Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 2, Lesson 19Sefer Even ShelemaPart 43Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:10Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Perek bet, ot yud-gimel, the last ot in this perek,0:05and then we go to another subject.0:06This is what's good about this perek.0:08If you're following and0:10you listen—I mean this book, excuse me—this is what's good about this book,0:12is that each perek is a different subject.0:14Sometimes things feel a little heavy, like,0:16Oh my gosh, this is too hard.0:18You go to the next perek, it's like a whole new book.0:21It's a whole new subject.0:23Again, it's talk about musar,0:24and it's talk about how things work,0:25but it's a different way of things,0:27you know, a different discussion,0:29and it's really something very, very nice.0:31All of them are very, very nice,0:32again, without—doesn't need my0:36haskamah. Hata'avah, last piece,0:37ready?0:39Hata'avah, ein ra'ui lelech achareiha klal. Ta'avah—it's not proper that you should go after it at all.0:43Aval—now remember, we kept on saying before,0:46there's ta'avan, chemdah, we already know by now.0:47Ta'avah is a physical desire, and chemdah is monetary things.0:53Aval chemdat haparnasah vehamamon eino asur0:55legamrei. You know, it's an amazing thing, right?0:56You would think they're the opposite, people say, right?0:58Okay, but he's telling you that the desire for parnasa and money,1:03it's not asur completely,1:04kemo shekatuv, like it says in the pasuk,1:09Right?1:10We see. So why is—if it's really a problem,1:14why—you know, that should have been the question people should have asked.1:16If it's really a problem, why is the Torah full of it?1:19You know,1:20lemashal, I'll give you an example.1:21This is a little bit of a chinuch, right?1:23One of my relatives1:25who has a little bit more guts than we do1:31is—so she has a kid that's, I1:33don't know, first, second grade, very young, basically.1:37So she got a call from one of the teachers:1:40Yeah, your son... still, he's always going crazy.1:43So she says, Can I ask you a question?1:44She says, Yeah.1:45When my son does good things in1:47school, what do you do in school?1:48How do you reward him?1:49She says, I give him candy.1:50She says, Listen, I am so careful not to give sugar1:54and all these food coloring to my kids in my house,1:56and my kids in my house are okay.1:58If you want to give him candy and he's going crazy,2:00it's not my fault; it's your fault.2:02Don't reward him with things that are gonna drive you nuts2:05and then come back to me and complain.2:07If you don't know how to control the class without the2:09things, you take care of it,2:11right?2:11So she's put her in her place,2:12which is a very true thing.2:15And my wife,2:17she, you know, after she heard this story,2:18so she got a phone call from one of my son's2:21teachers. She told2:22them, Listen, my wife has her own style.2:24She says, Listen,2:25I'm not telling you what to do,2:27but I'm just telling you, for my son,2:29do me a favor.2:30You know, don't give him sugar.2:31It doesn't work good with him.2:33He goes cuckoo,2:34okay?2:34Just for2:35my—what do you mean?2:36Just for my son,2:37okay?2:38So she thought, the teacher thought that my wife is crazy.2:40How do I know?2:40Because she told her later the same thing.2:42She was like, She told my wife is crazy.2:43She tried it.2:44Then she said, You know,2:45I have a son.2:45The teacher said like this:2:46I have a son in my house2:47that drives me nuts,2:48and sometimes I can't stand to be next to him.2:51That's what she told my wife.2:52I said, Let me try it.2:54She went home.2:55She said, We're cutting out all the candies,2:57all the things from the house.2:58Yes, they can get out, but in the house we're cutting it out.3:00Said the kid was completely different.3:02They were invited the next time,3:04like a few weeks later,3:05they were invited to her mother3:07or her3:09mother-in-law, I don't know whether—she called up the mother3:10or mother-in-law. She says, Listen,3:11if you want me to come to your house,3:13you cannot give any of my kids candy.3:15Then I would come.3:17They came.3:17She loved it.3:18She saw that the kids are very different.3:20So she now—look how far it went.3:22That mother went to tell all her daughters the same thing:3:25Make sure you don't give them things.3:27But it's me to say3:29that if your child, right,3:30if the