Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 10, Lesson 33Sefer Even ShelemaPart 197Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:006:58Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:04Even shelema, perek yud, ot lamed alef. It says over here, HaKadosh Baruch Hu bara et ha'adam lehativo ba'achrito. The purpose of creating a person, as the Mesilat Yesharim brings it right also in the beginning of the book,0:14the goal of it all is that Hashem created the person to really, that eventually his end to give him good.0:23Ve'af im ha'adam chata. Well, we know about, we're going to read about Gehinnom and punishment, so you might get the wrong idea.0:28No, even for a person's sins, HaKadosh Baruch Hu machaziro lizeh olam pa'amayim v'shalosh ad sheyitaken ma she'ivet. A person brings it back, Hashem brings it back, give you another chance.0:36Go ahead, I'm going to give you another chance. You're going to do it. You're going to be able to do it.0:39You're going to fix what you messed up.0:43Ve'noten oto b'Gehinnom ad sheyitztaken v'ya'avor mimenu hazehama. And then there's certain things that you picked up along the way, so that is why Gehinnom is there.0:48Gehinnom is there to clean them up.0:50If you guys were asking this past week about, you know, Gehinnom, when Kaf HaKela, we're talking about0:56Kaf HaKela, I don't know, we got into Kaf HaKela, but we were saying, what, you know, these guys, what's Kaf HaKela, what's1:04Gehinnom? We said, no, you're zocheh to go to1:07Gehinnom. It's a zechut. There are some people with Kaf HaKela for a long time, and then they have the zechut,1:10they enter Gehinnom just to clean them1:13up. Now, what's the difference now between gilgul, what we know as gilgul, which is bringing back, and1:22Gehinnom? Hachiluk hu, ki mi shehaya tov me'techilah, a person was good from the beginning,1:26gufo zocheh gam ken la'olam haba, his body is also zocheh to get1:33olam haba. Aval mi shelo tiken me'techilah, however, a person who didn't do what he was supposed to do in the original bodies,1:39hagufim harishonim kalim vene'evadim. So those bodies shouldn't be here.1:42They're not zocheh to come up, so they are gone. They get gone.1:46But the person himself, who is the neshama, has a chance to come back in a different body.1:53Umi she'eino metaken pa'am revi'it, a person who doesn't even fix even the fourth time,1:56az avdat tikvato vrachamana litzlan, then there's no hope,1:58chas v'shalom. So we were learning in the shul, believe it or not, we were learning2:03Shaar HaGilgulim. Sounds like not a common book that people learn in2:05shuls, but our shul is not a common shul, baruch Hashem.2:08We do a lot of interesting things over here.2:10There was one point where we did learn Shaar HaGilgulim for a certain point of time,2:14and everybody's heard this concept:2:15you only come back in gilgul three times.2:17Yet we learn in Shaar HaGilgulim that Arizal brings down2:21that you could come back in a gilgul many, many, many times over until you fix.2:27Right, so, but he does bring down this concept of three or four times.2:30So we're going to explain it today, be'ezrat Hashem,2:32and we're going to fit it all together,2:34that there's no contradiction between what the Gra says over here2:36and what the Sha'ar HaGilgulim also brings down.2:39So let's start first with the source of these words.2:43That means, where does it come from that there's such a thing as Gehinnam,2:47and where does the Gra say that, and regarding gilgul?2:51So let's see in the sources over here.2:54They're bringing it from Mishlei, perek yud-daled, pasuk aleph.2:58Pasuk says, which we have quoted this week also in Parashat3:01Korach, the Midrash quotes this3:09pasuk: חַכְמוֹת נָשִׁים בָּנְתָה בֵיתָהּ, וְאִוֶּלֶת בְּיָדֶיהָ תֶהֶרְסֶנּוּ. The wisdom of women has built her house,3:13and the wickedness with her hands she destroys it.3:18And the Midrash, connecting to last week's parashah, Parashat3:22Korach, quoted this pasuk comparing