Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 2, Lesson 8Sefer Even ShelemaPart 33Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:48Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:04Emun Shelema, perek bet, ot hei. Like we said yesterday, the next part of Emun Shelema gets very, very practical, and you're going to see it's beautiful.0:12You want to know now practical steps of how to take care of your0:18yetzer hara? Listen to the following. Listen to what he brings down in the name of the0:22Gra. Let's begin with the0:23beginning. Limud ha'agadah. Tov lichbosh et bo yetzer hara shel0:27ta'ava. You have a yetzer hara of ta'ava? You need to learn more agadah.0:31Open up midrashim. Open up midrash. If you can't read the Hebrew, get the English.0:36The midrash says it. Just a whole bunch of midrashim put together in English in a story format.0:43Learn agadot of Chazal. Learn Ein0:46Yaakov. Open up Midrash Rabbah, Midrash0:50Tanhuma. Those are midrashim of agadah where they speak about stories and lessons that Chazal bring out,0:54not just stories of the parashah, but actual lessons.0:57When you learn agadah, that is good. There's a guarantee? No, but it's good.1:01It's a very, very powerful tool to help a person capture the yetzer hara of1:06ta'ava. What about the yetzer hara? Remember the two yetzer haras, the main yetzer haras the Gra always mentions is ta'ava and1:12ka'as. What about1:19ka'as? Uv'limud halachot shenimshalu le'esh, v'tzarich lezeh chimum rav, tov lichbosh al yado et haka'as. By learning halachot, which are compared to fire,1:25that—and because halachah, you see people in halachah, right?1:28It's a lot of action back and forth and yelling and1:32whatever—that is good to use to capture the yetzer hara of anger.1:41V'i efshar leharog et hayetzer hara ela baTorah. Listen to this. It's impossible to completely wipe out the yetzer hara unless you use Torah.1:48That's a famous Gemara, Masechet Kiddushin.1:50The Gemara says, Barati yetzer hara, barati Torah tavlin. I created the yetzer hara and I created the Torah for it, to counter it.1:58That means with all the things—you can read all the psychology books, and you can go to therapy and everything2:05else—they will definitely help you.2:07But al yedei Torah is the only way where a person can actually wipe out the2:13yetzer hara. Again, I'm not coming to minimize therapy,2:15chas v'shalom, and I'm not coming to say also that a person who needs therapy should just say,2:21I'm going to learn Torah. I once was having a conversation with a person who had a chemical imbalance in his brain, and he needed medicine.2:29This is not—it wasn't even a joke.2:31He had serious problems.2:32I don't, you know, we won't say anything right now,2:35not to give anything, whatever.2:38And of course, you know, he heard a class similar to what we're saying,2:41and of course the rabbi is going to say what it says in the Gemara,2:43and that Torah, of course, is made to capture yetzer hara, and only through Torah.2:47So the guy took it all the way.2:49He says, I don't need medicine.2:51I don't need therapy.2:52I don't need anything.2:54Just learn Torah.2:55That's all I need.2:55I'm just going to learn Torah. But he had a serious problem.2:58Yes, Torah will definitely help and definitely will kill the3:02yetzer hara, but there are other issues that prevent you from learning Torah,3:05right? You can't even learn Torah properly because of your mental state,3:08just like a person who's physically ill.3:11The Gemara says,3:13A chash b'grono, ya'asok baTorah. Any type of sickness could also heal you from the Torah,3:18right? Through the Torah.3:19But yet we know, the Chazal tell us that you could go to a doctor and be3:23nitrapeh, and Rishonim discuss this.3:24So a person has to take the normal thing plus as well as the Torah as well,3:29and that's why I wanted to emphasize over here3:32is that we're going to learn about Torah,3:35but again, some people, especially in our generation,3:37they have more issues,3:39and