Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 2, Lesson 15Sefer Even ShelemaPart 40Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:06Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:03Even shelma perek yud alef. I love statements like this that begin like this:0:07Derech hayetzer hara. It's an unbelievable statement. I'll tell you why.0:10I'm telling you how things work.0:12You go to a manufacturer of anything, of a computer, of a clothing, of a car,0:20and he tells you, Listen, we make the car over here,0:23and I'm telling you the way it works is as follows,0:26all right? Sometimes what I do is, you know, you go, you look up videos of how to do things,0:31how to, you know, how they had to put on my boiler.0:33The way the boiler works is like this.0:35Okay, beautiful, now you understand.0:37So statements like this that come from the0:39Gra, it doesn't come from, you know, stam a person with his own observation.0:43This is the Gra talking.0:46He says, Derech hayetzer hara... he's telling you how the yetzer hara works.0:52Lehasit b'tachlal limud, v'gam limnot ta'avato. In the beginning he tells you, No, go learn Torah,0:54and also enjoy both worlds.0:57Why should you neglect yourself?0:59So he wants you to learn and get your ta'avot at the same time.1:02Why?1:05Ki im yesito shelo limod klal, lo yishma lo. We're not dealing with a, you know, a human being who's not so clever.1:14We're dealing with the yetzer hara. It's a malach, rabotai. It's an angel,1:16and he's been around for a long time.1:18He knows how to work.1:20He knows the best way and how to get to the person.1:22He's telling you because if he would try to dissuade you1:26not to learn at all,1:27lo yishma lo. You're never going to listen to1:28him. What? You want me to leave my religion? You want me to leave my Torah?1:33Kasher gilasman haguf. But at the same time, you're allowed to learn and enjoy.1:35What's the problem?1:36When a person accustoms himself already1:38of just making sure that he always has to be physically taken care of,1:43az meila lo yilmad. That's it. He got him.1:44Then eventually he'll give up himself from learning,1:49ki tarud tamid limnot anat haguf, because he's always very busy trying to fulfill his1:54ta'avot, to make sure that he's physically comfortable,1:59vayetzer hara omer lo shezeh zikli briuto k'sheyazov regelo. And then... The yetzer tells him, Ah, excuse me, no, no, not then. When he's not getting his2:06hana'ah haguf, the yetzer tells him, But you're ruining it.2:08You're ruining yourself,2:09health-wise. I'm not telling—he comes from an intellectual point,2:13right? You're gonna not be healthy.2:14If you're not gonna be healthy, how are you gonna learn Torah?2:16So you need to take care of it.2:20And then all the yetzer is, you know, he's working just getting the next step,2:24which is what?2:25To make sure that he becomes a little lazy now from running after Torah2:31u'mitzvot. Even though with this it will not be missing from the2:34ta'avah, it's okay, we just want to get him lazy,2:37and once you're lazy, you fall out of it,2:39then you don't want to do with them anymore.2:42Even if it's effortless, even if it's so easy to do already,2:46he already got what he wanted.2:49Before we get to the actual, what do you call it,2:52to the actual2:55... it's interesting because I'm learning now a lot about different things.2:59I'm reading a lot of books,3:00and it talks when everyone institute change in any place,3:03there's always gonna be resistance,3:05right? Think about it.3:06When you come with any rule,3:08even in your own house,3:09From now on we're doing this,3:11guess what's gonna happen?3:12Oh!3:13Right? Big balagan.3:15In New York City here, in Brooklyn,3:17they said, No more turning right on Avenue U,3:21on Avenue—not Avenue, excuse3:23me—on Kings Highway, Avenue P,3:27and Avenue...3:29Oh, people came out, protests and things,3:31da da da da. But they took that into calculation beforehand.3:33They knew that they have more people that don't care than people that do care.3:39So they figured the protest,3:41but if it would have been a big protest, whoa,3:43right?3:43They thought about it beforehand. They did.3:45Why? Because they know any change will always...3:48The bus lane now.3:49Oh, so you see,3:50once you start3:51changing—but what you do is,3:52when you start changing a little bit very slowly.3:54Now, what would happen if you convince the people that this is good for them?3:58Then the people come and demand, and they say,4:00This is what we want.4:01So the yetzer hara is the same way.4:03If the yetzer hara will come and tell you and attack you head4:05on with things of value that you believe are very, very important to you,4:10he can't get you.4:12There's a famous Gemara,4:21כך דרכו של יצר הרע. היום אומר לך עשה כך, ומחר אומר לך עשה כך, עד שהולך ועובד עבודה זרה. What?4:21This is a Gemara?4:22What's the Gemara talking about?4:23Today he tells you this, today he tells