Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 12, Lesson 3Sefer Even ShelemaPart 224Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0010:55Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00So we're in the Eben Shelema bonus tracks. We're doing the0:07Miluei Even. We would like to talk a little bit about Mashiach ben Yosef a little bit today, and then bring a concept,0:12Mashiach ben David, Mashiach ben Yosef, and he brings from a nice concept from a nice book over here,0:19different books, whatever, and the idea is basically expanded. So let's see.0:25From the Derech Eliahu, it says like this: Bechor shoro0:32hadar lo, v'karnei re'em karnav. It says the bechor of his ox. This is the bracha that was given to Yosef0:37HaTzadik, right? And he comes, the Gra says, V'ha'ikar ha'inyan al Mashiach ben Yosef.0:41The main thing that that bracha was going on was on Mashiach ben Yosef.0:45That bracha was talking about Mashiach ben Yosef, shehu harishon0:48l'geulah. He's going to be the first one to deal with the0:53geulah. L'kach ne'emar bechor shoro. That's why he calls him bechor. He's the0:57firstborn, right? Mashiach harishon, he's going to be the first Mashiach.0:59Like it says in the Zohar, Aryeh limino u'Mashiach ben David,1:04gur aryeh Yehuda, which says the merkavah has four creatures,1:09the1:13chayot, right? Ufnei aryeh el hayamin l'arbaatan. The face of the aryeh, of a lion, is to the right.1:17The lion represents Mashiach ben David,1:20as we know Yehuda was compared to a lion,1:22as it says in the pasuk, Gur aryeh Yehuda,1:28gur aryeh... right? You're compared to a lion.1:30Basically, lions and Yehuda are always compared to each other.1:36V'hashor l'smolo. And when you go back to the ma'aseh merkavah that Yechezkel is talking about,1:39he says on the left is a shor, is an ox.1:42That represents who? Mashiach ben Yosef.1:43That's Mashiach ben Yosef, she'atid l'hashmid hakol. He's going to destroy,1:47as we know the power of the ox is to knock.1:52Right? So he says, Kemo shekatuv b'Raya Mehemna, like the Zohar says,2:01נטלי כולהו מגבורה, ומשיח בן אפרים נטל נקמה משנאוי. That they, Mashiach ben Ephraim, it seems like to be now more,2:05the Zohar is even more specific where the Mashiach is going to come from.2:08He's saying it's coming not only from Yosef, but specifically from Ephraim.2:13He's going to take out the revenge of the Jewish people.2:17Bedegad, Mashiach ben Yosef,2:21ihu dekaramiz, atei lachrokaha et kosi b'otenu. As we mentioned also, that Mashiach ben Yosef will be the one who takes care of the enemies,2:29and that's the remez when Balak told2:38Bilam, עתה אלחוכה את כל צרינו, as we mentioned. You know, they were worried that they're going to eat them up like the way the ox.2:42Why did Torah use the mashal as an ox?2:44And the answer is because the ox is Mashiach ben Yosef,2:48and the power of Mashiach ben Yosef is to go—not to be, but to go against the enemies of the Jewish people,2:57right? And why does it say2:59yerek hasadeh? As we know, the grass of the field is referring to also the3:04resha'im, and it says in the pasuk,3:11כסמח בפרוח רשעים כמו עשב. Fine.3:11In any case, that's the revenge,3:14that's the power of Mashiach ben Yosef,3:17is to go against the evil,3:20to wipe out the evil.3:22In another place, the Gemara also discusses this.3:24It's based on the3:26Gemara in Bechorot. So we know the Gemara in3:29Bechorot in Sanhedrin Beit Atuna, there was a whole debate between the rabbis and the people from Athens.3:32It seems to be the wise men of Athens,3:35and over there it's a very mystical Gemara,3:37it's a very, very deep Gemara.3:40And the simple meaning of the Gemara sounds very confusing.3:43Comes the Gra and gives a deeper explanation.3:45So let's give you one of those debates.3:48It says like this,3:48they asked him a question:3:52משרא דסכיני במאי קטלי לה? The row of the knives,3:56how do you cut it?3:58Row of knives.3:59Now usually, how do you4:00harvest—excuse me—usually people harvest what? Harvest wheat, produce, any thing like that.4:05The Gemara is saying,4:06they asked him the question, they asked the rabbi this question:4:08How do you cut rows of—how do you harvest rows of knives?4:12So they answered him, the rabbis answered them,4:15bekarna damra. You do it with the horn of a donkey.4:19So they asked4:20them, Umi4:22ika karna lhamra? What are you guys talking about?4:23Does a donkey have horns?4:24Donkey doesn't have horns.4:26So they answered them back,4:28Umika mishad desakinei, and are there rows of plantations of knives?4:33Right?4:33Now you should know,4:35the Gemara over there,4:35most of the Gemara is like that.4:37They ask a question that's very strange,4:39they answer them with a stranger answer,4:41and they challenge that strange answer,4:43and the Gemara says,4:44Yeah, but your question doesn't make sense in the first place.4:46So that's what seems like over here, the whole debate4:48comes, the Gemara says,4:49No, something is deeper over here.4:51Katav Rabbeinu, comes the Gra and writes,4:54Mishrad desakinei. What was their question that they were asking to,4:56what were they alluding to when they said,4:58a row of knives?5:02So that's referring to the ashir,5:06the wealthy5:08man—excuse me,5:11the asav—it's referring to5:13Esav, who was blessed with the berachah of living