reward itself is damaging,3:33you don't give it.3:35You don't give it.3:36So now we come back.3:37If you're telling me the whole time,3:38Get away from3:40taavah. Hemdat, it's horrible.3:41Look in the Torah,3:43right?3:43Everybody is dying to get those3:49berachot: Ve'achalta ve'savata u'verachta, ve'achalta ve'savata... We say it every day.3:50What's going on?3:50Get food, get money.3:53Also, so he's explaining to you,3:54the3:55berachah that the Torah is talking about,3:57that hemdat parnassah, it's okay.3:58It's not3:59asur legamrei, but with a condition:4:02rak sheyihyeh be'emunah. On the bottom,4:03explain what does mean4:04be'emunah. It4:06means beyosher. Right? You got to be straight.4:08Money is not the bottom line.4:09Unfortunately, people that get sucked into money,4:11the money becomes the bottom line,4:13and all the rules of the game4:16are all pushed to the side.4:18ועשית הישר והטוב is gone.4:20וגזל is gone4:21sometimes for some people.4:23Not everybody,4:23but for some people it's gone.4:24But,4:26ופשוט ועשית הישר והטוב, it's, you know,4:26it becomes called4:28דעלים גבר — whoever is stronger survives,4:29and you crush everybody4:30who comes in your way4:31and everything else.4:32So it's not4:34ביושר, ולא יגבה ממון שאינו שלו. Don't touch any money that's not yours.4:35Be very careful4:36not to touch money that's not yours.4:39And of4:39course, the real4:41ganavim that steal outright,4:42you know,4:42that's child stuff.4:44That's — we're not talking,4:45we're not dealing with4:45amei ha'aretz, we're not dealing with such,4:46you know, low-class people.4:48You know,4:48when you get them high class,4:49the stealing becomes very different,4:51right?4:51It becomes more4:53in the higher class4:54and higher things,4:55and a person has to be4:56always checking himself.4:57If he's honest,4:58he's not honest.4:59So let's see on the bottom5:02the source of these words from,5:04what do you call it,5:06from the Gra. Look what it says in the pasuk:5:10להצילך מאשה זרה. The pasuk says that basically5:12— Shlomo HaMelech was talking about the Torah.5:14He says5:14it's going to save you,5:15or he's talking about his book, really,5:17or the Torah5:17— it depends how you interpret5:18the beginning of that book.5:19It's all in the beginning of Perek Mishlei.5:21It says5:21this is to save you from a strange woman,5:25מנכריה. Also means strange,5:26right?5:28אמריה החלקה, where her words are very slippery.5:31Okay,5:31what does that mean?5:36Nefsha shetaavah hi hana'at haguf mamash, vehemdah mah she'ein bah hana'at haguf. The Gra writes,5:37which he's written a few times,5:39we saw it a few times,5:40that taavah is physical, bodily pleasures.5:45Hemdah is not bodily pleasures.5:49Vezu hataavah nikret nochriyah. This5:50taavah, that's a bodily pleasure,5:52is called in the pasuk5:54nochriyah. Why?5:56Ki taavot einam reuyot livnei Yisrael. Taavot are not for the Jewish people.6:00Vehem laam nochri. They belong to the goyim.6:03Asher lom Bnei Yisrael hemadah, not for the Jewish people.6:08Us,6:08that's not what should be driving us.6:10We should not be6:10driven by the newest6:12taavot, by newest temptations,6:13by newest physical pleasures.6:14Velachen hi6:15dugmat Bat El Nechar. That's why it's compared6:16to a nochriyah, to6:19a goyah. Goyah, get away,6:20we all know.6:21Assimilation, get away,6:22get away, stay away from them.6:25Vahemdah hi6:28hanekret isha zarah. The hemdah, which is desire of the money,6:29is called a strange woman.6:31What does it mean?6:32Ki ishah shemBnei Yisrael hi6:34muteret likach otah lishah. You can marry6:34any Jewish woman you want.6:39Ki ishah zarah shelakach otah ishah, helezu asur ligaa klal uklal. In general,6:40the ishah zarah means6:41she used to be married,6:43she's a divorcee, right?6:45Or she could6:46be, whatever,6:46but she was previously married.6:48She's a6:49ishah zarah. She's now a regular woman.6:50She's, you know,6:51basically6:54Arby. Ken hemdat haparnasah vehamamon eino asur mikol vekol. So too,6:56it's definitely not first choice.6:58Take a guy who's single,6:59he's starting7:00to date, 22 years old,7:01right, prime age,7:02and they tell him,7:03okay, we have a great girl,7:04she's divorced,7:05but wonderful family,7:07right? Once you hear that word7:08divorced, well, but no,7:09she was only married for a week,7:11a month,7:11three months,7:12you7:12know, some people say.7:13Who cares?7:14Once the word divorced is there,7:16it's