Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 2, Lesson 1Sefer Even ShelemaPart 26Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:009:47Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Eben Shelema, perek0:04bet, סעיף א'. Like we said at the end of yesterday's class, in this perek we're focusing on specific0:12midot, and these specific midot, these three, are the midot ra'ot, the bad0:20midot. And these three are not just random bad0:23midot, but these three really are what we call the headings, the headlines.0:28These are the main bad0:33midot, the main bad ones that everything extends from these three.0:37And the first one that we have in today's perek,0:40in סעיף א' or whatever, not aleph, is0:44alot. There's a lot of things to talk about.0:47It's a big thing. I don't know if I'm able to go through the whole thing,0:50but we could start at least with a little bit,0:53just to give us a little bit of an introduction and to get into it at least.0:57We'll see, we'll watch the time as we0:59go. כלל המידות רעות הם, says the Eben Shelema,1:06דכלל מידות רעות הם כעס, תאווה וגאווה. What basically includes all bad midot under one umbrella are these three things:1:12כעס, anger; תאווה, desire; וגאווה, which is taking too much pride,1:19having too much pride, what we call1:22haughtiness, which are really the three things that were mentioned in1:26פרקי אבות, which are1:30קנאה, תאווה וכבוד. As we know, that people are jealous, you start to become very, very upset,1:36right? And we're going to see all that.1:37But he says these three are the same three.1:40The three that are mentioned in פרקי אבות that says,1:45מוציאין את האדם מן העולם, קנאה, תאווה וכבוד מוציאין את האדם מן העולם, which are jealousy, running after your desires,1:48and running, chasing after honor,1:50מוציאין את האדם מן העולם, are the same as anger, chasing after your1:54desire, and1:57גאווה. וכל אחד כלול משניים. And he said each one of them... is really made up of two components put together.2:04Hainu, meaning,2:06bekaas. When it comes to anger, it's made up of two things that create anger.2:10What is it? Ra2:13u'mirma. Pay attention, this is very deep.2:15We're going to clarify everything later on,2:17but right now he's defining.2:18Kaas, which we know, just regular anger.2:20Well, really anger is two parts.2:23There's ra, there's evil,2:25and there's mirma, which usually means trickery,2:30right? So what's the definition of evil?2:32What's the definition of2:33mirma? He says like this:2:34Ra hu2:38b'hitgalut. Evil is in the open,2:42outright evil.2:43U'mirma, and trickery,2:46hu2:48echad b'peh v'echad b'lev, is when a person is what we call a hypocrite,2:51two-faced. He'll tell you one thing, but he really means something else.2:56Those two combined together,2:58that's under the category of3:00kaas. Now, you might wonder,3:01what in the world does anger have to do with a guy who is a3:05trickery, with a guy who is a hypocrite,3:07or a guy who is outright evil,3:08maybe connected to outright evil?3:10So, like we said, right now we're only introducing.3:13We're only bringing the subjects of what he says over here.3:16Everything will be learned,3:18everything will be clarified later on,3:22okay?3:23Let's continue.3:26Ta'ava. The second heading,3:28the second category of3:31bad middot is what he calls3:32ta'ava. What's3:35ta'ava? Ta'ava v'chemdah. It's included from desire.3:38That's how we translate3:40ta'ava, and chemdah also means desire,3:41but chemdah, he's going to explain what it is3:44means. Ta'ava hu3:46hana'at haguf mamash. Ta'ava is physical, bodily pleasures.3:51It can go on achilah u'shtiyah, for example, eating, drinking,3:53and you can think of all other ta'avot you can think about.3:57That's what we refer to when we say3:59ta'ava. It's referring to things that are— Physical bodily pleasures.4:05Chemdah is desire for things that are not bodily pleasures,4:10like, hegon kesef v'zahav, ubgadim ubatim, like money, silver, gold, clothing, nice houses.4:21Today we could add, you want a nice car.4:23It's not a physical pleasure.4:24Yes, we all agree4:26it's more comfortable to ride a Lexus4:29than it is to ride maybe a Dodge,4:32right?4:33But that's not called,4:37you know, taavah. That's called4:38chemdah. I want the Lexus.4:40It's a4:41chemdah. It's a certain kind of kavod,4:43and I want it.4:44And sometimes I don't care about the kavod.4:45I'll drive it privately.4:46But that's also what we mean when it comes to4:49chemdah. So in English, they translate it the same way.4:52Taavah and chemdah, they'll be translated as desire.4:56But like we said,4:57it's two completely different levels of desire.5:00The desire over here is for what?5:02The desire is for,5:05taavah is for bodily pleasures,5:06and chemdah is