Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 11, Lesson 7Sefer Even ShelemaPart 206Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:26Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:04Even shelema, perek yud alef, ot vav. We're in the subject of the future geulah and Erev Rav and a lot of different things,0:10so let's see what he says over here. Interesting, very interesting subject.0:15It says very big. I'm giving you a warning, this is very, very big.0:19It might take us a bunch of days because we're going to discuss now the subject of Erev Rav,0:25okay? And I'm looking at it, and I would like to go through this clearly.0:31So, you know, people, like as an insult, there's a—we all know a mamzer means a person, a child who's born from a forbidden relationship.0:39In halacha, a mamzer—we'll [unclear] that halacha0:42is not like Rabbi Akiva, that a mamzer is only born from a relationship where the punishment would be karet or worse.0:48A regular issur lav is not. The only exception to this rule is a person born from an niddah;0:55he's not called a mamzer. In any case, in modern Hebrew today they use that word mamzer as an insult,1:01or they call him the son of a mamzer, you know, like that, as an insult.1:05Not in halacha is he really a mamzer or not a son of a mamzer,1:08you know. No, they just, you know, they call a guy like that, whatever it is.1:11So the same thing, people use it also for Erev Rav,1:15right? People, when they have a group of people that they start to do things that, you know, that cause you trouble,1:20oh, Erev Rav. It could be even—no, not even, I'm talking about the word Erev1:25Rav—even in, what's it called, even in shuls sometimes, you know, like you have those troublemakers, oh, the Erev Rav, those guys.1:31Now, does that mean they're really Erev Rav? It could be, I don't know.1:34But if we know, do we know their genealogy, did they come from or not? We're not sure.1:38But let's just give a little background for who the Erev Rav is and how actually it plays a big role,1:43as we're going to see from the words of the Gra. They play a major role.1:47They played a major role in Jewish history, but they're going to play a very big role also when it comes to— The future geulah as well.1:55What's the eirev rav? Let's give a little bit of background.1:57What happened is, it started like this.1:59Bnei Yisrael were in Eretz Mitzrayim. They were pure Jews.2:03Chazal tell us one of the zechuyot of Bnei Yisrael was that they never, ever, ever married a goy.2:10Nobody ever married a goy.2:11There's one exception: the lady who got raped by an Egyptian, and we know about that guy, and we know about her son.2:16But everybody else, that's שמעי בת דברי, as the Torah brings it2:20out, but everybody else was never, never, ever married.2:22So they were pure, pure Jews. They were children of2:24Yaakov. Avraham is actually Yaakov, and not only Avraham is Yaakov, Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, literally like that,2:30not Yishmael, not anybody else.2:32And that's the Jewish people.2:34And when they came out, the pasuk says,2:37וערב רב יצא עמם. There's a big, big mixture of people that came with2:40them. Chazal tell us, who were these people?2:41These were Egyptians that wanted to convert.2:44Moshe did not ask Hashem about them.2:46He thought it was a pikidon of Hashem.2:47Think about it:2:48we're here, we're slaves to these people.2:50We were slaves to these people.2:51They looked down on us, right?2:53They stepped on us.2:54It could be some of these guys maybe were like, you know,2:57like it was in the Holocaust.2:59Maybe some of these guys were good Egyptians3:01that maybe tried to help the Jewish people,3:03some of them, right?3:04It's possible.3:05Not every Egyptian—it's possible3:06not every Egyptian was bad, right?3:09And Moshe felt, you know what,3:10it's kiddush Hashem,3:10let's take them out.3:12Let them want to convert,3:12let's take them out.3:13He didn't ask HaKadosh Baruch Hu.3:14And it seems like from words of Chazal that3:16Hashem was not happy with3:18him, because the first time we find that they made trouble,3:21major troubles, by the3:22eigel, they're the ones who came up with the idea of making the3:26eigel. And therefore when Hashem tells Moshe,3:29Lech reid ki shichet amecha, go down because your nation3:33has destroyed—Chazal tells us, amecha, your nation.3:34It's not the nation of Hashem?3:35We're not the nation of Hashem?3:36Chazal tells us, no, that was your nation that you brought out without asking Me,3:40they're the ones who made this3:41eigel. And throughout the Midbar,3:43we find again that they keep on making trouble.3:48We have Sasuf, shebikshu, avutah avah, parashat Ba'alotcha. There, when mitaveh ta'avah, they caused a lot of3:50problems. Constantly, they kept on coming up and they caused problems.3:53They were also left outside the clouds,3:56and that added to that.3:58Now, we didn't decide who's in and out of the clouds.4:01We didn't make the clouds.4:02We didn't custom make them from China and bring them to the