Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 3, Lesson 10Sefer Even ShelemaPart 53Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:37Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Perek gimmel ot zayin. Might even end up doing ot chet because it's very short,0:06especially zayin is something that really we brought the source earlier from a certain Gemara,0:13and now the Gra basically, he's just bringing here, like he said,0:17the Eben Shlema took all the words, all the pirushim from all the commentaries of the Gra, and he organized it in a systematic way based on subject.0:24So, you know, obviously it might come up again, like we said.0:26So let's see, we might even get to0:37chet. בעוון משא ומתן שאינו באמונה, גונן קליפת נוגה רחמנא ליצלן נפשות ושפע מזונם מהקדושה. By stealing, the sin of stealing is so bad that when it—not only just0:42stealing—even if a person doesn't do business honestly, it steals the klipat nogah.0:48The klipat nogah, a certain klipat, takes the nefashot laalenu and the shefa of the mezonot from the kedushah, takes it away,0:55which means there's a certain salary, a certain shefa that comes from kedushah,1:00and a person—how do you translate shefa in1:04English?—flow, the spiritual flow that allows the physical materialistic blessings to come, right?1:12They come from either kedushah or come from the side of1:16tumah. Now, I mean, somebody can be very wealthy, and it could be from the side of kedushah, which means it's given as a berachah from Hashem.1:22And we know that something that comes from berachah from Hashem has no side effects.1:26And something could be from the side of tumah, which is really set up for him to fall into something bad, right?1:33That's the one that comes. It's kind of like eating fatty foods.1:37Tastes great in the beginning, but over time it builds up, clogs up the arteries, right?1:43After a while, a person sees, whoa, you know, like he realizes, he starts to see the damage that has been coming from his pleasure.1:49But all depends where he's coming from. A person also gets full from eating healthy, right?1:54It doesn't have any side effect. It actually makes him stronger.1:57Same thing like this also works in the way we get our materialism from kedushah.2:02If we get it from kedushah, it has no side effect.2:05It's only blessings, it's only good things.2:07If it comes, lo alenu, from the side of tumah, lo alenu, it does horrible things.2:11So now he's telling you through a person's business dealings are not honest.2:17Then it takes away from that shefa of2:20kedusha. It takes away even nefeshot from there.2:22Where does it come from? From the words of the2:23Gra. The Gra, if you remember the story about the Rabba bar Chana in Bava Batra,2:27it says that he was walking once in the desert, and an Arab said, Can I tag along?2:32He tags along with him. He tells him, Let me show you where heaven and earth meets.2:36And he goes and he shows him a spot where heaven and earth meets.2:38He sees windows over there, and he takes his basket and he prays.2:42And then after he's done praying, he turns around and he sees that the Arab is not there and the basket's gone.2:47This, we said this, I think, last week sometime,2:51no?2:52Why am I2:54getting strange? It's a Gemara. I remember saying it clearly.2:56Okay, let's read it inside the Gemara. I guess after I'm going to go faster.2:59Let's see the Gemara again one more time.3:04Amar Rabba bar Chana, zimna chada hava ka azina b'midbara. I was walking in the desert, v'itlui v'talvei b'hadana hu taya. And there was a certain taya, meaning an Arab, that came and he wanted to tag along.3:16Amar lei, Ta, achvei lach heichi d'nashka aravra kahadadi. Come, let me show you where earth and heaven meet together.3:19The Arab said this to the Jew.3:21The Arab said this to3:25the Rabba bar Chana. Aze v'chazaei d'abid kavei kavei. He went and he saw that the place where they meet, there's just windows and windows.3:29When I say windows, there's no glass over here.3:31It means opening.3:32Back then, the windows means chalon in the Gemara always means a hole in the wall,3:38right? Not a glass. We're just used to glass windows.3:42But a window over here means just an opening,3:44okay? Anyway,3:47shakalta lisltaei, anachta b'kavta d'rakia. He says he took his basket and he put it inside this window of3:56the sky. Ad m'tzalina, baita v'lo ashkachtei. After he prayed, and then he looked for it and he couldn't find it.4:03Amar lei, Ika ganbei hacha? He says, Is there any ganavim? Amar lei, Hai galgala d'rakia hu d'hadar. No, no, no, it's not the4:05ganavim. It's because you put it in the window of the sky, and being that the sky is a galgal,4:10it's like a wheel, basically, it's like a ball, and it turns,4:14so therefore that's why it's gone.4:16Nata ad l'machar v'ashkachta. Come back tomorrow and you see, you come back, you'll find it because it's like a wheel,4:20right? It turns, and you come back and find it.4:22That's what the Gemara says, obviously something very deep.4:24On that comes the4:26Gra and says. What does it mean,4:29shekaltel es