Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 11, Lesson 13Sefer Even ShelemaPart 212Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:57Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Perek yud alef, ot zayin.0:06Lefi shehadorot mitma'atin v'holchin. It's still the subject0:08of—we're up to a new letter today,0:10a new concept.0:14Lefi shehadorot mitma'atin v'holchin, as the generations get closer to Mashiach,0:19the lashon he's using over here,0:21the generations get smaller and0:22smaller. It doesn't mean smaller in number,0:24but it becomes weaker and weaker in greatness.0:28V'ha'idraf gabrin. At the same time, the0:30dor, as we saw now,0:32the dor is not necessarily the descendants of the0:34dor, but the dor is actually either0:37people that act like the0:40dor, and those are regular Yisraelim that act like the0:43dor because they're influenced by the0:44dor, or it could be the neshamot of the0:47dor that came back in a gilgul,0:50right? Either way, they're getting more and0:52more. They get more and more, as we saw, that we get to Mashiach.0:56Lefichach hutzerchu chachmei hador1:00b'chol dor v'dor ligzor gezerot u'seyagim chadashim. That's why the chachamim of each generation,1:03they keep on coming up with more1:04chumrot, more gezerot, more1:06gezerot, and there's more fences and1:08more fences. Why?1:09Legdor1:10pratzat prutzei hador. In order to fix the1:13pratzat hador. I'll give you an example of what that means for a1:15second, just to see why we have to make more fences.1:19Take a jacket, right?1:22You're wearing a jacket, like a regular suit jacket.1:24Imagine now, how much material,1:28or let's say you have a wool jacket, right?1:30How much wool are you using for the jacket,1:33whatever it is, give the number.1:35Let's say one pound, two pounds,1:38okay, of material. Good?1:40Now imagine a person gets a rip in the jacket,1:44right? So now what do you have to do to fix the rip?1:47You can just stitch it,1:49but just stitching it along the1:51line is not going to really hold it,1:52right?1:53But let's say you do stitch along the1:56line, so you stitch a little bit more than the1:57line because you got to hold it together.1:58Automatically, right now, to fix the stitch,2:01to fix the rip,2:02you have added more than what was before.2:07That means your jacket before and your jacket now2:10has now more material.2:12Okay, now imagine you put a patch.2:14Obviously, you have to put much more,2:16right? So anytime you have a rip,2:18you have to add more to it.2:20So too, the Erev Rav have made rips2:23and breaks in our religion,2:26and therefore every time we need to fix it,2:28we have to add more fences2:30because we keep on trying to fix,2:31and every time we try to fix,2:32remember, you always have to add more2:34to secure it that doesn't rip again.2:36So that's what he's saying.2:37That's why we find there's so much more2:39and more and more2:40gezeirot as we get closer and closer to Mashiach,2:42because all due to the Erev Rav,2:43they make the problems.2:44And then they go around complaining,2:47Whoa, the rabbis are always coming out2:49with the2:50gezeirot, they're always coming out with things,2:51and2:53the ... and they call you all different things.2:54But they don't understand that2:55our gezeirot are because of them.2:57I remember once I went to a doctor,2:59right? The doctor was a Jewish doctor.3:01Clearly, I wouldn't call this guy religious.3:03Maybe he keeps Shabbat3:05to what he thinks he keeps Shabbat,3:07right? And he was a specialist.3:09He was not a regular doctor.3:10He was a specialist,3:10only one time in my life.3:13Now, he goes,3:15Oh, so what do you do?3:17Yeah? Oh, you have a shul?3:18Oh, very good.3:19And then he started making like some jokes,3:21which seemed to be3:22jokes, but they were really putting down,3:24like, Hey, I call the shuls,3:26you know, the store of the rabbi,3:27you know, and these are his customers.3:30Okay, I thought it was a3:31joke. I didn't think it was funny.3:32Okay. Meanwhile,3:33then all of a sudden,3:35I'm not answering him.3:36I'm not—okay, nodding my head for3:37everything. He closes the door.3:38He locks it.3:41Like this, he gets a serious face.3:42He gives me3:44a 25-minute speech3:47about how the3:49chachamim went out of control,3:51being gozer,3:52and I guess he learned some3:54halacha