gone.7:17That's so, it's not first, you know, choice.7:20So that's what he's telling you.7:24Hemdat haparnasah vehamamon eino asur mikol vekol. It's not that7:32chemdat mamon is asur, ki ken ketiv, וְלֹא תַחְמֹד אֵשֶׁת רֵעֶךָ, בְּכֹל אֲשֶׁר לְרֵעֶךָ, בְּכֹל מַעֲשֵׂה יָדֶיךָ אֲשֶׁר תַּעֲשֶׂה, right?7:33It says in the7:34pasuk, Hashem will bless you7:35with such things.7:40אך באמונה מאוד ולא יעשה עוול. However, it has to be with emunah,7:43without any twistedness.7:46Don't touch any money7:47that's not yours.7:48וְרֵעֵנוּ של אשתו, that's what it means,7:50של אשתו. As long as that isha7:51is still married to a man,7:53you cannot touch it.7:55So the isha7:56isha, right,7:57she's going to give it from her.7:58As long she's married.8:00It's asur. She wants to get divorced, and then you want to marry her?8:04Okay. But even that is not preferred.8:06So you see also the same thing in musar, in business,8:09right? We see sometimes people that have possession, we want them.8:12They have customers, we want those customers.8:14They have a clientele, we want them.8:16We want line, we want to knock them out8:19of, right? And that's in a way which, you know,8:22it's like what David was criticizing on his level, of course,8:25of what he felt that she belonged to him,8:29he knocked out the competition,8:31right? If she belongs to you, and the Zohar explains8:34that really Batsheva belonged to David.8:36The mistake was that he jumped the gun.8:39He saw through a hakodesh correctly.8:41She belonged to him.8:42The mistake was that you jumped the gun.8:44You didn't wait.8:46If he would have waited, the same thing would have happened.8:49And the same thing we tell everybody.8:50That's what8:51the Gemara says, that kol harodef achar hasha'ah, hasha'ah rodefet oto, something like that.8:58What is it? Nerdefet... I don't want to quote the Gemara wrong,8:59but the idea of the Gemara is that9:00if you run after something that doesn't belong to you yet,9:03you end up losing it.9:05But if you don't run after it,9:07it will come to you.9:08It might come more, it takes much longer, but it will come to you.9:10What's coming to you will come to you.9:12You don't need to be, you know, aggressive for it.9:16So he's saying over here the same thing.9:18Like it says,9:20Natata be'emunah. The first question they ask you after 120 is,9:24Natata be'emunah. What does it mean, Natata be'emunah? It means,9:25did you make sure that the ishah that you had9:28was not9:29ishah zarah? Did you make sure that it belongs to you, which is the money?9:35Lachen nikreit Achimda ishah zarah, shehachimda mevi'ah lechmod mamon shel ish zar. That's why chimda is called9:37ishah zarah. You look in the Mishlei, now he's giving you a rule.9:39Whenever it says ishah zarah, it refers to mamon.9:41Why?9:43Because it brings you to desire other people's things.9:45Think about it.9:46Before you were in a certain line of9:48business, you never cared about this guy has and this guy has.9:50When you come into their line of business,9:52all of a sudden you feel them as your competition.9:56Anyone's after that. Anyone take over their things.9:57It's a crazy thing, right?9:59I mean, if you imagine somebody would tell you,10:01Baruch Hashem, just got married,10:02you know, we joined a new neighborhood.10:04I wish I had that guy's wife.10:07Ay, ya, isiko. How do you talk like that,10:09right?10:09But when we talk like that in money,10:12you know, like you talk in business,10:13right? I'm gonna take over the whole market. I'm taking over.10:16What is that doing?10:18What did Amazon do?10:19Took everybody's wives.10:20I mean, again,10:22that's what it is, right?10:23A guy makes money,10:24Amazon copies it,10:25says Amazon's choice, goodbye.10:30Ish gazalah, right?10:31You took somebody else's thing.10:33No, I didn't take, I took my—10:34So you're allowed to compete.10:35There's also rules of halachot.10:36I'm just telling you the idea of it.10:38We don't— if we would put it together,10:40Shlomo HaMelech is putting it together,10:41we'd start to see ourselves in a whole different picture.10:43We'd start to look at ourselves and say,10:45Whoa, maybe.10:46And if it's gonna be coming to you,10:47I'm telling you it's gonna come to you.10:49It's gonna come to you,10:50or whatever, it will come to you in the right way.10:56And that's the meaning of10:58pasuk. Ish gazalah is11:00mamon, and nochria is11:03ta'avah. I do agree that they're taking a lot of things that Amazon—