you that.4:25What's this, that?4:26And the answer is,4:27he tells you things that you want to hear,4:29right?4:30And once he tells you things that you want,4:31he's got you on his side,4:32slowly, slowly, slowly.4:33Now you're with him,4:34he's your buddy,4:35right?4:35As one rabbi said,4:36I know my yetzer hara by his first name.4:38His name's Yetz,4:39you know?4:39What's going on, Yetz?4:41We talk on a first-name basis,4:43you know.4:43Some people, you have to go over full, you4:45know,4:46Mister so-and-so, Mister yetzer hara.4:47No, no, no.4:47Yetz, me and him are buddies,4:49right?4:49That's how your yetzer hara looks at you.4:50You're a buddy.4:51Once he got you,4:52right,4:53and then what he wants to do is4:55get you more into the4:56ta'avot, and then you yourself would not want it.4:59There's a mashal.5:00I once heard it from Rabbi Tauber, a beautiful mashal,5:02explains the evil between Amalek5:05and between Mitzrayim.5:07Why do we always,5:09תמחה את זכר עמלק? What's the evil of Amalek?5:10So he gives a mashal.5:12A father kicks out his son,5:14but the father is very influential man.5:16He's got a lot of money,5:17he's got a lot of, you know,5:18he's got a lot of people behind him.5:20He's a tough guy.5:21But he kicks out his son,5:22he wants to teach him a lesson.5:23The son goes out,5:24and now the father has enemies.5:26They find that the son is without his father,5:28they come and they beat up on him.5:30But the father finds out soon enough.5:32He sends his guys,5:33they go and they take these gangsters5:34and they beat the daylights out of them,5:36and5:36they wipe out some of them.5:38Good,5:38don't mess with my son.5:40Another group finds out5:41that the father kicked out his son.5:43They said, No, we're not going to be5:44idiots like the other one.5:45They take the son, they bring him in,5:46they give him food,5:47they take care of him.5:49Right?5:50And slowly, slowly,5:50they start telling him,5:52You're a great guy.5:53You don't need your father.5:55Part of us.5:57Your father kicks you out.5:58We love you,5:59right?5:59And slowly,6:00slowly, the father, after a while,6:02he comes6:02and he sends a letter to the son,6:03Okay, come back.6:04He says, Okay, I don't need you.6:06Who's worse?6:08The second guy.6:10You understand?6:10It's more evil,6:11and you're completely disconnected.6:14So that's the difference6:15between Mitzrayim and Amalek.6:16Mitzrayim, they took us6:17and beat the daylights out of us.6:18They put us as slaves,6:20and they killed us and did things.6:22Hashem came and brought ten makot.6:26Amalek's shita is that6:27kefirah is to get into,6:30asher karcha baderech. He cooled you off,6:31right?6:32That you now don't want Hashem.6:34Hashem says,6:35Such an6:35attitude—now, of course,6:36if it would have extended,6:37it would have been much6:38worse—such an attitude,6:38you got to wipe it out.6:40No, no, no, no,6:41no leftovers.6:41Mitzrayim, after three generations,6:43you can marry them.6:44Not so by Amalek.6:45And this is the derech of the6:47yetzer hara. That's exactly what the6:47yetzer hara wants to do.6:48You know,6:49it's a small fish for him6:50to just do this6:51aveirah. It's not a big accomplishment.6:52The big accomplishment is6:54when you say,6:55I don't want to do it.6:56Oh,6:56you say,6:57I don't want to do it.6:58He is6:59accomplished. And that's really,7:00I'll tell you,7:03letovah, mikol melamdai hiskalti, right?7:03You have to learn from everybody.7:05Even from the7:06rasha'im, you can learn even more,7:07right?7:08And7:09letovah, it's the same way.7:09You want to get anybody7:10on your side,7:11you want to get anybody7:11to do something,7:13if you come in7:13and force something on them,7:14you're not going to get anywhere.7:16If you come7:17and you convince them,7:18you show them,7:19You're my buddy,7:19you're my friend,7:20we love you,7:21da-da-da, and then he wants to do it,7:23you accomplish everything.7:24Now,7:25you can manipulate it.7:26You can use this idea7:27to manipulate your way7:28around things.7:29Or if you're a good person,7:30which you're listening to this class,7:32I'm assuming you're trying7:32to be a good person,7:33so7:34you can use it in a positive way.7:36You want to influence your kids,7:38your spouses7:38in the right way7:39to go in the right direction.7:41That's the way to do it.7:42And think about it.7:43I've had talks with fathers,7:44I've had talks with couples7:45so many times.7:46You know,7:47what's common7:48statement that people will tell me?7:49You know how many times I7:50yelled? You know how many times I told them?7:53So7:54I learned this from a therapist also.7:56Obviously it didn't work.8:01Right, you yell at the child, obviously it doesn't work.8:02At which point did you decide that it doesn't work?8:05It doesn't work. It really doesn't work.8:07You yell, you yell, you yell, it doesn't work.8:09So you realize, hey, obviously something is different.8:12We got to get them to be on our side.8:14So once