Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 11, Lesson 9Sefer Even ShelemaPart 208Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:23Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Eben Shelema, perek yud alef, the last perek, ot vav. We're still in the discussion of the erev rav.0:11Yesterday, Bina was part of the Eben Shelema that he mentioned. We discussed about Mashiach ben Yosef.0:17We introduced the concept of Mashiach ben Yosef.0:20For those who were not familiar with it, maybe those who just heard about0:24it, and we'll add just a little bit more that we didn't say yesterday, because most of what we did yesterday, we read it in here.0:28We always find that there were two leaders amongst the Jewish people, even from the0:34shevatim. We had Yosef, who was the king in Mitzrayim, who was the leader.0:38He was from the leader of the Rachel Imenu, and that's why the bnot of Shevah were always, you know, around him when he was younger.0:47There was Yosef who was a leader, and there was Yehuda who was the leader of0:51Bnei Leah, and these were the two main wives of Yaakov0:54Avinu. And even later on, when it says that in Parashat Vayigash that Yosef and Yehuda kind of like battled over1:04Binyamin, it says in the Midrash, the pasuk,1:24Ki neh melachim na'atsu yachdav. The kings are coming against each other, right? And we find that the king of the behemot, the king of the animals, the domestic animals, is the ox, and the king of the chayot, of the wild animals, is the lion. Yehuda is compared to a lion, and Yosef is compared to an ox.1:33Yehuda gur aryeh Yehuda, and by Yosef it says, Bechor shoro hadar lo. So we see this concept again of two leaderships.1:38It again repeats itself when the shevatim split and they go following Yeravam ben Nevat to the north,1:45the ten shevatim, led by Yeravam ben Nevat, who came from Shevet Ephraim.1:51Where is Ephraim from? Ephraim is from Yosef.1:52And the other two tribes stay in Yerushalayim, and they're led by Yehuda, the kingdom of Yehuda from Malchut Beit David.2:02So again, this concept repeats itself here, later on in history.2:07So there's always those two leaders, Yosef and Yehuda, which is David, and that's Mashiach ben Yosef versus Mashiach ben David.2:14Okay, let's come back now.2:17In the discussion of the Alei Rav, he explains that there is, basically you have to filter it out.2:25There's three2:29avot, Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, and amongst them, on the side of, I guess, not so clean, you have the descendants,2:35or you have the other things, which are Yishmael, Esav, and the Alei Rav.2:41So most of—he brings this from the sources brought down over2:49here—is the Gran, Biurei Aggadot, in Sabbat d'Bei Atuna, that is Masechet Bechorot.2:54I don't want to get into it because most of the stuff that are said in the actual words of the3:00Gra were actually brought by the Even Shlema, so I'm going to skip that.3:03But I want to go on to the next piece from the Tikunei Zohar,3:07where he brings the next idea that the Alei Rav corresponds to the subin.3:12What's the subin? We said that it's light shell on top of the wheat kernel, and that comes out when you grind it.3:18And we said all the difficulties in the exile, in Galut,3:22because that's like grinding the Jewish people to get rid of that psolet, to get rid of those subin.3:27So let's look over here in the source from the Gra, the Alei Rav.3:34Ready? Have you see it?3:36Hei. Ha'Alei Rav, al heima amru, kashim gerim3:40l'Yisrael k'sapachat. Regarding the Alei Rav, there's a famous Gemara, and a lot of people take it in a simple meaning,3:45and a lot of people feel like a little bit insulted from it.3:48It says the gerim are difficult to the Jewish people like a3:53sapachat. What's a sapachat? Sapachat is a growth that comes on the person who has3:59tzaraat. It's a skin, basically, disease and starts to grow and starts to spread.4:03The Gemara says the converts are difficult for the Jewish people like a4:08sapachat. Tzum nidbak me'od, and it gets literally attached to a person's body,4:12as opposed to tzaraat on a person's house or a person's clothing.4:18Dechonegai meinam nidbakim kisapahat. All other