Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 1, Lesson 7Sefer Even ShelemaPart 17Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:33Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:05Even Shelema, perek alef, ot zayin. Today we will speak about how a person works, or at least the direction he should plan to take in fixing his0:16midot. And we'll see some very, very important things,0:18and really this main thing over here is based on a pasuk in Mishlei that we all use as the foundation of0:26chinuch. Chinuch means raising our children in the right way.0:30That could be done in schools, that could be done in the homes, and in general you're dealing with anybody,0:35not only children, but it's just easier by children because children, you know, the pasuk says,0:42Ki ha'adam etz hasadeh. A man is like a tree.0:44If you look at a tree, really the difference between a tree and a plant is that a tree will basically just solid by itself0:53and just produces fruits every year.0:55The tree doesn't really change much.0:58Leaves will go on, leaves will go off, but pretty much it's the same routine. It keeps on going.1:03But a plant has to be replanted every single year.1:06Now, a human being, the Torah compares him to a tree,1:10Ki ha'adam etz hasadeh. And just like a tree, when it's young, you could see so much changes right in the beginning,1:17right? But after a while it gets to a certain age, and then the tree kind of stays the same.1:21Same thing with human beings.1:22When they're young, you see so much about the human beings.1:26They're so different.1:27Every day is another change in a kid's life.1:30For sure you see after every year,1:32not only physically, but even the way they mature, right?1:35You see very, very big difference in the beginning years of a person's life.1:39Once he gets married,1:41and then he gets to a certain point where he kind of like just, you know, he changes in the seasons here and there,1:47but otherwise he's pretty much the same person.1:49So by children, that's the best time to really shape them. And direct them in the right ways1:56because they are the most, or the effects on them to be the most visible and most effective in those prime years of their life.2:07So that's why chinuch is usually associated with children more than anybody else.2:11So we can see some very, very important things today on how a person works on his2:14middot. Let's read it inside.2:16He says like this:2:17Af mi shetiv'o ra. We said a person is born with a certain—the way2:20his middot are based on his physical makeup and everything else.2:23So we do see, yes, people that are heavier are usually lazier.2:28Usually.2:28Is that an exception?2:29There's exception.2:30But there are things that people are naturally born with,2:34naturally born with.2:34So even whose nature is naturally not so good, right?2:39He has a nature that's really bad middot.2:43Lo yelech neged hateva legamrei. And although we learn that you have to go against it, right,2:47in order to work you have to go to the other extreme against your bad2:51midah, the Gra says don't go 100% against it,2:55ki lo yitkayem. Because something that you're born with, an inherent2:59trait—remember we learned,3:00we learned that there's two types of middot that a person has:3:03a middah that you're born with and a middah that you develop over the years depending on who you hang out with and your surroundings,3:10right?3:11So it could be a person is, you know, it's funny,3:14my kids got this magazine, a Jewish magazine that's talking about billionaires,3:18and they have all different types of things and, you know, crazy, crazy things about billionaires.3:23If you're a millionaire, you don't make it to that, right?3:25It talks about only billionaires,3:27the 1% of the world,3:28okay?3:28And it talks about some people that are crazy, crazy money,3:31and they're, you know, like it says about the owner of IKEA.3:34He reuses tea bags.3:36He was driving until 2005 or3:41'07, he was driving a 1993 Volvo.3:44And when they told him, you know, why don't you get a new car?3:48Trust me, he can afford a new car, right?3:49The ... right?3:50Why don't you get a new car?3:51He says, It's working.3:53Who cares about the years?3:54It's working,3:55right?3:55There are people just like that, you know,3:58and those are rare.3:59But in general, people are, even if they're not spenders, when they start becoming billionaires4:05and they make a lot of money and they start hanging out with the rich and wealthy,4:09and even sometimes they're not billionaires, right,4:11they start getting to the habit of spending.4:14Good?4:14So those are developed4:16middot. We learned about that already.4:17So a person who is born with a teva that's bad,4:19he's born like that.4:20He's born as an angry, as a4:23hothead. He's born as lazy.4:24He's born as everything else.4:25He says,4:27Lo yelech neged teva legamrei. Yes, you do have to break your middot.4:30You do have to go against them, but not all the way against4:33it. Don't go head on completely all the way,4:37ki lo ... You will not be successful.4:40You have to