Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 10, Lesson 3Sefer Even ShelemaPart 168Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:53Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Even shelema, perek yud, ot alef, part0:04three. The reason why it's part three is because there's so much contained, like we said from the beginning, in this small little paragraph.0:11So we discussed already that the wealth of a person has, it comes from the leaves.0:17Like we said, the bank accounts. I think that Mashal went very, very well with bank accounts, with checking accounts and saving accounts.0:23It's a very good way to understand what the Gra has been saying.0:26The second part of this piece, it says like this. We'll repeat it again.0:31Ve'ein tzaddik ochel peirot ba'olam hazeh, ela im ken yesh tzaddikim0:34harbeh ba'dor. A tzaddik who does eat fruits in this world, he'll only do it if there's a lot of tzaddikim in the generation as well.0:45So over here, they take us, before we go to the words of the Gra himself, they take us to a note on the bottom,0:52a pointer from the author of the Even Shelema. He writes,0:57עיין באור לתיקוני זוהר. Look in the explanation of the Gra on Tikunei Zohar,1:03daf kuf mem-chet, amud bet, kemach, שבזמן הגלות, in time of galut,1:16אין התורה אור, אין נעשים ניסים ואין עונשים הרשעים כמו שהיה בזמן הבית בימי משה. Wow. When the times when we had a Beit HaMikdash, when the times when Moshe Rabbeinu was around,1:25yeah, the world ran differently. And when the Torah talks about punishments and tzaddikim1:32rewarded and resha'im getting punished, there used to get it, yeah.1:37You would actually see miracles, things beyond the laws of nature, clearly, and Hashem governed it that way.1:44But now the Beit HaMikdash is destroyed, it's not the same.1:49והכל תלוי ביד המזל, ואין זכות ואין חוב אלא לעולם הבא. And everything is really on the mazal.1:51And therefore, what happens to all the good and the bad deeds, it's all1:56in olam haba. Oh wait, there's a place for, but it's not here in this world anymore.1:59Once upon a time, he says, when the Beit HaMikdash was around, everything was done over here.2:03And then he brings also from Daf צד ח' עמוד א' in Tikkunei Zohar,2:09דעולם נידון אחר רובו, אבל עכשיו אין זכות מועיל. The world is judged after the majority. Rabotai, majority,2:14the majority of the world, we have to be together with them.2:17And therefore, the zechut doesn't really help.2:21What do I mean? It doesn't help so much for olam hazeh.2:27So you see from here that you can be a big tzaddik and you have a tremendous2:31zechut. Why is it not coming? Why are we not getting?2:34And the answer is because really the reshaim don't let it.2:38So it's not to say, chas v'shalom, that there's no zechuyot. Of course you have reward. I want to be very clear.2:43Of course you have reward, and sometimes it'll overflow to this world.2:47But the reshaim prevent a lot of it from coming down.2:51The reshaim can prevent a lot of it from coming down.2:53Let's see now the words of the2:59Gra. He writes over here on the pasuk in3:03Yeshaya. The pasuk says,3:05Im ru tzaddik ki tov, ki peri ma'alaleihem yochelu. Say the tzaddik is good because the fruits of their work they eat.3:15Shibbechu et ha-tzadik, kemo yit'ameru kopo ale aven. The pasuk is praising tzaddik, just like we find that the wicked are also, you know, they speak up.3:24What is that talking about? Look in the bottom.3:26He quotes Rashi on the pasuk in parashat3:32Ki Tavo. It says,3:33Et Hashem he'emarta hayom. You promised Hashem.3:35He'emarta. Rashi says,3:37Ein lahem eid muchach ba-mikra. What's the word3:39he'emarta? If you can tell me the word he'emarta means to say,3:43that's amar. What's3:45he'emarta? So Rashi says there is no other word in the pasuk that can compare to the word3:52he'emarta. V'li nireh shehu lashon hafrashah v'havdalah. According to Rashi, he understands the word he'emarta to mean as separation.4:00U'matzati lahem eid, v'hu lashon tefe'el, kemo yit'ameru kol po'alei aven. He says, I found another support for myself where it says in the pasuk,4:05Yit'ameru kol po'alei aven. So what's yit'ameru? They speak up. It doesn't make sense.4:08It just says yomru. What's4:10yit'ameru? Yit'ameru means separate.4:14Right, the