things that don't attach to the person's body like4:24the sapachat, v'nikra'im nega ra, and they're called nega ra, rashei tevot of the following:4:29nefilim, giborim, Amalekim, refa'im, and Anakim.4:35The nefilim, giborim, those are different giants that are mentioned in the4:40Torah, and those giants were, you know, we find4:47in Parashat Devarim, Parashat Bereishit, you know, all these different giants or different people that were evil, basically.4:52They were, what's it called, people, some of them were supernatural or whatever.4:57Torah tells us about them, but over here the Gra is saying that they represent this5:03nega ra. They are represented by this gerim.5:07So it doesn't—sounds from the Gra, it doesn't literally mean converts. A lot of great converts.5:12You have Ruth, who was also a convert, and we have the whole Mashiach come from Ruth, right?5:17So it's talking about not exactly converts, but people who attach themselves to the Jewish people.5:22And the Gra explains over here what these represent.5:26He says, Nefilim,5:29heima rotfim achar ta'ava. What the Nefilim are—remember, nega ra is rashei tevot Nefilim. That's for the nun,5:33gimel is giborim, ayin is Amalekim, resh is refa'im, and the last ayin is Anakim.5:40So he explains what these represent.5:42Nefilim, the giants are mentioned as Nefilim in the Torah.5:46What was mentioned in the Torah? It says, V'haNefilim hayu ba'aretz, and they wanted5:51bnot ha'adam, right? They were pulled after the desires of this world.5:55They followed the girls, the ladies, and they did all types of not proper things.6:01Let's keep it clean.6:02So. Over here, saying that's in the nefilim represents the people who run after the6:11ta'avot. Ve'azlin batar zenut, vechen batar batza. They follow zenut.6:15How do you say zenut in a clean English word?6:18Basically the rated, the bad desires, right, between men and women.6:23And batza is also referring to shochad, blackmail, right, running after money.6:28They'll do anything for a buck.6:30Giborim. Now the next people are6:33giborim. Giborim, anshei hashem sheborim batei knesset uvatei midrashot, la'asot lahem shem. These are people who want to make a name for themselves.6:40These are people that are donating shuls, donating, sponsoring things just to make a name for themselves,6:46not because to help out, but they want to make a name for themselves.6:49I want to point out that if a person wants to donate and put his name on it, there's nothing wrong with it.6:53Don't go around and say, Oh, look, he put his name on the shul, on the kolel, on the yeshiva. He is not a good guy.6:58No. There's a Rashba, Rabbi Shlomo ben Aderet, one of the Rishonim, who's quoted by the Rama, who quotes the halacha that says it's a mitzvah, it's a good thing for a person to put his name on a shul7:09because it encourages other people to also put their names on, you know, to donate.7:15So the Gra obviously knew the Rashba, he knew the7:18Rama. As we know, the Gra has a commentary on Shulchan Aruch, right?7:21So what is he saying over here? These are people who want to make a name for themselves.7:25These are people—so, kavana nobody knows what the real intention of a person.7:28Sometimes a person says, Yeah, I would like to keep something in memory of the deceased. Why not? That's good.7:33Or even himself, he wants to keep something.7:35But people are only doing it for the sake of a name, right?7:37It's kind of like when you advertise for your business, right?7:40Let's say, you know, I know that in these tournaments that they have, like Wimbledon or any other of those tournaments,7:49like, you know, like the NBA or basketball games, right?7:51Let's take, okay, a football game, a football game, right?7:54They have, you know, the Super Bowl.7:56So the Super Bowl is considered like the greatest game of the whole...8:00And it's watched by millions and millions of people.8:03And a lot of times, I'll tell you, it's sponsored by Pepsi, it's sponsored by Coors Light, it's sponsored by this and this company,8:08right? They're not doing it because they want the game to go on8:13l'shem shamayim of the game. They want it because they want to publicize themselves.8:15That's the