Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 10, Lesson 27Sefer Even ShelemaPart 191Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:008:13Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:04Even chapter, perek yud, ot chaf dalet. Today's piece is very small, but very, very, very long. How can it be small and very long?0:10And the answer is because what we're going to say is actually a big, big subject.0:15It's a big discussion. In the back of this book, they have about five pages of two columns each0:21of going through and trying to explain, you know, this whole concept, this whole idea.0:28So I don't know how much we can get into it. It's also connected to later on.0:34Also, the one concept that he brings over here, that Even Shlema brings over here,0:39we don't find really later on in this, over here in this place over here, that he discusses it at length,0:45or, you know, how he brings the sources from the Gra. We don't find the Gra actually says it at length,0:49but it will come up later on. So we're in ot chaf dalet, and over here,0:54let me know that there's still se'if lamed aleph and lamed bet, which we'll soon see.0:58I'll try to maybe scan it just very quickly today, just to get an idea of it.1:02In any case, let's see.1:07After the gezar din, after Hashem gave the decree already, a person can't do any more teshuvah.1:13It's over. That means, let's say, let's take a simple case in mitat beit din1:19shel matah. Once upon a time when we had the Sanhedrin used to execute people,1:21so let's say a person was mechalel Shabbat and his punishment is1:26sekilah. So two people who saw him and they warned him, and they come and they testify on him,1:31and the court finds him that he's guilty. Now a guy says,1:34No, no, no, no, no, I do teshuvah. I'm going to bring1:36korban chatat, right? It's too late. You can't do any more teshuvah, right? It's over.1:40So he's telling you also in Shamayim also, if they give a certain gezar din on a person,1:44you can't be saved from death.1:48However, teshuvah is not over.1:52Don't think, the guy shouldn't think that, Oh, you know what? He's sentenced to die anyway,1:56so it's over. There's nothing for him to do.1:59What's the point of doing teshuvah? And it says, No, teshuvah helps.2:01How does teshuvah2:09help him? The Gemara brings down the halacha in Masechet Sanhedrin: kol hamemutin mitvadin. Lifnei mitatam. All the people that are supposed to get killed, executed in Beit Din,2:13have to do vidui beforehand. We learn it from Achan.2:16But it says by Achan, Achan is the guy who stole from2:21when Bnei Yisrael went into Yericho, and Hashem brought down the walls,2:25and they were able to capture the city very easily.2:27They had a lot of money, they had a lot of treasure,2:29and then the next place they went to fight was a city called Ai.2:34And over there it says that 36 people died.2:36Some say it was one person who was equal as 36 people.2:39In any case, Yehoshua was stunned.2:42He says, I don't understand. The second battle already we ran away and 36 people died?2:48What's going on? So Hashem tells him, There's somebody who stole from the2:52cherem. When you went into the city in2:56Yericho and you said that whatever money that we have is going to be all2:59cherem, it's all going to be to HaKadosh Baruch Hu,3:01one guy went and he stole from there.3:03After doing the lottery, it was discovered it was Achan,3:05and he was put to death.3:07But before he died, Yehoshua tells him,3:09Come and be mitvadeh. Come and confess.3:12And the Gemara in Sanhedrin, perek shishi, goes through the details exactly what Achan said,3:17and over there he says, he admits that he stole here, he stole there.3:21Good? And because he stole, right,3:25so that's why he tells him that's why he3:27gaveihaim. Now the Gemara says from there it wasn't just a conversation;3:28he was actually doing teshuvah.3:31Part of doing teshuvah is you say vidui, you confess.3:34So what's the point? Anyway, for3:37he punished him. What's the point of confessing? What's the point of doing teshuvah?3:39So he says that teshuvah helps him,3:42that takes him out of Gehinam after he suffers3:45what he suffers. He goes through,3:47the teshuvah will help him that he eventually gets out of3:50Gehinam. Now that's talking about a person who nigzar on him to die from3:55Beit Din. If a person has a gezeirah from Shamayim that he has