ba'alei aven, the wicked people, are separated.4:17Ad kan leshon Rashi. This is what Rashi says.4:19On comes the Gra and says4:22on the pasuk,4:30Imru tzaddik ki tov, right? דהיינו שבחו את הצדיק כי טוב, שהוא טוב לבריות, ואז פרי מעלליהם יאכלו. So to imru tzaddik ki tov means praise,4:34right?4:34Because when you separate4:37something—when you praise something, you're separating him.4:40Imagine somebody getting up and saying, singling out,4:42I would like to give a praise to, you know, the people that made this evening possible,4:48right?4:48So you're singling them out.4:51That's4:53a lashon hafrashah. He says,4:54Imru tzaddik ki tov, back to4:55upstairs, when it says,4:59Imru tzaddik ki tov, ki peri ma'alaleihem, היינו שהצדיקים, praise them.5:02Why? Because they're good;5:03they're good to other people.5:06Ki peri ma'alaleihem, היינו שכר קיים לעולם הבא, the fruits of their work,5:12which is the ken kayemet l'olam haba. But the fruits that usually people eat in this world,5:15as the Mishnah says in5:22Peah, אין לו דמשתא דם אוכל פירותיהם בעולם הזה, וקרן קיימת לו לעולם הבא, right?5:23It says,5:24אימתי, when do you eat from those peirot, though?5:28בזמן שיש בדור הרבה צדיקים. Only when there's a lot of tzaddikim in the generation.5:33אבל אם אין לו אלא צדיק אחד, גם פירותיו אין לך לעולם הזה. But if you're the only5:35tzaddik, you don't even get the fruits of your labor in this world.5:39וזה שכתוב, ki peri ma'alaleihem, לשון רבים, that's what it says,5:40the fruits of their5:42ma'alaleihem, in plural.5:44Only when there's a lot of5:46tzaddikim, then the tzaddikim are able to be zocheh to eat.5:48But if there is no, you won't be able to get it.5:51It will stay for you in olam haba. Next,5:56Kol dodi dofek, another proof,5:57another—the same idea from another place in the6:01Gra, from6:02a pasuk in Shir HaShirim. Famous6:06pasuk, Kol dodi dofek. The lady in Shir HaShirim says,6:09I hear the sound of my beloved knocking,6:13and he's saying,6:14Pitchi li, open for me,6:16achoti, my sister,6:18rayati, my friend,6:20yonati, my dove,6:22tamati, my pure,6:24sheroshi nimtal, my head is soaking with dew,6:28kevutzotai kresisei layla,6:30the ends of my hair, which is my6:33peot, are soaking with the rain of the night.6:36What is—now we know that, of6:38course, Shir HaShirim is not to be taken6:41literal; it's6:42all mashalim. But in any case,6:44the Gra gives his own6:45peirush. He says,6:49explains the6:50Gra, there's two types of rewards.6:52There's reward for Torah6:54and there's reward for doing mitzvot.6:56Schar Torah hu tal. The reward of Torah is the dew,6:58like it says,7:01Ki tal orot tallecha. Hashem, your dew is the tal.7:03As we know,7:04Chazal tell us by Matan Torah,7:06when Bnei Yisrael died7:07from hearing Hashem saying,7:11Anochi Hashem Elokecha,7:12He put them tal7:14shel techiyat hameitim, brought them back to life.7:15It's the tal of Torah that brought them back to life.7:20The mitzvot, hem k'mo geshem. But the mitzvot,7:21each7:23mitzvah has a separate—lachen domin letipot hageshem. That's why they compare to7:25the drops of rain. As we know,7:26rain7:28has—each one drops,7:30right? You see, like when you look, you know, is it raining?7:32You put the lights on the car,7:33you see one at a time,7:35right? It just hits you at the same time.7:37Okay, so he says,7:41Now we know by Torah7:43u'mitzvot, mishtazez in7:44peha masechet Peah,7:46that you eat the keren in7:48Olam Haba and peiroteihem in Olam Hazeh.7:52Ach im rov olam einam re'uyim. However,7:52says the7:53Gra, if the majority of the world is not deserving,7:55ein noten Hashem olam hazeh,7:56af latzaddikim shebahem, kedua. The Hashem doesn't even.8:00Give the people who deserve it. The world doesn't deserve it. They don't even get it.8:06And Hashem will give the Jewish people, though, in Olam Haba, even the fruits.8:11And now you can understand the pasuk. Open for me. What does it mean, open for me?8:15Chazal tells a famous word, Pitchi li petach shel... Right?8:19When we know that Shir HaShirim, the man in Shir HaShirim is referring to Hashem, and the lady is referring to the Jewish people.8:25Hashem is on the Jewish people. Open for me. Open what for me? What door?8:28As we know, pitchu li petach ke-pitcho shel machat,8:33right? Do