Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 11, Lesson 11Sefer Even ShelemaPart 210Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0016:10Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Eben Shelema, perek yud alef, ot vav.0:03This is part, I think we're already up to part number0:06five. We keep on going more into this part because there's a lot to talk about. Today,0:09we're going to discuss something very interesting about the Aretz Rav.0:14Again, we're still in discussion of the Aretz Rav.0:17We're going to discuss two points, really.0:18Point number one is regarding the galut, the last final galut, the Aretz Rav.0:24We're going to see what we left off yesterday saying is that they're worse than the goyim.0:28The Aretz Rav is worse than the goyim.0:29We're going to see now an interesting, not twist, but a twist to what we usually thought we understood or we thought we knew.0:36We're going to see something the Gra says a little differently.0:38And the second part that we're going to discuss is also the suffering of the talmidei chachamim under the rulership of the Aretz Rav.0:47Okay, let's see first over here the Gra in Masechet0:55Berachot. Before we get to that, we know that the number four represents the four galuyot.1:00We know we're in the four exiles.1:02These four exiles were already from the beginning of the creation.1:05The Torah is min ha-mez, as the pasuk says1:09that, Veha'aretz hayetah tohu1:15vavohu vechoshech al פני תהום. Chazal make a derashah: tohu, bohu, choshech, פני תהום represents those four terminologies, represent the four galuyot.1:25Avraham Avinu in Brit Bein HaBetarim was shown the four galuyot.1:29Yaakov Avinu in the dream of the ladder was shown the four galuyot,1:33right? And it continues. It keeps on coming up again and again and again.1:36Even there's another midrash about Yitzchak when he told his son Esav,1:42... whatever was the pasuk over there, and also over there1:47it's minamez the four galuyot.1:48Basically, the four galuyot are coming up all over the place.1:51The most distinctive place where we find that's like mefurash is by Daniel, Sefer Daniel,1:58in the dreams that he used to have, where he says clearly he sees four different creatures,2:03and clearly over there the creatures represent the rulership of the animals that will rule the world before Mashiach would come.2:11Now, it's an amazing thing.2:12Look what he says over here,2:14the Gra says over here:2:21ועוד מין ד', שנישראל בעצמם שנדבקו בערב רב והיו כמוהם, כמו שכתוב ויתערבו בגויים וילמדו מעשיהם. Says the Gra in the middle of a subject, we're jumping in the2:24meran, he says, there's a fourth type, and that is there's a fourth type of Jews,2:27and those are the Jews, right, that they're really Jewish, right,2:32but because they got, they basically got attached to the Erev Rav, and they wanted to be like them.2:42And that's the meaning when it says,2:46Veyit'arevu ba-goyim, vayilmedu ma'aseihem. Veneged zeh yesh arba2:50minei nega'im se'et u-vaheret, right? And this is why we find also, there's also four types of2:56tzaraat. If you open up in the, what do you call it,3:00if you open up the Mishnah, Masechet Metzora, right,3:07I think that's what it's called3:08here, Masechet Nega'im, that's what it's called, Nega'im Metzora.3:10In the first Mishnah it says over there3:13that there are four types of3:14tzaraat. In the Torah it talks about two, and then it says about something called a3:20se'et. Se'et, Muchajat tells us, is the second one under it.3:24And there's baheret, and there3:28is—excuse me—there's se'et and baheret, and there's a3:30sapachat, which is basically a subcategory of each one of these two.3:34So he says, se'et u-vaheret, the top two, right,3:37those are3:41neged Yishmael v'Eisav. Ve-sapachat neged Erev Rav. The sapachat is corresponding to the3:45Erev Rav, and that, he says, why is it corresponding to the3:48Erev Rav? Because sapachat is like an extension.3:51Shenitdabkei Yisrael. As we said already, kashim3:54gerim l'Yisrael ke-sapachat. Chazal say that gerim are difficult to the Jewish people like3:59tzaraat, but it uses the term4:01sapachat. And we already saw that gerim doesn't mean converts4:03over