about3:55muktzeh. If he says Moshe Rabbeinu was around,3:57somehow this guy3:58knows what Moshe Rabbeinu3:59would hold.3:59Anyway, Moshe Rabbeinu4:00was around,4:01he would say this is all nonsense,4:04this is da-da-da-da-da. Now keep in mind,4:05when I walked4:06into—when I was walking into,4:08you know, when you go by a4:09doctor, there's like seven rooms.4:10There's a waiting room,4:11and then afterwards4:12you get your turn,4:13and they tell you,4:14Wait in the other room,4:15where they're going to weigh you4:16and4:16write. As I was walking to my room,4:19I happened to pass4:21by one of the other rooms,4:22and I saw this same doctor4:24getting a massage4:25from his non-Jewish secretary.4:26And this guy's telling me4:27what Moshe Rabbeinu is going to hold.4:28You know, I thought it was4:29very interesting.4:30I said, Okay,4:31right? He's like, you know,4:32God is not evil.4:34I said, Okay.4:34He doesn't—4:35I said, Okay.4:36Everything he4:37said, I said, Okay.4:38He got more upset.4:41In any case,4:42but4:44that's exactly what it is.4:45That's the4:46..., right?4:47They're the ones.4:48They're the ones who do4:48whatever they want to do,4:50and they go around4:51making complaints,4:51and they don't understand4:52that we have to make4:53gezeirot because of them.4:53And then we make the4:55gezeirot, Oh, all machs with the4:56gezeirot. Now let's see4:57a few very important4:59points of4:59view that they bring.5:00First from the5:01Gra, and then he has5:02some5:02ha'arot from the bottom.5:03It's very, very important.5:03Look at the5:04Gra. He comes from the Tikkunei Zohar. Lefichach, he writes,5:09Bechol dor vador avdin gederot chadashim. In every generation,5:10we make new fences.5:13Lefi sheha-dorot mitma'atin, v'ha'aravim mitgabrim, because the5:14generations are getting weaker5:15and weaker5:17spiritually,5:17and the5:18yetzer hara is getting stronger5:19and stronger.5:22Tzarich legeder chadash, legdor ha-prutzah shepartzu ha'arav. That's why we always5:23need that new fence5:24to protect5:25what the5:26yetzer hara, or to5:27seal up5:28what the5:28yetzer hara has broken.5:32V'shamru et mishmarti, mishmeret lemishmeret. That's the idea5:33of making a5:35mishmeret lemishmeret. I would like everybody5:37to please look5:37on the bottom5:39in אות י״ח and ט״ט that they bring over here.5:42Right?5:43Chazal tell us,5:46a Gemara Masechet Eruvin, Rav once went to a place,5:51and he,5:52bika'a matza v'gadar bah geder. He found5:52an open area5:54and he put a fence.5:55Comes Rashi5:56and explains,5:56what does that mean?5:58Amei haaretz hayu. He went to a city5:59and he saw6:00that many of the people6:01are6:02amei haaretz, u'mezalzelim b'mitzvot, and they used to be6:04mezalzel in mitzvot. And therefore,6:05what did Rav do?6:10V'hechmir aleihem la'asot siyag l'Richak min ha'aveirah, k'dei ha'goder b'kar perutzah l'shomrah. So6:11Rav, what he did is,6:12he was6:13machmir on them.6:13As we see also6:15in halacha a lot of times,6:16are they bnei Torah?6:17They're not bnei Torah.6:18We find that6:19if the people are bnei6:20Torah, if the person who's asking you6:21is a ben Torah,6:21what does it6:22mean he's a ben Torah?6:23He's a talmid chacham, he knows what he's doing,6:24right?6:24We find some6:25leniencies. But if6:27it's amei haaretz, right,6:28we are6:29machmir on them. I'm going to say one thing6:30which is famous,6:31because you can't say everything,6:32because6:33give me the amei haaretz might get6:34a hold of this,6:35right?6:35But the Gemara says,6:37for example,6:40V'hagita bo yomam va'layla, right?6:40You have to learn6:42Torah yomam va'layla, day and night,6:44which sounds like6:45every single6:45night, every single6:46night you have to be6:47learning.6:47The Gemara says,6:47and even if you said6:49Shema Yisrael,6:50just the word6:51Shema Yisrael,6:52technically you6:53fulfilled the chovah, because it is6:54yomam va'layla. Then the Gemara concludes6:56with the following words:6:59V'davar ze asur le'omro bifnei amei haaretz. And this thing,7:00not only7:00saying,7:02asur, it's forbidden to say in front of7:03amei haaretz, right?7:04The next opinion says,7:05no,7:10mitzvah le'omro bifnei amei haaretz. It's a mitzvah to tell amei haaretz. What's going on?7:10What's the machloket here? And the machloket is very simple.7:12There's two types7:13of7:14amei