only reason, because they have 500 million viewers,8:18and that's why Pepsi will sponsor that.8:19They won't sponsor an event that only has 25 viewers, even though it's also a football game,8:24right? They're not going to sponsor the high school game between some no-name city,8:29right? So this is what we mean when a person is donating for the sake of a shul.8:33He wants the shul to be built. He wants more Torah. He wants people to learn Torah. He wants8:37to—fine, that's great. Okay, he's putting his name. That encourages other people.8:41Now, the level of l'shem shamayim could vary on different people.8:45And then there, he wants people to grow. He wants people to kolelim, to learn, whatever.8:50But a guy who's doing it just to publicize his name,8:53he's like the Pepsi sponsoring the Super Bowl,8:55right? If it hadn't been 10 million viewers, or there's not so many people there,9:02he doesn't care about the shul running or not.9:04He cares that he should have his name in a place that is most public.9:10That's called9:11לעשות לשם. Those are the9:14giborim. מסיטרא דפלגא. That's from the side of9:18Dor הפלגה. עמלקים. Who are the Amalekim amongst the Jewish people?9:24הם ראשי סנהדרין בגלות, כלי חמס בגוזלים עניי ישראל. They're the people who are put in leadership positions in exile9:30who—wait, wait, not every person who's a leader is9:33from Amalek, calm down—who actually are abusing their position to steal from the poor,9:39to take advantage of the poor.9:40Those are the Amalekim.9:42They take advantage of the poor and they take from their money for their own personal reasons.9:46ועליהם נאמר: היוצרה לרע. Regarding them it says,9:51צריה were the rosh, and they come from the sitra of Dor9:57המבול. Next, Refa'im. We're up to the, the negarad,10:01the reshit ha... Refa'im. Who are the10:04Refa'im? Hem shemitrapim la'asot gimilut chasadim v'ha'alei Torah. They're the ones who have the ability,10:07but they're relaxed about giving and supporting the poor,10:15supporting the people who learn Torah.10:17They could help out.10:18They want to sit back on the side, and they don't want to help out.10:20They're lazy.10:21They're not doing out of,10:22what's it called?10:23It could be they're doing out of laziness,10:24it could be out of malice,10:25but they're not doing it, you know, because they don't want to get involved in Torah.10:28They don't want it to continue.10:30That's10:31the Refa'im. Anakim.10:32That's the last letter.10:34Again, all these words mean giants10:37in general, some different Amalek, but whatever.10:40Anakim,10:40hem hamezalzelim b'talmidei chachamim. Anakim are the people who disrespect the10:46talmidei chachamim. That's the negara.10:49That's the meaning of the Gemara10:51that says,10:53Genim kashim l'Yisrael k'sapachat. Those are the people that don't behave like a Jewish person,10:56don't behave like Jewish people.10:57We're not talking about people that did this once.11:00We're talking about people that this is how their whole life is.11:02This is what they do.11:03So now we're getting to see a clearer picture of the Erev Rav11:07that's mentioned by the Gra,11:11or at least the way the Gra is explaining it.11:13We had a question yesterday and two days ago:11:15is the Erev Rav,11:17are the Erev Rav descendants?11:19Are the Erev Rav11:21not descendants,11:22but they are just the neshamot,11:25or they're not neshamot,11:26but people who behave like the Erev Rav?11:28Now we're getting to see11:29it's like that third answer.11:30They're like people that are behaving like the Erev Rav,11:33and they're behaving in special ways.11:35They could be Jewish people,11:36they could have great lineage,11:38they come from great11:39yichus, but they're behaving like the Erev Rav.11:43So we're already above our ten-minute mark.11:47Let's see,11:48I would like to do other things.11:49There's another piece over here on the bottom,11:52so maybe I'll just summarize it.11:54Okay, so the summary is as follows.11:57The person who put this book together says,11:59you know, the rabbi who is of the Ibn Shalma,12:02who took from the words of the Gra from all over,12:03he says there's a lot of places12:06where the Zohar speaks about the Erev Rav,12:08and