teshuvah, which Chazal tells us, do a little bit of8:38teshuvah, v'ochala bo l'Eretz Yisrael, and I could come and bring you to8:42Eretz Yisrael. Why? Sheloshim matal b'schar Torah. My head is soaking of tal. I have a lot of reward for you.8:45One type of reward is tal, the dew, which is in the Torah that you learn.8:49Give v'sotai, which is what? The ends of my hair are soaking with geshem, with8:55rain. The rain is what? Olam hazeh,8:59the fund of mitzvot, ha'ayin sachar ha-mitzvot. I can't give you until you come back.9:04When Hashem brings us back, and now you have a lot of tzaddikim in9:07Eretz Yisrael, that's when you get the reward of even Olam hazeh.9:12Okay. Now one last thing he brings over here on this point9:15from the Gra on the Masechet Baba Kama. It says over there,9:25When a person damages, right,9:28let's say you damage somebody's property, whether it's on purpose or by accident,9:32you have to pay. And what do you have to pay with? Let's say all you have is real estate.9:36Now in real estate, there's different levels, right?9:40There's, we all know, real estate could be very high real estate or very low real estate.9:44And even though it's the same value, but it's going to go up.9:48Let's say you have in some sort of city in the middle of the country.9:53Right? That type of real estate, let's say, is worth9:57$200,000. And you have real estate that's in New York that's worth10:01$200,000. You have a small little apartment in Brooklyn.10:02But you know that the real estate in Brooklyn, five years, that $200,000 will be10:09$700,000, where the real estate over there will go up to maybe10:14to $220,000. Right? So which one do you—10:18which one, how do you pay? Says the Gemara, with metav aretz, with the best real estate. And right now it's worth $200,000. We take the one in Brooklyn to pay for10:25your— okay. So says the Gra, that's halacha. Now the Gra comes in and brings out10:29a derash. Gemara says, Masechet10:32Hagigah, right, if a person is not10:41zoche, then— excuse me, a person who is zoche, notel chelek chavero b'Gan Eden. You get not only10:43your share in Gan Eden, you also get the share of another person in10:55Gan Eden. Right? And everybody knows that there's a damage over here that's happening in Shamayim,10:59because now people's rewards are being messed up and shifted to other people,11:05right? And who suffers because of that?11:07Ends up the tzaddikim get suffering from that.11:09So he says,11:17לכן צדיקים לשלם הנזק לצדיקים במיטב, אפשר שסידם זיבורית זהו עולם הזה, נותן במיטב העולם הבא. Even when you lose, which means—look, it's an amazing thing what he's saying over11:21here—when the resha'im cause that the tzaddikim don't get the reward in this olam hazeh11:25because the world is not deserving for Hashem to give the reward of good deeds in olam hazeh,11:32what happens? Then they have to pay11:36b'meitav haaretz. Where does Hashem give them the reward?11:39B'meitav haaretz, in the best of the land, which is olam haba. That's where the reward comes from.11:44One last thing on this point, over here he brings down on the bottom,11:49the Gra writes on the pasuk in11:55Mishlei, וצפון לצדיק חיל חוטא, שהצדיק נוטל שכרו מבתל מזוות עשה. Anybody who's mevatel mitzvat aseh,11:58Hashem gave the opportunity for somebody to do a mitzvah, and he didn't do it.12:02The sechar is waiting. Hashem is waiting to give that sechar to the guy who's going to do it,12:05but he's mevatel it. Who takes it? The tzaddik gets to take it.12:08And the pasuk says,12:15Ugmul yedei adam yashiv lo. The way a person does, what a person does basically,12:19the actions a person takes, Hashem gives it back to him.12:22Ketav Rabbeinu, the Gra writes,12:24Hashem mochiach lo, v'lo shomea lo. If you ever try to correct somebody who's a rasha, who's doing any12:28aveirot, he doesn't listen to you, noten sechar mitzvotav. You get the reward of his mitzvot.12:33All right? As it says in the Gemara,12:37Masechet Hagigah, zachah notel cheleko, v'chavero b'gan Eden. That's the same idea that we're saying over here,12:40right? The same—the resha'im prevent us, and they don't give us. Don't worry,12:43it doesn't go away. You'll get it on laba, and much more. And this is still on part four to this. Hashem will do it tomorrow.