Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 11, Lesson 12Sefer Even ShelemaPart 211Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:09Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:02Eved Shelema, perek yud alef or vav. We're up to the sixth part already over here in this ot, in the subject of Erev Rav.0:09We're still not going to be done even after this ot, but today I would like to finish this ot vav on the Erev Rav.0:17Again, we're repeating why we're spending so much time on this, because it's very halacha lemaaseh; it's talking about our days.0:25Today's last subject we would like to talk about the same point a little bit, but just go a little bit further,0:33of how the Talmidei Chachamim in each generation are represented by Moshe Rabbeinu,0:39which is really they're all, you want to say, gilgul of Moshe Rabbeinu, or they have a nitzotz of Moshe Rabbeinu,0:44or they have a shefa from Moshe Rabbeinu, and Moshe Rabbeinu is connected to them,0:49and especially the gadol hador, the greatest leader of the generation.0:53In any case, we are dealing right now with this point, and we want to deal with this.1:01We'll see also soon that Eliyahu Hanavi, when he comes, and the coming of Eliyahu1:07Hanavi, that's also connected to Moshe Rabbeinu, as we'll see, be'ezrat Hashem, all this very, very soon.1:11Let's read over here what the Gra writes in Tikunei Zohar. It seems like from the sources they bring over here,1:17it's in many places. He writes like this:1:21HaTorah nikret arusah. The Torah, we know, it's called arusah, as it says, Morashah. Kehilat Yaakov. Torah says, ... Yaakov, and the Gemara says,1:32Al tikrei morasha ela me'orasa. She's like a bride who's engaged to you, right?1:40And the Gemara says over there in Masechet Pesachim, Kol halomed Torah bifnei am ha'aretz, ke'ilu bo'el arusato bifanav. A person who learns Torah in front of am ha'aretz who can't understand Torah,1:45so the am ha'aretz sees it as if you're taking his bride away from him.1:55Vama adusato, deGemara adusah hi miSinai. Why is the Gemara—not the Gemara's meshalim. We come to understand the more you learn and the deeper you look into the words of Chazal,2:01you see how very particular they were in their words, and their meshalim are not random.2:06They're actually very, very thought out, and the words are very, very carefully chosen.2:12So the question is, why did Chazal call the Torah2:18arusah? Arusah, by the way, is like the word in Arabic, arus, but not exactly married,2:23but it's like, you know, you give her kiddushin, the first step of marriage,2:26but it's like what we'd call engagement, but a little bit more than engagement.2:28Why is she called arusah? He says because she's already arus from Sinai.2:33Like it says, Torah2:38tzivah lanu Moshe, morashah, al tikri morashah ela me'orasah, ... But, so then one second, if she's married to us, why is it only2:42erusin? And the answer is, beautiful, beautiful explanation:2:46she's arus because in Sinai we accepted upon ourselves the Torah,2:50but you're not married to her. The nisuin is the next step of marriage.2:53You're not married to the Torah until you actually learn the Torah itself.2:57Like it says in the pasuk,3:03Ki bTorat Adonai cheftzo, uvTorato yehegeh yomam valaylah. In the beginning, Chazal tell us3:06in Gemara Masechet Avodah Zarah, in beginning it's called Torat Hashem,3:08this is the pasuk in Tehillim,3:10and then afterwards the pasuk refers to the Torah as the person's Torah.3:17Aval lefnei miyut haTorah, lefnei Moshe ben Amram lo zachah eleha. This is all the regular Torah.3:20Every single Jew, even am haaretz, is shayach to the Torah.3:26However, that the penimiyut haTorah, which is what we call the Kabbalah,3:31the secrets of the Torah,3:34even Moshe Rabbeinu was not zocheh to it, right?3:38This is a big chiddush he's saying over here.3:43Ve'aken lo zacha lekanes l'Eretz Yisrael, and this is why he was not zocheh to enter3:48Eretz Yisrael. And this all happened as a result of Moshe breaking the luchot and hitting the3:52sela. Even