Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 11, Lesson 8Sefer Even ShelemaPart 207Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0010:35Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:02We're in Eben Shelema, perek yud alef, ot vav, part0:06two. Like we said in part one, if you didn't hear, make sure you hear it first.0:09So in part one, we went through the Eben Shelema only. It was a big piece, and we said we wanted to go through this very well.0:14We said the subject here is the erev rav. There's a lot of erev rav and what their role is.0:20We gave a little bit of background of exactly what could erev rav be referring to,0:23and what we left off yesterday without clarifying, we want to see more in the0:29Gra, is are the erev rav straight descendants?0:33Like, for example, when we say a person is a Levi or a person is0:36Kohen, we know he's a straight descendant from Shevet Levi.0:39At least we have a chazakah that he's a straight descendant from Levi, who is the son of0:45Yaakov, right? And no matter how far down you go in his lineage, he's a kohen, right? He's going to always have descendants of Leviim.0:51So when we say erev rav, are those real descendants of the erev rav,0:56right? Just, you know, they got mixed up, we don't know,0:58so we assume they're all regular Yisraels, which means by this, then it goes by, without saying,1:04it goes without saying that every single person who's a kohen or a Levi is not from the erev rav.1:09That's one way to explain it.1:11Another way perhaps to explain is that, no, erev rav could be the neshamot of the erev rav,1:16and if it's the neshamot of the erev rav and they came back in gilgulim,1:19they come back in gilgulim, so then it could be that any person could be an erev rav.1:26His brother may not be, and he could be.1:28His son may be, and he may not be, right?1:30Because it's a neshama of the erev rav.1:33A third option maybe could also be, again, it's all this is a maybe,1:37is that the erev rav is the people who conduct themselves, who act in the ways that the erev rav did.1:43And perhaps maybe kabbalistically they'll also gain the neshama, or at least have an1:50ibur. Ibur means, al פי sefer Shaar HaGilgulim, means a partial1:55neshama will be combined with another neshama in their lifetime from the erev rav.1:59Again, all this is all possibilities of what the erev rav.2:02But one thing is for sure, the Gra says that they will make a lot of trouble.2:06And therefore there's going to be, we said right before this piece2:10in Ot Hey, there's going to be a lot of suffering, right? חבלי משיח, right?2:13Like a woman before she gives birth, there's a lot of pain.2:16And we said there's also going to be a lot of suffering before the geulah.2:18The Gra explains part of that reason is because we need to grind up the Jewish people,2:24because that's the only way we can get rid of the bad elements.2:27That's the only way we can get rid of the srubin, the shell on the wheat kernel.2:31Okay, let's see now, before we get to inside the actual2:36Gra himself, there's on the bottom we mentioned an idea. We said over there that we have Avraham, Yitzchak, and2:43Yaakov. These are really the foundations of the Jewish people.2:45As we see all the time, we pray and there's zechut and everything else.2:48That's2:49pashut. If you don't know that this is true, then go back and read the Chumash and come back.2:53Anyway, Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov is the foundation of the Jewish people,2:55but each one of them actually corresponds also, they had with them, like everything that's good,3:01like Shlomo HaMelech says,3:04זֶה לְעֻמַּת זֶה עָשָׂה אֱלֹקִים, right? Everything has also a certain part that's bad to it.3:09Avraham has Yishmael, Yitzchak has Esav, and by Yaakov Avinu, it's the erev rav,3:16right? So we said that the reason why we have the two Mashiach, Mashiach ben Yosef, Mashiach ben David,3:22is in order to kind of like filter out the first two, Yishmael and Esav.3:28So now this concept of Mashiach ben Yosef and Mashiach ben David, we'd like to go into it a little bit more3:34because we all know about the concept of Mashiach.3:37All of a sudden, we're being introduced, at least for some of us,3:41are being introduced. What, there's now a second Mashiach? What's going on?3:44And it's not that guy. It's not the cheese and rice,3:47okay? It is not, that's not what I mean,3:50chas v'shalom. But there is all of a sudden a Mashiach called Mashiach ben Yosef.3:54And what Mashiach ben Yosef, where does it come from?3:57So let's take you, or navan, to bring you the Gemara.3:59The Gemara, Masechet Sukkah,4:02daf nun bet amud aleph, it says, the pasuk says in4:07Zechariah, V'safda ha'aretz mishpachot mishpachot levad; mishpachat beit David4:09levad, u'nasheihem levad. Good? The land will be eulogizing families, families alone.4:15The family of Beit David, of the household of David, will eulogize,4:19and their wives will eulogize alone, right?4:21Says the Gemara, what's this eulogy that Zechariah was prophesizing on?4:27Hai hespeda mai abuteh? What's this eulogy?4:32פליגי בה רב דוסא ורבנן. Says the Gemara, there's a4:36machloket between Rabbanan and Chachamim. Chad amar Mashiach ben Yosef4:38sheneherag. One says the eulogy that Zechariah was prophesizing about4:43is the eulogy of Mashiach ben Yosef,4:45the Mashiach from the descendant of the tribe of Yosef.4:50V'chad amar yetzer hara