for external possessions.5:11Gaavah. What's5:14gaavah? Ge'eh, ga'on. We find the terminologies5:16ge'eh, which translates, again,5:19doesn't mean necessarily how the guy is going to explain it,5:21but it translates as ge'eh, which means5:24haughty, and ga'on usually means genius,5:27but we'll see what that means.5:28So he says,5:31Ge'eh hu balev. A ge'eh is somebody in his heart.5:34Inside, I think I'm better than this guy.5:36I think I'm better than people.5:37I'm thinking I'm better than, you know,5:39כביכול Hashem Himself.5:41Some people get to that level.5:43Ga'on hu harotzeh lisror al anashim. But ga'on is a different type of5:49gaavah. This is a5:49guy, ga'on is a guy who wants to rule other people.5:53His gaavah is that he wants to take control of other people.5:57And we all know that, right?5:58That could come in many, many forms.6:00And again, we'll elaborate on all of this,6:03be'ezrat Hashem, maybe in the next class.6:04Right now, we want to finish the Amidah and continue.6:09So, vechol zeh, he says,6:13vechol zeh kalul b'tefillat Elokai, netzor leshoni mera. He says these three things,6:14which is6:16kaas, ta'avah, and the way we define it,6:17he says really that's what we're praying for6:19right before we step back from Hashem6:21and we finish the Amidah6:22and we want to say thank you, Hashem,6:24and we want to step back.6:25You know, technically the Amidah really stops,6:27Baruch Atah Hashem, and Baruch Moshe... shalom.6:29That's where it finishes.6:30That's where we should have stopped.6:32We add Elokai, netzor based on the Gemara6:35in Masechet Berachot6:37that says different rabbis6:39concluded their Amidah in different ways,6:41and that's why we say Elokai,6:44netzor. And what does it say over there?6:44How does Elokai, netzor include all these things?6:47He says like this.6:48We begin by saying,6:49Elokai,6:51netzor leshoni mera. Guard my tongue from ra.6:52What's this ra?6:53Remember, ra and6:55mirmah are the two things that make up6:58ga'avah. So we say, guard my tongue from evil,7:00usfatai midaber mirmah, and my lips from speaking7:05mirmah. Mirmah, like we said, is trickery7:08or7:09hypocrisy,7:10which is one word,7:11you know,7:13echad b'peh v'echad b'lev. You say something,7:14you don't really mean it,7:15right?7:16You're7:17two-faced. Next we say,7:19v'limkalelai nafshi tidom, and those who curse me,7:21let my soul be quiet.7:24That's by7:25ga'avah, right?7:26If I feel that I'm deserving of certain pride7:29and I'm a certain chashuv person,7:32then,7:32ha, how can somebody do this to me?7:34So I'm saying,7:35no, let my soul be quiet to those who curse me.7:40V'nafshi ke'afar lakol tihyeh, and let my soul be like dirt.7:43That's corresponding to7:44ga'on. Ga'on, which means7:45I want to rule over people.7:48Petach libi b'Toratecha. Open up my heart to learn Torah.7:51That's what7:53means, I want my desires to be of what?7:55To be of studying of Torah. Hu hefech et ta'avato, ...8:00It's the exact opposite of bodily desire. What's bodily desire? I want to sit on my couch, or my massage chair, or in my jacuzzi.8:08I just want to, you know, eat my, you know, right? I want to eat my breakfast and lunch and dinner in bed, watching a movie and getting in jacuzzi at the same time,8:17right? The avah is, I want to sit, don't want to do anything. That's people's ideal vacation.8:23So, v'chemdat Torah tzrich l'shev b'menuchah. So by Torah also, you need a certain also relaxation to be able to learn Torah.8:29If everybody's bothering you and you're physically not feeling well, very hard to learn Torah.8:36So you need that little calmness for study of Torah.8:44Another proof that Torah corresponds to taavah, the Gemara's famous words, says8:52Brodan, Tana d'Vei Eliyahu: Before you ask that you should have Torah in your stomach, ask that you shouldn't put food and drinks in your stomach.8:59Different time we'll explain the depth of that statement, but you see again that Torah is compared to food.9:04Instead of food, ask for Torah. Then we say,9:09u'vimitzvotecha tedof nafshi, and with your mitzvot my soul should run after them. That's the opposite of9:14chemdah. Chemdah, we said, desiring external possessions.9:21Shezeh darkam, kesef lirdof tamid, kodim tamid. People who run after money are always running after more money.9:24If there's a possibility that they can make more, oh, they're always running it.9:27Another opportunity to make more money, they're always running after it.9:31Ki ein adam meit vachatzi ta'avato b'yado, because we know the rule: a person doesn't die even with half of what he desires in his9:37hand. He's always running after, he's always trying to get more and more and more.9:43Okay, with that, we'll continue with the next time we're already up on time.