Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 2, Lesson 10Sefer Even ShelemaPart 35Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:28Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Eben Shelema, perek bet, ot zayin.0:03So let's do the Eben Shelema first, and then we'll see the peirush of the Gra on the side.0:08We're talking about the middot of taavah specifically right now.0:12So we saw yesterday that taavah could literally take away from a person his middot, the good middot that he's born with.0:18So he says over here,0:23Lo yomar ha'adam elech me'at achar ha-taavah ve'echamda, ve'achar kach efrosh meihem. Now, don't let the yetzer hara fool you and tell you,0:25Okay, you know what? I'm going to go, I indulge taavah a little bit. I'm just going to, just a little bit, just I'm going to go a little bit after taavah and0:32chemdah. We said taavah and chemdah are two different things, just to remind everybody.0:35Taavah is physical pleasure. Chemdah is, I guess, property pleasure or monetarily pleasure, right?0:44Having a lot of money. That's not physical pleasure, right?0:47Unless you want to swim in your money.0:48And it's having a lot of possessions, owning a lot of cars and houses and real estate.0:53That's0:54chemdah. So he says, don't say, you know, I'm going to go just a little bit. I'm going to get a little bit of taam, and then I'll let it go.0:58You know, just I want to get a taste.1:06Ki keivan shematchilin shochach achareihem, nitrad veholech min hachayim, ve'nitchaim legamrei. You literally get pushed away completely.1:11Ki kashe me'od lifrosh meihem. The concept of teshuvah still exists even by middot, but just very, very hard to1:18let—once you start, once you get into it, it's very hard to let go.1:21I mean, just a side point, I'm not here to prove his point,1:24but just we see how people literally killed themselves when they found out that they became bankrupt.1:30The whole story a few years ago when people, you know, stole money from other people, right?1:34Over here, somebody told me he was in the city, somebody jumped off the 30th floor and then it was on the news.1:38Why? He owed a lot of money. He did some bad investment,1:41and, well, he still had money. The guy's still running his house1:44and doing, but it's very, very hard to now know that you can't live without them.1:51Ve'af mi sheyesh bo yirat shamayim. Listen to this strong statement.1:53Even a person has yirat shamayim. He is a God-fearing Jew.1:58He learns Torah, he knows a lot of Torah, and he has a lot of2:02mitzvot. When you pull after taavah, you end up losing everything.2:06So let's see if he's going to bring the Gemara later on.2:10Okay, we'll start with the פירוש, and then we'll fill in. I mean, you know, we just add in what we know also.2:16Look on the bottom. It comes from a pasuk in Mishlei, perek bet, pasuk2:25yud. כל באיה לא ישובון, ולא ישיגו ארחות חיים. Whoever enters it does not return, and they do not reach the ways of life.2:31Simple meaning of the pasuk, whatever Shlomo HaMelech is talking about over there,2:35it could be bad friends, I think, that perek was talking about,2:37but he's saying whoever enters it does not return, and they will not reach the roads of life.2:42Comes the Gra and explains:2:47שלא יאמר אדם ילך בשרירות לבי ואחר כך אשוב. A person shouldn't say, you know what, let me go enjoy myself without any limitations.2:51שרירות לבי means having no limitations, just, you know, kind of like the concept of Mardi Gras the goyim have,3:00right, right before—there's something called, I forgot what it's called, Baruch Hashem I forgot.3:04But anyway, they have this holiday that they fast, believe it or not.3:07Okay, so right before they fast, because, you know, they're going to be judged,3:11their quote-unquote Rosh Hashanah, it's like in April time, so they have Mardi Gras.3:15Mardi Gras is basically a week of doing whatever you want.3:18Get it out of your system, you know what I'm saying,3:20right? So don't say that, and then I'll do teshuvah.3:24That's what the pasuk says: כל באיה תיכף כשבאים אליה לא ישובון. That's what the pasuk says. Whoever enters it,3:28like, ביאה means coming in, right, just a little bit,3:32לא ישובון, לא יהיו יכולים לשוב ממנה. It's very difficult to return from it.3:34והוא נגד הולכים אחר חמדה. Who's that talking about?3:37That's people who follow the chemdah, which we explained chemdah is monetary things.3:46כי לא יכול לשב במנוחה והשקט, אחר שהיה דואג תמיד אחר ממון וחמדה. You can't sit in peace and quiet.3:51After your whole, after you started already this sort of running and getting money,3:55this is the concept of gambling.3:57The guy comes in, he puts a quarter, he won.4:01Most people, unless the guy is really