the wife of On ben Pelet to the wife of3:27Korach. Wife of On ben Pelet saved his life,3:30bantah beitah, and the wife of Korach, who instigated him to go into the fight,3:34she destroyed her house.3:36Now let's see how the Gra explains it.3:39He says, the Gra—let's first give you another3:41pasuk. Says the3:46Gra, כמו שנאמר: עצתי תקום, וכל חפצי אעשה. It says Hashem, My advice will be upkept,3:52and all what I want, I will do.3:57What do you mean? I'm asking a question.4:01What kind of statement is Yeshayahu Hanavi saying in the name of Hashem?4:07If Hashem says something, who's going to be able to go against it?4:13וְלוּ כֻלָּם כְּאַיִן נֶגְדּוֹ, וּמֵאֶפֶס וָתֹהוּ נֶחְשְׁבוּ לוֹ. Everybody is compared to Hashem is nothing.4:19מי אמר לו, מה פעלת זאת? Who's going to tell Him, Hey, why'd you do this?4:21Hashem has to say, Whatever I want, I'll do.4:24Is there a question about that?4:27וְעַנְיָן. What it means, of4:32yeshar רצונו של הקדוש ברוך הוא להטיב לברואיו ולתת בהם... Hashem wants to really help the person.4:36But it's an interesting thing.4:39Hashem could have created4:40a Gan Eden and take a person, just put him4:41in Gan Eden and just give him straight reward.4:44But that doesn't work that way,4:46as the Mesilat Yesharim explains, because the nature of a person4:49is—that Hashem created such a nature,4:51true—but the nature of a person is that4:53you got to feel like you earned it.4:55And to just get something for free that you didn't earn,4:58it doesn't feel good.4:59Even though a lot of people say,5:00yeah, a lot of lazy people might prefer it,5:02but there's nothing like accomplishing,5:06like earning something,5:08like, you know, being able to overcome a challenge.5:11That's how we get drawn to Gemara,5:14because Gemara is challenging.5:15It challenges us,5:16that we think a certain way,5:18and then all of a sudden, boom,5:19the Gemara throws us something,5:20you have to start thinking.5:21And then just when you think you understood it,5:23we challenge you to go a little bit deeper.5:25And it's the same thing in sports.5:27It's the same thing in business, right?5:29If a person is just at the top of the world,5:31it gets a little boring after a while.5:33He's always looking for that challenge.5:35That's the nature of a person.5:36So to just give a person a reward5:38without a challenge5:39is not really so rewarding in itself.5:42The reward is actually the challenge itself.5:44Even those basketball players that make millions of dollars,5:47I guarantee if you go5:49take any of those5:50guys—and these guys are very competitive,5:51very, very5:53competitive—they want to be the best.5:54They want to be the top players.5:55You go to one of those top players5:57and tell them, listen,5:57you're getting right now four million dollars a year.6:00It's a lot of money,6:00four million dollars a year, right?6:02I will give you forty million dollars a year,6:04don't play.6:05I don't think they'll take it.6:08Every year I'll give you forty million6:10dollars and just retire.6:11How much? From now till 120,6:12how much you're gonna live,6:13I'm gonna give you.6:14They will not.6:15But you can't touch a basketball again.6:17They will not.6:18They want to go.6:19They enjoy.6:21They love the competition.6:22What do you mean?6:23You lost.6:24Take a guy like LeBron James.6:25Sorry to quote him,6:27but, you know, but take a guy who's considered6:28like one of the top basketball players,6:30yet he has barely won a championship,6:32right?6:33He gave up a lot of6:34money to go at one point to another team6:36so he could win a championship,6:38right?6:38Because it was,6:40you know, listen,6:40there's a competition.6:42You got to,6:42you got to, right?6:43It's not just the money.6:44It's not just that.6:45So that's how we are as humans,6:48every human being.6:49So that's why Hashem6:50wanted to give that to a human being.6:52He wanted to give him the reward,6:53but the reward has to be earned.6:55So in order to be earned,6:56it could only be earned.