Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 11, Lesson 19Sefer Even ShelemaPart 218Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0017:25Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01בן שלמה, perek yud alef, ot tet. This is going to be, I believe, part four.0:06In today's section, we're going to discuss the two types of Mashiach and the two types of0:12geulah. As is brought down over here on the side notes that are brought basically as a source of the Gra himself,0:19which means we're going to be reading the words of the Gra himself, and we're going to see later on.0:23So it says over here, let's begin. Gemara Masechet Berachot,0:29at the end of the fifth perek, daf lamed daled amud bet, the Gemara says like this:0:34Kol hanevi'im lo nitnabe'u ela limot haMashiach.0:39All the prophets, what they were able to foresee, and all the good things that they said in their prophecies,0:47was only speaking about the days of Mashiach.0:49Aval l'olam haba, ayin lo0:56ra'atah. But regarding olam haba, the Gemara says, no eye has seen, as it says in the quote pesukim for that.1:00Now, the Gemara continues and says, U'pliga d'Shmuel, but this disagrees with Shmuel.1:06Why? What did Shmuel say?1:07Ein bein olam hazeh l'olam haba ela shibud malchuyot1:11bilvad. And Shmuel says there's no difference between this world and the world to come.1:16The only difference is shibud malchuyot, is that in the times of Mashiach,1:24we will have the goyim to be subdued,1:27which means, what means subdued?1:28That means we're not going to be ruled by the goyim.1:32We're going to have our own power and our own control based on the Torah,1:37not based on secular knowledge, and we don't need America's favors and we don't need anybody's1:41favors. We run it the way we want to run it, which is according to the Torah.1:47That's a Gemara.1:48Now, it sounds like a1:51machloket. There's a famous Arizal. Before we get to the Gra, so you can appreciate the word of the1:56Gra, there's a famous Arizal that says that when it comes to machloket in the Gemara,2:03especially by a aggadata, especially by things that are not halacha, really both are emet.2:10The only thing is each person is saying one aspect.2:12So over here, would this rule should also apply?2:16Seems like to be very hard.2:17You hear one person is telling you that it's going to be something beyond, beyond people's ability.2:23We don't even fathom what's going to be.2:25And somebody else is saying, No, world is going to be a normal world.2:29Everything is going to be the same.2:30Whatever they're up to in technology will be the same.2:32The only thing will be different is that we will have a real Jewish kingdom.2:40That's the difference, right?2:41Comes the Gra and says,2:44אלו ואלו דברי אלוקים חיים. These, they're both correct. Shemuel and the other opinion.2:49How can they both be correct?2:50Then it says,2:52כי ב' ימות המשיח הן. There's two types of days of Mashiach.2:56Now, on the bottom over here and in the back also,2:58they bring at length what this means, the two types of Mashiach.3:05And maybe we could just summarize it in very, very short,3:08because I want to try to get to more things over here.3:11And he says that basically what it means is,3:18היינו, ימות משיח בן יוסף. There are days of the Mashiach ben Yosef,3:22and then there's days of Mashiach ben David.3:24Mashiach ben Yosef is also the3:29zechut. It's all dependent on3:31zechut. As we learned already, Mashiach ben Yosef,3:34he is, you know, as Chazal tell us also,3:37there's a pasuk that says,3:41וְהָיָה בֵּית יַעֲקֹב אֵשׁ וּבֵית יוֹסֵף לֶהָבָה וּבֵית עֵשָׂו לְקַשׁ. I think that's the pasuk exactly.3:44But basically, Yosef has the power to burn3:49Esav. It's a famous, famous derashah from3:51Chazal. And we saw that already, that the Gra told us3:55that Mashiach ben Yosef's power is to conquer the goyim,3:59to defeat the goyim, to get rid of goyim,4:01and Mashiach ben David is going to up the level of the Jewish people in Torah and mitzvot.4:06That's the goal of each one.4:08And we saw already that Yosef lived in history.4:11Yosef himself lived amongst the goyim,4:13and he prepared it in a way that the Jewish people should live away from goyim4:18and not have influence from the goyim,4:19as it says that he requested that they have Goshen only for the Jewish people.4:26He also moved around all the Mitzrim in different lands,4:29so this way when the Jews