to die because of his3:58aveirah, sometimes it could be that teshuvah will not help him,4:02and it could be that it will.4:03We don't know.4:04But in cases where he's going to have to die, the Gra is still telling you4:11that teshuvah helps him.4:12How does it help him?4:12It helps that he could eventually come out of4:16Gehinam. Look in the source where this comes from.4:19A pasuk in Sefer Yonah.4:21It says4:24over there, וַיָּטִלוּ אֶת הַכֵּלִים אֲשֶׁר בָּאֳנִיָּה אֶל הַיָּם לְהָקֵל מֵעֲלֵיהֶם, וְיוֹנָה יָרַד אֶל יַרְכְּתֵי הַסְּפִינָה, וַיִּשְׁכַּב וַיֵּרָדַם. When they were on the ship, and the ship was rocking because of the storm,4:31and it says that the sailors all tried to go back to the dry land, but they couldn't4:37because the ocean was going stronger and stronger.4:41The storm was getting stronger and stronger.4:43The Gra says, על פי דרשה, he says,4:49שרצו ללך בדרך הטובה, בדרך החיים. And we said it already in the past, based on the Zohar, the Gra explains the whole Sefer Yonah,4:54like the Zohar explains it also,4:56talking about the neshamah that comes to this world, and the ship represents a person's5:00guf. So he says5:02they tried to go בדרך הטובה, בדרך החיים. They tried to do teshuvah. They tried to go in the ways of the Torah.5:09וְלֹא יָכְלוּ, כִּי הַיָּם הוֹלֵךְ וְסֹעֵר. But they couldn't because the ocean was getting stormier and stormier.5:17עכשיו אינן תשובה מועלת. But it was too late to do teshuvah because already in Shamayim they decreed that he's supposed to die.5:23Like it says,5:26כִּי חָפֵץ ה' לַהֲמִיתָם. There's a pasuk that says5:27Hashem wanted to kill them,5:29right?5:30Not here.5:31It's the pasuk in Shmuel Aleph.5:33In any case.5:35But you see that Hashem wanted to kill them,5:38right?5:38That this sometimes Hashem wants to kill somebody.5:40Ah, you're going to ask me a question.5:43The Gemara says,5:45Ki lo echpotz b'mot hamet. Well, that's the Gemara's question5:47in Masechet Niddah. In one place it says Hashem doesn't want a person to die.5:51Another pasuk says,5:54Ki chafetz Hashem lehamitam. Gemara explains that two different things:6:01kan kodem gezar din, kan leachar gezar din. One is before gezar din, one is after6:04gezar din. One is before the decree, one is after the decree.6:06After the decree,6:09chafetz Hashem lehamitam. There's nothing to do;6:09it's over.6:11But before the gezeirah in Shamayim, before the decree in Shamayim about a person that's supposed to get killed,6:17that Hashem doesn't want a person to die;6:19He wants him to do teshuvah.6:20So then what's the point of doing teshuvah?6:21And that's exactly what the Gra says,6:22that teshuvah helps him, is that brings him out of6:26Gehinom. That's the next piece over here.6:27They quote another pasuk in Yonah,6:32Vayita'ef alai nafshi et Adonai zacharti. When Yonah was inside the stomach of the fish,6:36he says like this:6:37When I fainted, I remembered6:40Hashem. He says, the Gra again explaining,6:45he says, Achshav matchil lehazkir miktsat ma'asim tovim she'asah kodem moto. Yonah is starting to explain some of the good deeds that he did before he died.6:51But Yonah didn't die;6:53he's in me'ei hadagah. So it means the person who dies,6:56he starts to remind himself,6:59starts to mention the good deeds that he did before he died.7:03What do you mean?7:04You're already dead.7:05It's over,7:06right? And teshuvah,7:07what's it going to help?7:10But7:12it'll help him that once he suffers7:14what he has to suffer7:15in Gehinom, it'll take him out,7:16כידוע, as is known.7:20He says that even when he was sick7:23and he was dying,7:23he turned to7:26Hashem. Even though he only turned to Hashem because he's in a desperate situation,7:30he's dying,7:33still Hashem accepts people7:35even when they're dying,7:36even when they're going through tremendous suffering7:37in the last moments of their life,7:38in the last moments of their lives,7:40He still accepts them.7:44And that's where Yonah concludes and he says,7:46My prayer has reached Your holy chambers,7:49which means— That Hashem accepted it.7:54He accepted it in7:57Shamayim, even though he's doing it out of, you know, he wouldn't.8:00He didn't do this when he was living the good life.8:03And even though it's not the best teshuvah, but still it's teshuvah nonetheless, and it'll help him. How?8:07After he suffers the suffering8:09Gehinnom, he'll be able to come out. Baruch HaShem, amen v'amen.