Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 10, Lesson 18Sefer Even ShelemaPart 182Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:10Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00Even shelema, perek yud, ot tet vav.0:04In the notes that they bring from the0:07Gra, it looks like there's a lot of, what do you call it,0:11a lot of sources from the0:14Gra. Let's see what we could do.0:15Let's start with0:17the Even Shelema. He says like this:0:20We keep on seeing different travels, right?0:22You have to go seven things,0:24and there's no contradiction here.0:26As we explained already,0:27there's sometimes a difference between tzaddik and rasha,0:31right? Rasha has to go through seven,0:33and the tzaddik through three stages.0:36But now we're telling you the travels itself.0:38There are eleven travels that every person has to travel.0:41What is0:42that? Number one is,0:45from the place,0:46whether it's a hospital,0:47from his house.0:47That's why there's a minhag to pass by,0:49you know, at least in our neighborhood,0:51right, to pass by the house0:53on the way to the0:55levaya, right? From his house0:56to the kever, to where he's going to be buried.0:58Hasheni, once he's buried,1:00he travels to the next place.1:02What's the next place?1:03We said everybody has to pass1:04Gehinom, even tzaddikim have to go to1:09Gehinom. We already said this.1:10Even if a person is a1:14tzaddik gamur, right,1:15they still have to pass by1:19Gehinom. Hashlishi, the third travel is,1:22miGehinom l'Gan Eden. From Gehinom to Gan Eden.1:25Nice.1:27From Gan Eden,1:28where do you go to?1:29You go to1:30Sheva raki'im. You go to the seven1:32raki'im, the famous Gemara Masechet1:34Chagigah that says there are seven skies.1:38U'misham, after the seven1:39raki'im, you go l'Gan Eden1:40Elyon. You go to the higher Gan Eden.1:42There's two Gan Edens.1:43Did you know that?1:44Now you see it, right?1:45And then you go to the higher Gan Eden.1:48Now,1:48the seven raki'im are number four.1:52Right,1:53there's seven over here.1:54So from three,1:55then you get another,1:56that's ten.1:56And from the seven1:58reki'im, we go to Gan Eden1:59Elyon, that's number eleven.2:00And that's eleven travels that we mentioned.2:03Now,2:05uvchol makom, seder ha-din v'cheshbon. Every level that you move up,2:06that means from rekia2:07one, number one,2:08to number two,2:09to number three,2:10number four,2:11each level and level2:12as you go,2:13they judge you all over again,2:15right?2:16And this din2:17v'cheshbon, we're going to explain this,2:19what it means soon,2:22what it means,2:23what it means that they judge you.2:25So2:25let's look on the bottom2:27in Harod2:27v'Urim on2:28lamed hei. Look what he says.2:29He says,2:31Ulay, the guy who is writing this,2:33he's saying,2:34Ulay ka'al ha-din shezeh ketem ba'avro, bein ha-dino kodem sheyichanes l'Gan Eden Elyon. Before you enter Gan Eden2:38Elyon, we're going to see in the next letter,2:40letter2:41tezayin, that you have to go through2:43Nahar Dinur,2:44the river of fire,2:46the closest thing I could, like,2:47resemble this to,2:48if you want to get an idea of a river of fire,2:50you ever see the lava from a volcano,2:53how when it comes out?2:58Okay, maybe that's where a2:59person gets judged the tenth time.3:02The eleventh is when you actually3:03enter Gan Eden3:17Elyon. B'nei shekol tzaddik notim lo madul l'fi chiburo, v'chen bichlal yesh sham beit dargim, k'mo shekatuv l'soif lamed bet, v'kmo shegam b'Gan Eden hatachton shekatuv din v'cheshbon. In each place3:18you have to give another3:19din v'cheshbon. As we know,3:21this is a rule.3:22Anything good that comes to a person,3:24any promotion3:25that they're about to give a person,3:27we always have to3:29go through a judgment.3:30Judgment means3:30that we have to see3:31if we're worthy of it3:32or we're not worthy of it.3:34Think of how we work in life also.3:36Imagine you have a company,3:38and