exceptional,4:03most people cannot stop.4:06Why? Once you tasted that little bit of,4:08wow, I can do this,4:10right? The guy could lose maybe on top of what he already earned,4:13he could lose another $20,000, but I won.4:17I was able to win, and that's like the worst thing,4:19right? If you want to wish berachah for some person,4:21tell him that he should lose the first ten times,4:24because the first impression when he wins,4:26now in his head, okay, if I won now, I could always win,4:29and that's really what it is.4:33... It's very hard to pull away from.4:38... It's very hard to do teshuvah, because they're always trying4:41it now. If you can't get it, and we know what goes on in the world,4:44then there's shticks, there's legal4:46shticks, and then it turns into illegal4:48shticks, and then it turns to straight-out stealing,4:53okay? Now the pasuk continues, says,4:55And they will not reach the roads of life,4:57hu neged ba'alei ta'avot. That's referring to people who run after4:59their ta'avot, like we said, ta'avot are physical desires.5:03A person's concentrated,5:04we said yesterday,5:05a person who's concentrated on his physical desires5:08is concentrating on himself,5:10and everything becomes only about him and getting his desires.5:12He's not all-signing the Torah.5:13He can't be all-signing the Torah.5:14He might learn Torah,5:15but he can't be all-signing the Torah.5:21When their whole head is focused on getting5:25their ta'avot, they can't understand,5:26they can't reach the roads of life,5:28which is,5:31derecheha darchei noam, v'chol netivoteha shalom, right? The roads of the Torah.5:34Ki tavah hi hefech haTorah. The ta'avah is exactly the opposite of Torah.5:37Where do we get that from?5:38Midrash mefurash.5:39Tana d'bei Eliyahu, it says,5:46Ad she'ata mevakesh sheyikansu divrei Torah l'me'echa, bakesh shelo yikansu achila u'shtiyah letoch me'echa. Based on the pasuk,5:49the pasuk says,5:52V'Toratecha b'toch me'ai. David HaMelech says,5:55Your Torah is in my tummy. Interesting, no?5:56Torah is in my brain.5:58Or maybe tell me my heart,6:00my tummy, my stomach.6:02So comes6:02the Eliyahu Hanavi and tells us,6:04before you pray that your Torah should enter your stomach,6:06like David HaMelech prayed,6:08pray that you shouldn't get6:10ta'avot. Comes the Gra and explains the depth of this.6:12It means these are two opposite things.6:14The ta'avot are the opposite of Torah.6:17One who is focused on6:18ta'avot, or not even focused on6:20ta'avot, but cares about6:21ta'avot, it's very hard to grasp the Torah.6:24Next, another peirush from the6:26Gra, and he says over here6:30from Mishlei, perek hei, pasuk vav. The pasuk says,6:36Orach chayim pen tefales, na'u ma'agloteha lo teda. The ways of life6:39you might not step on.6:42Na'u ma'agloteha. Ma'agalot is like the wheels6:44or basically the steps6:46also. Na'u means they move,6:47na' va-nad tehi ba'aretz, lo teda, you will not know.6:52Don't let the6:53yetzer hara, which we spoke many times in the past,6:55the yetzer hara, that's always, yetzer hara that's mentioned in the pasuk6:58refers to7:00ta'avot, right, as we can all understand7:02the mashal of it.7:04He says, don't let her take you off the path.7:07V'telech... Don't say, I'm just going to follow a little bit,7:10just, you7:11know, I'm going to enjoy just a little bit.7:14Not only will you not be able to reach the way of life,7:17like it says,7:20... ela afilu lo yasigu l'hachzir chayim, vehinu shelo yed'u klal orachot. You won't even know how to get back on the road.7:23You completely lost the GPS.7:25Some people still have the GPS,7:26Baruch Hashem, they can get back.7:27But a guy who goes after the physical desires,7:30he lost his GPS.7:31He doesn't even know how to get back.7:33Next, we said also,7:35even a person who has7:37yirah and Torah7:38and7:38mitzvot, when he goes after7:39aveirah, he loses everything.7:40Where does that come from?7:42It's a short peirush from7:48Mishlei, pasuk... And the reason why I do this, by the way,7:50is also we get to learn Mishlei at the same time,7:52right?7:52We get to learn a lot of pesukim from Mishlei. Otzar nechmad vashemen binveh.8:01Chacham. A storehouse that's desirable of oil, and good oil, like olive oil, back then was very good.8:09Bitvei chacham, it's in the home of a8:13chacham. Uchsil adam yevaleinu, and a foolish person just eats it all up.8:16What's its otzar? Comes the Gra and says, Otzar8:19hu yirat Hashem. How do I know? It says,8:22Yirat Hashem hi otzaro. Pasuk says, right?8:25The yirat Hashem is the otzar, the storehouse of the person.8:27V'nechmad is the Torah,8:32right? Nechmadim mipaz rav, right? The Torah is considered nechmadim.8:35It's nechmad; it's more desirable than great jewelry.8:38V'shemen