haaretz. There's amei haaretz who feel very,7:15very discouraged.7:17I can't learn7:18Torah day and night.7:19Okay, listen,7:20do something.7:21Look,7:22even Shema7:22is good enough.7:23That's the second type7:25of7:26amei haaretz, mitzvah le'omro bifneiha. Even Shema is good enough.7:28Kavachomer if you do7:29more. So the guy7:29is going to get7:30encouraged to do more.7:31Then the second type7:32of7:35amei haaretz, who's mezalzel b'mitzvot, right,7:35part of the7:36eid of Rav and his friends,7:37who's going to say,7:38Shema is good enough?7:39Chalom, I don't need anything else.7:40Shema is good enough,7:42right?7:42So7:43you see that7:44there's certain7:45halachot that even though7:46they're halacha, you don't say7:47it in front of7:48amei haaretz, because7:49they're going to be mezalzel more. But talmid chacham, you can tell him,7:50you can be lenient,7:51right?7:52So that's also,7:53we find, he's saying7:54that the7:56eid of Rav is, that's what they're doing.7:57There's a lot of things7:57that they...8:00Keep on doing it, keep on, and we have to be more and more machmir because not to lose our religion.8:04Now comes the next piece and says something more amazing.8:08He brings from the8:11של״ה הקדוש. Those who don't know who the של״ה was, he used to be the chief rabbi of Prague,8:19right? Rabbi, what's his name? Rabbi Horowitz, Rav Horowitz.8:22Rav Horowitz is actually a8:24Levi, and they come originally, the real, real, real Horowitzs—I mean, the original family—originally comes from Spain.8:33So they actually used to be8:34Sefardim, but today is a famous Ashkenazi last name,8:36right? But he was a big mekubal, a big8:39talmid chacham, talmid of the Tosafot Yom Tov, or the Rav of the Tosafot Yom Tov.8:42In any case, he says like this.8:44The של״ה writes like this:8:48בכל דור ודור החומרות מתפשטות. Every generation we see more8:52chumrot. Look, in the Torah it's clear.8:55What was8:56assur? Only what they got in Torah, whatever Hashem told them,8:59365 issurim, and that's it.9:02And then we see Moshe added a few9:04takanot, right? Says now you have to read every Monday and Thursday.9:06And he added a few more gezerot,9:09right? And according to some Rishonim also, the gezerah also of muktzeh started from Moshe Rabbeinu.9:17Whatever need there was, he felt.9:22Then we find—we're just talking about yichud, right?9:25See that David HaMelech goes there,9:27yichud on9:31peniot, on9:33single girls, Beit Shammai, Beit Hillel. In each generation they keep9:34on—we know, chazal had many, many gezerot.9:36And the idea of it is,9:42the poison of the snake which started from9:45the beginning, as the world becomes older and older,9:49the poison spreads more and more.9:52Poison of the snake becomes more and more.9:55We need to protect ourselves more and more,9:57right?9:58It's kind of like bugs,10:00right? The world was much cleaner once upon a time.10:03We didn't have chemicals,10:03we didn't have10:04machinery, we didn't have everything.10:04So you could have eaten10:07more fruit, but there's not, right? There's no such thing as organic.10:09Everything was organic.10:11Everything was good.10:12Everything was healthy.10:13But what happened is when people started playing with it,10:17right, somebody taking more10:19fences. There's bugs everywhere10:20because there's pollution everywhere.10:22There's dirt everywhere.10:24That's the metziut of the world.10:26It gets worse and worse.10:27So what do we have to do?10:28We have to be more careful.10:29So now you can't buy regular fruits without checking them.10:34There's everything is infested.10:35Oh, it was never like that once upon a time.10:37I agree,10:38but that's what happened to the world,10:40right? Somebody just gave me a whole speech10:41and said,10:41but even the food that we eat in America,10:43that there's so much diseases in it,10:46right?10:46And we know10:48it's not healthy.10:49So therefore we have to do,10:50we have to eat10:51devorim, and at the same time10:52we have to eat also,10:53we have to buy the medicines10:54and pay for everything else10:56to kind of like fix that.10:58So he's saying,10:59spiritually it's the same thing.11:00That's why we need more fences.11:06U'poretz geder, yecheshenu nachash, right? The pasuk says11:07anybody who breaks the fence,11:08the snake bites him.11:10What does that mean?11:11According