here; gerim, we're talking about those4:07Erev Rav, u-min ha-revi'i. But one second, we just talked about now three types of4:10tzaraat: Yishmael, Eisav, and4:14Erev Rav. But there's four types of4:16tzaraat. Who's the fourth one?4:17It says, Midah hu neged ma shekatuv, V'hayah be'or besaro nega4:21tzaraat. And the Torah says it should be in his skin as a nega4:24tzaraat, v'hem neged arba chayot shel Daniel,4:26which corresponds to the fourth animal that Daniel saw.4:29That fourth animal, we know,4:32v'arbaa kasha neged kulam. The fourth one is the worst out of all of them.4:35The fourth animal was the wildest animal.4:37It was an animal that was destroying.4:39We know it represents also Edom.4:41V'chen arbaa minei behemot4:42me'ot. We also find that there's four types of non-kosher animals4:45that the Torah speaks about, even though there's tons and tons of non-kosher animals,4:48but the Torah singles out four,4:53right? And gimel maaleh geirah. There are three of them that are4:56maaleh geirah, right? They are able to chew their cud.4:59I mean, there's only one that's not, and that's the5:05chazir, right? V'chen arbaa galuyot, right? And also the5:06arbaa galuyot, gimel galuyot avonam, three,5:08and Chazal tell us, why is that so?5:10Why how did the four animals compare to the four5:14galuyot? It says, in the first three, we know what the aveirot of the Jewish people were,5:19right?5:19Just like the non-kosher animals, on the outside you could see the camel,5:23the shafan, right?5:25You could see on the outside why they're not kosher,5:27because what?5:30Huh?5:31Because their feet don't have the simanim,5:35even though they're5:37maaleh geirah. But the fourth one, which is the pig, is the exact opposite.5:40On the outside he has the kosher siman,5:42but on the inside the pig doesn't have the kosher siman.5:45That means the aveirah is on the inside,5:47the evil is on the inside,5:48the tumah is on the inside.5:50So Chazal tell us also, why do these four animals correspond to four5:54galuyot? Because the sin of the Jewish people was on the inside in the fourth5:58galut. The first one was5:59avodah zarah, גילוי עריות, שפיכות דמים. That was public, that was outside.6:02Everybody knew what the aveirah was.6:03You got to fix it.6:04The fourth one was sinat chinam, was on the inside.6:06I can say, I love you, I come to your party6:08and I give you a kiss and I give you an envelope,6:10but there's such a sinah in that envelope,6:13and I'm giving you...6:15He stole everybody's money to make this party,6:17right?6:17That's sinat chinam. That's the fourth6:19galut. That's the pig.6:20That's the galut of Edom.6:22And that's what we said, the four types of Jewish people,6:24the four types of people that attach to us.6:31V'chen neged arbaa reshaaim, avodah zarah, גילוי עריות, שפיכות דמים, v'sinat chinam neged kulam. And also, arba klipei dechita. We said also this for layers of the shell on the wheat.6:45Motz v'teben v'gimel eider rav, de'adbik bahu, subin mursan. Beit Hillel kol echad mishtein, v'Rabbi Yehu se'or v'chametz, v'nohu mitchalah, rak dechametz achar kach. And also, we have the motz, the teven, and we said the subin,6:51and now we're discovering the fourth one.6:53What's that fourth one?6:54That's the chametz in the dough,6:57and that fourth one is the Jewish people that attach themselves to the7:03eider rav, and that's very, very difficult.7:11V'chen arba yetzarim te'avanim, ka'asani, chemda, v'letzani, v'kasher keneged kulam. There's also four types of min yetzer hara, four categories.7:14What are they?7:15Ta'avani, the one who runs after7:18ta'avot, right?7:18That's the yetzer hara, eating and, you know, other ta'avot and seeing and everything else.7:23Ka'asani, the guy who's always angry and making fights,7:26right?7:27Chemda, the guy who's always desiring.7:30He can be the nicest guy,7:31but he's always—he wants more, what's called monetary things.7:35That is, that's more mamon.7:37And letzani is the guy who makes fun of everything.7:40That's the worst out of all of them.7:42V'zeh kasher keneged kulam, and that's not the7:45eider rav, that's the Jewish people that learn from the7:47eider rav. And now we see something, like we just said,7:49that's