come, they shouldn't be embarrassed to have brit milah.4:33And it also says that when Yosef passed away,4:37right,4:38Vayamot Yosef kol dora hu, Vayakom melech chadash, it says, when Yosef and Chazal says there's a connection here. When Yosef died and all the shevatim died,4:48Bnei Yisrael started mingling with the goyim.4:51And why does it say in the pasuk,4:53Asher lo yada et Yosef? Because Yosef clearly separated himself from the goyim.4:56He didn't eat with them, as we see when the brothers came to visit.5:00He didn't do anything with them.5:01He completely didn't do anything with the goyim,5:04separated from the goyim,5:04Jews to be Jews by themselves.5:07And that's Mashiach ben Yosef.5:08And then we find that Yehuda,5:10Vet Yehuda shalach lefanav Goshna to set up a yeshiva.5:14Yehuda was in charge of making sure that there's a yeshiva,5:16and that's Mashiach ben David, who comes from Yehuda.5:21Those are the two types of Mashiachs,5:23says the Gra. That's also the two types of geulah that we find.5:28It says that5:37Im zachu, achishena; lo zachu, be'ita. If Bnei Yisrael zocheh, I'll speed up the geulah, and that's going to come through Mashiach ben Yosef.5:40And if they're not5:42zocheh, then it has a specific time, and that's Mashiach ben David.5:45And that's the two types of5:47geulah. When Shmuel said,5:54Olam k'minhago noheg. And all the differences, שעבוד מלכיות בלבד, that's in the times of Mashiach ben Yosef.5:56If we were5:58zocheh, where Chazal tell us that really6:00the world is divided into 6,000 years.6:02The first 2,000 years are6:04tohu vavohu. The second 2,000 years are the years of Torah.6:07And the last 2,000 years are the years of Mashiach.6:10But the Gemara concludes,6:12but now, what do you mean, Mashiach didn't come?6:13No, it's the times when we could have had Mashiach.6:16Those are all the times of the6:18zechut of Hashem could have sped up the6:19geulah, who could have brought Mashiach ben Yosef.6:21We will have our own Jewish kingdom.6:24We won't be suffering through the hands of the goyim.6:27But we were not zocheh, and we have to wait for that end time.6:30What would have been different if Mashiach would have come?6:32Nothing.6:35שעבוד מלכיות בלבד. And when Mashiach ben David comes,6:37that's when no prophet has ever seen.6:40That's a prophecy that the Gemara says,6:43עין לא ראתה, nobody has seen.6:45That's the two different types of6:46Mashiachs. That's the two types of6:49geulah, and everything now is answered up6:51because everything is now. The Gra just opened up our6:54eyes and showed us that these are the two types.7:00Okay. Now, we'll come back to another piece7:02that they bring over here from the7:04Gra in his commentary to7:08Sifra d'Tzniuta. Yeah, okay, look what he says over here.7:10היינו ימות משיח בן יוסף, וזה תליא בזכות. The days of Mashiach ben Yosef are dependent on the7:16zechut, as it says,7:20זכו, אחישנה. ואם זכינו היה מתחיל בתחלת אלף החמישי. He says if we were7:22zocheh, it would have started at the beginning of the 5,000th year,7:26right?7:27That means from the time that it turned the year7:324,000. You hear that?7:32When the year 5779, going on7:385780. We are 220 years before7:426000. That means we've missed it out for about 1800 years.7:461800 years where we have missed out on the days of Mashiach.7:50We could have had Mashiach from that time already.7:54Then he can understand. That's what he says over here.7:57That's what Shmuel says,7:58that there's no difference between our days and—8:00That means in this world, there is a Mashiach except for8:05Shibud Malchuyot. At that time, still Eisav will not fall yet.8:09In the sixth thousand, which we're living in, when the time of Beitah would have come in,8:15יבוא עשיו וגוג ומגוג על ה' ועל משיחו. Then, as the nevuah says by David HaMelech, he says in Tehillim,8:22right, ננתקה את מוסרותימו ונשליכה ממנו עבותימו. That's talking about the times of Gog and Magog.8:24Eisav will come together with Gog uMagog, because Gog uMagog is not part of8:28Eisav, and they all come to fight against the Jewish people,8:31and Mashiach ben David will come up,8:32ויפולו כולם ביד משיח בן דוד, and they all fall into his hands.8:39וכשיבוא משיח בן דוד, קיים מה שכתוב: בלע המוות לנצח. Mashiach ben David comes, then we get to experience the other8:42nevuot, which are there's no more death,8:45וכל ייעודי הנביאים, all the promises of the8:47Neviim, is going to come. That's called8:50לעתיד