use the nature that God has given you in a positive way.4:48Don't break it, but use it.4:49They say that4:52Rav Yitzchak Hutner, who used to be the Rosh Yeshiva of Chaim Berlin here in Brooklyn,4:55was a genius at figuring out people's talents and how to use them,5:00where, you know, most places, any institution, any school, any yeshiva, any organization, any army,5:06they have a certain cut.5:09You know, one of my rabbis calls the cookie bread man.5:13You know, you have to look this way,5:14you have to act this way, right?5:16Listen, I'm running an army over here.5:18Everybody's got to run this way.5:19If it doesn't fit your schedule, you make it fit your schedule.5:22And I'm running the situation, and I'm producing certain students, right?5:25If you're not into music and you come to my music school,5:28you gotta, you know, you gotta bend and mold yourself according to the way I want you to come out, right?5:34So Rabbi5:35Tzvi was—so in his yeshiva, actually, he was very talented in figuring out people's kochot, people's abilities,5:40and everybody had to be the same.5:42He was able to direct them using their abilities in a positive way.5:46Most yeshivot today model that same thing.5:49You know, not5:50every—yes, everybody has5:52chochmat hamit, hacham, and5:52yirat shamayim. That's the ikar of our lives.5:54But now, there are certain middot, there are certain people, you know,5:56this guy is good in5:57kiruv. He's a people's5:58person. He knows how to talk.5:59Or there's people that, you know, people trust him.6:01You know, this guy is good6:04in—this guy can learn all day.6:05Rav Chaim Kanievsky never gave a public speech in his life, right?6:08His nature is not that, but he's written so many sefarim.6:10You know, he's affected more people than those speakers, you know, that go around speaking.6:14So you have your nature and you work within your nature6:17how to, you know, direct in the right way.6:19So he gives a mashal:6:23Mishenolad b'mazal Maadim, who mukrach lihyot shofech dam. A person who's born in the mazal Maadim, Chazal tell us6:26it's called Maadim, right?6:28So he is, you know, born in a way that he will6:37spill blood. יש בידו להטפליות שוחט ובודק. One of the mezamnim here—you have, you're doomed to be a murderer?6:38And he says, no.6:40He can be a6:41shochet. If you're going to go against your nature6:44and you're going to become just a guy who distributes, you6:48know, food packages to the needy,6:50it's not going to be successful at the end.6:53But what you could do is you could be a6:55shochet, which is a regular guy, that's good,6:57or6:58מוהל שהוא צדיק, or you could be a mohel7:00and go and do brit milot,7:05ולא להיות לסטים. Instead of being a robber, a gangster.7:07V'zehu shekatuv, and that's the meaning in the pasuk,7:12חנוך לנער על פי דרכו. Train the child based on his way.7:17Why? גם כי יזקין לא יסור ממנה. Even when he gets older,7:18he won't go off of what you taught him.7:20A lot of times we get so disappointed.7:22We put so much investment7:23and we work and we work7:25directing children in a certain way,7:27and they get older,7:28they stray right off the path.7:31But the pasuk says,7:32but if you train him right,7:33he won't go off.7:34So what's going on?7:34I did train him.7:35My answer is maybe you did it,7:37but not7:38על פי דרכו. If you allow him to use his talents,7:40it's so comfortable using his talents.7:43It's kind of like,7:44you know, I once heard a beautiful mashal,7:46just to get an idea of what I'm talking about.7:48Imagine I would tell you right now,7:50okay, ready?7:51I want you to write for me your name.7:53How?8:00How easy is it to write your name? I know we all got used to typing, might be a little hard,8:03but could you please write your name on a piece of paper?8:06Everybody who's listening to this, just try it.8:08You can put pause. You guys can't put pause8:09who's listening live, but the ones who are listening, you can take a pause.8:12Go take a piece of paper and write now, write your name.8:16Good? How easy was that? Very easy.8:19If I would ask you to do this many times over, would it be easy? Would it be8:22fine? Yeah. Or if I tell you your success depends on how you write your name,8:26right? Much easier to do, no?8:28So now, okay, watch.8:32I'm doing the same thing now, just switch hands.8:35Put the pen in your left hand and write your name.8:37How comfortable is that? Not comfortable.8:40Try to do it again and again and again.8:42After a while, right?8:44If you're not forced to, if you're not forced to, if I tell you success depends on this,8:49you'll try very hard because you want to be successful, but at the end it's very uncomfortable.8:54You hate doing it over and over again.8:56You're gonna look for something else to be successful in8:59because it's against your nature. It doesn't fit with you.9:03If it doesn't fit with you, you always try to escape from it and go somewhere else.9:07Hanoch la na'ar al pi darko. If you train him based on his nature that he's,9:10you know, let's say take a person who, you know, can't sit still, right?9:14You try to force him to be that scientist in