Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 10, Lesson 22Sefer Even ShelemaPart 186Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:009:00Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:04אבן שלמה, פרק י' אות י"ט. A short piece today, but an important piece, as usual. It says like this:0:11אף על פי שהקדוש ברוך הוא מעניש. Till now we've been learning the hadinur, Gehennam, and all the different things, and sounds like, you know, there's punishment,0:17and of course there's דין וחשבון. And even though Hashem does punish, however, the punishment0:25is—Hashem doesn't try to go punish; doesn't go out of His way to try to punish0:29you. The opposite. Hashem wants to help, obviously. But even in His punishment, He tries to be a little bit more lenient.0:35It's kind of like a person getting pulled over. The cop could technically give you, you know, many tickets.0:40He decides, you know, I'll give you three tickets instead of five tickets,0:45or you'll get the five tickets, but you'll serve—as long as you serve a little bit of time, you're okay.0:50And that's what the Ibn Shabbat is saying over here.0:53נכנס לפנים משורת הדין. Hashem tries to do beyond the letter of the law. He doesn't try to give you exactly what you really deserve.1:00That's for regular people. However, there are exceptions. There are some people that it's different.1:05Who are these people? There are two types of people that he says about them.1:08Number one is:1:12הבעל הרע לבריות, משלמים לו כגמולו ממש. A person who's evil to people, he's just bad. You know, some people are just bad.1:22It could be they do עבירה, דין, right? But they're just bad. They're very, very negative and bad to other people.1:26They pay him ממש like he deserves.1:31We're not—Hashem's not going to punish him extra, but he's going to get what he deserves.1:35And therefore, if he did עבירות that he deserves a, you know, a real burning in1:41Gehennam, he's going to get it. Hashem's not going to try to do1:45לפנים משורת הדין. That's one type of person that Hashem pays him what he deserves.1:48He doesn't try to, you know, let him go out a little bit easier.1:53וכן לגבה לב. And so too, to a person who is a1:57בעל גאווה. A person who's a2:00בעל גאווה, גבה לב, a person, you know, what they say in Arabic,2:05שايف حالו. Shayef halo, you know, he feels he's up there, he feels he's better than other people,2:10that person also, Hashem pays him also like he deserves.2:14And it's interesting. We know that2:16Chazal tell us — not Chazal, the pasuk says in the Torah2:22— that ki b'tzelem Elokim nivra ha'adam. And there's a whole big discussion:2:25what does it mean that we're created in the image of Hashem,2:28and obviously it doesn't mean literally.2:31One explanation of that is that a lot of middot that Hashem has, kind of2:37He implanted in the human being.2:39One of them, for example, Hashem says2:42a person who is a2:44baal gaavah, oto lo uchal — I can't stand him.2:46And Chazal tell us that a person who is a2:52baal gaavah ein nichnas b'chasato shel Kadosh Baruch Hu. He doesn't enter the area of Hashem.2:55Hashem says, It's either Me or you, right?2:57And we all have the same feeling when we see a person who is very, very3:01haughty. A person who is3:03baal gaavah, a person who goes on showing off,3:05and even though he might have good qualities, but just showing it off,3:09it turns us very off.3:10We don't want to be next to him.3:12We don't want to be in his area.3:13And not only that,3:14when a person is3:16baal gaavah, we're always looking to get him to fall.3:19We want to see when he falls.3:20A guy who goes around showing off,3:22Oh yeah,3:23oh, you don't understand Gemara?3:25So easy. What's so hard?3:27Such an easy Gemara, right?3:29And the explanation is like this, and he has it right.3:32So we're looking deep down like we want him to one time3:35say the wrong explanation.3:37Ah, look, he fell.3:38Yeah, that's how we have as a nature.3:42Kiv'yachol, that's a nature we find Hashem does that also to3:45baalei. A person who davens, Hashem says, Oh, you're walking around all the time, your whole life,3:49like a big shot?3:50Come, come, let's give you what you deserve.3:52Why are you a big3:55tzaddik? Let's see if you're all that or not.3:56Let's look at your deeds and let's see what you deserve,3:58and you get exactly what you deserve.3:59It's a very, very interesting observation.4:05But anyway, that's what the Gra says,4:09and the Ibn Shmuel calls the Gra. Over here on the bottom, they bring the source from4:12Yeshayahu, perek gimmel, pasuk yud4:13alef. Pasuk says,4:17Oy l'rasha ki gemul yadav ye'aseh lo. Pasuk says in4:20Yeshayahu, Woe to the rasha, because gemul yadav ye'aseh lo, the deeds of his actions is what they're going to pay him back.4:25Hainu, says the Gra on that,4:30Shekol ha'anashim she'nechbarot ha'katuv baTorah, kol b'tzedek v'din. Every punishment that says in the Torah, everything is justified,4:33everything is according to the law.4:34So what do you mean?4:35So why,4:37Oy l'rasha ki gemul yadav ye'aseh lo? Even