לבוא. Good? Fine.8:53And then he says we can explain one final Gemara.8:56What does the Gemara8:58says? Okay,9:00the Gemara says in Masechet Berachot9:02that the famous thing that we say in the Haggadah,9:07אמר לבן זומא לחכמים. Chachamim say,9:14כל ימי חייך, right, למען תזכור את יום צאתך מארץ מצרים כל ימי חייך. Why does it say9:20ימי חייך, ולא ימים? כל ימי חייך, אלא הלילות, right? That's9:24the9:29derashah ben Zoma. But the Chachamim disagree. Chachamim omrim, ימי חייך העולם הזה, כל ימי חייך לעולם הבא. Good? That's what the9:31Mishnah famous. We say it in Haggadah9:32shel Pesach. The Gemara continues9:34and says that there was actually a continuation in that debate.9:39אמר לבן זומא לחכמים, בן זומא tells the9:42Chachamim, וכי מזכירין יציאת מצרים לימות המשיח? Right?9:43Do we mention9:44yetziat Mitzrayim Mashiach? It says that those days will not be mentioned.9:47אמרו לו, so they answered him, לא שתיעקר יציאת מצרים ממקומה, אלא שיהיו שעבוד מלכויות עיקר ויציאת מצרים טפל. They answered him,9:51no, we're not saying that9:55nobody's going to mention yetziat Mitzrayim in the future,9:57but we're just saying9:59that the main thing will be,10:01in the future, geulah will be the main thing,10:04but yetziat Mitzrayim will be secondary.10:17Tanya Rabbi Yehuda omer, Rabbi Yehuda, זו מלחמת גוג ומגוג. Okay? The Gemara gives a mashal over there, basically.10:21I don't want to go through the whole Gemara inside.10:23Those who know, know it, and those who don't know it,10:26okay,10:27we'll just hear it from the outside.10:28The Gemara says,10:29imagine a guy was going home and he came across a lion,10:33right?10:33After he fights with the lion,10:35he was able to save himself from the lion.10:37Woo!10:37He's telling everybody,10:39You know what happened to me?10:40There's a lion.10:41I almost got killed, and I saved myself from the lion.10:43And all of a sudden, he meets this huge snake,10:46a cobra, standing up to attack him,10:48and now he's saved from the snake.10:51Yeah?10:57Right? So now what does he do? He forgets about the lion, and he goes and he tells everybody the story of the snake.10:59I missed one more detail,10:59sorry.11:00He was walking home,11:01he comes across a fox,11:03right?11:03A wolf, actually.11:05He's saved from the wolf,11:06and then he sees a lion,11:08right?11:08Then he gets saved from the lion.11:09So till now, he's been telling everybody the story11:11of how he was saved from the wolf,11:15but now11:16he's telling everybody how he was saved from the lion. He continues walking. What does he see? He sees a snake. Now he forgot about the lion.11:27He forgot about the wolf. Now he's telling everybody11:27how he was saved from the snake.11:30Says,11:31so too, the Jewish people,11:31we're talking about yetziat Mitzrayim, how we were saved from it.11:33But in the future,11:34when Hashem is going to save us from this11:36galut, we're going to start only speaking about this.11:38That's the Gemara.11:39The Gra has some questions over here.11:41He says,11:41number one11:43is, you bring me a proof that we're not going to remember11:45yetziat Mitzrayim. Number two is, right, you also bring me that olam hazeh they won't remember. Also, when it says that when he was saved from the lion,11:57it didn't say he forgot the story of the ze'ev, and then it says that he forgot the story of both of them.11:59So he explains,12:02Ki ge'ulat hiyeh pa'am rishonah mi'shibud olam hazeh. He says12:02the geulah will be the first time12:04from enslavement in this world.12:06V'achar kach hog magog, and then there's going to be the war of Gog12:11uMagog. U'mehebi... okay. And then after Gog12:13uMagog, right?12:17Okay, so basically it comes out like this.12:19First,12:19the wolf is compared to12:22yetziat Mitzrayim, and that's what we're talking about till now.12:24And then we're going to be12:26freed from shibud olam hazeh.12:27We're going to actually have our own kingdom,12:29and then we're going to,12:31you know, everybody's going to talk about,12:32okay, Baruch Hashem, we're saved from the galut.12:35But then all of a sudden,12:36we have our own kingdom,12:37Gog uMagog is going to come,12:38and that's going to be very dangerous for the Jewish people12:41because it looks like they're going to attack all the Jewish people.12:43And then when Hashem saves us from that,12:46that's like being saved from the snake,12:47and we're all going to be celebrating, Baruch Hashem,12:52we're not going to be in danger