the lab working on something,9:18it's very difficult.9:19But if he's doing something where he's active and he's involved,9:22moving from place to place, yeah, he can be learning,9:25but let him be learning and let him be giving out speeches,9:28going and getting involved in different things.9:30That's, on his nature, he's much more comfortable,9:32it's much easier for him to stay on it.9:35He's not gonna look for different ways outside of it.9:38So that's the meaning over here of9:43hanoch la na'ar al pi darko, gam ki yazkin, even when he gets older, lo yasur mimena, he won't go off of it.9:45Let's see the פירוש, which, guess what,9:47is on the same pasuk. Of the9:50Gomel Venah, we're going to read the actual commentary of the9:52Gomel Venah. He says like this:9:53On the pasuk,9:56Hanochal na apidako, gam ki yaskin lo yasur mimena, the Gra says,10:00Ki ha'adam yefshar lo lishbor darko kelomar mezalo shenolad bo. A person can't break the mazal that you're born in.10:03Like it says in the Gemara,10:23Haiman de'mazalai, ki yegabar tzadkan. A person who's born in mazal of tzaddik, he'll be a tzaddik, a person who's doing tzedakot. And you see, there's certain people by nature, you know, just always giving, that's always doing mitzvot. U'shenolad b'mazal ra. What about if the guy is born in a bad mazal? Al zeh nitna bechirah b'yad ha'adam. So does that mean he's doomed?10:25Does that mean he has no choice?10:26He has to do10:27aveirot? The answer is no.10:29The answer is no.10:30He can do whatever he wants.10:31He's now given the choice.10:34You could use your mazal in any way that you want,10:40or tzaddik or rasha or beinoni. You could either be a tzaddik, using mazal in a positive way,10:43or you could be a wicked person,10:44or you could be an average person.10:46And the Gemara says, for example,10:49Haiman de'ma'adim, yihyeh shofech damim. A person who's born in mazal of10:52Ma'adim—this doesn't mean redhead.10:53People think, Oh, he's a redhead,10:54he must be.10:55That could be another sign,10:56but the mazal has an effect.10:58In mazal of10:59Ma'adim, then he's going to be a11:02shofech damim. Hach dabi. Well, he could choose to do it.11:04Either he could11:06be—the Rav Asher says—he could either be a mohel,11:07which he's doing it as a11:09tzaddik, or he could be a11:10shochet, which he's an average person,11:11he's doing his11:11parnassah, or, lestim, he could be a robber.11:17Vezachar elo shochef damim hu, lefi shemazalo moreh sheyihyeh shofech damim. Rav Asher mentioned these three options11:20because the person who's born in a mazal11:22that's Ma'adim, which means he's going to spill blood,11:26but he has the choice to decide11:28what kind of blood does he want to spill,11:44based on what he wants. He wants to spill the blood of mitzvah, or he wants to spill the blood of, lo aleinu, of innocent people and be a wicked person. Vezeh shene'emar—skipping—Vezeh shene'emar, Hanochal na apidako, derech mazalo. What's mean darko, according to the Gra over here?11:46It means his mazal, v'tivo, his nature,11:49ken tahanichehu la'asot mitzvot. That's how he's trained to do11:54mitzvot. Veaz, gam ki sheyaskin lo yasur mimena. Even when he gets older,11:55he won't go off of it.11:58Aba kesheta'avirehu hamazalo, when you make him go against his nature.12:04Atah yisma lacha miratotcha. Now he's going to listen to12:05you because he's scared of you.12:08But afterwards, he doesn't feel12:10that he needs you anymore.12:11By the way, today it's about the age of nine.12:14Yeshum zeh. Just go12:15home. He doesn't need you.12:16He is not scared of you.12:17Ki אי אפשר לשבור מזו. You can't break it.12:18As one therapist,12:20I heard it from her,12:21she said a beautiful idea.12:22She says,12:23I wear glasses12:25and my prescription is minus eight.12:28That's very bad,12:29okay?12:30She says,12:30My baby one time woke up in the middle of the night12:32and I had to make him a bottle,12:34and we were upstairs12:35and she had to go downstairs to the kitchen.12:37So I couldn't find my glasses,12:39and the baby was really, really crying.12:40So she went down12:42and she squinted,12:43and she was able to find where the bottle is,12:47and she knew an idea where the milk is,12:49and she squinted.12:50She was able to pick out the red milk12:51that the baby needs,12:52and she was able to make him a bottle.12:55She thought about it.12:56She said,12:57Wow, I don't need glasses.12:58I was able to see.12:59No?13:00I squinted and I was able to see.13:03She says,13:04Yeah, but the problem is13:04that can only last for a certain amount of time.13:07So somebody who sees her13:09in the middle of13:10the night says,13:10Ah, you don't need glasses.13:11Look, you're fine,13:13doesn't realize that13:14you're fine for that moment.13:16So same thing,13:16if you take a kid13:17and you push him in a certain way,13:18Look, he's doing it,13:20but if it's against his nature,13:22the question is not that,13:23oh, you know,13:24may work and may not. For sure not going to work.13:25The question is,13:26what is going to burst?13:27What is the can going to come out of the box,13:30as they say.