Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 2, Lesson 9Sefer Even ShelemaPart 34Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:46Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:30Eben Shelema, perek bet, ot vav. This is a very, very scary Eben Shelema. This is a very scary gra. We're going to read it, explain what it is from the Eben Shelema, then we're going to see the source from the actual words of the Gra himself. Mi shenimshach achar hata'avah, mafsid af midotav hatovim shebeteva tolato, vehem nikra'im begadim. A person who is nimshach, which means to say he loses himself to his ta'avah, and he's always running after his0:36ta'avot, he loses the good midot that he's born with.0:39He could even lose the good midot that he's born with.0:42So we've spoken about this in the past. We said in the Eben Shelema itself, and the Rambam also brings it down,0:48and let's, you know, if you think about it, see how true it is.0:50There are some people that are born with certain0:53midot. They could be good, they could be bad.0:54You see some people, just like certain kids are always very sweet, very kind,0:59they can't hurt people,1:00and there's some people who are just cruel, harsh, even when they're kids, you know.1:03And you can't blame kids;1:05they have bad midot, they have good1:07midot. People like to blame parents for everything.1:09They just want to blame something for someone, right?1:11Now, people are born with certain traits. We see,1:14look at Yaakov and1:15Esav. Chazal tell us that they were born, each one was born with different types of traits,1:19and each one had to use it in the proper way.1:21It's not to say that Esav wasn't1:24a rasha. Of course Esav was a rasha, but he used his midot in the wrong way.1:28David was born, Chazal tell us, with the same midot as1:32Esav. How could David HaMelech be such a big tzaddik, even the fourth leg of the merkavah, while Esav was1:38a rasha? It's a choice what you do with your1:41midot. So there are people that are also born, like we said, with good1:45midot. And how could you lose these good1:46midot? You might think that's natural, it's part of you.1:48The answer is no.1:49We know for a fact in our lives, if you have kids that, you know, since they were young1:55they were one way, and you see when they grew older they're completely different.1:58And sometimes they don't lose it, but sometimes you see people that lose it.2:01And the answer to that question, how could they lose it,2:05says the Gra, if a person runs after his ta'avot, or he's pulled to his2:09ta'avot, even if he doesn't run, but he just, you know, the ta'avot pull him.2:13Chooses even the natural midot that he's born with, the good ones.2:20Next, hanimshach achar hemdah. A person goes after desire.2:23What's the difference, taavah and2:26hemdah? So we already explained taavah is physical desires, physical pleasures.2:31Hemdah is not physical pleasures.2:34Hemdah is pleasures that are not to your physical body, but like money, only things.2:41A person is always looking to become so2:43wealthy, be that person who owns buildings and to be so rich and to have a lot of popularity and fame.2:51That person who's running after2:54hemdah, me'abed ha-midot, he loses other parts of2:56midot. What are these2:57midot? These are midot that a person has gained as a child.3:01Yes, there are some midot, as when we're young, we develop them,3:05whether we worked on them or we were around the right people, around the environment,3:10so we develop also good3:11midot. But a person who's running after that hemdah loses those good midot as well.3:15Why is that so?3:19Being that you're so focused on running after taavot, you have no time.3:27Time could also not just be time, but you have no mindset.3:31Your mind doesn't allow you to focus on yourself and to look out for yourself to fix3:37the midot, because so focused on getting, running after hamazeh, you won't be able to break your3:45midot, the bad midot that you have now, you won't be able to break them.3:48This is unbelievable.3:51This is an unbelievable thing that the Gra is telling us over here,3:54because if any of us have noticed a change in ourselves. Then we can source it back.4:01It's an amazing thing. The Gra is giving you an answer if he had such a question:4:05Why did I change? How could I change?4:06How could it be that my kids are not the same anymore?4:09They used to be this way and this way, that way. Or4:10how about this? Even if you don't have such a question, but if you're worried,4:15how can I protect my children not to lose good middot,4:17the good qualities that they have when they're kids?4:19And the answer: make sure you don't get them lost in running after olam hazeh and4:24earning all these things.4:25Let's see the words of the4:29Gra himself. It comes from4:34Mishlei, perek vav, pasuk vav— I mean, pasuk vav-zayin and chaf-chet. The pasuk says in Mishlei, Shlomo HaMelech says,4:42הֲיַחְתֶּה אִישׁ אֵשׁ בְּחֵיקוֹ בְגָדָיו לֹא תִשָּׂרַפְנָה? Is it possible that a person stokes fire on himself and his clothing won't catch fire?4:53הֲיִהַלֵּךְ אִישׁ עַל הַגֶּחָלִים וְרַגְלָיו לֹא תִכָּוֶינָה? Could a person walk on coals without his feet burning?4:57That's what the pasuk says.4:59It seems like to be very simple, like what Shlomo HaMelech mechadesh.5:02Wow, you know, that's the book of wisdom.5:05Shlomo HaMelech is telling me that if I put fire on myself, I won't burn.5:09If I walk on coals, I won't burn my feet.5:10What's going on over here?5:12Comes the Gra and he explains.5:14He says,5:17כִּי מִדּוֹת נִקְרָאוֹת בְּגָדִים. We find that middot are also called clothing,5:20as we know, that a person wearing certain clothing can be identified,5:25right? If you see a policeman right away, you say,5:28Hey, this is a policeman. How do you know?5:29And the answer is, look at him.5:32He's wearing a uniform that tells me he's a policeman.5:35Middot of a person are like clothing to a person.5:38A person who is nice to people, a