anymore.12:56We could technically stop over here,12:57but there's one more piece I really wanted to do,13:01okay? So over here,13:02I would like you to see,13:03there's a beautiful piece over here. They bring,13:05it's a lot of different points over here.13:07They all come from the Gra's commentary13:09on Tikunei Zohar,13:10and he says like this:13:12when the Gemara says in Rosh Hashanah13:15that13:15there's a13:20machloket between Rabbi Eliezer and Rabbi Yehoshua. According to Rabbi Eliezer, the Jewish people will be redeemed in Tishrei.13:22Rabbi Yehoshua says it's going to13:24happen in Nisan,13:26okay? Also, there's another Gemara.13:28It says13:29when Hashem redeems the Jewish people,13:31it's going to13:33be echad me'ir u'shnayim mishpachah,13:35as the pasuk says, one out of a city,13:36two from a family.13:38And Rabbi Yochanan says,13:40no, one out of a city is able to be13:42mezakeh the whole city to do teshuvah,13:44two people from the family who do teshuvah13:46will be mezakeh the whole family to do teshuvah.13:50And again, the Gra says both statements are correct.13:52How is that so?13:53He says,13:55b'tchilat hiyeh pegidah b'Tishrei. Hashem will start redeeming the Jewish people13:57in Tishrei,13:58and if they're14:00zocheh because of their14:03zechuyot, then Hashem speeds up the14:06geulah. Right,14:06and they will come out with wealth.14:10However, if the Jewish people are not14:13zocheh, and14:14Hashem is not bringing it through14:15zechut of14:17Achishena, and we're going to have to bring it, the geulah is going to come in its time,14:24as im haya geulah b'itah, then if the geulah would have come in Tishrei,14:26since that's a zman of14:27din, chas v'shalom, nobody would be left over.14:30The only thing that would be left over14:31is one person, city, two from a family,14:33because midat hadin is usually in Tishrei.14:36And then also we would have to have14:37also Mashiach ben Yosef who would come;14:39he would also have to die.14:41Therefore,14:44then the geulah also will not be14:46so final like it was14:48at Kor. We had a14:50geulah, we had a second Beit HaMikdash, but it didn't last,14:53right? Mashiach will come14:55into Tishrei, but he will be covered14:56until14:58Nissan. And then from that point,15:04in that in-between time,15:10there'll be tremendous amount15:11of suffering to the Jewish people,15:12like we find even in Mitzrayim.15:29Moshe appeared, then he disappeared, and15:30they suffered tremendously, increased the work tremendously in Mitzrayim. Then that Nissan, the Jewish people will be redeemed15:31with a lot of15:38chasadim. And the Mashiachs15:39will try to do as much as they can15:41to protect the Jewish people,15:42that the15:43geulah, they beg Hashem that the geulah should come15:45in15:46Nissan, because that's when the15:47midat harachamim is around.15:52Moshe will protect the city15:54Yerushalayim, and the two15:56Mashiachs will protect on the Jewish people.16:00Which are the family. And that's the meaning of Rabbi Yochanan that says,16:03Echad me'ir mezakeh et kol16:07ha'ir, u'shnayim mishpachah mezakin kol16:09ha'mishpachah. The simple meaning was that one person of the city would be16:12mezakeh the whole city,16:13but al pi the Zohar, what the Gra explained, al pi Kabbalah,16:17the echad means representing Moshe Rabbeinu.16:20He will be the one who protects16:22Yerushalayim. And the shnayim mishpachah, the two people16:26who protect on the16:28mishpachah, who is that? That's the two Mashiach,16:31Mashiach ben Yosef, Mashiach ben David,16:32that will be mezakeh the whole entire16:35mishpachah to do teshuvah and to be protected,16:37that Hashem should redeem them in the geulah that's going to come in16:42Nissan. Finally, one last statement and we'll be done with this.16:48Yetz'u b'Nissan shehu midat hachesed, yetz'u b'aniyut. When they get redeemed in Nissan, which is through chesed,16:52they'll come out with poverty,16:55כי עני נצרך לחסד, because who usually needs the chesed?17:01So as we know, everybody that does anything with17:03the ani is all pure chesed,17:05and since we need that chesed, we'll be poor then.17:07I have my own theories of how it might happen,17:10but I'm sure you could come up with your own.17:12I'm only going to say what it says,17:14and my opinion is batel to what it says over here,17:18and we'll just, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll wait with yearning eyes17:21for the geulah.