though, in those places that he did those things,3:55he had a reason why he did it, right?3:58But still, that's what happened.3:59Now, if you think about that story of breaking the luchot and hitting the4:04sela, who were the people that really were the fault of Moshe doing this?4:12It was all because of4:13Erev Rav, the ones who made the egel, that made him break the luchot,4:15and then the ones who kept on challenging Moshe when he says,4:18Hey,4:21hamin ha-sela הזה נוציא לכם מים? They're the ones who kept on picking up rocks and saying,4:24No, no, no, come and dig it out of this one.4:26That made him hit the rock.4:32They're the ones who caused him breaking the luchot,4:35and they're the ones who caused him the mistake to hit the rock.4:40That's why he wasn't zocheh to enter4:43Eretz Yisrael. Entering Eretz Yisrael seems to be understood now on a higher level,4:46which is really the4:47penimiut haTorah. Now, I guarantee you, Moshe Rabbeinu knew more Kabbalah than we could ever know.4:52But obviously there's something deeper about the4:55Torah, what he's calling the penimiut haTorah, that Moshe Rabbeinu wasn't zocheh to yet.5:05He says, And this is all going to take effect,5:08all took effect in the Jewish people.5:10They're not zocheh now to learn from the5:13etz chaim, the etz chaim which is referred to over here in Gan Eden,5:17which is hinted to in the pasuk,5:20Etz chaim hi lamachazikim bah, and we're only going to be zocheh to that when we are alone in the5:23future, when Mashiach comes. As it says in the pasuk,5:26Badad, and Yaakov, that Yaakov will be alone.5:30And that's when the Jewish people will5:33do—why specifically that time in the future?5:35Because that's when the Jewish people will do teshuvah5:38and they get rid of5:40their egel hazahav, and then as a result they'll get back the original5:46luchot, which they weren't exposed to them yet.5:49Why?5:50Because right when Moshe Rabbeinu came down, he broke them,5:52so they never were exposed to those5:54luchot, but those luchot will come back to them.6:01And that's the meaning that it was6:06nit'arest by Yaakov. What I mean is because it was only given to Moshe Rabbeinu.6:12And the kiddushin was supposed to be completed through the nisuin of Bnei Yisrael,6:17and they lost it.6:18And that's perhaps another meaning of,6:23Vayinatzelu Bnei Yisrael et adyam meHar Chorev. They took off the jewelry.6:25As we know, when people get married,6:27right, they have jewelry. When you get engaged, you give a ring,6:30you give some sort of jewelry,6:31and that kind of, you know, gets you married.6:34But they had to take it off.6:35They took off that jewelry by Har Sinai.6:39Okay, that's one6:41pshat. One more piece6:42says6:46over here, says the Gra, another place.6:50This is another explanation the Gra has on6:53Raaya Mehemna, which is in, what's called, in the Zohar,6:58Parashat Pinchas, and Aderet Eliyahu,6:59his commentary on Sefer7:01Devarim. He writes an interesting thing.7:03He says,7:04just like in7:05Yetziat Mitzrayim, Moshe was kaved peh.7:07What does that mean, kaved peh?7:09You could say he used to stumble,7:11his lips were heavy,7:13he wasn't able to express himself clearly,7:16and therefore Hashem sent him Aharon7:17to be his mouth.7:19So Moshe was kind of like whispered to Aharon,7:21and Aharon would express it to everybody else.7:25Moshe would say7:27the halacha, stam, like very closed up,7:29and Aharon knew the meaning7:31and he would elaborate it.7:32Right? A lot of times, for7:34example, we have a rabbi that teaches us. Why?7:36Because the words of Tosafot are satum,7:39or the commentaries,7:39right? They write one line. What did they mean?7:42And then, or the Mishnah will say something,7:45one-liner, and you have three pages of Gemara to explain what it means,7:48right?7:50V'ken yihyeh la'atid lavo, says also in the future7:51it's going to be like that also.7:55She'achshav b'galut ein halacha b'makom echad. Now in galut,7:56we don't have a clear halacha in any place.7:59There's always a machloket.8:00Right? In every single thing, there's