Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 1, Lesson 5Sefer Even ShelemaPart 15Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:43Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:00We're up to Eben Shelema, Perek Aleph,0:06Se'if Hey. Today's se'if is actually very short.0:09We'll see how much time it takes us,0:11because just because the words are short,0:13we've learned already that it doesn't go by the words.0:16It depends how, you know, how what we do.0:19In any case, so he says over here a very important thing.0:22He says,0:23Hamiddot hem lefi teva haguf vehanefesh. The middot are based on a person's physical makeup, the body, and his nefesh,0:34what we call already the spiritual makeup.0:39Umishtanim lefi ma'asehem begilgul rishon, and they are different0:42based on—that means each person is, based on his actions even in previous0:48gilgulim, will be different from somebody else.0:50Like we said already in the past,0:51not everybody's middot will be exactly the same,0:54which is one of the reasons why the Gra explains0:56why we don't have any command in the Torah about how to have certain middot,1:02because when it comes to mitzvot, there's an exact measurement.1:06And I mean to say, when it comes to sukkah,1:10there's a measurement. There's a minimum of what the size of a sukkah:1:13seven by seven tefachim by ten tefachim high.1:18That's how it's got to be.1:20There's a certain measurement.1:21Whether the guy is big or whether the guy is small,1:23it doesn't make a difference. That's the measurement of the sukkah,1:26and everybody has one standard measurement.1:28And when the Gemara says that somebody suggests a different measurement based on the person,1:33the Gemara will say,1:35Natata d'varecha l'shiurim. We can't do that when it comes to1:37mitzvot. There's a specific measurement that we all have to follow.1:39If it's a kezayit or whatever it may be,1:41we follow the1:43basic—you know, there's one measurement for everybody.1:46There's one standard for everybody.1:49When it comes to middot,1:51you can't have a command in the Torah on it,1:53because it will be different based on each person.1:57As the Gra is saying over here,1:59it could be a person's makeup, a person's middot,2:01are based on the physical makeup and the spiritual makeup as well.2:06Vema'asim hem lefi haruach. The ma'asim of a person is based on the ruach that he has.2:09So we never discussed this in this class, at least.2:13But it's worth it maybe to mention it over here,2:16is that the2:18Gra, whose commentary, or at least the2:20Even Shelema, comes from the Gra's commentary all over Shas.2:23I mean all over Shas and all over the Torah,2:25and also in commentaries he has also on the Zohar.2:28So because this piece that we're learning right now2:31comes from his commentary on the Zohar,2:33we want to just introduce a concept to go down the Shaar HaGilgulim.2:37We're also here with the makeup of a2:40person, and that is there's the physical and there's the spiritual.2:43We call guf and neshama.2:45What most people may not know,2:47I mean maybe the people who are listening to this class,2:49at least they've been with us long enough,2:51maybe they will know by now,2:52but most people out there,2:54even if there are people who do know about the neshama, about the soul,2:56don't know that the soul itself is actually made up of five parts.3:00And the five parts of the soul have five different names.3:03They are called nefesh, ruach, neshama, chaya, and3:10yechida. Rashei teivot: Naran3:13Chai. So if this is the first time you're hearing this,3:15it might sound very, very confusing.3:16If not the first time and you've heard this many times from us,3:19so it's easy, it's a nice review.3:21But let's repeat what their names are again:3:24nefesh, ruach, neshama, chaya, and3:28yechida. I've said them in this specific order because3:30that order actually is the highest level.3:34It goes from the lowest level to the highest level based on these names.3:37These are parts of the neshama.3:39We've discussed in the past that the lowest part,3:41which is called the nefesh,3:43the lowest part of the soul,3:44that's where the midot are.3:46So he's telling you over here the following,3:48that since the midot are based on the person's nefesh,3:51so we said spiritual part,3:52but it means the lowest part of the spiritual part.3:54That's what connects the body to the other four spiritual parts,3:58which is what the mitzvot, what connects to the4:02mitzvot. So he's telling you the midot are from the nefesh,4:06the ma'asim, the actions a person does.4:08That means when you fix, when you keep on doing4:11mitzvot, you learn Torah and everything else,4:12so you're affecting the other four parts of the neshama.4:15That lowest part of the four parts is called the ruach.4:18So he says,4:22he compares it, he gives a beautiful4:26mashal. An animal by nature is what? Is instinctive.4:31It doesn't have choices.4:34It doesn't make choices.4:36It just does what it feels.4:38And even more so, animals that are made to be in the wild.4:43So a horse is an example of where you have a physical entity, an animal,4:49it does whatever it wants.4:51But if you have a person riding it,4:53you could direct the horse wherever you want.4:56So he says, just like we know a rider is able to control the horse5:01to go in a straight line,5:03to run where he wants,5:04to run5:05marathons—to, not marathons, but, you know, to go into contests,5:07to jump over things,5:09right? He can do it.5:11But if he's a wild horse,5:13so you need then a little bit harder work.5:18You know, the trained horses,5:19if you get yourself a professional horse,5:21these are horses that are,5:26you know, that are a high breed. You know, they spend like tons of money on them,5:28especially in the Middle East,5:30right? So these kind of horses,5:32they raise them very