Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 11, Lesson 5Sefer Even ShelemaPart 204Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0016:35Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Perek yud alef in Eben Shelema, ot dalet.0:05Bizchut shemitrachakim me'otam ha'oskim bilmud philosophia Elohit.0:10In the zechut that we distance ourselves from the people who are0:14osek, are so involved in the learning, in the study of philosophy,0:19philosophy about religion, religious philosophy.0:23Again, this is not talking about sefarim like the Ramban0:27and, you know, who has some stuff on philosophy, or the Rambam, or other things.0:32Talking about, you know, people, scholars who have such a discussion,0:38right? Limudiyot vitbayot. Also, learning about other learnings and0:44itbayot—we'll see what that means in a second,0:46right? All these things over here, he brings on the bottom, he says,0:51as long as it's against the Torah, anything that's against the Torah,0:56yizku l'atid lavo l'or Hashem, in the future, will be zocheh to the light of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.1:04Okay? So they all bring down, the famous over here on the bottom,1:06I see, they all bring it down that the Gra writes, the famous thing that the Gra writes in his commentary on Shulchan Aruch,1:18he says there's a famous thing, there's a famous psak from the1:21Rambam. The Rambam writes that regarding different mazalot and different things,1:26that they don't have all this magic doesn't really have any power, all nonsense.1:31All these were done by goyim to fool the people who could be easily fooled,1:37like young kids and people who are not intellectual, people who are not so intelligent.1:41That's the magic. It doesn't really, really have power.1:44So the Gra, in Biur HaGra on the Shulchan Aruch, he writes very, very strongly.1:50Actually, I think they write it over here.1:52Oh, they do bring it over here.1:53Okay, we're going to read it in a second.1:54He writes very strongly against it, as we'll see in a second.1:57Let's just see the pasuk, the source in Yeshaya, perek bet, pasuk vav, in the Gra's commentary.2:02It says in the pasuk,2:04Beit Yaakov,2:08lechu ונלכה באור ה'. Ki2:12natashta עמך בית יעקב, כי מלאו מקדם ועננים כפלשתים, ובילדי נכרים ישפיקו. Pasuk in Yeshaya says, the house of Yaakov, let's go and walk in the light of2:16Hashem. Why? Because you have left your nation, Beit Yaakov,2:21because they were full of people, like this, in the old days of the2:29Pelishtim, and used to hang around the goyim.2:30He says,2:39פירוש: בשבילה זכו שנתתה עמך, כושקתוב, ושחחי עמך ובית אביך ובית אביך ויתאוה מלך יופייך. In the zechut that you leave your nation,2:42it says in Tehillim,2:44forget your nation, your father's household,2:46and the king will desire your beauty.2:52כי מלאו מקדם. Because your nation—why did you leave your nation?2:54Why is there zechut to leave your nation?2:56Because your nation was full of things of3:01מקדם, לכן נתתה עמך וזכית לאור ה'. What does it mean,3:02מקדם? What's this3:04מקדם? She says,3:09מקדם ועננים, בילדי נכרים, הם הפילוסופיה, אלוהית, לימודית ותורנית. This is the philosophy that is referring to3:13philosophy that's3:15אלוהית. That means spiritual,3:18you know, philosophy about religion,3:21or any regular philosophy,3:23or natural philosophy.3:24And he explains how they're fit in the pasuk.3:27The word מקדם is3:28אלוהית, referring about, you know, all these Greek philosophies,3:32and when they speak and they discuss3:34how was the world created.3:35Again, it's not coming from a Torah point of view;3:37it's coming from— Goyim,3:39right? And they start putting them questions3:42and these things,3:45kemo shekatuv, me'ona elohi Kedem, ve'onenim, hainu yod'im lechaven hasha'ot kemo hovei shamayim. Also these people who know how to look at the times3:51and the, what we call today, not3:53astrologists, you know, the ones in the newspapers,3:54what are they called?3:58You know, when they give you the zodiacs4:00and everything else.4:01Those are people that look in, you know, the stars4:03and stargazers and all these things.4:06Ve'al derech nokhlim hu teva'iyot, and all those people that work only with the natural law,4:10against what the Torah says.4:12No, nature, this is how it is in nature.4:14But telling you, you know, the spirituality in nature,4:16no, and evolution, all these different things.4:19And the zechut that we stay away from all these things,4:22we'll be zocheh to the light of Hashem in the future.4:23Then he writes over here a famous thing.4:26This is a famous thing that I was just saying beforehand,4:28the famous thing of the4:29Gra. So4:31Shulchan Aruch quotes a halacha, right?4:33And