to this,11:11the pshat is explaining11:12that we need fences11:14because when you break the11:15fences, the snake right there.11:16That's what it sounds like,11:17right? Well, and the Gemara uses this pasuk11:20for whoever breaks the fences of the11:22chachamim. So the pshat he's telling you11:24is the zohama of the nachash11:25that's spreading throughout the whole world.11:26The chachamim have to keep on making fences.11:28As soon as you break that11:29fence, you're gonna find the snake over there.11:31That's the snake.11:32Not11:33necessarily that you get bit by a snake,11:34which could be also11:36pashut pshat. That's also true.11:37But the zohama of the nachash,11:38when you break the fence of the11:41chachamim, there's the zohama of the nachash right there.11:47The 36511:48lo ta'asehs that Hashem commanded us in the Torah11:50is that we should make sure11:53not to reawaken11:54or to keep more of the poison of the snake,11:57the spiritual poison of the snake.12:00However,12:01when the generation keeps on breaking,12:03and we allow the zohama of the nachash,12:05we allow this poison, the spiritual poison of the snake,12:07to get more and more,12:11so then we basically have to make more12:14issurim to get more protection.12:19Had this took place in the Torah,12:22then yes,12:23there would have been the12:25same—it's an amazing thing,12:26look what the12:26Shlah says—had the same thing that happened12:29throughout the generations12:30happened even by Matan Torah,12:32it would have been also recorded in the Torah.12:34So all these people that keep on saying,12:35Oh, chachamim keep on12:37making—oh, it's derabanan, come on, what, chachamim keep on coming12:40up—oh, chumrot upon12:41chumrot, and our12:42generations, we keep on getting12:44chumrot and chumrot and chumrot and chumrot. What's going on?12:44Everybody keeps on complaining, right?12:46And yeah, the Shlah is saying,12:48had this taken place,12:49Moshe Rabbeinu would have written in the Torah.12:51Just like we see in this week's12:53parashah, what happened?12:53There was a fear that the12:58nachalot, that the shevatim would lose their portion13:01in Eretz Yisrael, so he made a13:03gezeirah that they can't marry13:03not to the13:05shevatim. It was only effective to a certain time,13:07but we made a13:08gezeirah such a thing,13:09everybody should only marry within themselves.13:11So you see13:12there was a situation that came up,13:13he made it.13:14It seems like, to be13:16from the Gemara,13:17it seems like13:17when the Torah13:18commanded on tzitzis, because somebody13:20was mechalel Shabbat, he didn't have a reminder,13:21right?13:22So you see13:24things were in the13:25Torah based on what came up.13:28But zeh nechlal b'mah she'asah haTorah, ki hakol nechad. But when the Torah was13:31oser the 365 on a Kabbalistic level,13:33to understand this is,13:35includes all the issurim today.13:37How does it include all the13:38issurim? Because remember,13:38we got to subdue,13:40we got to keep the zuhama in its place.13:42We keep on,13:44or a lot of us13:45keep on making13:46aveirot, so we keep on giving in to the power,13:48so we now need to bring it back.13:50So we need to do extra things13:51to bring it back.13:52It's like a person:13:53you eat healthy,13:54you stay healthy.13:55Once,13:56if you've been eating not healthy13:57for 20 years,13:58now you want to make a diet,13:59you can't just eat healthy again.14:01Now you need to exercise14:02more than a regular person.14:04Now you need to be on a stricter diet14:05than a regular person.14:07So that's the diet,14:07the spiritual diet that we have.14:12And that's why Hashem14:13gave a general command.14:15Chachamim of the generation,14:16you make your own14:17mishpat, you make your own fences,14:18based on what you see.14:19You see it spread,14:21make a fence.14:23Okay.14:28... amazing statement,14:29the shlah ends off with:14:31Therefore,14:31in every generation,14:32when they see14:33that they need to make another fence,14:35then that fence14:37is equal to the14:39de'oraita. Amazing line.14:40So the next time14:40somebody tells you,14:42Oh,14:42it's derabanan, you tell them,14:44it's according to the...14:45it's very close,14:46it could be de'oraita even,14:47right?14:48Because it's on a Kabbalistic level14:49for sure it is.14:50It's all the same idea.14:51Baruch...