you have a big company3:40where you have already,3:41you know,3:42you're not running the company by yourself3:43with a few employees,3:44but you actually3:44have many, many employees,3:46and you have also3:47a team3:48that works for you.3:49So you sit there in the meeting3:50with the team.3:52Now you want to talk about promotions.3:54We want to talk about3:54who to move up.3:56So each person,3:57when his name comes up,3:58we start to see.3:59Like the Gemara says,4:00for example,4:01when they wanted to find4:02a new Rosh Yeshiva4:04or a new,4:05what's it called,4:08Av Beit Din, and they removed4:09Rabban Gamliel, they wanted to get4:10somebody else.4:10So they said,4:11Okay, let's bring Rabbi Akiva.4:12He4:12said, No, you can't bring Rabbi Akiva;4:15ein lo zechut avot. He comes from a family of gerim,4:17and he cannot be the leader.4:19So you see,4:19every single person4:20that they thought about promoting,4:22and they said,4:23Okay, does he deserve it?4:24Does he not deserve it?4:24That's how it goes in Shamayim also.4:26So they bring this guy4:28who passed away,4:28and they want to bring him now4:30from the third rakia,4:32from the third heaven,4:34to the fourth heaven.4:35And they say,4:36Well, no, no, no, no, no,4:37give4:39a din v'cheshbon. Does he deserve it?4:39But we just gave4:40a din v'cheshbon when he went from two to three.4:42Yeah, but now we got to see all over.4:43But this is three to four.4:44It's different,4:45right?4:46If I'm judging something,4:47you know,4:48lemashal, we make judgments also,4:49if you think about it.4:51When we want to give,4:53let's say you have a service4:55that's needed,4:56let's say either on your phone4:58or it's needed on your car,5:01right?5:01So you have an option5:02to go wherever you want to go.5:04But you go through5:05din v'cheshbon right now.5:06Actually, not you go through5:08din v'cheshbon. You go through5:09a cheshbon, but you put all the mechanics5:12in Brooklyn5:13and even beyond Brooklyn5:14through5:16a din. Should they deserve my business or not?5:20This one's too far.5:21This one's too expensive.5:23This one's too slow.5:24This one, I know him too well,5:26and if something goes wrong,5:27I may not want to give it to him,5:28right?5:29I don't want to deal with it afterwards.5:30But you basically go through5:32a din, and there it's a small thing.5:33So if it's such a small thing,5:34like fixing your car5:35and it's like only5:37a hundred dollars, it's not a big deal.5:38But if we're talking about,5:39let's say, you're buying a new car5:41and you have to spend5:42ten thousand dollars and you need a5:43mechanic who's going to really look into it,5:45okay, so the din that you give5:48and how you decide,5:50the judgment call5:51that you're going to take5:52to decide if you're going to take5:53that mechanic or not.5:54So now we're dealing5:54with something much bigger.5:55You think much more.5:57You analyze much more.5:58And the same thing5:58when you buy a house,5:59even more so,6:00right?6:00Oh, we're not dealing.6:01And when people6:02who are single,6:03they're coming to get married,6:04and you give a6:05din that's much higher.6:06So you see,6:07even though you've thought about,6:08you know, like,6:09you know, people tell you,6:10okay, you go out with a girl,6:11right?6:12You went out6:12one, two, three, four.6:13Every date6:13you have to decide6:14if you should continue or not,6:15right?6:15So they tell you,6:16okay, why don't you just get engaged?6:17You're ready6:17or not,6:17seven times.6:19It's6:19not a difference.6:20To go out is from6:22six times to6:23seven times. Okay, I have to think,6:24do I really?6:25But to get married,6:26whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.6:27That needs a different6:30din v'cheshbon, because the stakes are much higher.6:32And that's what we're saying6:32over here also.6:33Even though a person6:34has been judged,6:35has been judged6:36in every single stage,6:38but when the