this4:35halacha is in siman kuf ayin tet, halacha vav, and it comes from the4:37Rambam. He writes like this:4:39Mi shenashcho akrab, a person who is bitten by a scorpion,4:45mutar lechosh alav. You're allowed to be lochesh alav. What's lechosh? The word lachash means to whisper,4:48right?4:48You're allowed to whisper a certain kind of spell,4:54even on Shabbat.4:56Why? Because the guy is in sakana,4:58so there's no problem4:59of refuah. What about magic?5:00He says,5:03Ve'af al pi she'ein hadavar mo'il klum. The Shulchan Aruch writes, even though it's nonsense,5:05the whisper is nonsense,5:12hu mesukan, since the guy is in sakana, hitiru lokeh deyesh lo taref da'ato alav. Chachamim will matir it because the guy thinks that he's being healed,5:15right?5:16He thinks that, I'm saying this magical spell,5:18I'll heal him,5:19but it really does nothing.5:20Now,5:21sounds like from5:22Shulchan Aruch, which he gets it from5:24the5:25Rambam, that all the Munatra command are all about magic5:26and all these things.5:26It's really nonsense.5:27Why is the Torah5:28commanding? Because people think it means something,5:29but it's really nothing.5:31Good?5:31That's what it's clearly like that.5:34Vekatav Rabbeinu, the famous words of the5:36Gra, he writes like this:5:37HaRambam. All this comes from the5:42Rambam. Vekein katav beperusho Mishnayot leperek daled deAvodah Zarah. The Rambam writes the same exact thing5:44in his commentary on the Mishnayot5:48in Masechet Avodah Zarah, perek daled. Aval, however,5:49although this is the opinion of the5:52Rambam, kol haba'im acharav chalku alav. All those that came after the5:54Rambam disagreed with him.5:56Sheharbeh lachashim ne'emru baGemara. We're finding5:58Gemara pages and pages that discuss5:59about different types of spells6:01of people that you could say6:03and they have power.6:04But where did the Rambam now get it from6:05that all this means nothing?6:10והוא נמשך אחרי פילוסופיה הארורה. He was dragged by the philosophy.6:12As we know,6:13the Rambam used to read a lot of philosophy.6:16He used to read about Aristotle6:17and the books of Aristotle6:18and everybody else,6:19but he was pulled after it,6:21the cursed philosophy.6:25ולכן כתב שכשפים יש שמות ולחשים ושדים וכמיעות, הכל הוא שקר. That's why the Rambam writes6:28all magic,6:29all types of6:31hashbaat shemot, you know, saying the names of6:33different angels6:35and demons,6:36and all types of whispers,6:38you know, spells6:39and demons6:40and kemiot, all this is nonsense.6:44אבל כבר היכו אותו אכות קודו. But all the6:45Acharonim, all the rabbis that came after him,6:47hit him over his head.6:50We see a lot of stories in Gemara6:52that are based on all these spells6:55and magic6:55and everything else.6:56What made the Rambam go such a way?7:05ופילוסופיה הטעתו ברוב לקחה, לפרש הגמרא הכל בדרך הליציי ולעקור אותם פשטם. It's that philosophy7:07that he used to read7:08that made him make such a mistake,7:09because philosophy is slippery.7:11It's very slippery.7:12It can be very convincing.7:14You read it,7:14it makes a lot of sense,7:16and it made him7:17force him to learn the7:18Gemara that doesn't have anything supernatural.7:22Everything has to make sense.7:23Everything has to be based on...7:25Therefore,7:26when it says things in the Gemara,7:28he has to say it doesn't mean it's literal.7:32says7:34the Gra, I don't believe in all this nonsense.7:37I don't believe in all this philosophy,7:38not from them7:39and not from all of them, from any of them.7:42Whatever Chazal spoke,7:44they spoke in its simple meaning.7:45That's what it means.7:47I'm not telling you that when Chazal said...7:50They only spoke in a very shallow way.7:52No,7:52it has also deeper stuff.8:00But not the depths, like the way the philosophers explain that it's all based on, you know, logic and has to make sense, and you throw it in the garbage.8:10Ela baalei emet, it has deeper meanings based on the baalei emet, which we know these represent the Kabbalah.8:16There's a famous, famous Gra that's in the biur haGra on the Shulchan Aruch; it's brought down in many other places.8:23And this is why, really, a lot of Sefardim and the Acharonim, Hatam Sofer and others, hold that you shouldn't be studying,8:29you shouldn't read all the philosophical books.8:32Even the books that were written by Rishonim, in our days it doesn't really apply.8:35We don't need to answer these questions.8:37You should just know that, you know, we think, you know, the world is always the same.8:40For example, we see in our days there's a lot of, you know, in our short lifetime8:44— Hashem should give us long life — but even in our short lifetime, we see how many challenges come against the Jewish