sheneherag. One says on the yetzer hara that gets killed.4:52Comes Rashi and explains,4:58U'mitnabela atid sheyispedu al Mashiach ben Yosef sheneherag b'milchemet Gog uMagog, and in the war of Gog uMagog, Mashiach ben Yosef will be killed in that war.5:04So the eulogy will be on Mashiach ben Yosef.5:07So we see, Gemara clearly discusses this concept5:10that there's going to be a Mashiach from the family of Yosef,5:14or Yosef HaTzadik, that is, the tribe of Yosef.5:16Now,5:20the Zohar HaKadosh, in several places, brings down the concept of two Mashiachs.5:24Let's begin.5:25Parashat Mishpatim, it says,5:37שמבית משיח בן יוסף נמשל לשור, כמו שכתוב בברכת משה ליוסף: בכור שורו הדר לו. It's brought down over there in the Zohar5:39that Mashiach ben Yosef is compared to an5:42ox, as Moshe Rabbeinu, when he gave a bracha to Yosef5:47HaTzadik, what does he tell the tribe of Yosef? He says,5:59בכור שורו הדר לו וקרני ראם קרניו, בהם ינגח יחדיו אפסי ארץ. Right? He will be able, with his horns,6:02right? He compares Yosef to an ox that has horns6:06that's going to be able to knock out all the people, the ends of the earth.6:10And the Zohar says over there,6:15וְנֹקֵם מִן עֵשָׂו. He's going to be, Mashiach ben Yosef, he's going to come6:17and he's going to be rallying up the6:20Jewish—I don't know, rallying6:20up—but he's going to take out revenge from the enemies of the Jewish people.6:23There's another6:28derashah on the pasuk, כְּלָחֹךְ הַשּׁוֹר. This week's parashah we just read, Parashat Balak, says over there6:32that he sends a message to6:33him. He says, Listen, I'm worried about these Jewish people.6:35They might lick up,6:38you know, swallow us up,6:39like the way you put an ox by a field,6:43he swallows up all of the grass.6:45Now you think it's just random6:48that Balak said this message6:51to Bilam to try to record it? According to—oh, the more the Jewish people will come and eat us up6:54like the way the ox eats grass,6:56comes the Zohar and explains7:00that he saw Balak was able to7:03foresee, or the Torah,7:06the mez of the Mashiach ben Yosef compared to a shor,7:10שֶׁיִּנָּקֵם הַשַּׁעִים שֶׁנִּקְרְאוּ עֲשָׂבִים, who's going to take revenge against the wicked people.7:14And why are the wicked people compared to grass?7:16No, pasuk says in7:21Parashat Shabbat, דְּפְרוֹחַ כְּעֵשֶׂב. The resha'im grow like the grass7:23until—because they're all over,7:24and that's why it's called7:25chayim. Anyway,7:33וְהַיֶּלֶד הַלָּד, עמוד קפז, שבת, דברי עוד, דברים רבינו, בניין משיח בן יוסף, לְרַמֵּז, we'll see more about Mashiach ben Yosef.7:42It sounds like this person summarizing,7:45sounds like you get a picture7:47from the words of the7:48Gra that the concept of Mashiach ben Yosef7:50is to subdue the wicked people.7:53Right?7:53And that's the concept of.8:00of freedom from the slavery of the kings, right?8:04We all know we're in galut, we're under the shabud galuyot, we're under the enslavement of the8:10galuyot, which means we're not necessarily slaves. We say we have freedom, we can vote,8:14but we're under the spiritual powers of the goyim.8:17We have a lot of influence on the goyim; they can't really feel as free as we want.8:21Even a lot of the Jews are influenced.8:23So Mashiach ben Yosef will free us up from that.8:27Mashiach ben David, ... lemshoch bisae bTorah, bRuach HaKodesh, bKiyum kol yaadei haNeviim. Mashiach ben David sounds like his job is not to free us, but to take us to the next level,8:37right? To take us higher in spirituality, in Torah and Ruach HaKodesh,8:42and to fulfill all the words, all the prophecies of the8:47Neviim prophesied about the Jewish people, the good things that will happen to the Jewish people.8:50And that's how the Gra himself will explain the pasuk based on the Zohar:8:55demegulat yehe bchesed lo yamut, Mashiach ben Yosef.8:58If the geulah would be based on chesed, right, there's two ways we can get the9:03geulah: either chesed or din, as we'll see,9:04then Mashiach ben Yosef will be9:06zocheh. In fact, if you ever look in the siddur, in the tefillah of9:15Tishkon btoch Yerushalayim ircha kasher dibarta, you'll see in that berachah some siddurim will bring down9:19from, I believe it's Sechidah or from the Arizal,9:22that a person should be mechaven when he's saying that,9:26that Mashiach ben Yosef should not die9:29al yedei Armilus harasha.9:31I don't want to get into now who's Armilus harasha right now,9:34but it seems to be that that person will be the leader9:37in the time of the war of Gog9:40uMagog. Now, he brings also in Midrash9:45Lekach Tov, Parashat Balak, he says also it talks a lot about Mashiach ben Yosef,9:48and also Pirkei Hechalot, it's brought down in9:53Maamar Geulah dRamban, which we also have in the shul, happens to be,9:55and the peirush of the Ralbag on Parashat9:58Vayechi, he says, mishmaei ben Yisrael. On that pasuk10:01he says that Yaakov Avinu gave to Yosef10:07HaTzadik, that's a remez on Mashiach ben Yosef.10:09And if you want more, in the back of the book over here10:11we have a section called10:13Ben Uvein, and there he also talks at length about Mashiach ben Yosef.10:17So anybody who's interested in this subject,10:19there's a lot of sources we can provide you.10:21In any case, we wanted to discuss that point.10:23How much time we have?10:26Okay, I think we'll stop here.10:28We'll discuss today Mashiach ben Yosef;10:30tomorrow we'll come. Like I said, we can take our time with this piece.10:33We can spend our time.