stakes are higher,6:41so then he has to go through6:42a whole new6:42din v'cheshbon to see6:43if he's worthy for that level.6:45Now, let's see6:48where the Gra writes this.6:50So it's interesting.6:51He writes it on this pasuk6:51in Parashat6:53Devarim. It says in the beginning6:54of Sefer6:58Devarim, it says, Eleh ha-devarim asher diber Moshe el Bnei Yisrael... It says in the pasuk after that,7:04achad asar yom meChorev, eleven days from7:07Chorev. I mean, the place that they were at7:10is a 11-day travel from7:17Choreb. On the way to, on the road to Har Seir, ad Kadesh Barnea, until Kadesh Barnea. Comes the Gra and says,7:21V'al derech haremez hu kach. That's pashut pshat, the pasuk.7:23But there's a7:24remez in the pasuk.7:25The pasuk is hinting to something else:7:30sheyesh yud alef masa'ot shechayav adam lis'boa ad sheyavo limkom menuchato. There are 11 travels7:31a person has to travel7:32till he gets to his final,7:34final resting place,7:35and that's again7:36Gan Eden HaElyon. Now what is it?7:37And he goes through all these7:3811, like we just said,7:40from his house to the grave,7:41from the grave to7:42Gehinom, from Gehinom to7:44Gan Eden tachton, from Gan Eden tachton to seven7:45reki'im, from seven reki'im to7:48Gan Eden HaElyon, okay?7:49And each one, he says,7:50you have to give7:51din v'cheshbon. Now the Gra connects it back7:52to the pasuk:7:55V'zehu shekatuv b'halasar yom, and this is the meaning7:56when it says there's 11 days.8:02כלומר, שאחד עשה נסיעות הוא מחורב. There are eleven travels from, the pasuk says, meChorev. What's Chorev? Pasuk ... but he says,8:12Chorev מביתו של בני חותו חרבה. Why is it talking about eleven travels when a person goes away from his house?8:16Why his house? Because that's what8:20he—Chorev could also be from the word8:24חרבה. חרבה, חריבה in English,8:25it's very easy,8:27חרבה. But basically, a deserted place.8:30A deserted place.8:31Why is it deserted? Because when you leave the house, it becomes deserted.8:34דרך חצר עיר, you have to go through8:37חצר עיר, זהו גיהנם. As we know, שעיר represents the midat8:46hadin. עד קדש ברנע, until you get to קדש ברנע, until you get to the Gan Eden HaElyon, which is also referred to as8:53קדש ברנע. Okay. Now, the, what's it called,8:57there's another few pieces from the9:02Gra. I just want to, you know, I'm going to skip where the Gemara that he brings it from,9:05just go straight towards the9:06Gra. The Gra says,9:14אין לך אדם כלל שאף אם הצדיק עובר דרך שם אין לו רשות לשאול, לשלול בו כלל. Nobody has any rulership.9:16I don't care who you are,9:17even if you're a tzaddik, you have no rulership over9:21Gehinnom, אלא הוא דרך אל גן עדן. You must go through9:23Gehinnom. Every tzaddik, even himself,9:24even if the guy is a tzaddik, he must go through Gehinnom to get to Gan Eden,9:32שהולך הוא לגן עדן ולא לדונו בו. You go through Gan Eden.9:33Doesn't mean they're going to judge you in it, but you have to go through it.9:35Like it says,9:40לא תעשון נפשי לשאול, לא תתן חסידך לראות שחת. Then he mechapeir for this. He said, Hashem, please don't— Let my soul end up in9:46Gehennam. What do you mean, end up in9:47Gehennam? You find this all the time,9:50that tzaddikim are always scared and crying9:51they have to go through9:52Gehennam. What do you mean?9:53You're the biggest tzaddik.9:54You're worried about9:55Gehennam? The answer is no.9:56We have to go through it,9:57and we're scared we're going to get caught up in it,10:00and that's what we're worried about.10:02Don't let a tzaddik, don't let your chassid, which is referring to himself,10:06David HaMelech, to see destruction.10:09And look what David HaMelech said.10:11It seems like twice he's praying that he shouldn't get stuck in10:14Gehennam. And the first time he says the10:17word, Lo ta'azov, don't leave me alone in the deep grave.10:20And then he says,10:23Don't let me lir'ot shachat, right?10:24So we're referring to Gehennam one time as Sheol, one