they need to either be on medicine or take the proper therapy or to be well as well.3:46Okay, let's come to3:48the—let's come to the3:51Gra's peirush. The first one comes from3:56Mishlei, perek chaf-hei, pasuk chaf-hei. Let's read the pasuk.3:57Pasuk says,4:00Im raeiv sonaacha, ha'achilehu lechem, v'im tzameh hashkehu mayim. If your enemy is hungry, feed him bread,4:05and if he's thirsty, give him water.4:08Why? Ki gechalim atah choteh al rosho, because this way you are putting coals, talking coals, on his head.4:15As we know, the pasuk in4:19Mishlei, the way the Gra explains it,4:20he goes on a deeper level to explain.4:23What else, besides the simple meaning, is it talking about?4:26The simple meaning of the pasuk is,4:28don't go head on against your enemy,4:33right?4:33Don't go against your enemy head on,4:35but rather what you should do is4:37go to him by talking to him,4:40being nice to him.4:42What?4:42My enemy has to be nice to him?4:43Yeah,4:44your enemy should be nice to4:45him. When you're nice to your enemy,4:48then he will also be nice back to you.4:51That's a different discussion.4:52That's the simple meaning of the pasuk.4:53Comes the Gemara and gives us a little deeper.4:55He says,4:57Who's your enemy over here?4:59The pasuk is also, ... on your5:01yetzer, he's called an enemy,5:02as the Gemara, Maseches Sukkah, says towards the end5:05that the yetzer hara is also called5:07soneh. Now, it says in the pasuk,5:10What does that mean, feed him bread?5:12Well, let's give you an introduction from another5:16Gemara. The Gemara, Maseches Kiddushin, says,5:22If ... moshechehu l'beit hamidrash, im even hu, nimoach; im barzel hu, mitpotzetz. If this disgusting person comes across of5:26you—who's that disgusting person?5:27That's the5:28yetzer hara—what should you do?5:30Drag him to the beit5:31hamidrash. In the beit5:32hamidrash, if he's a strong as stone, he'll melt.5:34If he's metal, he'll break.5:40Why is the Gemara telling me5:41if he's stone or if he's metal?5:43Is it just a5:44mashal? And it says, No.5:46The Gemara is coming to tell us something very important,5:48and that is there's two types of5:50yetzer hara. כמו שאמרנו, לעיל, like we said many times already,5:55יש תאוני וכעסני. There's yetzer hara for5:57taavot, and there's yetzer hara for anger.6:01וכעסו יותר קל לסבול מן התאווה. Anger is much easier for a person to6:04capsulate than taavah, like we said already a few times.6:06Why? Because we said anger,6:08all you have to do is just get away from it.6:11Don't deal with it anymore.6:12You could actually just avoid it.6:15But taavah, you have to deal with it6:16because you need it to live.6:20וכנגדם נקראת התורה גם כן אש ומים. And that's how we find the Torah is compared to two different things.6:24Sometimes we find the Torah is compared to fire,6:26and sometimes it's compared to water.6:29Like it says in the pasuk,6:32הלא כה דברי כאש, my words are like fire, says6:34Hashem. Another place we find it says,6:37הוי כל צמא לכו למים, whoever is thirsty, go to the water,6:39and the water and מים אל התורה, right?6:43והיינו, what's the idea of here?6:44Why is the Torah sometimes compared to fire,6:46sometimes compared to water?6:47Comes the Gra and puts it all together.6:48He says,6:50שבתורה יש שני דברים, הלכות ואגדות. Because in the Torah we find there's two things.6:52One is halachot,6:54as the whole, right, you see in the Gemara,6:57there's basically6:59עשיית המצוה, keeping the mitzvot,7:04ואגדות נקראות מים, שמושכין לבו של אדם כמים. And the stories and the lessons of the Gemara,7:07the Gemara brings out life lessons,7:08those are water.7:10Why?7:11Because, why they can be like water is, you know, sweeps away with it7:15a lot of things,7:16right? Not like fire that burns;7:18it sweeps away things.7:20So the aggadah is the same idea.7:23It sweeps people away.7:24It grabs them,7:30right? שבאגדות דברי מוסר, שבזה ישבר יצר הרע של תאווה על ידי מוסר. Through the7:32aggadah, through the mussar of the7:34chachamim, that's how you break the7:36yetzer hara