person who's respectful,5:42or a person who's cruel, or a person who's very disrespectful,5:46who has bad middot, you could see it on him on the outside5:49and how he acts. You can tell about the person,5:52and therefore they're considered like clothing.5:58כמו שאמרנו לעיל, ופירוש אשר ישים פסוק פשטי את כותנתי, ברוך ה' יש שני מידות. So the Ramban says, but there's two types of6:07midot. One type of midot are the midot a person is born with,6:10and that comes to him natural.6:16Beit, אותן שרגיל את עצמו והם טבע שני. The second is things that a person worked on himself,6:19or he just became accustomed to them.6:21Again, it doesn't have to mean that he actually worked on himself;6:24it can be just that he was around the right people.6:26When he was a kid, he always hung out with the people who are classy,6:30and you see, it's an amazing thing.6:32The kid's friends have a major influence on him.6:35He hung out with certain people, and therefore he developed certain good6:38midot. So he explains,6:40Hamidot נקראות בגדים, like we said, midot כמידתו, חזל tell us. Midot bad, and Chazal said midot means6:47midato. And the Gemara says,6:49We explain all this, that why they're called begadim, and he's bringing just proof.6:54That's, however, those midot are considered like clothing;6:57those are the ones that a person is born with.7:00But the one that a person accustomed himself to,7:03so the word in Hebrew for that is hergil.7:06Hergil can also come from the word regel, feet.7:10The midot a person accustomed himself,7:12which means he trained himself to, or he developed,7:16he picked up after he was born,7:17not something that he was born with,7:19are considered regalav.7:21And now he could come back and understand the pasuk.7:23And he says,7:26If you notice the pasuk that we quoted in the beginning,7:28Shlomo HaMelech was talking about burning,7:30burning the clothing or burning your feet.7:33So he says, what is Shlomo HaMelech coming to be7:36melamed? He says,7:39when Shlomo HaMelech was talking about burning fire on yourself7:42and your clothing catches fire,7:44he says,7:47Hu neged hamidot haraot shehit'ava. That's corresponding to a person who goes after the7:51ta'ava, the ta'ava bifnim, within him.8:00That's what it says, heiko. Heiko means on his chest. It's on him directly.8:04And Shlomo HaMelech says, What do you think?8:06You're going to run after taavah and your clothing won't burn? What does that mean?8:09Begadav, referring to the middot that you were born with.8:13Ota middot, middot amor.8:18You abed otam mechamat shehurgal lemalot taavato, because you're always focusing on yourself.8:21You're always focusing on your desires.8:23The good middot that you have will be gone.8:25You become a selfish person8:27who's running after his physical desires and you don't care about anybody else.8:35If the good middot that you're born with you lose,8:38says the Gra, for sure you're not able to work on developing new good middot,8:48because you're always running to satisfy yourself.8:52People are always running to satisfy themselves,8:54not just become selfish. They8:56lose the sensitivity of caring about others9:00because they become the center of attention. They have to get everything they want.9:06For this person needs to break his9:10taavah, and that he shouldn't have, you know, shouldn't be the center of attention, always running after his own9:15taavah. That's why it says, tisarefna, it burns.9:17That's what it does. It really burns all the good middot9:20completely, takes it away.9:22Next part of the pasuk, it9:23says, You think if a person walks on coals he won't burn himself?9:31That refers, says the Gra, hu neged hachemdah, shehu holech tamid lemachakim uleradev tamid bishfachim ulerchovot. Why is it hinted in the word of feet?9:36Because for chemdah, acquiring things,9:40it forces a person to always travel and to go far.9:42There's a great deal over there. There's great things.9:45There's always more opportunity from the place that you live.9:48Think about it. We live in New York City,9:50the center of the whole entire world in business.9:52Yet we're always traveling to China and to Vegas and to all different places.9:56Why? Because there's more opportunities outside also.9:59And that's the idea. Today with the internet, we see how we travel,10:02right? We're all over the world.10:04That's the idea of10:05chemdah. A person who has the desire to acquire things is always on the go,10:09is always going, traveling to try to bring it.10:12And the pasuk says,10:13Yit'ek raglav lo tekavena, his feet won't burn,10:19ki ein lo paneh lehishgia al atzmo ma asher yuchal lishbor. Also, this guy also has no time to focus on himself.10:27And a person who has trained himself since his young10:32in certain midot, being that they're not natural to you,10:35you acquired them.10:35Anything that you acquire is very easy to lose.10:38Anything that's yours, it's very hard to lose.10:41It could be lost, like we said,10:43but it's much easier to lose something that you acquired that's not yours10:47than something that's yours.10:48So he's saying over here,10:49the midot that a person has developed and acquired10:52are much easier to lose.10:54You don't need to be after ta'avot, physical desires.10:57Even the external kavod and acquisition of possessions,11:02that will also make you lose them.11:05Why? For the same reason.11:12And because, again, he's not focused on his spiritual;11:15he's focused on the physical world11:16and trying to gain that extra money and extra things,11:20and that's why he ends up losing it.11:23There's one more piece over here,11:25but because of the time we're not going to be able to do it.11:27And again, in this piece,11:28the Gra just repeats the same idea11:30on a different pasuk,11:34and it's the same point.11:36Running after your desires,11:38whether it's physical or others,11:39makes you lose the11:41midot. And if it's physical desires,11:42it makes you lose really the midot that you're born with.