the Gra himself also commented on it a lot.12:11So he says, in short,12:12we're going to summarize it.12:14So he says like this,12:15based from the Zohar in different places,12:18here's in short, ready?12:19The Erev Rav are the ones12:20who really caused the Jewish people12:21to sin throughout all the generations.12:23They're compared to the yetzer hara in a human being, in a person.12:27They're like the yetzer hara amongst the Jewish people.12:29Why?12:31Because the yetzer hara shows you12:32that you can be successful,12:33you can do all these things.12:34They started out from the Egel, right,12:36and then throughout all the sins in the desert,12:38we always find the Erev Rav,12:38as we mentioned in the past.12:40And being that the Jewish people see them12:42because they're living amongst them,12:43they look like regular Jews,12:44we can't tell the difference,12:45they see that they're successful.12:47So it must be if they're successful,12:49they know what they're doing.12:50So they start following their ways.12:52That's a very scary thing, right?12:54Because we see a Jewish man12:56who's successful,12:57obviously doing something right.12:58Now it could be on many levels.13:00It could even be religious.13:01They keep mitzvot,13:02but they're, right,13:03it's all their kavanah,13:04like we just said beforehand.13:05Now, he's also that this is one idea.13:09The other thing is also13:10there's a time when the Erev Rav will take over.13:13When is that?13:14That is in the end of Galut,13:16as we explained already.13:17The darkest part of Galut13:19is right towards the end13:20because it's right before the light shines.13:22So Erev, from the word evening,13:25Rav is leader,13:26and when it's going to be total evening,13:29Erev, when it's going to be very dark at night,13:30which means right before the Galut is over,13:33then they're going to be Rav.13:34They're going to be the leaders.13:35They're going to be the heads.13:36And they're going13:37to—but again, not every head. Baruch Hashem,13:38we have great leaders,13:39but sometimes we have leaders,13:41they're steal from the Jewish people.13:43They disrespect the Torah.13:45They make fun of13:48talmidei chachamim. They put them down.13:50And this, he says,13:51is brought down in many places in the Zohar.13:53You can look in Parashat13:54Bereishit, Parashat Naso, right?13:56And this is what Moshe Rabbeinu13:57and the13:58Talmidei Chachamim all will suffer under the Erev Rav.14:00This is the pain that they go through,14:03Moshe Rabbeinu representing the14:05Talmidei Chachamim. And now you can understand when the Gemara says,14:09Rabbi Yochanan, Rabbi Yochanan, chutzpah יסגי, it's going to be a lot of chutzpah. Why?14:11Because the Erev Rav,14:14who are really—they're not world class,14:16they're not the leaders, they're not the leaders.14:17They're the Erev Rav.14:19They're lucky they're with us.14:20They're going to take over,14:22and they're going to14:23not take over;14:23they're going to step on the true people14:26that were supposed to be14:28mechabed. And then over there14:28the beraita says in Sotah,14:30Chochmat sofrim14:32תסרח, the wisdom of the14:33Talmidei Chachamim will be spoiled14:34because they're going to make fun14:38of—yirei chet yema'asu. People who yirei chet will obviously be kicked out of their cities,14:41and they'll not find a place to settle,14:44right?14:45Unfortunately, people who do14:46mitzvot, You're14:47frummy, you're14:48frummy, people put them down.14:49You can't do14:50mitzvot without being put down,14:51even by people14:52who also seem to be religious,14:54right?14:54Ladies want to wear skirts,14:55people make fun of14:56them. What happened?14:57Why do you have to be so14:59machmir? What's going on,15:00right?15:00But that's also what we're suffering through15:03in our days,15:04and that's what's going to be also.15:05That's what the Zohar is saying15:06in those days15:09at the end of the galut,15:12בעזרת ה' before Mashiach, they're going to be very powerful.15:13In any case,15:14we'll pause over here.15:15I don't want to say15:15we're stopping; we're going to pause over here.15:16We'll come back,15:18בעזרת ה', next time we learn,15:19we'll continue the subject.