Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 10, Lesson 28Sefer Even ShelemaPart 192Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:13Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:05אבן שלמה, פרק י' אות כה. Says0:12over here, the אבן שלמה, מי שמת קודם שלוש עשרה שנה על פי משפט בית דין של מעלה על עוון אבותיו. A person who dies before the age of0:17thirteen, why would he die before the age of0:20thirteen? Because in beit din shel מעלה, they said0:22he deserves to die because of0:28a sin of his father.0:29Now, why would a sin of a person's father be0:33מחייב him? As we'll soon see that there's a0:38pasuk, right? פוקד עוון אבות על בנים, and Chazal tell us in many places also0:41that there are certain aveirot that cause death to a person's children.0:46So that's what he's saying over here.0:47A person who dies before thirteen years old,0:50based on the judgment in beit din in the heavenly court,0:54it's on a person because of his father's sins.1:00Anything from the age of twenty and above,1:03that's his own responsibility.1:09אבל מי שמת משלוש עשרה עד עשרים, as in Obaronshin shel מעלה, but a person who dies in the in-between time, between thirteen and1:13twenty, in that period of1:16time, then he's not1:19חייב. Over there, he's not subject to1:22punishment because of1:25bedin shel ma'alah. Al ze ne'emar, on him it says,1:29יש נספה בלא משפט. Now, some people who are taken really without judgment,1:33af al פי מקום מקום, but yet everything is still1:36b'tzedek, everything is still righteous.1:37Don't think, chas v'shalom, there's any mistakes over there.1:40We'll see this concept actually right now1:44before we come back to the words of the1:46Gra. Let's just see what does it mean,1:49אין עונשין של מעלה. Look on the bottom over here.1:51The Gemara, the famous Gemara Masechet Shabbat says,1:54Hashem wanted to get rid of the Jewish people,1:56and he went over to the Avot.1:59He went to Avraham. He says,2:00Your kids sinned. I want to get rid of them.2:02So Avraham says,2:05Okay, ימחו על קדושת שמך, get rid of them.2:06He went over to Yaakov. He says,2:08Your kids sinned. I want to destroy them.2:13He says, Okay, ימחו על קדושת שמך. So Hashem says, You know what?2:14The only person I have left to go and go to is2:19Yitzchak Avinu. He goes to Yitzchak Avinu. Yitzchak Avinu defends the Jewish people.2:21Part of his defense of trying to defend the Jewish people,2:24he tells Hashem like this:2:28כמה שנותיו של אדם? How old2:30does a person live?2:35It says in the pasuk, ימי שנותינו בהם שבעים שנה. So Yitzchak Avinu tells him,2:36Take away twenty years anyway you don't punish on them.2:39And Rashi writes over there,2:41as we find in this week's2:44parashah that we just read in Parashat2:48Shelach, Hashem punished them to die2:50on the midbar from the age of twenty and above.2:52He punished the people that are younger than2:55twenty. So that's where we find this concept,2:58that a person from the age of twenty and above,3:02that's when bedin shel מעלה punishes, and also says in the3:06Yerushalmi, Masechet Bikurim, perek bet, halachah aleph, צא מהם עשרים שנה שאין בית דין של מעלה עונשין וכורתין. Twenty years of a person's3:11life, in the beginning, the first twenty years of a person's3:13life, bedin doesn't give him punishment of karet or anything else.3:19וכן הוא במדרש רבה, in Parashat Korach, and Rashi brings it down3:21also in this week's3:25parashah, אין בית דין של מעלה מענישים עד כ' שנה. And the Rambam also brings it down,3:28and also the Zohar.3:30Good? Now.3:34Let's come back3:36to see the source of the Gra.3:39So basically we have3:41three categories. Category number one are people who die3:46before, I mean after the age of 20.3:47That's category number3:49one. That's the people who are, and if they die,3:52or, you know, that's a punishment that they deserve on their own.3:55Gilgulim, not, I don't know, I can't get into that right now.4:00Good? But mutar, just pashut pshat. A person after the age of 20 is responsible for his own thing,4:04and beit din shel maalah punishes from the age of 20 and4:07above. If a person dies under the age of 13,4:10and the chayav mitzvot at all, how can they die?4:11And the answer is because of their punishment because of the father's4:16avonot, right? And we mentioned that already. And then between 13 to 20,4:19where they're responsible for their own4:21avonot, but yet beit din shel maalah doesn't punish them,4:24that's called yesh neshpei belo mishpat.4:26But we said, chas v'shalom to think that it's not4:29b'mishpat. Of course it's b'mishpat, but it's not the mishpat that we normally understand.4:32Let's see where this comes from.4:34We'll start with the words of the Zohar into Tikkunei Zohar,4:37parashat Pikudei. It says,4:42Mitlesa shnin ad esrim, kulhu itmesru al yeda d'ruha achara, dikrei this name. I can't say it over here.4:44We're not allowed to say malachim's names that are not common,4:48so I'm not going to say it.4:50So the Zohar says from 13 until the age of 20,4:53everybody is given over to4:55the power of this ruach4:58achara, that's called, or this other wind, this malach5:01called this name5:03that starts with the aleph-gimmel. Then, that’s where the snake5:09that represents the snake that, you know, the snake5:13that's akum, that's represented by the5:16samech-mem, that's the cause of the death of the whole world.5:25That's the yetzer hara. It says, from the age of 20 and above,5:27a person is judged by the