salta? Either he took his basket and he put it in the window and then he prayed.4:33He says,4:35Hitpalalti laHashem sheyiten li mezonotai. What the Rabba bar Hana is saying is that4:37I prayed to Hashem that He should give me my4:41parnasa. Like it says,4:46Sha'alu Talmidei Yehoshua, ma ya'aseh adam veyit'asher? Amar lahem, yarbeh b'schorah veyisa veyiten be'emunah. They asked רבי יהושע in the Gemara, what's a person doing in order to become wealthy?4:48Rabotai, listen up.4:50What's a person doing to become wealthy?4:52It says in the Gemara,4:54Rabbi Yehoshua told them4:55he should do business a lot,4:58and he should do his5:00masa u'matan, and his dealings and his business should be done with faith, according to the Torah.5:05So they told him,5:08Harbeh asu ken velo he'elu. I'm saying, if you want to be ashir, you have to do more business,5:12yeah? Okay, so he tells them what5:15he means. A lot of people did this and they weren't successful.5:17Now people work crazy,5:18they have their phones on, and they're working off their phones5:21even when they're away from the business,5:23and they're even doing it honestly, it doesn't work.5:26Ela yevakesh mi mi shehaosher shelo. At the end he tells them,5:27okay, so what you got to do is you got to pray to the owner of the wealth, which is Hashem.5:31Basically you got to pray to Hashem, they should give you wealth.5:33So he says,5:36Lezeh asai gam ken sheyitpalel kodem mi shehaosher shelo. So this is what this Rabba bar Hana is telling us,5:39that he prayed to Hashem, they should get wealthy.5:42Ve'achar kach chazar leparnasato, then he went to look for his basket, which represents the5:46parnasa, and still5:48lo matza. He says, Hey, where'd it go?5:50I can't find it.5:51That means parnasa is not coming in.5:52What happened? I did what the Gemara says. I'm praying, it didn't come.5:56So5:57amina, gambei ika hacha? So Rabba bar Hana says,5:58Hey, are there any ganavim over here?6:00Why are you asking if there's any6:05ganavim? פירוש, sheklipat nogah hi haגונבת את השפע מהקדושה. There's a6:07klipa, which is, let me explain for those who are not familiar with the word6:10klipa, means a certain level of evil side.6:14Everything in the world has two parts.6:18Right?6:18It has kedushah, there's kedushah, and there's tumah.6:20The tumah is also known as6:23sitra achra. The tumah is also known as6:27klipot. Klipot is basically a way that the chachamim refer to,6:30or the mekubalim refer to,6:32the evil side, the6:34sitra achra. The reason why it's given the name6:36klipah, which is a shell,6:37because a shell is a cover to the fruit6:40and doesn't allow you to get the fruit,6:43right?6:44And you can only survive when it's on the fruit.6:46Think about it: when you take off a shell,6:48look what happens right away afterwards,6:50right? It dries up and then it's gone. It's garbage,6:52right? So same thing also, the tumah can only6:55get—the sitra achra only has power6:57by clinging onto the kedushah,6:59and at the same time7:00it blocks you from the kedushah.7:02Good. So now he says, he says7:05there's a klipah called7:08nogah. It steals the shefa from the kodesh.7:12Why?7:13From the sin of people who don't do business honestly.7:17For example,7:18they rip off other people.7:22So what does it do?7:23So we steal from others,7:25so it has the right also to steal from others.7:30That's why Shlomo HaMelech says7:32this is the way of people who steal:7:34it takes the life of his owner.7:37Now literally we know7:38when a person steals,7:38you're literally stealing the person's7:40parnassah, you're stealing his life. You put his life on it.7:43As7:45the baalei mussar explain, the Gemara says that people7:46already put their lives at7:48sakanah in order to get their7:49parnassah. How many people travel on airplanes?7:50It's not putting your life7:51in sakanah, that's why you say7:52hagomel. How many people, the Gemara says,7:54they climb all the top of the street7:55to do their work?7:56You're putting your life...8:00Right, some people, you know, depends on their customs, they put their lives in8:04sakana. They work in, not in the Bronx, that's, or in Newark and all these places.8:08You know, people have been held up by guns, and especially people who own diamond stores.8:12Why are you putting your life in8:13sakana? And there's a certain amount of sakana that people put themselves in in order to get their parnassah,8:17and you take away that parnassah, you literally take away their lives.8:20By studying over a year, even the spiritual,8:24if when a person takes away from somebody else, so then the sitra achra also takes from them.8:31That's why he thought, the Rabbanan Chanah, when he lost his basket, he says, What's going on?8:36He thought that they took away the shefa that was supposed to come to him.8:42That's why he says, you know, the Rabbanan, and even the Gemara8:45in Masechet Niddah tells him, Make sure you do your business honestly.8:48In fact, it connects to this week's parashah by Vayetze.8:51It says when Yaakov comes to Lavan, he tells him, Listen, I gotta go already.8:57I've been here 14 years. I worked