for taavot. והלכות הם דינים שהם אש. And halachot is dinim, halacha, it's like fire.7:41Like it says in the Gemara,7:45Masechet Taanit, daf dalet, אורייתא הוי דקאמר תחבה. If you guy is angry, it's the Torah.7:49That's the Torah inside of him.7:52וחלוק בין התפוסת למוח, and that's the difference over here7:55when the Gemara says,7:56the7:57topic yetzer hara, it'll either break—8:00Melt. If he's stone, he'll melt. If he's metal, he'll break. The idea is like this:8:07idea is shemitpotzetz techef b'makom v'makom, v'noshar kilu. Fire, right? Fire breaks it apart completely.8:12Mitpotzetz, not just break; really mitpotzetz is like more like shatters.8:16So through fire, you completely shatter the8:24yetzer hara. But melting takes a long time. For something to really melt,8:27it has to soak in water for a long time,8:31and then it starts to melt, right?8:37That's what the Gemara says: if he's stone, he'll melt.8:40Stone melts, yeah, after a while, like the story of8:43Rabbi Akiva, drop after drop after drop, it eventually will make an effect,8:47because very, very hard to break the yetzer hara for8:50taavah, but it'll go away eventually with the Torah.8:57Why is the yetzer hara of taavot called9:00even? The answer is because it's9:03mitamtem, like it says in the Talmud. It's interesting,9:05the pasuk says that when Mashiach comes,9:10Hashem says in the pasuk,9:16V'hasiroti mechem et lev ha'even, v'natati lachem lev basar. I'll remove from you a heart of stone;9:19I'll give you a heart of flesh.9:21So I always understood it that, you know,9:25we're going to lose feelings in those days.9:27We don't care about anybody.9:29And that also has a lot of truth.9:30We see people have become very, very selfish in our days,9:33as we are, you know what,9:35even the goyim are calling, we're the I generation, right?9:38It's not just the phones and the tablets,9:40but we're so focused on ourselves.9:42But really, it's connected also to what the Gra is saying over here,9:46because the lev even is the lev of9:50taavot. We become a generation of just running after9:53taavot, and really taavah shows selfishness:9:57only focus on myself,9:58only focus on me.10:00And that's why it's compared to a stone.10:02The yetzer hara of taavot is compared to a stone,10:05and it's mitamtem levo shel adam. It blocks up the person's heart10:08and makes him only focus on his10:10taavot and on himself, on his own desires,10:12and he couldn't care about anybody else.10:16Now,10:19v'im barzel hu, mitpotzetz me'esh. And if the yetzer hara is made out of steel,10:21that's10:22min hamez, the yetzer hara of10:24ka'as, it says it'll shatter.10:25That represents yetzer hara of10:28ka'as. Why? Because it's easier.10:29It's easier to shatter.10:30If something is standing in front of you,10:32if you have to melt it, it'll take a long time.10:34But if you have to shatter, it's not a big deal.10:35Just take a big hammer, boom,10:37and you break it down.10:40Because you can break it by just getting away from it completely.10:45That's why you can break it right away.10:46And that's the meaning of the10:48pasuk. We come back to pasuk in10:51Mishlei. Im ra ev sonacha, if your10:54yetzer hara, which is the enemy,10:56is hungry,10:59right? Hachilehu lechem. What's lechem?11:00Lechem represents the11:04halachot. Why?11:05Because lechem, everybody needs to learn.11:08It's a basic staple of food, right?11:10Everybody needs bread.11:11You got to put bread on the table.11:13So everybody needs11:15halachot. Every single person needs,11:16even the most basic Jew needs to know what to do,11:20right? Jew needs to know it's all about halachot and what to do and11:25mitzvot. So, v'im tzame, and if he's thirsty,11:28hashkehu mayim, give him water.11:29And we said the water represents aggadot11:31because they're moshech like water.11:33That's against the yetzer hara of11:36taavot. This is where the Gra says it in11:39Mishlei. A beautiful, beautiful idea.11:41So we'll stop over here, bezrat Hashem,11:44and we'll continue next time.