the tzaddik who does4:39aveirot, oy lo, because you're also going to get, you know, you do an aveirah, you get punished for aveirah, like the Rambam writes.4:44So why does the pasuk say only, Oy4:53l'rasha? Ela, says the Gra, I'll tell you why: K'sheha'rasha tov la'beriyot, HaKadosh Baruch Hu metiv imo gam ken u'ma'anisho b'chesed. If this rasha person is committing aveirot, he's also good to other people.4:57He's a baal tzedakah.4:59Yes, he gives tzedakah, he gives a lot of charity.5:02Then guess what?5:03Hashem also, when He comes to punish him, He punishes him with chesed also.5:08So, you know, there are people with big hearts, as you know.5:11Unfortunately, the resha'im maybe, they do5:14aveirot, and sometimes they do aveirot b'mezid also,5:16but they're good to other people.5:17They really, really help other people.5:18They really care about other people.5:19They're going to get5:21Gehenom, but Hashem does it, what?5:23He's ma'anisho b'chesed. He'll get his punishment, but5:33it'll be b'chesed. Lo lefi hagemul hara'ui al pi hatzedek, kach ha'yu darkei haTorah, al pi haTorah, v'ha'ones al pi hadin. What you did al pi haTorah, that's based on the law,5:36and the punishment is based on what you broke and what you didn't break.5:42V'hasivcha ma'asav, v'sof maaseh ha'ones minhag b'chesed. But at the end, when you get the punishment, you'll get it only5:51b'chesed. Aval k'shehu ra la'beriyot, but that's till now we've been speaking about a person who's good to other people.5:54But a person who is not good to other people,5:56he's always negative about other people.5:58He's always talking down. He's always knocking people.6:01And sometimes people knock communities.6:04A lot of people like to knock their own community.6:06Our community, they're all a bunch of6:08ganavim. All they care about money. All they care about themselves.6:11You hear that from every person, every community,6:13always knocking his own community.6:14So why are you living there?6:16Go move out,6:17because we all know there's benefits, right?6:19So stop knocking.6:20Talk good.6:21Talk positively about your shul.6:23Talk good about your rabbi.6:24Talk good about your friends.6:25Talk good about your6:27in-laws. Come on, there's a lot of good also.6:29But people who are ra,6:34asai ein menakin lo min haonesh klal. Then that's it.6:34You get what you deserve.6:35They don't cut down.6:39Ela kegmul yadav, vishlemut yaaseh lo. We pay him exactly what he deserves.6:41There's no chesed.6:42You get6:43exactly—listen, you're not going to get extra.6:44You just get exactly what he deserves.6:46And that's the meaning in the pasuk that says over here,6:52Oy lerasha ra. Look at the pasuk.6:53Woe to the rasha who's ra.6:54Which ra?6:55He's ra6:57labriyot, kigemul yadav yaaseh lo. Every person does6:59aveirot, yeah, but the rasha who's a7:01ra, the person who's a rasha that is also ra7:05to labriyot, he's going to get it exactly as he did.7:09Vzehu shekatuv, and that's the meaning also in the pasuk in Mishlei,7:14Yad lyad lo yinake ra. Hand to hand will not be cleansed from evil.7:18Hand to—ra labriyot lo yinake mehaonesh hakatuv. A person who is bad to other people7:21will not get cleansed from the punishment7:23that says in the Torah.7:25And lemin yad7:26lyad, you get exactly what you did.7:27Yad,7:28yad—the hand that stole,7:29you're going to get that hand punished.7:35Vken amar kan, oy lerasha, hainu ra labriyot lo yinake haonesh hakatuv, lefi gemul yadav yaaseh lo. He's not going to be getting the chesed treatment.7:37He's going to get the midat hadin treatment.7:39He's going to get exactly as he deserves.7:42Now we improve over here.7:43A person who's7:45baal gaavah, where does he get it from?7:46And the answer is over here on the note,7:48they bring it out from Perek Bet,7:50se'if bet,7:51all the way in the beginning of the book.7:53Over there, the Gra says the same idea.7:55It says—8:00That person who is a baal gaavah, they pay him back exactly8:04middah k'neged middah. Let me read a few.8:08Af al pi sheHaKadosh Baruch Hu dan et ha'adam, dan oto lifnim mishurat hadin. Even though Hashem judges a person, He judges him lifnim mishurat hadin, like we just said, like favorably.8:15Makom makom, lebaal gaavah, however, a baal gaavah lo yinakeh klal. He's not cleansed.8:20V'eino noten lo min haTorah mamash, and he gets judged exactly like he did.8:29V'gam afilu mishpat rak b'levavut, v'gam ken meto'am mushkachas lifnei Hashem. If you're not an outward baal gaavah,8:32if you were inside gaavah,8:33some people have gaavah only on the inside.8:35Inside they feel they're better than other people.8:37They feel they're greater than other people.8:39They don't feel that Hashem maybe has given them qualities that makes them more responsible than other people.8:45They just feel that they're better than other people.8:47That person also, la'aleinu, Hashem also gives him the punishment the same way.8:51He gives him the punishment as what he deserves.8:53So that's from perek bet,8:56se'if bet,8:57and with that we finish Otiot. Baruch...