something very interesting that he's mentioning now,7:51is that besides the7:52eider rav, we see the people that learn from the7:54eider rav that act like the7:56eider rav, those are even worse than anybody else.7:58Okay.8:00Now we're going to learn about the last thing over here in this section, if we can finish it today,8:05and that is the suffering of the Moshe Rabbeinu, because Moshe Rabbeinu did really suffer because8:11of the death of Rav, and how that is going to play out before Mashiach by the8:18Talmidei Chachamim of the generation, we're also going to suffer. So let's see. It says like this:8:25Just like we know that the sun rays, right, or the light of the sun, it reflects off the moon and the stars.8:37In every generation, there's one person where the light of Moshe Rabbeinu shines on him, right? One person.8:48And he, in turn, gives his reflection back to all the8:59Talmidei Chachamim. And all the chiddushim Torah that we have in this world is because of the light that comes from Moshe Rabbeinu.9:05As it says that also Moshe, we know that Moshe gave his light over to Yehoshua, right? And Yehoshua eventually.9:13So it's interesting. So now you can understand when it says in the Gemara, it says,9:26The Zekeinim b'oto dor, mah hayu omrim? Pnei Moshe k'pnei chama, u'pnei Yehoshua levanah. That's not a joke over here. Moshe, just like the sun gives light to the moon, and also to all the stars.9:32The other stars are the Talmidei Chachamim of that generation, but the main light comes from the sun to the moon,9:37and that is the Moshe Rabbeinu is that sun, who's always giving because he got the Torah.9:43And there's one person in each generation who's a gadol hador. I don't know if we know who it is,9:47not necessarily what the newspapers make famous, right? But there's that gadol hador, and from his zechut,9:53right, all of us get that chiddushim, all the other9:56Talmidei Chachamim. Now, ve'oro mitzayem et talmidei chachamim. At the same time, being that he's the one who gives the or,10:02again, all this is from different places from the Gra; most of it comes from the Zohar,10:06okay? He says, And the light,10:13ve'oro mitzayem et talmidei chachamim, shemebuzim begalutah b'tra'a, v'nidafim min ha'ayin ra. And he suffers with the talmidei chachamim also, because he's the one who's mashpia to them.10:19When talmidei chachamim suffer, he also suffers. Why are they suffering?10:22Especially in the last galut, when they're being chased by the10:27erev rav. Kemo shekatuv, v'chochmat sofrim tisrach, v'erechetimasu, yima'asu, v'sar mera mishtolel. The wisdom of the—what does it say in Sotah at the end of days, before Mashiach comes?10:36The wisdom of the scribes, of the talmidei chachamim, will be spoiled, right?10:40Okay, rabotai, chidush Torah. Okay, tell us stories, Rabbi.10:44I'll never forget that time when we had people that weren't part of our10:48shul, it was Simchat Torah, and a lot of people came, right? I came to make an announcement,10:52right? I just wanted to make a small announcement about the ladies' guys who were trying to start,10:57and then some ladies were sitting around—now, we're not from11:00a shul, we don't even have ladies in the11:01shul, okay? At least five of the guys are in our11:04shul—and said, so this lady got everybody quiet,11:07Shh, the rabbi's going to speak.11:09Chabod, Rabbi, tell us a story.11:12No, no, what was the story? Tell us a joke.11:14That's what it was. Tell us a joke.11:15You know, the attitude, again, she said it very innocently,11:18but the attitude of, like, what became the speech is what?11:24Stories and jokes.11:25If you dare say a chidush about Torah, so, right,11:28people—chochmat sofrim tisrach, yirei chet. People stay away from sins.11:33Yima'asu. What do you have to be so machmir for?11:37V'sar mera mishtolel, right? And the guy who goes away from evil, he's considered like a weird person.11:44וזהו שכתוב, והוא מחולל מפשעינו. And that's the meaning when it says that he is inflicted from our sins.11:50Who is that? Those are the talmidei chachamim. Our sins, he gets inflicted on,11:53because when he tries to keep mitzvot, we look down on him.11:59וכל ענין מדבר הכובד תלמידי חכמים בגלות