time as10:28shachat, and one time we're saying,10:29Lo ta'azov, don't leave me,10:30and one time we're saying,10:31Don't let me see it.10:32So he explains the10:37Gra: He calls out tzaddikim tzrichim la'avor derech Gehennam rishon levan. Everybody has to go through the first10:41Gehennam, and that's—there's seven levels.10:43Each one is deeper than the other one in10:45Gehennam, and the first level is called Sheol.10:47Everybody has to go through that.10:48Sheni, the second one is called10:51shachat. What's the difference between rasha and10:53tzaddik? Both of them have to go through10:55Gehennam. He says10:56there's two differences.10:57Number one is11:00that tzaddik eino over rak derech, aval rasha bamedor rishon. Tzaddik is not staying there.11:01He has to walk by.11:02He has to go through.11:04He has to, you know, just like drive through.11:06V'gam lo kola shachat also, he doesn't even see the second level at all.11:12Aval rasha, doesn't walk through;11:13he's staying there.11:14That's his waiting room.11:16V'gam bechol zeh meidor Gehennam. Not only that,11:17he goes down to shachat and to other places,11:20and that's why11:21David HaMelech prayed, Lo ta'azov nafshi Sheol, don't leave me.11:23Make sure,11:24Hashem, help me stay as a11:26tzaddik and not end up staying in11:29Gehennam, right?11:30Even though I have to go through,11:32but Lo ta'azov, don't leave me there,11:33right?11:34Save me there.11:35And then also,11:37please save me from having to go11:39lir'ot shachat, even to11:41see—not to11:41say that—even to see the second level,11:43because,11:44Da'im d'amar rasha, help me11:45from there. And now11:46the Gra connects it back11:47even to11:49the Mishnah, Perekei Avot, that says the difference between11:54Talmidav shel Avraham Avinu and Talmidav shel Bilam HaRasha. It says11:58Talmidav shel Avraham HaRasha yorshin Gehennam, v'yordin l'be'er shachat. They inherit11:58Gehennam, they go to11:59be'er shachat. What does that mean?12:01They12:02go in Gehennam, they obviously go into12:05shachat. In general,12:06Gehennam is called Sheol.12:08The Gemara, yorshin Gehennam, that's what he says.12:10Their inheritance is12:12Gehennam. That's for that place.12:18And not only that,12:19they go down to12:21Er Shachat, but tzaddikim don't even go down12:22to the second level of the Er12:29Shachat. Okay,12:30one more place from12:32Mishlei. It says,12:35Kofer nefesh ish oshro. A person12:37who's wealthy,12:39he pays12:41kofer for his soul.12:43Varash lo shama ge'arah, and the poor man12:45doesn't hear any yelling12:47or anybody that rebukes him.12:49What is that talking about?12:51So12:51the Gemara says12:52in Masechet Eruvin, as a side point,12:54there are three people12:55that don't see12:56Gehinam. And what are they?12:57One is12:58people who are very, very ani,13:00people who have13:01stomach pains all the time,13:03and13:06reshut, right?13:07The13:07reshut seems like government13:09or government officials.13:11ויש אומרים אף מי שיש לו אשה רעה, and some say13:12even if he has a bad wife,13:14he also doesn't go see13:16Gehinam. So the13:17Gemara says over here13:18on this pasuk,13:22Kofer nefesh ish oshro, even13:22tzaddikim must go through Gehinam. Even tzaddikim has to go through13:25Gehinam, however,13:26his mitzvot protect him from13:28Gehinam taking over him.13:30But mi sheya'alav dikto gehinnom, lo yishma ge'arah klal. But13:30a person who is a13:34rasha, a person who is ani,13:37he wouldn't even13:38pass through13:39Gehinam, as the Gemara says13:39in13:41Masechet Eruvin, like we just said,13:42three people are exempt.13:43The13:43rasha lo shama ge'arah, he doesn't have to.13:45The13:45tzaddik has to go through13:46Gehinam, but he could pay it off13:47with his13:48mitzvot to protect him.13:51Okay.13:54Let's see.13:57I think that's it.13:58I'm scanning everything else.14:00Okay,14:00we could stop over here,14:02Baruch Hashem. Tomorrow14:02we'll continue to the next stages.