Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 1, Lesson 8Sefer Even ShelemaPart 18Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:33Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:03Eben Shelema, perek alef, ot chet. We're talking about middot and how one works on middot and how certain people are born with certain natural middot.0:13Today's class will be focusing on a person who is born with naturally good middot, but he's a rasha,0:23right? That means, and we see, unfortunately, some people like that. They're the sweetest, nicest people.0:28You know, some people are deceiving. They're very sweet to you,0:31right? When you get to really know them, you find out that they're really, like, you know, horrible people.0:35That's part of the trick. You know, they're very nice until they need, you know, like they say,0:42adam nikar bekiso, koso, uvekaaso. You see when it comes to kiso, and you see when it comes to business, how they employ very, very mean tactics and whatever cruel things.0:52So we're dealing with a person who has beautiful, wonderful middot, but he's a rasha.0:56So the Gra says something amazing.0:58Let's look at the Eben Shelema inside.1:05יש מי שנפשו טובה וטבעה במידותיה, ואף על פי כן הוא רשע. There are people who are naturally, you know, not naturally, like we said, the nefesh has middot that are just wonderful.1:14And yet he's a wicked person. What does it mean he's a wicked person?1:17It means he does aveirot. He knows what's right.1:23Rasha, like we said, always, we learn rasha from the word of,1:28from malchut, right?1:35אל תשת ידך להיות עד חמס. What is the pasuk? אל תשת ידך עם רשע להיות עד חמס, something like that.1:41Or basically, the Torah tells us you're not allowed to accept a witness that is a rasha,1:46and there's a Shulchan Aruch on it in Choshen Mishpat, siman lamed daled, that deals with these1:51halachot. What is considered a rasha? What makes him a1:54rasha? It says if he transgresses any aveirah that has chiyuv malkut on it.1:57In order to be chiyuv malkut, you have to do it on purpose.2:00We all do aveirot, but to do it on purpose, then the person is considered a rasha,2:04and obviously higher2:06aveirot. So a rasha, by all times, whenever you see the word rasha,2:09it's not the guy that you think, oh, that guy who's not keeping his word.2:13It could be he's a rasha, it could be2:14he's not a rasha. If he knows that's wrong and he does it anyway, it's called a rasha.2:18Right?2:18And it could be even the smallest2:20aveirot. But if usually most people that you know that do aveirot and they are religious,2:25usually—not the case, you know, all the time—but usually is that they justify what they're doing.2:32That means if you ask them, they don't think they're doing something wrong.2:35And other people that you see them doing something wrong,2:38and they know what they're doing, but they don't know that it's wrong,2:40right?2:41So to get somebody that knows this is wrong and I'm going to do it anyway, that's a rasha.2:46So he says, if you see somebody like that and he has good2:52midot, lazeh notnim lo kol sacharo ba'olam hazeh. This guy, for his good midot and being nice to people and everything else,2:57whatever he does, Hashem gives him the reward in this world,3:01shelo yihyeh lo chelek l'olam haba. Why?3:02Why? What do you mean?3:03Such a sweet guy, he's going to lose3:05olam haba? Yeah, you know why?3:08מפני שהיה נקל לו מאוד לעשות טוב ולא רצה. Till now we're explaining that having good midot is a great assistance for a person to be able to do3:16mitzvot. It's so much easier to do3:18mitzvot. We pointed out how Rabbi Akiva—it says about him3:22that when Rachel, the daughter of the richest man in the world,3:24saw this am ha'aretz, she could have married anybody,3:27but she took this guy and she wanted to marry him.3:30Why? Because she saw that he had good midot, as Maharsha points out.3:34And she said a guy with great midot can become somebody great.3:37So this guy who is a rasha, he had great midot; he could have been somebody great,3:42right?3:42And he still didn't,3:44so that's worse.3:46It's like a guy who's been blessed to be a billionaire3:50and he doesn't give tzedakah.3:52It's worse than the guy who just barely makes it.3:58ועליו נאמר, אוי לנפשם כי גמלו להם רעה. Woe to their nefesh, which is referring to4:01the midot, because they cause evil upon themselves.4:05אבל מי שנפשו רעה ויש לו תכמים לחיצר. But a person who is naturally born with— Bad4:09midot. He's angry by nature.4:11Look at his father, and you see what's going on,4:13right? His father never worked on his4:15midot, and he developed an midat of anger,4:17and it's unfortunately inherited.4:20A father not only gives over a guf, a resemblance in the body,4:24but a father inherits, gives over to his children also,4:27a father or mother that is, also4:30midot. Because, like we saw till now,4:32the midot are in the nefesh, and nefesh is part of the4:35guf. It's connected to the4:36guf. So you can inherit bad midot also, or good midot to your children.4:39So a guy who has bad4:40midot, and he's always constantly battling with4:46the yetzer hara, as lefum