upon a time, you know, we saw that video,8:17you know, ... scared terrible.8:19At least you got them controlled for those period of time that they're in your house.8:22After your house, they're gone, and I don't know what they're doing,8:24which is horrible by itself.8:26But if you want, really, the best chinuch is to teach them.8:29And this answers another question in8:31chinuch. You know, I have the non-religious, you know,8:33I used to learn with non-religious kids.8:35I'm not talking about little kids. I'm talking about 19, 20 years old.8:39So, Rabbi, you don't have a TV?8:40I said, no, I don't have a TV.8:41What do you think, when your kid gets older, he's not going to go watch a TV?8:44He can't watch a TV?8:44He goes... I said, I can't be in control of my kid wherever he goes, even now.8:48Forget about older.8:49Even now, he could go and, you know,8:52I know kids that sometimes, you know, no internet,8:54they'll go to Staples and go to the internet,8:57right? They could get internet from anywhere else.8:58The point of chinuch is not that I control them.9:02The point of chinuch is that I train them,9:04that they know on their own that this is not good,9:07that when they go somewhere else, they know this we don't do.9:09Why? That's how I was trained,9:12not that's how I was forced.9:13You could force somebody, but if you're not looking over their shoulder,9:18you don't know what they're doing, and they're going to lie to you.9:21Chazal tell us the same thing by a woman who's scared into doing the mitzvot,9:24a guy who puts fear,9:32... Why? A guy who scares his wife,9:36and, lemaaseh, I know cases like this,9:38who scares his wife, right,9:40into doing mitzvot,9:40and all of a sudden she's up to her sixth day of counting,9:44she's going to the mikveh in two days,9:45she sees a stain of blood.9:48This is,9:50according to lashon, it could be de'oraita when she does the bedikah.9:52She has to count over,9:53but her husband is fuming.9:55What's she gonna do?9:55He's gonna flip out if I tell him.9:57So she doesn't count.10:00She doesn't count all over again.10:01She continues.10:02Seven and six,10:03you know, next day she goes to the10:05mikveh. Why? Because she's scared of her husband.10:07So, look, I put10:09firm. My house runs.10:10Yeah, but what are you running it on?10:13So the way to get them is10:21like,10:22... Send you to the principal.10:25Okay, so, right?10:28For us, ... Let's see the10:30Gra over here10:30already. I'm on10:3110:30. So let's just see very quickly.10:33... on the bottom over here,10:39... What do we say in10:41vidui, right?10:43Ta'inu, we got lost.10:46Ta'ta'nu. Sounds like we also got lost.10:47It's a double.10:48Like we made others lost.10:50You want to say,10:53okay? Sanu mi'mitzvotecha. We were straight away from your mitzvot and from your laws,10:56which are good,10:58v'lo shava lanu, and it's not worth it for us.11:08Says the Gra about the yetzer hara: ... Learn also for your own benefit.11:11You know, let's say11:12segulah, right? Ki אי אפשר ... כי לא ישמע אליו. The yetzer hara can't tell you, Don't learn at all.11:15You're not gonna listen to him.11:18... Learn, but also for your own benefit,11:22because ... And then when you get so accustomed to the luxuries11:25that you can't live without them,11:27what happens?11:30אז ממילא הוא ילמוד, כי צריך לזה, שהוא מורגל בו. Then you got so used to those luxuries,11:33you can't live without them.11:36וזה מתחילה תעינו. That's the meaning of11:39ta'inu. היינו שסבורים שנוכל לעשות שניהם. This is where we got lost.11:41It all starts from that first word,11:44ta'inu. How do we get lost?11:45We thought that we could grab both worlds at the same time,11:48enjoy11:49olam hazeh and be also a big11:54tzaddik and kadosh, ... Then we got really lost.11:59Then we got so used to the luxuries12:01that we can't live without them.12:05And all of a sudden, we can't handle without them,12:08it's sick,12:10and the yetzer tells us, you see, you can't live without them.12:12You need them.12:14And then what happens?12:15We start to go off the path,12:19because we're always busy running after12:21the good things that this world has to offer.12:24And then what do we say at the end?12:26It's not worth it for us.12:32What does it mean? That even when we have the ability to do mitzvah12:35without any effort,12:36and we got to the point that we lost the flavor,12:40we're out of it.12:40We fell out of it.12:41We're not in the mood for it anymore.12:42And this applies to each person on his own level.12:44For some people it could be maybe12:46tefillat Shacharit. For some people it could be mitzvot, covering her hair.12:49It could be for people keeping Shabbat.12:51It could be for people keeping kashrut.12:53All the same idea, every different level.12:55It is a lot connected with Torah12:57or a person's lifestyle.12:59That's what the Gra is talking about,12:59but you can apply it in small scales on everybody's level. Baruch Hashem, amen v'amen.