people,8:49like so fast, and things keep on changing.8:52Lemashal, the internet, right?8:53Everybody's always dealing now, what do we do? How do we deal with the internet?8:56Raising our children in such a perverted society.8:58The challenges that come up every single generation.9:01In the days of the Rishonim, the challenges were from philosophy, right?9:06There were a lot of questions that the goyim wrote challenging the authenticity of our Torah,9:12challenging the existence of God.9:14All this was a big, big deal back then, so all the Rishonim had to answer.9:18The Rambam had to write his books, and the Ramban had to get into debates9:23with Christian kings and Christian monasteries and people who used to be Jews that went off the9:28derech and challenging him.9:30All the Rishonim had to get into it, but the Acharonim all bring down9:33— and even Chovot HaLevavot has the first section of Chovot HaLevavot, right over there,9:37also talks about all these different things.9:40If you look in all the Acharonim, they say, you know, today, Baruch Hashem, with the coming of the Kabbalah.9:46We don't need to get into all that.9:48A person who's really interested, you want to know more about godliness and everything else,9:53learn a little bit about Kabbalah.9:54Yes, Kabbalah. Even we spoke about Kabbalah,9:57because that's the real stuff.10:00That's the real stuff.10:01Because otherwise, you know, you get all these questions and you have no answers.10:04You know, they used to say, we know that there was one of the major movements that destroyed Eastern Europe.10:09Let me just give you a little background history, because we're Sephardim, most of us are not familiar.10:13In Europe, you know, before the war, before World War II,10:17that's where the majority of the Jews lived.10:21And for sure the Ashkenazim, right?10:24And there's no question the Ashkenazim were much more, and still are much more than10:28Sephardim. But almost all now, I'd say 80% of them lived in Europe.10:31Europe means all the way from Russia all the way to, what do you call it, all the way till England, right?10:39The whole thing is, we're calling that Europe.10:41Now, there was Eastern Europe, like Russia and Poland, right,10:45and Lithuania, those kind of places,10:47and there was Western Europe, like, I guess you'd call Spain also Western Europe, Germany, France.10:54The Jews of Eastern Europe were much, much more religious than the people of Western Europe.10:59In Western Europe, what brought them down, unfortunately, was the movement of reform.11:06Reform started in Germany, in Berlin,11:09and that's also where the Nazis started from.11:12As the Meshech Chochma said, 100 years before the Nazis came to power, Meshech Chochma says,11:18because they started reform over here, you'll see that the problems will also start from here.11:21In any case, over there, the, what's it called, reform came out,11:26basically there were liberations.11:28There were people who were getting rights.11:30It started in Germany, in France,11:32and that's where there was a lot of intermarriage.11:34I think there was like 50 to 60 percent of Jews intermarried because they were given freedom.11:39They were not subjected to only live in Jewish neighborhoods.11:43They became professors and doctors and lawyers, and they joined the goyim.11:48In Eastern Europe, they were much more religious.11:50One part of the reason is because the Russians hated the Jews, and they always put them in their own places,11:55so they always stayed around each other.11:56But there was also a movement that started in Eastern Europe that started also looking down on religion.12:02They were called the Haskalah, the Enlightenment movement.12:05These guys were, most of them, or their best, were people who actually went to yeshivot12:09and went off the derech afterwards.12:11And Haskalah was very attractive.12:12One after the smartest12:13used to have their spies in the yeshivot. Who were the smartest yeshiva guys?12:18And they'd come to try to lure them, to try to grab them, to try to bring them into their places.12:24So they say, a line,12:27they say, you know, how did they get the Haskalah?12:29How did these guys go off the derech so much?12:31They say on Shabbat afternoon, after eating chol, where you get very tired,12:34they used to open up the Rambam, Moreh Nevuchim, where he has a lot of questions in philosophy.12:38They would just read the questions and go to sleep.12:41This way they only had questions, didn't have answers.12:44Right?12:45I don't know if it's true or not, but that's12:48the idea of that, when you have questions.12:50So a lot of times, you know, people don't have questions.12:52People