tzaara agra. So for this guy,4:49don't think that, you know what,4:50at the end of the day, the mitzvah that he accomplishes4:53is the same like everybody else.4:55They both did the same.4:56They both came to4:57shacharit. They both controlled themselves4:58when somebody screamed at them.5:01No, no, no, no, no, no.5:02This guy, who's naturally born with5:04harder midot, for him to control his5:06yetzer hara is much more difficult.5:09Even though they both accomplish the same thing,5:10his sachar is much greater.5:14And if at times he slips5:16and he doesn't5:20have a ... HaKadosh Baruch Hu nichnas imo lifnim mishurat hadin. Hashem kind of,5:22I don't want to say looks the other way,5:23chas v'shalom, because Hashem never looks the other way,5:25but Hashem acts in chesed,5:27right? Because this guy is a little exceptional.5:29That's an amazing statement right now5:31that the Gaon miVilna has just told us.5:33So if you look on the bottom,5:35you see where he brings the5:37notes. In our book,5:38you see that the5:40ktav, the font changes5:42between different paragraphs.5:44Most of the font is what we call5:46otiyot merubaot, which means regular letters.5:49And now the font over here,5:51for our subject,5:53is brought in letters5:54that are what we call Rashi letters,5:58font of Rashi letters.6:00So whenever you see that in this book,6:02it means it's Kabbalah.6:04Right? So to do this publicly6:06in front of everybody,6:07and to say every single thing,6:11people might get lost.6:13So I'm going to pick,6:14select some paragraphs,6:15and that we'll pick from there.6:17Good? So look at where it says,6:20Vechatav Rabbeinu. This comes from the Tikkunei Zohar,6:22the Gra's commentary on Tikkunei Zohar.6:24He writes like this:6:25We know the concept,6:28tzaddik vera lo, and6:30rasha v'tov lo. Okay? That is a concept that's brought down6:33in Masechet Berachot, that you have a person who's a righteous person6:35and he has bad.6:37Right? The simple meaning of the Gemara means6:38that he has bad things happening to him in this world.6:41Rasha v'tov lo is a bad person,6:44right, evil person,6:45does aveirot, and he has good time in this world.6:46We know that concept.6:48The Gaon MiVilna gives a peirush in the commentary.6:50He explains like this:6:54Tzaddik vera lo sheyesh lo nefesh ra. A person6:55who's tzaddik, but he's ra6:57lo, so not the way6:59we explain the7:00Gemara, which means he has bad things going in this world,7:02but the Gra says7:03another explanation means ra7:05lo, for him he has something that's evil.7:07What is that? His nefesh.7:08He's born with bad7:12midot. All his7:14midot. He's just born with natural bad7:16midot. He's selfish.7:18He runs after7:20ta'avot. He's, you7:22know, very angry all the time.7:26But ruacho lo tovah, but his ruach,7:27which is the neshama,7:28which is connected to the7:30mitzvot, that's good. Why?7:32Because he's doing7:34mitzvot, and that's completely7:35in his choice. It's not something you're born with.7:39Vehu machriach hanefesh ledarko, and he is forcing the nefesh,7:43forcing his7:44midot to act in the way7:46that he wants his ruach to go.7:48He's decided intellectually7:49this is the right thing to do,7:51and now he's working on7:53the yetzer hara. As it says,7:56Vechabshah ha'ish darko lichbosh. Right?7:56Vezehu tzaddik vera lo, shekashe lo.8:00He has a very hard time to always overcome his8:05yetzer hara. V'yitzro gadol me'od lefi nafsho. And based on the nefesh that he has, his yetzer hara is so great.8:18V'hu yadua b'midotav, ma'asav shemidotav lefi haguf, v'hanefesh u'ma'asav lefi haruach. Lefi haguf v'hanefesh, kama, sorry, u'ma'asav lefi haruach. As we said outside beforehand, and it's a known thing8:22that a person has been born based on his physical, you know, the way he's physically made up,8:27and the nefesh he's born with, both are inherited from his parents, right?8:31Like we said, usually people are heavier and usually lazier.8:35It's the way they're born. It's not their, you know, it's not their, you know, so much in their choice.8:40But it could be their choice. They could force themselves.8:43So, but this guy has a harder time. He's not like anybody else.8:51But a person who's the opposite of this guy, that means what?8:55He's born with naturally good8:58midot, and it was very easy for him to do a lot of good things.9:01But he didn't want to do. He wanted to enjoy this world.9:04There's a lot of this world that could offer.9:09And this is what the Gemara means in9:11Masechet Sukkah that says in the future the tzaddikim will see a huge mountain,9:14and that will be the9:18yetzer hara. Who is that talking about?9:19That's talking about what the Gaon of Vilna calls the tzaddik9:23v'ra lo. That's a guy who was born with a very, very difficult9:27yetzer hara because he's born with a bad nefesh.9:29He looks at this big mountain. How was he able to accomplish it?9:32When Hashem takes off those bad midot from him, everything will be, he'll soar, right?9:37Okay, he brings a few more commentaries from different things, but we got the main idea.9:41I want to go to the paragraph that9:46says, you see where it says,9:50Vechatav