Midbar.4:05Hashem decided to make the clouds.4:06He decided they should be out.4:07They don't deserve to get that special privilege.4:10But you could understand how people, when they're excluded,4:13they feel, hey, we're second-class citizens,4:16and they, you know, it seems like they didn't like it,4:21right? They didn't like it,4:22and they caused a lot of trouble, basically, for the Jewish people in the Midbar,4:27and a lot of problems always came from the Erev Rav.4:30Okay. Now, after that point, we don't find so much mention of the Erev Rav.4:34We do see that other people tried to join the Jewish people, like the4:40Givonim, and they were not really, you know, in the beginning,4:42they clearly were not leshem shamayim.4:43They didn't want to convert because they wanted to be Jewish.4:46They converted. Why?4:47Because they were scared of being killed out,4:51because the Jewish people were coming, wiping out4:53Sichon. Anybody came in their way.4:54They said, let's be smart. Let's convert.4:56So they really were supposed to be killed,4:59Yehoshua, because of chilul Hashem, said, you know what,5:01we're not going to kill them, but we'll make them work for us.5:04But these Givonim were not pure Jews,5:06and also they caused trouble later on.5:07We find way later that in the times of5:11Shaul, yes, they got affected from Shaul because of5:14Shaul, and they wanted that his descendants, some of them should be killed,5:18and they would not be satisfied with the money.5:20David HaMelech was ready to offer them a lot of money.5:22A lot of Jews died. They didn't care.5:24They wanted them to be killed.5:24They wanted to be hung until they get forgiven.5:27Later on in history, we find again the Shomrim, Shomronim.5:31These are people that supposedly also converted to5:34Judaism because they were attacked by lions.5:35But yet in the times of Chazal, they said,5:37no, now they have a din of— Goyim,5:42because we find that they had, they were still worshipping5:45avodah zarah. So we always find these people that kind of like joined the Jewish people,5:48but they weren't really there 100%,5:51right? Most of them,5:52and they ended up causing trouble to the Jewish people.5:54Sometimes we were able to filter them.5:56Sometimes we were able to say, Hey, these guys are not.5:58Sometimes we couldn't because they're already part of us.6:01Okay,6:01so that's a little bit of a brief history of people that are Erev Rav.6:05Now, we all know that souls kind of recycle.6:09So we're going to see now with Gilgul Atidah6:11how those souls recycle and everything,6:13how does it come, how does everything fit together.6:15So look what it says over here.6:17The Ibn Shmuel quotes as a summary from the6:19Gra. We're going to see every single detail.6:20I really want to see this again in very big detail.6:22He says like this:6:26Just like when you have6:28tevuah, nice videos you can find on YouTube, actually.6:31I found some videos, actually, when I teach the 39 melachot,6:34I found some videos6:36of—actually, you learn how the melachot were done.6:39So a wheat stalk, right?6:41You don't have the wheat kernels;6:42you have to kind of dig through it,6:44right? There's like shells upon shells.6:46So in the wheat stalk, there's three types of basically garbage or waste.6:50What is it?6:51The motz, the teben, and the subin.6:54Let's begin. Let's explain what each one is.6:57Motz is the, what's it called,7:01the shell on top of it.7:03Teben is the actual straw,7:05right? You don't use it; you only use the top.7:08The subin is kind of like the lower quality that gets filtered,7:11that gets—not filtered—sifted at the second sifting.7:16There's like these three levels.7:21So to the Jewish people, who are compared to7:23tevuah, as we find in beginning of the Torah,7:26it says,7:27Bereishit bara Elokim. Rashi brings that over there.7:30Three pshatim what Rashi is. One of them is, Rashi is the Jewish people,7:33as it says,7:35Rashi, tevuah. Hashem compares us to tevuah, to produce.7:38So too by the Jewish people, who are compared to produce,7:41we also find that there's also three types7:45of—basically, I don't want to say second7:46level, but three types of waste that we don't belong.7:49Who are they?7:50Yishmael, Esav, and Erev Rav.7:53Yishmael, we know, is the son of Abraham7:57Avinu. Right,7:57the second son of7:58Avraham Avinu, Esav is the second son of Yitzchak.8:00And Erev Rav, we discussed that a little bit,8:02what Erev Rav is. V'neged Avraham Yitzchak, shemim yatzuu es Avishmael, b'nei mashiachim shem Mashiach ben Yosef, Mashiach ben David.8:08Corresponding to Avraham Yitzchak, who produced Esav and Yishmael, like we just said,8:14Hashem will bring two Mashiachs that will kind of like stabilize, or like, you know, take care of the two types of psolet of Yishmael and Esav.8:25Who are they? Mashiach ben Yosef8:29and Mashiach ben David. Mashiach, the son of David, which means a descendant from David8:37HaMelech. V'hem yibarru es Esav u'motz veteben, and they'll cleanse out, they'll sift through the Jewish people, and any