Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 2, Lesson 4Sefer Even ShelemaPart 29Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:009:20Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:08Eben Shelema, perek bet, ot gimel. Bara gufe, yesh tov v'ra. In evil itself, within evil itself, there's also some good and some0:15evil.0:21D'hainu, ta'ava hu tov shebara. For0:21example, ta'ava is the good in the evil, v'kaas hu ra shebara. And the kaas is the evil in evil.0:25V'hatov shebara, and the good in the evil,0:28d'hainu hata'ava hu garua min hara. But the good in the evil is actually worse than the regular evil,0:34ki al yedei hatov sheb'sitra achra hadam nitpateh, because that's how a person gets looted into the evil.0:39Because nobody will be on their guard when somebody is coming very, very evil.0:43But when something is good within evil, so that's how they get you,0:46and that's really a very scary thing.0:49And the Gra is known to say this in other places.0:52The Gra says, if you see yourself running towards mitzvot, stop.0:57What do you mean, I'm running towards0:59mitzvah? Did you earn it? Did you work on it?1:02Do you know how hard it is for a person to develop?1:04Imagine, the1:05yetzer hara. It doesn't make sense that the yetzer hara is trying to make a person do a1:10mitzvah or allows a person to do a1:12mitzvah. V'hakam, you have all of a sudden it's getting big and big and big,1:15and you have such a... you're doing so much.1:17Be careful.1:18The yetzer hara is digging up something for you in the back.1:20So that's why this is a very important rule that the Gra is saying over here,1:28is that the only way you could get fooled by the yetzer hara is by the good in evil,1:33by the good inside of the evil.1:34So, you know, it's like the famous saying, if somebody comes to you and says,1:37Hey, worship avodah zarah,1:39or let's join Christianity,1:41right?1:42But if somebody tells you, No, no, no, no, let's join this shiur,1:46let's join this shul.1:49Okay,1:50you go there,1:51you hear things that are maybe sound a little bit different from what you're used to,1:55but not off.1:57You don't think anything is wrong,1:59right?1:59But you don't know,2:00but that's really where it's really evil.2:02That's, I don't want to say things on recording right here,2:05but hacham Ovadia used to yell about certain groups of people.2:08Says they're worse than the2:10chilonim, but they're religious.2:12They keep Shabbat.2:12He says they're worse.2:15Why?2:15Because of what the Gra is saying over here.2:16A person only gets fooled by that.2:19Only person gets sketched by that.2:23If the goyim would come to a person and tell him,2:26Hey, come join us,2:27everybody knows2:28to stay away. But if you, you don't know how to2:29stay away. So the tov and the ra, the good and the evil from the2:34sitra achra, is very, very tricky.2:36We're going to pause.2:37So this אות ג has like three paragraphs, as you can see over here,2:40one, two, three,2:41right?2:41We're going to pause by each one and see the source in the actual words of the2:46Gra. Look,2:48it comes from pasuk2:50in Mishlei, two pesukim in Mishlei, two different explanations.2:52Look what he says over here.2:53Pasuk says in2:54Mishlei, in perek bet, pasuk2:59yud bet, לְהַצִּילְךָ מִדֶּרֶךְ רָע, מֵאִישׁ מְדַבֵּר תַּהְפֻּכוֹת. The Torah will save you from the evil way,3:03from a man who speaks3:05twistiness. Says the Gra, and very important yesod,3:10בסיטרא אחרא הוא גם כן דוכרא ונוקבא. A little bit of pikkabalah over here.3:11In the yetzer, in the, excuse me, in the sitra achra, which represents the evil side,3:17right,3:18the world of evil,3:19there's also male and female,3:20which represent different types,3:22like physical male and physical female,3:25chas v'shalom. This, what it means, is just a concept for us to understand.3:28There's a giver, receiver;3:29that's a different class.3:32וְהֵן סוד תאוניביקה ועשני, and they represent taavah and3:35kaasah. And remember, we mentioned in the past that the Gra has this klal:3:38the two main yetzer hara are taavah and3:41kaasah, desires, running after a person's physical desires,3:44and anger,3:45which you could tell right away3:46if you think about it. Whenever you had a desire,3:48whenever you had anger,3:49they are completely two different parts.3:51They don't get along, if you want to say.3:54וְהַטוֹב, the good, which is3:59taavah, the good thing, which is taavah, because taavah can be good for,4:02you know, listen, you can eat,4:03there's kosher food,4:04that's actually worse than evil.4:09הַכַּעַס, כמו שכתוב, טוב כעס משחוק. What does the pasuk say?4:11Anger is better than laughter,4:13Kohelet says,4:15כי על ידי הטוב של הסיטרא אחרא אדם מתפתה. Because why is it better?4:17And it says, for a person to protect himself,4:19he knows how to protect himself from the evil of the evil.4:22But the good and the evil,4:24he doesn't know how to protect himself from it4:25because it looks good.4:28Another pasuk in Yeshayahu says,4:33אִמְרַת ה' מצואת בין ציון ודמיו ירושלים