הזה. That whole thing is talking about that whole suffering12:03in perek in Yeshayahu, it's talking about the talmidei chachamim in this last galut.12:05Another place he says,12:08וזהו מדה כנגד מדה שקיבל את עֵרב רב. So why does this happen to Moshe Rabbeinu?12:11It's a midah keneged midah, because he's the one who brought the Erev12:16Rav, והם עשו את העגל, and they're the ones who ended up making the12:19egel. ועל ידי זה נשתברו הלוחות. Because of that, the luchot broke,12:24שזה גרם שכחת התורה וכל הגלויות. That's what caused the breaking of the12:29luchot, what caused the forgetting of the Torah, and as a result of that, we have all the12:32galuyot. So kind of like midah keneged midah, so Moshe Rabbeinu kind of has to also suffer throughout12:41those generations. וזהו שכתוב, לך רד. We know the famous12:45Midrash of Chazal, Hashem tells Moshe Rabbeinu, Go down, go down ממדרגתך, מן המז ירידה והשפלה. The pasuk is clearly hinting to going down,12:57ובהסיר אותיות ראש עין, שהוא ראשי תיבות של עֵרב רב, נשאר המניין רד. Right?12:58We take out the word from Erev12:59Rav, ראש עין, what do you have left?13:04204, gematria of 204, which is13:09רד, right? So that's the13:11לך רד, go down because of the Erev13:17Rav. וכל דור שאין בו הרעת משה בן עמרם, אינו נכלל בחשבון נון דורות. There's a famous statement from the Zohar,13:20right?13:21The Zohar says that there are 50 times,13:26I think the Zohar or the13:28Gra that says there are 50 יציאות, 50 times13:31it says...13:33Yetziat Mitzrayim, listening,13:35says fifty times13:37yetziat Mitzrayim in the Torah, and represents also the13:40fifty shaarei binah, fifty levels of13:42shaarei binah, and the famous fifty generations of the world.13:46However, any generation that doesn't have a Aharat Moshe Rabbeinu13:48is not counted as part of the13:52fifty. Sometimes there are13:54generations—we just said before,13:55every generation.13:56He says sometimes no.13:57Sometimes Moshe Rabbeinu doesn't find anybody he could come to,14:00he could be mitgaleh with him.14:05ולכן יציאת הגלות תלויה בלימוד הקבלה שהוא תורת משה בן עליו השלום. That's why we need to learn Torah14:06and not only Torah;14:07we also need to learn Kabbalah,14:08because, says the Zohar,14:10because that's the Torah of Moshe Rabbeinu,14:12and Moshe Rabbeinu is waiting for that person14:14to be mitgaleh in him.14:16And like all the Gedolim say,14:18that the guy is learning just Kabbalah14:20and he doesn't know the14:22Gemara and doesn't know all of the things,14:24ma ze shaveh, right?14:25Doesn't understand all the things,14:27the other ones,14:27not Torat Moshe Rabbeinu.14:29Now, another place from the Zohar,14:31from the14:38Gra, ורשב"י וכל העומדים אצלו זכו לדבר מניצוץ ממשה גופו. We know in the Zohar14:40there's a section called14:41Raya14:42Mehemna, and a lot of times he'll say14:43Raya14:44Mehemna. Raya Mehemna is an Aramaic translation14:46of the word14:48ro'eh ne'eman. Ro'eh ne'eman means a faithful shepherd,14:50that was Moshe Rabbeinu,14:51because he shepherded,14:53right,14:53in last week's14:54parashah, Pinchas, we just read.14:55What does it say?15:02יפקוד ה' אלוקי הרוחות איש על העדה, ולא תהיה כצאן אשר אין להם רועה. What does it mean?15:06That means there was a ro'eh till now.15:07So Moshe is called the15:09ro'eh; he led the Jewish people.15:10So he says over here15:13that Rashbi,15:15who mentions Raya Mehemna a lot,15:16he was zocheh to actually15:17speak directly with15:24the15:27ניצוץ משה רבינו, ששלדו תיקוני רעיא מהימנא, קרעיא מהימנא שייך לתיקונים. גם עניין מגיד שבא לאדם הוא נשמתו בעצמו, also15:27the15:29Maggid. Right, it comes to a person.15:30We know that15:31the Beit Yosef,15:32Rabbi Yosef,15:32had a special angel15:34that was called the Magid15:35that spoke to him.15:36The Midim of the Ramchal said15:38that Ramchal used to speak15:39also with a special angel,15:41right?15:42That is the neshama itself.15:47But15:48it has a common clothing.15:49It comes in the clothing15:50of the mitzvot that a person does,15:51and it speaks to his own neshama.15:54Okay?15:55One last thing.16:00I think, oh, 16 minutes. Right, stop here. Tomorrow we'll finish.16:05We're going to do more, be'ezrat Hashem. We'll finish it up tomorrow. Baruch Adonai l'olam, amen v'amen.