b'Emunah ani v'rokev al hachamor. That's referring to Mashiach.9:52It's a pasuk in Zechariah that says,9:56and the Gemara explains that Mashiach is going to be a poor person riding on a donkey.10:01Good? So he explains this now:10:03Ani al haruach, an vatan ketargumo. Ani is referring to the person's ruach, the10:13middot. He's humble. V'gam b'peshuto, shehu tzaddik v'ra lo. And what it means also,10:16rochev al hachamor, right? If you want to ride, yeah, the easiest thing to ride is a horse.10:20You don't ride a donkey.10:21Donkey has his own brain, and that brain doesn't usually—he's a10:25chamor, okay? And it's very hard to control.10:28Ani v'rochev al hachamor says the Gaon miVilna is referring to a person who is a10:36tzaddik b'ma'asim, but he's born with the body of a10:39chamor, bad middot. The guf is not helping him,10:42literally working against what he wants to do.10:45Very, very big challenge and very difficult to maneuver.10:48There are some people born with sterling middot, wonderful middot.10:51They have a horse, very easy to run and jump10:53and places. Some people are born with cars.10:56And I'm saying, unbelievable,10:58they could just—you know, they're smooth. Everything is easy, Baruch Hashem.11:01Everyone has his own nisyonot. That's a11:03tzaddik v'ra lo, according to the Gra. One more paragraph:11:09V'neh hanefesh lefi hazman ufi leidato. So what determines now if born with good middot or not middot?11:12I want to stress again,11:14if a person is born with good middot or born with bad middot,11:17it doesn't mean he has a choice.11:18I mean, it doesn't mean he lost the choice to choose between good and evil.11:21You could force yourself, even with the bad middot,11:25if you're born with bad middot, to control the middot.11:29And like we said, the11:31Gaon miVilna explains it like riding a donkey.11:33You can maneuver it. It's very hard, but you can control it.11:36It's within your control.11:37And a person who has great11:40midot, he can also use his wonderful11:41midot, like let's say take a sweet guy,11:43very nice guy.11:44He can use his personality, his11:47charm, to, you know, sketch people, to rip off people,11:52and to manipulate people,11:54right? Because he wants things done and they'll go.11:57Sometimes you see that by ladies more,11:59right? Women who have like a wonderful charm,12:02chen, right? Chen is something given from12:04Hashem. Some ladies who have a12:06chen, and they know how to manipulate things to take it to their advantage,12:10that they should personally benefit from it,12:13and in a bad way we're talking about.12:14So that is, again,12:16doesn't mean just because you're born with good midot or bad12:18midot, you're automatically a tzaddik or12:20rasha. No, you have the right, you have the power to choose how do you want to maneuver it.12:23She says,12:24V'nei hanefesh. Now how would they determine if a person was born with good midot or bad12:30midot? The nefesh, lefi hazman u'kfi levadato. All depends on the time that he's born12:32and how he's born.12:38And, does that mean you have no choice in that?12:39He says, no.12:40You can control what time you can have it.12:42Doesn't mean birth,12:44right? Like12:46we learned already,12:48a person who is born even in a12:50mazal, you have control to choose whatever you like.12:52You could choose that what?12:54You could be a mohel,12:56you could be a12:57shochet, or you could be a12:59lestim. We saw that already,13:00right?13:01V'zehu v'chipshuha, and that's the meaning when Hashem gave the command to Adam Harishon.13:06He told him,13:07take over the world and capture it.13:09What does it mean, capture it?13:10It means capture your13:12yetzer hara. I gave you the power, the ability to control your13:18yetzer hara. V'chazakta v'hayita le'ish moshel, like the pasuk says,13:19you should be strong,13:20you should rule.13:30מקום מקום, אשת חיל עטרת בעלה, וקרני כעצמותיו מבישה. So second, להחם תמיד בא וכפום צערא אגרא, ולכן זכה דוד להיות משיח ה'. David HaMelech is a prime example.13:33He was born in Mazal13:35Maadim. He was also a redhead.13:37He had every single, you know, quality13:40or every single13:42midah to be a person who shofech damim.13:44And the Gemara says13:45even he was ready to kill Naval,13:47right?13:47He ruled that he should be dead,13:50and then13:51Avigail saved his life.13:52And there's a strange Gemara,13:53but we can explain according to this.13:54The Gemara says that13:56taba'ota, he wanted to be with her;13:57she was13:59nidah at the time, and she said,14:01you know, How can David HaMelech ask that?14:02And the answer is,14:03the Gemara is trying to tell you14:03that the midot of David14:05HaMelech were very, very hard to conquer.14:06He had midot that ran after horrible things,14:09but he was able to control and use it14:11in the right way.14:13So you have the choice.14:14Even though you're born with some difficult challenges in life,14:17but you have the choice to choose as you like.14:19Now,14:21we're... one time14:22I wanted to do one more paragraph,14:23but we're not going to have time,14:26ezrat Hashem. We'll continue the next paragraph next time.