for you two daughters.8:59Basically, I didn't do anything.9:02I gotta already build myself up.9:03He says, Please don't go.9:05Please stay, because ever since you came, I saw9:08berachah. He says, Okay, fine, but I want to work now for a real salary,9:11right? He says, Okay, what do you want?9:14Nogbah secharcha hayom. He tells him, You tell me what you want,9:17right? So he tells him, This is what I want.9:18I want these specific types of animals.9:20What does Lavan answer?9:22Lu yehi kedvarecha. Yaret should be like yours, like what you said.9:27Lavan, the guy is trying to steal a penny,9:30right? From—he's trying to rip off every little dollar that he could from Yaakov9:33Avinu. He says, Inshallah, it should be like you;9:35they should be able to get it.9:36The Ben Ish Chai explains that what Lavan was saying is like this.9:40He says that Yaakov, who picked a certain specific types of animals,9:44it was very rare to get those colors of animals that Yaakov wanted.9:49And Lavan thought that this is a perfect thing9:51because he knew that if Yaakov Avinu would take these types of animals,9:56then, you know, it's not going to be9:57so—he's going to end up taking more animals.9:59And then when he steals, he's able now,10:01the tzad hatumah is able to steal from him back,10:04and he's to get the shefa.10:05Yeah, take it, no problem.10:06I want you to steal, because when you steal,10:09his side, which is the side of tumah, is going to have also,10:12it's taking from him.10:13And that's why he says,10:14like you said, it should be done.10:16And that's why he said what10:18he said. Yeah, you asked a question.10:19This rabbi is saying that he came and he couldn't find the basket,10:22so what, he wasn't doing business in10:24emunah? Then he came back, he did emunah, then he found the basket?10:27No, that's why he was wondering.10:28He says, Zeh ganavim here.10:30What do you mean, zeh ganavim here?10:31He thought that maybe I'm wrong of doing10:36masa v'tan emunah until the taya told him,10:38No, no, that's a galgal.10:39That means it's not because of you,10:40but normally it would have been because of that.10:42Yeah, there's also another aspect where people become rich and not rich,10:45which is galgal hoyo, you know,10:51Hashem mashpia u'morish, I mean. Now look on the bottom.10:53It's very, very interesting on the bottom.10:55He quotes here on the bottom,10:59Chavav, says, B'divrei Rabbeinu mevo'ar chidush gadol. Listen to this.11:01He says, comes out from the Gra a big11:11chidush: דלא רק הגזלן החוטא צריך לבוא בגלגול, אלא גם הנגזל. Even a person who got stolen from,11:19kedei sheyuchal hagazan lehashiv lo gezelon, in order to return his gezelah. Not crazy?11:28Uvsefer Asar Ma'amarot to Ramam miPano, one of the big mekubalim, he writes like this: Bechlal zeh halavin hakalin, lashon nitan letashlumin, vezeh acharon yechabed lezeteles. He says one of the lavin is that if you steal money, Torah says,11:34vheshiv et hagezelah asher gazal, right? He says, however,11:38im lo shilem, if the guy never paid back what he stole,11:44afilu hamitah einah mechaperet legamrei. Even death does not completely11:46atone, as it says,11:48nefesh baalav yikach. When you steal from somebody, you took the soul of the guy.12:02Im lo kadam hanigzal umachal, unless the nigzal is mochel. Unless the nigzal is mochel. Vetalmid gedolah hi, lenigzal odenu chai, sheyimchol lo, vemechayeh gezel, veleachar moto. A lot of times people say,12:05I'm not forgiving.12:05The guy ripped me off two million dollars,12:08and you want me to forgive him?12:10He's telling you it's good for the nigzal to be12:13mochel. Why?12:15Because it's good to be mochel whether the guy is alive or not.12:25Why? It says,12:27baalav. Because by you forgiving, then they'll return to you and you won't return to them. What does that mean?12:32That means you don't have to worry to come back in the12:35gilgul that you're not forgiving.12:36It's okay. He's going to return to you.12:38We're going to make sure that you come back in the12:39gilgul, that you get it back.12:40Now you don't want to come back in the12:59gilgul, right? Veal mah shekatav, afilu hamitah mechaperet, katav Pirush Rav Yehudah, legam hanefesh mekabelet onesh lachar mitah, kmo shekatav Rikanti, vyesh mechachmei hakabbalah haachronim sheomrim ki kabbalah beyadam, ki kol hagonev o hagozel et chavero, atid letaken meavato velamut mitah teniyanah. Anybody who steals,13:01the mekubalim bring down, he's going to die another death.13:03What's the second death?13:05That's through gilgul. That's through gilgul.13:06This is what it means.13:08What does it mean, notel nishmato? Shene'emar, nefesh ha'adam... It means he's taking his own neshama later on.13:14His own neshama also he's taking away.13:16And this is what it means when the Rambam says,13:23Tova gedolah la'nigzal sheyimchol, right? Because literally, you yourself are saving yourself, the13:27nigzal, from having to come back in a gilgul to get a payback.13:30So I always say we're going to do more,13:32end up not doing so much,13:34but Baruch Hashem, we did. We did good today, Baruch Hashem.