who grew up, let's say, with simple emunah don't have questions.12:54All of a sudden, the guy starts to come and say,12:56How do we know that Hashem really exists?12:59Maybe He doesn't really13:00exist. The guy starts saying, Hey, you know what, maybe.13:02And how do you know that this is true?13:03Because Christianity—oh my gosh—the guy starts getting questions,13:06right?13:07Hey, what's going on?13:08Now, if you have questions, we have answers, Baruch Hashem.13:10A lot of great organizations out there, Arachim, and Baruch Hashem, in Hebrew and English,13:14and we have answers to a lot of these questions.13:16But if you don't have questions, to create questions is a problem.13:20When a person—and that's what they bring down, all these books, even from the Rishonim.13:23If you don't have these questions, you sit and you ask these questions,13:26you might end up with the questions and not the13:28answer. When you have the question, not the answer, it's a very big problem.13:31Especially when you feel that you read the answer and it doesn't make sense to you,13:34and you feel like you know the answer,13:36but you really don't know, that's an even much bigger problem.13:39How many people who are not so religious today, not religious at all,13:43they identify with Judaism, but they think it's all a joke.13:45Why?13:46Because they grew up in schools where the religious—not, I don't say the level,13:52but the Torah level—which means people weren't so knowledgeable in Torah.13:58They had maybe rabbis, they called rabbis,14:00but these rabbis didn't really know so much Torah and anything else.14:04So when the kids had questions that they were14:06wrong, and they asked these rabbis, the rabbis didn't know how to answer them,14:08so they felt, oh, you know, there's nothing to it.14:12There's a great story. You've heard of Kirk Douglas? He's a famous actor.14:17Michael Douglas.14:18Kirk Douglas is a famous actor.14:20His father's Michael Douglas, also an actor, very famous guy.14:24This guy Michael Douglas was Hoseh b'tshuva in the age of 70, 80.14:28He was in a helicopter, and the helicopter crashed.14:31It went up and it crashed.14:32And after that, he started to think, what's life all about?14:35And he started going researching. He was Jewish,14:37and he looked into it and he discovered,14:39odd, eventually he was14:41Hoseh b'tshuva, and he bought the building for Eretz Torah right opposite14:45wall, right opposite the Kotel, you know, the building of Eretz Torah over there,14:48that was bought by him,14:49a special building to make it for kiruv.14:53He was14:55Hoseh b'tshuva by... So one of the things that he says14:58is that one time he was out, and that night he was discovering,15:01he was in Israel, in Jerusalem,15:03and he was standing overlooking the Kotel, right?15:06And he was like holding back from becoming religious.15:10What was holding him back?15:11He says he keeps on remembering when he was a kid.15:14How he heard the story of Abraham taking his15:18son, so, and the kid is crying and doesn't want to be killed,15:21and his father's got a knife trying to kill him,15:22and only Hashem had to stop.15:24So what kind of religion is that?15:25You know, you take a kid and you try to kill him, right?15:28So the rabbi told him a great answer.15:30He says, I understand. When you were a kid, you learned math, right?15:32You learned one plus one, two times two is four, whatever.15:35Did you stop there, or when you grew up, you started going into it more and more?15:38He says, No, of course. When I get older, you start to learn more about math,15:42and what you learn as a kid, you realize there's much more to it when you get older.15:45He says, How come when it comes to Judaism,15:47a lot of people would learn, when they learn first, second grade, it stops there.15:51Nobody goes into the story deeper. Nobody goes into the questions deeper.15:54Now we know, Baruch Hashem, we learn Gemara, we see how deep it is.15:56But a lot of people's Torah...16:00Torah stops there. What they learned when they were little kids.16:04And we all know what goes on in school, how they learn, right?16:07You know, their head is halfway out the classroom because they're waiting for recess or lunch,16:12or come back from recess or from lunch,16:14and when they're given very, very little Torah, especially in all these places that, you know, they barely teach anything.16:20And that's what a guy establishes his whole Judaism on. He has questions all his life,16:24right? Go and look deeper into that subject.16:26So that's the questions that could be coming up from all these things.16:29We went a little longer, but... Baruch Hashem, I think it should be...