this opinion, that opinion. You could learn it this way, you could learn it that way.8:05We don't have it so clear.8:13And there's a lot of contradictions between the8:16Chachamim, and a lot of questions that they have on each other, or on themselves, on the Gemara, on halacha, that it's not clear to them.8:22And we already explained that the Talmidei Chachamim in each generation have the light of Moshe Rabbeinu,8:30and that's the meaning, and that's the kaved peh, that's the heavy mouth.8:34I mean, just like Moshe Rabbeinu was kaved peh, what does it mean?8:38His mouth was heavy, meaning that he wasn't able to express himself clearly.8:46So too, the halacha is not so clear also in galut by the Talmidei Chachamim who are from the spark of Moshe Rabbeinu.8:53However, just like we had Aharon back then,9:03and so too when Moshe Rabbeinu comes, he's also not going to say the halacha clearly.9:07You know why? Because people will say, Oh, it's a new Torah.9:10Has v'shalom, it's not a new Torah. It's the same Torah.9:12He said the Torah the same way it is now.9:14However, Eliyahu, who Pinchas, who was just had from Mizera Aharon,9:21he'll... Eliyahu, who is also descendant of Aharon, as we know, Eliyahu Pinchas, who is Eliyahu, right?9:28Pinchas and Eliyahu is one and the same person.9:30He's going to be the one who is going to elaborate and explain it to the Jewish people.9:37He's going to clarify it, and that's going to be new to us. Not because it's new,9:44has v'shalom, but it's going to be new for us to understand because we see it, we understand now even clearer.9:50He brings over here, on the bottom, bottom, he brings the Zohar for this.9:54I remember seeing this, ... Eliyahu, right, in the beginning,10:01right? ... yeah. Ve'eleh hadevarim. Right, that's how it begins.10:05And we know Sefer Devarim is really like the words of Moshe Rabbeinu; that's where he started speaking.10:13Ve'eleh ze otiyot Eliahu haNavi yud, right? Elihu, whatever. I'm saying, but I remember there was a remez over there about Eliyahu Hanavi and that Moshe Rabbeinu, Eliyahu10:18Hanavi, the la'atid lavo. So he brings the source of it from the Zohar. It says like this:10:58דהכי דאבינא בקדמיתא קבל פה וקבל לשון, הכי יוקים לי קודשא בריך הוא קבל פה בוראיתא בעפא וקבל לשון בוראיתא שבכתב. Moshe Rabbeinu says in the Zohar, just like I used to be originally kaved peh and kaved lashon, right, heavy mouth and heavy lips, right, so too Hashem will, says Moshe Rabbeinu about himself in the Zohar, Hashem will bring me in the future, right, and I'll be heavy in the mouth in the Torah sheba'al peh and heavy in the tongue in the Torah shebichtav. דלא יאמרו אינון דלא אשתמודעין לי, אחרא איהו. That people shouldn't say, Oh, I never heard this before. This must be something new.11:05ואליהו יהי לי לפה. Eliyahu will be my mouth. So the Gra's words are actually from the Zohar.11:08ורבינו מפרש. Now, in the Zohar it all says that Moshe Rabbeinu,11:12but the Gra explains,11:17דהיינו תלמידי חכמים בדור האחרון שהם ראשון משה. Who is that talking about? That's not going to be talking about Moshe Rabbeinu.11:20It's going to be actually the talmidei chachamim who are an extension of11:24Moshe Rabbeinu,11:28שאותי אצלם משה רבינו רבם רע, כמו שכתוב בגמרא, that by them, they won't have the halacha so clear,11:32right? As you see, it's very confusing, right? There's a lot of different opinions,11:36right? I remember the first time when I started approaching11:38halacha, you open up Mishnah Berurah, like, get lost,11:41right? Today, Baruch Hashem,11:42you understand Mishnah Berurah clarifies, but there's so many different opinions, right?11:44However, בגאולה שלמה התורה תהיה חדשה לנו. In the future geulah, the Torah will be like it's new to us,11:51שתהיה מפורשת היטב, will be very clearly explained.11:56אבל לא תהיה חדשה ממש באופן שצריך לפירוש. It doesn't mean it will be completely new.11:57It just means that we won't need the commentary.12:00We won't need another peirush upon peirush to clarify12:03it. It'll be very, very clear.12:05Baruch Adonai לעולם, amen v'amen.