ידיח. Hashem will wash the waste of the girls of4:37Tzion, referring to the Jewish people,4:38and the bloods of Yerushalayim He'll rinse.4:43Says the Gra, what is4:46this, צואת בין ציון? It means4:48hu ni'uf. It represents girls,4:50females; it represents the4:53koach ha-taavani, the power of the yetzer hara in the person4:56to run after his desires,4:58which is, you know,4:59znut and all these things.5:01וְדְמֵי ירושלים, the bloods of5:03Yerushalayim represents a different type of5:05yetzer hara. What is that type of5:06yetzer hara? That's dam, blood, bloodshed that comes from anger,5:10that comes from killing.5:13הִנֵּה יצרו וכוח הכעסני. See again how the pasuk is referring to these two powers.5:17And Hashem says He's going to wash them.5:20וְתאוות ה' מן הכעס. He says taavah is actually worse than5:26kaas. כמו שכתוב טוב כעס משחוק, וזה שכתב גם דמי ידיח בדחא בעלמא. And that's why the verbs that are used over here5:30for5:32צואת בין ציון, it says5:33רחץ. Rachatz is a deep washing.5:34הדחה is just rinsing.5:37Rechitzah is dipping it into a pool of water,5:41and netilah, just, you know,5:42just put a little bit, spread a little bit of water on it.5:44Why?5:45Because the yetzer hara of taavah is much harder5:47than the yetzer hara of5:51kaas, not just in by itself,5:53but because, you know,5:54lemashal, let's give you5:56a mashal. A guy who is eating, right?5:57He has to eat to survive.5:59But when you eat too much,6:01it's taavah, and that can lead to eating that's asur,6:03eating things that are, you know,6:04out of control, right?6:06So that's all part of6:08the... But you can't let go of it completely,6:10kaas. You just accept on6:11yourself and never to get angry no matter what,6:13and that's it.6:13You don't need it.6:14You don't need to use it.6:15And a few times that you need to use it,6:17which is once in a blue moon,6:20lo shaveh. That means you could go throughout your life6:22completely shutting off6:23kaas. Will you have really been accomplishing that6:26you captured that6:27yetzer hara? No, but you don't need to use it.6:29Taavah, you don't know such a thing.6:30If you try,6:31and the Gemara says that they did try that,6:34that6:35after Beit HaMikdash harishon,6:36prayed that there should be no yetzer hara for6:40taavot. People didn't want to be with their wives.6:42People didn't want also that6:44the chickens wouldn't have eggs6:46because they wouldn't mate.6:49So that's the idea over here,6:51that you have to use it,6:53and because you have to use it6:54makes it a little bit more dangerous.6:55Next.6:55Next paragraph, we go back to the6:58Even Shleimah. He says,6:59V'chen b'taavah v'chemdah. Also, we explained already what taavah and chemdah is.7:02Taavah is physical desire.7:04Chemdah is desire for external things7:06like money, possessions.7:14Hataavah hu garua, v'tzarich harchakah yotera mipnei sheyesh lah chelkat lashon. Taavah's worse.7:15Physical desires are worse.7:18Why? Because it's a very slippery slope.7:22Shemara atzmah l'adam koeh. It looks like it's there for your own benefit,7:25ledet lo ta'anugei olam hazeh, right?7:27To give you, you know, enjoy life a little bit.7:29What's the problem?7:30So it's not a big deal, you know,7:32yay, sit in a nice pool,7:34get suntan,7:35you know, it's relax a little bit.7:37But we know7:38it could also lead a person down a slippery slope,7:41right?7:41Then a person becomes in need for him,7:43can't live without it.7:44That's the idea of drugs,7:45right?7:46In the beginning it's just a relaxer.7:48It can be medication that he needs,7:50and after a while it's something, you know,7:52that he can't live without,7:54and we know the addicting nature.7:58Ma she'ein ken hachemda, not so when it comes to chemdah.8:05שנומני יחלו לשון, חמדה, זה לאתגייס לי, ואין לו הנאה ממש אפילו בעולם הזה. What's8:06chemdah? Running after money,8:07and everybody knows,8:08right? Yes, people are running and trying like crazy to have more and more money,8:12but they know, like, you know, it kills them,8:14right? You work nonstop, and you have so much stress,8:18and when you own so many different places, your head is all over.8:21It doesn't give a guy menuchah even8:24olam hazeh. So therefore, a person after a while says, you know, or him or his wife will say,8:27Who needs this? What do I need this for?8:31Right?8:32But when vacation, nobody says, What do I need this for?8:34Because on vacation, you always want more vacation.8:39וכן ברע אומר מה. And same thing in evil and trickery.8:43That's the idea of trickery,8:45like Lavan. He looks like your father and your uncle,8:48but he's really a tricky person.8:49And it just brought that example to show also the characters in the8:53Torah are really coming to shed light also on a lot of things that are in nature9:00or in the spiritual world as well,9:04on our yetzer hara, like over here. I'm looking at the time. I don't have so much time to go into it.9:08Tomorrow we'll come back because we'll review this point from the inside,9:11and then we'll come back to finish the whole piece, be'ezrat Hashem.