by the sword,5:17the knife,5:17right?5:19Vnekra ish sadeh, and he was called the man of the field,5:21right?5:24Ufarnasato hu cherev, vzehu mnato, and his parnassah was out of the sword,5:26and that's his profession, as we know,5:29al charbecha tichyeh. Now that's what they said,5:32Mishrad desakinei, the row in the field.5:34Who's the field represented by?5:36By... Esav, who was in5:39Esadeh, and he is the one also of knives,5:41the row of knives in the field,5:43because he was also blessed with the power of the knife.5:50Bemai katlei lei? Pashut pshat, katlei — how do you cut him off?5:51How do you chop him?5:51How do you harvest him?5:52But over5:53here, how is he going to fall?5:54How is the power of Esav going to fall?5:56What do they answer him?5:57With the horn of the6:03chamor. Uchtiv b'Mashiach ben Ephraim, shemsho al kol ha'olam vichaleh otam. It says in the Zohar,6:05because the Gra continues,6:07that Mashiach ben Ephraim,6:08which is Mashiach ben Yosef,6:09is going to rule the whole world6:10and he's going to finish them.6:11And it says,6:17b'choshcho roha dalo v'kaneh re'em kanav, bahem amim yנגח יחדיו, bahem ribot Ephraim. He has horns,6:19and with the horns he's going to knock out all these nations.6:23It says,6:25aval Esav lo yipol byado. However,6:26Esav is not going to fall in the hands of Mashiach ben Yosef,6:33kemo shekatuv, ad shetipol malchut tisha chodashim miYisrael, until they actually have the power over the Jewish people for nine months.6:37And then, vyabuu am gog uMagog al Hashem val Meshicho. Then everybody's going to gang up6:42with Gog6:44uMagog, Esav and all these people,6:45they're all going to gang up against Hashem and Mashiach.6:50Ki brechat avi varbechat chayah omedet lo. And his power and his6:52zechut that he's able to have that ability to fight against the Jewish people6:56is the fact that he had the blessing from his father,7:02ki zechut kibud aviv kayemet, because he had a zechut of honoring his parents.7:06As we all know,7:08the power of Esav that has lasted throughout the generations7:11was a tremendous amount of respect that he gave to his father,7:15so much respect that the Gemara tells us,7:17I think it was Rabban Gamliel that says,7:19Do you know how much I honor my mother, my parents,7:23and I don't come close to a tiny, tiny, tiny percent of a percent7:29of what Esav did towards his father,7:32how Esav was mechabed his own father.7:34And that's the zechut that they have.7:40That's why Hashem tells Bnei Yisrael,7:44listen, you're not going to be able to take the land of Edom.7:47Remember when he came to7:48Amon and Moab, Hashem says,7:49Okay,7:50listen,7:50they finding you,7:51wipe them out.7:51When it came to Edom,7:53He says,7:54No, no, no, no,7:54don't touch them.7:54Their zechut has not finished yet.7:56They have a7:58zechut. So, what, but how would they fall then?8:01The Gemara says, With the horn of the donkey, רצוןו מביא את משיח בן דוד, שהוא8:48עני ורוכב על חמור.8:56That's in the hands of Mashiach ben David. As we know, Chazal tell us, עני ורוכב על8:58חמור, it's a pasuk in Yeshayahu that refers to Mashiach. He is a poor person riding on a donkey. על9:02עַיִר בן9:51אתונות, the Gemara says. The Gemara says one second: חמור is represented by who? By Yehuda. That's the Mashiach ben David. Yet he told me the horn of the chamor. The chamor doesn't have a horn, and the horn is really Mashiach ben Yosef. ... It's only says about אפרים that he has horns, right? That he's compared to an ox, right? And Mashiach ben David is compared to a chamor. So what's going on? So the Gemara answers, ... What are you worried about? How is there going to be a row of knives? Don't worry. By that time already, when Mashiach ben David comes, the zechut of Yosef, of Esav, would have been finished. That row of knives, is it still going to be around? Meaning to say, do you think the zechut is going to last that long? By that time already, the zechut that Esav had of kibud av va'em would have run out. Perhaps that's alluding to the concept of respect, right? Once upon a time, maybe the world was very different. People cared very much for their parents, and they had respect. But as we see nowadays, society has completely crumpled, that there's no honor, there's no respect to parents. And that's perhaps—I'm adding this, by the way, this is my own personal thoughts—and that's perhaps, you know, what Chazal said in Sotah, that כלה קמה בחמותה, a bride goes against her mother-in-law, בן קם באביו, ... the young will be worshipped by the old. The older people will stand up for the younger. The son will go against his father. Perhaps that's what Chazal already saw, that the zechut of Esav, in the end of days, will be gone, because there will be lost that system of honoring older people, honoring one's parents, and that will be gone in those days. In any case, that is another concept over here of Mashiach ben Yosef that we also wanted to bring about. Here they quote from a book that's very, very nice, that goes through our tefillah and explains also the way things will probably play out in the end of days. Being that we're above time already, overtime, bezrat Hashem9:53maybe we'll come back to it on a different day, and we'll just say it outside instead of reading inside, because as you can see, it's very, very long. Amen.