way yotzei chovat tzedakah easily.0:28Ve'efshar hu noten yoter me'ahu. It's very possible also0:31that you probably will be even giving more than what you're supposed to be giving,0:34and that's better to do by making a little bit of money and just give0:38tzedakah than having a lot of money, velo yitaken mishpato, tzarich letaken kefi ha'ko, and not give in accordance to what you're supposed to give.0:47So that's interesting because the last book that we did was0:50Ahavat Chesed, and we saw that ten and twenty percent are not exactly ten and0:57twenty percent, because a person who is really a rich person is supposed to be much more than1:03twenty percent. Hashem is giving him much more.1:04The idea of giving a max, or the idea that the chachamim made a cap,1:09right, amar Hillel, kinu be'usha, hanoten lo yiten yoter mechomesh.1:13A person shouldn't give more than1:15twenty percent. Why? Shema yitztarech la'acherim, because he might come all the way on the bottom.1:20Shema yitztarech la'acherim because he might need other people's help,1:25and the Chafetz Chaim points out, but a guy who's a billionaire,1:27he's not going to need other people's help if he gives1:29twenty percent. He's doing very, very well. He doesn't have to worry about that.1:33So that's called, and even though he might be giving more than1:36twenty percent, he might not even be, according to halacha, he might not actually give properly.1:40Let's read you the lashon of Shulchan Aruch.1:43It says in Hilchot Tzedakah, in Yoreh De'ah siman reish mem tet, halacha alef:1:47Shiur netinatah. How much does a person have to give in1:51tzedakah? Im yado maseget kefi1:54tzorech aniyim. If he's able to afford it, as much as aniyim need.1:57Ve'im ein yado maseget kol kach, yiten ad chomesh nechasav,2:01matzavo nuchar. And if he can't really afford it, then he pays2:05twenty percent. That's the mitzvah, the preferable way of doing mitzvah.2:11Ve'echad me'asar, midah beinonit. And tefesent is an average person.2:16Pachot mikan, eina. But less than that, even though he does tzedakah, it's considered2:19eina. And that's why the Gra is writing that maybe he's not giving2:23in accordance to what he really needs to give.2:26So here, even the Gra, when he brings it on the pasuk2:30in Mishlei, it says in2:31Mishlei, Tov me'at b'tzedakah mi'rov tevuot b'lo mishpat.2:34Good is a little bit with2:36tzedakah than to have a lot of produce without any mishpat.2:39Tov l'adam sheya'asok me'at ba'olam hazeh2:44v'kabeil me'at v'ya'aseh tzedakah. It's good for a person not to be focused on money,2:47to do just a little bit.2:48Now you have to work less.2:49Work less is better.2:50It's good to work just a little bit in this world2:52and get a little bit of money2:53and do tzedakah with it,2:54ki2:57כאשר יש לאדם ממון מעט, הוא יוצא מדין חיוב צדקה בכך, because when you have a little bit of money,2:59the advantage of it is3:00that you actually fulfill your mitzvah of tzedakah easily.3:05Sometimes you might be giving more than what you actually need to give,3:09and that's even better.3:10However, that's better,3:11me'rov tevuot b'lo mishpat3:12than having a lot of produce without justice.3:14What's that mishpat?3:18Hu מה שאדם צריך ליתן עפי החוב והדין, that a person who has to do according to the3:20halacha, like it says in the pasuk,3:24V'zeh יהיה משפט הכהנים מאת העם. This is the mishpat3:25of the kohanim,3:26which we know that was3:28the tzedakah that they gave to the kohanim.3:32V'hainu, and that's the meaning3:33when Shlomo HaMelech says,3:34Sheyeh lelo rov tevuot v'lo mishpat,3:36where he doesn't give according to3:37halacha, like we just quoted3:39the Shulchan Aruch.3:39This is ot yud3:41aleph. Finally, the last ot of3:44perek gimmel, and that is ot yud bet,3:45and he says like this:3:47Af3:48al pi shegam midat hapazranut yoter3:51midai einah al tzad hayoter tov, even though giving out too much money is not good3:56when it's done too much, excessively,4:00ach lifa'amim yachol tzmach tovah mizeh, but sometimes good could come out of it.4:03So, mean to say,4:04spending too much,4:05a person is a spender4:06is also not good,4:07but sometimes4:08being a spender4:09can actually good could come out of it.4:11However,4:12midat hakilut beyoter,4:13stinginess.4:15And what people call,4:15No, no, I'm careful with my money.4:17That's called stingy, right?4:18The stinginess,4:19too much stinginess,4:21hu4:23achle machsor la'olam. That's actually no good for the4:25world. What is the meaning of it here?4:28Let's see the words of the Gra4:30in Perek Yud4:33Aleph, pasuk chav-daled, Mishlei. Shlomo HaMelech says,4:35Yesh mefazer venosaf od,4:37v'chosech miyosher ach lemachsor. The people who spend,4:38but they have more.4:41A person who holds back from being straight,4:44that comes out to lacking.4:47Says the Gra,4:49Shtei midot ba'adam. When it comes to spending,4:50there's two types of people:4:52kili4:53u'vatran, a person who is cheap, stingy,4:56and a person who spends.4:59Ushnehem einam al tzad hayoter. They're both no good.5:01Why?5:01Because even a person who spends,5:03even for good things,5:04even for good things,5:05it's not good.5:06Like it says,5:07hambases al bases yoter mechomesh. A person who spends,5:09he shouldn't spend more than 20%,5:12right?5:12So you see5:13that even spending,5:14and that's what the Chafetz Chaim himself points out,5:16spending,5:18Chazal limited you.5:20Chachamim to spend for excessive5:22materialistic things.5:23Ah,5:26however, b'midat havatranut, yesh5:27lefaamim shemefazer venosaf od.5:28When it comes to5:31vatranut, which means a person who,5:33what's it called...5:35A person who is a mevater,5:37you know,5:37who gives,5:38he says5:39sometimes a person5:41is mefazer me'osav. Meaning,5:42shepa'am achat natan adam5:45la'ani dinar b'shnat batzoret, v'lo haya lo5:46ma le'echol. Famous Gemara,5:47famous story in the Gemara,5:50in the Midrash,5:50excuse me.5:51One time a person gave money to an ani,5:54and it was times of hunger,5:56v'lo haya lo5:57ma le'echol, v'halach v'asaf kol5:59ha'itrogim shezarku b'shut harabim. Then he went and6:00collected—he didn't have what to6:01eat—so he went and collected all the etrogim6:04that people threw out in the6:10street. And then he happened to be,6:11he carried these things with him on a ship,6:13and when he got to a certain place,6:15they told him6:16the king made an executive order.6:19He's in love with etrogim.6:20Anybody who has an etrogim,6:21they're very rare in our country,6:22come, the king will make you rich.6:24Mit'asher, became very wealthy.6:25So lachen yesh mefazer v'notel od.6:27There's some people who spend,6:29Hashem gives them.6:31Mishu k'dei lihyoter. But you see,6:31even though it's not good to spend,6:33yes, sometimes when you spend,6:34right,6:35the guy gave his last penny to6:37tzedakah. He didn't spend on himself,6:38but he gave it up.6:39Look at the end,6:40Hashem blessed him.6:41But the person was very stingy,6:44v'lo al ha'yosher. He's stingy beyond,6:45right,6:46more than reserved.6:46He's more,6:47you know,6:48he's6:48beyond the regular rule.6:53Unfortunately, it comes out with harm to the world6:55because people don't benefit from this person at all. Amen v'amen.