refers to mitzvot,8:41right? Look on the bottom, he explains how shemen is mitzvot,8:44because we know ner mitzvah,8:46and a ner is a mitzvah,8:47and what's lit in the ner? It's a8:50shemen. Good?8:54V'chol elu asherahem b'nevei chacham. All these three you find8:56by chacham: the otzar, which is yirat shamayim;8:58nechmad, which is the Torah;8:59shemen is the mitzvot.9:00They're found in the house of the9:02chacham. Doesn't mean a rabbi.9:03Chacham means a smart, wise man.9:06Uchsil adam, what's the foolish part of the person?9:11Says the Gra, hu nefesh habehamit. That's the animalistic part of us that's running after desires.9:18Hu yevaleinu hakol, what does it9:19mean? Keshenimshach achar taavah. When you act like a chasil—think about it—what's a foolish person?9:20You always say, everybody says, when you see a fool, what do you say?9:24Ma afimoch. No, what does it mean, no brain?9:25Sometimes it's literally no brain,9:27chas v'shalom; you feel bad for the guy, you give him a donation.9:29And sometimes a guy, he's not acting with brain.9:32A guy who's running after—it's not logical to9:34him, there's no logic over there.9:36So what is he acting with?9:37The other part of the human being, if there's no brain,9:38is acting with the nefesh9:40behemit, which is the animalistic part of us,9:42like all other animals,9:44right? And that is9:46what he's telling you:9:47Uchsil adam, when a person is acting like a9:49behemit, he'll swallow everything.9:50What does it mean,9:51yevaleinu? Yevala hakol means he loses all these things.9:54If he had them9:55already, he ends up losing them.9:57Okay, I think it's ten minutes already,10:00so we'll stop over here.10:01The next part also,10:02he brings another pasuk10:03also from Mishlei.10:04You can look at it also,10:05but again, the same concept.10:07Even one who has already all these things,10:10he has Torah,10:11yirat Shamayim, everything,10:12he loses when he runs after10:13taavah. I would like to quote you a Gemara.10:15Again, the Gra doesn't need my support,10:18but there's a Gemara10:21in Masechet Avot. The pasuk says in the Torah,10:22Parashat Bo,10:27Hachodesh hazeh lachem rosh chodashim. This month is for you,10:29rosh chodashim.10:29We know when you get an aliyah,10:30there's no nekudot,10:31there's no10:33ta'amim, right?10:33The words are written plain,10:34just letters.10:35Good.10:35Gemara says about a Bi Meir,10:37I believe it was Rabbi Meir.10:38He once went to some place10:42where it was good waters,10:43it was enjoyable,10:44it was basically a very pleasurable place,10:48and he stayed there.10:49And then they asked him to get an aliyah,10:51and they gave him an aliyah.10:52And when he got an aliyah,10:53it says that he got the aliyah in Parashat Bo.10:56Now whether they read the10:57parashah the way we read it today or not10:58is whatever different discussion,10:59but when he came to read the Torah back then,11:01also whoever got aliyah would read the Torah.11:03When he came to read the Torah,11:04he read,11:08Hachereish haya libam, because11:09hachodesh, the letter dalet and resh look the same,11:11so it's not that it was written like that in11:13the Torah. By mistake he read it that way,11:16hachereish, and hazeh,11:17the zayin and the yud could be very,11:19right, you can see how he can make such a mistake,11:22and lachem,11:23the bet11:23and the chaf are also very similar.11:25So instead of reading11:26Hachodesh hazeh lachem,11:27he read11:28Hachereish haya libam, which means11:29their heart was like a mute,11:31a person,11:32cheresh, who cannot speak11:33and talk,11:33which means it was closed up,11:35like the word11:36cheresh, which is like locked up.11:38So the Gemara says that he forgot his learning,11:40and that's why11:43he was reading that way,11:44until he left the place11:46and they had to pray for him11:46and he got back his learning.11:48From that Gemara11:49you see, again,11:50whatever, there's a lot of depth to that Gemara,11:52but the message of that Gemara is11:57when you nimshach achar taavot, even a Bi Meir,11:59right,11:59lost the Torah that he knew.12:01And Rabbi Meir,12:01we know, was12:02usually,12:03whenever there's machloket in the Gemara12:04between Rabbi Yehuda and Rabbi Meir,12:05we posek like Rabbi12:06Yehuda, not Rabbi Meir.12:06You know why?12:07Rabbi Meir was so deep in his learning12:09that sometimes12:10he could have said something so deep,12:12we don't even really understand12:12what he really meant,12:14so that's why we try to avoid12:15posek like him in front of12:16the Mishnah. That's how the Mishnah explains, the Gemara explains.12:18So that's again12:20the same idea12:20what the Gra is bringing over here,12:21we're just bringing it as an extra resource. Baruch... amen.