mixture from motz and8:44teben, from these types of mixtures from Yishmael and Esav, he'll cleanse it out.8:48Is this literally? That means will there be literally people that descendants of Yishmael that are not really Jewish,8:54or people that are descendants of Esav that are not really Jewish mixed with us, and he'll cleanse it?8:59I don't think so, because there's a Mishnah that says in Eduyot that when Eliyahu Hanavi is going to come,9:06he's not going to be docheh, he's not going to get rid of families.9:09That means any families that has a chazakah of being Jewish, he's not going to get rid of them,9:13right? He's going to be mekarev. He's going to say, You thought you're a goy, but you're really Jewish.9:17He's going to be mekarev, but not going to be9:18docheh. So what does it mean he's going to cleanse out from the Yishmael and9:22Esav? It can be the influence of Yishmael and Esav, right? There will be no more Arabic singers or something.9:27V'hayu k'kamon, neruach u'vet Esav l'kash. It'll be like standing in front of the wind,9:33as it says in the pasuk, u'vet Esav l'kash. The family of Esav will be like straw, which means it'll blow away very easily.9:41But it'll still not be completely cleansed,9:46ad sheyibarru min ha'Erev Rav, until we actually cleanse them from the Erev Rav. Erev Rav is that last, this will be that last thing that gets stuck in the wheat kernels.9:57Shemneged ha'shubin shendevakim b'chatam me'od. That's that light shell on top of the wheat, right? You got to get rid of that.10:02And that's the erev rav, they're mamash attached. To get rid of the yetzer hara in the inside, that's easy.10:06Goyish, just get away, right? But to get rid of the erev rav, which are mamash there,10:11they correspond to Yaakov Avinu. So therefore, says the10:16Gra, oh, the ... they correspond to Yaakov Avinu. So therefore, ... they correspond to bitul Torah and removing the yoke of10:26Hashem, which means not wanting to have Hashem on you.10:31And they're so attached to the Jewish people,10:35and the real Jewish people are learning from their bad ways.10:40These are the wealthy.10:43These are the wealthy baalei gaavah, the wealthy10:47baalei gaavah. Pause. Nobody go around now and say, if you're listening to this and you're not wealthy,10:51and you're going to say, Hey, of course, right? It's always, I don't know,10:54people always like to knock wealthy people, right?10:57Don't go around saying every wealthy guy is erev rav. Calm down.11:00And don't say, No, no, no, I don't mean the good wealthy people, I mean the bad.11:03No, no, no. And if you're wealthy listening to this, we'd like a donation. No, I'm kidding.11:06And if you're wealthy listening to this, right,11:09don't go around feeling, No, no, no, you're erev rav, chas v'shalom. No.11:12We're talking about, when it says,11:16... alizei ga'avatech, those are the people who are11:20mitga'eh. They control11:22their ashirim, and they like to control11:24the Jewish community.11:29And regarding them11:31is when it says in the Gemara,11:34the Mashiach will not come until we get rid of the baalei11:36gaavah. Who are these baalei gaavah? Who could be11:39baal gaavah? If you're, listen, if you're the financial supporter of the community,11:42and everybody needs you for the money, and you like to control it11:45for your own good, that's what it is.11:48Now, you might say, one second, you could have somebody who's very big ashir,11:51and he's a very big controller. He likes to take control11:54and to twist the community in the way he wants,11:56and he has relatives, brothers and cousins that are, you know,12:00big tzaddikim. So it seems like over here, from what I'm understanding12:04is that it could be the neshamot of12:07Rav come back. It may not necessarily be that12:09you're a pure descendant from the12:12Rav, right? You might be a kohen and be12:15ali zeh gavatecha, and you'd be one of those ashirim that likes to control.12:18What does that mean? You're a Rav. You can be a Rav if you're a kohen,12:23right? But what it means is12:24the neshamot come back like that,12:26or it could be a guy who learns from the Rav that way.12:32Now, you can't get rid of subin. Like we said,12:35subin is really, like we said, is the shell on top of12:39the wheat kernel, and the only way you can get rid of it is12:41after you grind it, then you sift it.12:44So he says, just like you can't get rid of it until you grind it,12:49so too,12:51it's only the difficulty of the galut12:53that will filter out this12:56Rav. Only going through this rough, rough galut,12:59like form that's like grinding,13:01that will filter out13:03that. All what we said was right now is a statement from the13:07Even Shelemah. I would like to see the sources in the Gra itself, as we have seen so far,13:11that we get to discover a lot more things when we see it,13:13and we can pick on certain points, elaborate on them,13:16some of them we might skip certain points,13:18but we're going to talk about the same about all these things, and stay tuned.13:22It's a very interesting subject.