courts5:32that are called the zechut. He comes alone, he stands alone in5:36judgment, and he's judged on his own5:42averot. And if he's found guilty, he's given over5:44to the snake, which is really the5:57malach hamavet. It says, because from the age of 20 and under until 13,5:59basically from 13 to 20,6:02there's this... Ono malach6:05that's by him, that's represented by the snake,6:11because when he was growing up as a6:14child, he was not protected properly from the6:19averot, and therefore he,6:21because he was not protected from6:23those averot, there's something about him6:26that could affect him later on.6:29And then he's given over to the hands6:32of this malach that has the6:34ability to take away his soul from him,6:36to kill him basically,6:38and that's kind of like saying6:40like he's taken without permission from Hashem.6:44As the pasuk says,6:50v'einish nifbalo mishpat. But as that daa ketiv, v'net tov me'od, v'tenem v'neh tov me'od, dam hamalach hamavet. And this is the secret6:52when the Torah says,6:53in the end of creation of the world,6:59Hashem says in Parashat Bereishit, vayar Hashem et kol asher asah, v'hineh tov me'od, and it's very, very good.7:06Nachazal tells us, what's tov me'od? That's malach hamavet, dakdim lei ad delo yitpegim livatar, because Hashem brings the7:08malach. Why is it so good that Hashem allows the malach7:12hamavet to kill the person? The answer is because He kills him before7:14he messes up even more.7:21And this person who's in charge of it7:23stands on the gate7:28and brings his neshama up to the shamayim. However, the Zohar says,7:30anything under the age of 13,7:31the person is judged based on the sins of his father,7:36vitmasa beyadei hai askara dikaman, and he's given over to7:38the punishment of7:41askara, like we said. Okay, this is all the Zohar. Ad kan the Zohar.7:43Comes the Gra and says,7:47up to 13, a person is judged7:50based on his father's sins.7:5313 and above, a person is judged on his own sins.8:00In thirteen to twenty, they don't judge him in8:02Shamayim. But you see people do die at that age.8:06Hakol al derech zeh,8:08all based on what it says in the Zohar.8:11Now what? This is a scary line. It says,8:15שראו בו סימן שיחטא אחר כך. They saw that there's something that, you know, he's going to sin afterwards.8:20לכן הקדימו לסלקו מן העולם בעוד שהוא צדיק. That's why they took him away while he's still a8:22tzaddik. And that's the meaning,8:25ויש נשפט בלא משפט, אבל הכל בצדק. And that's the meaning that there's somebody who's taken without judgment.8:27Don't think there's no justice.8:29Of course it's justice. It's8:31all בצדק, but it's protecting the person.8:39Tosafot על בהג שמחקו לוקח נפשות במשפט. I'm not sure exactly what that Gemara is.8:42So the Gemara says, they bring it on the bottom.8:44The Gemara says, the Tosafot says,8:47מסכת ברכות, there's a berachah that says,8:54מוסיףים ברכת המזון בית האבל, לוקח נפשות במשפט. Hashem takes the souls8:55with justice.8:59And the Bahag says9:00you shouldn't say the word9:01במשפט, because we know that there's somebody who dies9:05בלא חטא וישרים בלא עוון. The Tosafot argues and says,9:07but don't erase it.9:08But the Tosafot doesn't explain why.9:12The Tosafot doesn't explain what it means. The Bahag is telling you this:9:13we see people that die even without sin.9:15We see, the Gemara tells us about that.9:18So comes the Tosafot and says,9:19yeah, but still don't take out the word9:21במשפט. Rabbeinu Yonah explains,9:26שאף על פי שיש מיתה בלא חטא, מקום כל אחד משפט, ויודע למה עושה כן. Even though there are people who die without a sin,9:29but don't think it's random.9:31Hashem knows exactly why He's doing it,9:33and therefore to us9:34we don't see the mishpat,9:36but it is mishpat in9:37Shamayim. And Rabbeinu Yonah writes in9:40מסכת ברכות דף נון חט עמוד ב', regarding a person who sees9:42a Jewish cemetery,9:44what does he say?9:45He says,9:48והמית אתכם בדין. One of the words that we say9:50when we see a Jewish cemetery,9:52we're supposed to9:53say—and by the way, this berachah applies still today—if you see a Jewish cemetery,9:56there's a special berachah you're supposed to say,9:57and that's only if you didn't say it within thirty days.10:00Anyway, he says over there,10:01the text says,10:07והמית אתכם בדין. ואף על פי שיש מיתה בלא חטא, מקום כל דבר משפט. The words of Rabbeinu Yonah is,10:09even though the Gemara tells us10:10there's such a thing as death without a sin,10:13however the ways of Hashem are justice,10:16and His din is a10:18din. His judgment is a judgment of truth.10:24And that's the meaning of Tosafot.10:27He wants to say10:28that even though— Even though,10:32what's it called,10:33you don't see the justice,10:35but it's still righteous.10:36And therefore, when it says that word,10:40b'mishpat, Hashem, loke'ach nefesh b'mishpat, that's what Tosfot says:10:42don't take it out,10:44don't remove it.10:46So that's,10:46yeah, today sounds a little scary10:48because, you know, we all get nervous10:50of these things.10:51You got to put emunah in Hashem. HaKadosh Baruch Hu does the best for us.10:54We got to do what's good, we got to do what's right,10:57and we have to understand10:59that part of also,11:01you know, the world of life,11:02you have to also have emunah in Hashem,11:04that whatever He does, He does for our best.11:06He's only looking out for our best.11:08Baruch Hashem. We should only see11:10chasadim tovim, be'ezrat Hashem. Baruch Hu, amen v'amen.