well.5:34I don't know if they educate them,5:35but they do a lot of things to them5:37that make them those types of horses.5:40So he's telling you5:41these kind of horses are easy to ride.5:43They're easy to direct.5:45But if you get a wild horse,5:46much harder to direct.5:47But it could be done,5:49right? You might have to train it much more.5:53You might have to discipline yourself5:54and discipline it much more,5:56but you could get it to do it.5:58He says,6:01We said that your midot are what?6:04Your midot are based on what kind of soul you have.6:07So he says,6:08even by nature you have bad6:12midot, right? And you're able, you're able to still control it.6:16How?6:16On the6:18ruach, the ruach of the person,6:20which is the6:22ma'asim, the actions that he does from the Torah.6:24That means the mitzvot that he does,6:26that if you— Charge up your6:30ruach, you could control your nefesh.6:33It's an unbelievable idea.6:35Through the Torah,6:36we've always spoken about,6:38or we've heard so many times from6:41Chazal that tell us that the neshama, or excuse me, that the mitzvot could change a6:46person. You could work on your middot6:48and you could change yourself through the mitzvot,6:49through the study of Torah6:50you could change.6:51Yeah, how does that work?6:54Because your study of the Torah6:56or your mitzvot that you keep6:58are from the four higher spiritual parts of the soul,7:02and you could change your middot also that way,7:05just like the middot could affect the fulfillment of the mitzvot.7:09We said people have bad middot7:10have a very hard time to keep the mitzvot,7:12and people with good middot7:13have a very easy time to keep mitzvot.7:14It works also vice versa,7:17that if you keep the mitzvot,7:18even with bad middot,7:20you can make it much easier7:22to work on your middot now.7:23People who learn Torah a lot7:25and see it tremendously,7:26you see people who have certain,7:28you know, when they're not religious,7:30they have a certain nature,7:31very wild.7:32They become religious,7:33they start keeping mitzvot,7:35then7:36all of a sudden7:37slowly they become more refined7:38and it becomes easy for them to work on the7:40middot, if it's anger,7:42if whatever it may be.7:47That is what the Gra is explaining over here in this concept,7:51that the mitzvot that are done through the—8:00Ruach could help influence the person's midot, which are in the part of the so-called the nefesh.8:10Okay? Now, on the bottom over here, we have a little bit of a note.8:14He says, in yud chet over here, he says,8:18This is not the word. We're not reading the words of the Gra now,8:22but we're reading the words of the person who put the book together.8:24And he's saying a very important idea.8:26He says this idea is taken from the Gra's commentary here, and later on8:31it's taken from the Gra's commentary on Zohar.8:33He said, The yesod ha'inyan hu, the basic idea is the following:8:39Shemidotim teva ha'guf ve'nefesh ba'adam. A person's midot come naturally to a person based on the makeup of his body and his soul.8:47Ve'yesh asher nolad b'mezeg tov midotav v'teva hem tovim. There are some people who are naturally good8:49midot, and you see them. There's some people just8:51adamy, just nice, not because they learned it.8:53They're just naturally nice,8:55right?8:57Ve'yesh asher nolad b'mezeg ra'a midotav. There's some people you see,8:59they're bad, bad9:00midot. They're just all the time looking to blame everybody else.9:03They talk so much,9:04and they're always running after9:07their ta'avot. So they're just naturally bad9:09midot. They're always angry.9:11How does that happen?9:14Why, it's not fair.9:15Why am I born with a bad midah and he's born with a good9:18midot, right?9:18And the answer is, he says, it's based on his previous gilgul.9:21In your previous gilgul, maybe you were not such a good person,9:26so you came back with these natural bad midot because you're not such a good person.9:32But don't think that just because I'm born with such bad midot, it takes away my freedom of choice.9:37No, that's not true.9:42Every single person could overcome that natural... The character traits that he has, and change them,9:51and to do good deeds.9:55And God does not judge you on the natural way that you are;10:00He judges you based on your actions.10:02So if you have good midot, there's more that's expected of you.10:04We said this so many times in the past.10:06We said it in Sefer10:07Ahavat Chesed a lot,10:08that a person who makes billions of dollars with a B,10:13okay, not10:14T-R, with a B,10:15and not M either,10:16with the millions of dollars today, you may be able to survive.10:19But with billions of dollars, you're considered a rich guy.10:22If you make billions of dollars, you're expected to give much more than 20%.10:27You're not expected to just give,10:29and not only that, if you don't give that amount, you're held accountable,10:32and God, you know, will hold you accountable and judge you for it10:37based on10:38why, because you have much more.10:39So a guy who was born with good midot, more is expected of him.10:43And a guy who was born with bad midot, it's like the guy who, he's an10:46ani, and he only makes, you know, barely just to survive.10:50So if he gives tzedakah, and he pushes himself to give10:53tzedakah, obviously God will judge it based on the way he himself is, what's it called, working on himself.11:01And that's what he's saying over here:11:05Lo ha-midrash ikar, ela ha-maaseh. Chazal tell us in Pirkei Avot,11:07it's not the speech rather than the11:08maaseh. What does that mean?11:09That means all the reward is based on how much effort he put.11:13The last Mishnah in the fifth perek of Pirkei Avot says,11:22Lefum tza'ara agra. What does it mean, lefum tza'ara agra? Based on the effort is how much you get your reward,11:25because not everybody is born equal.11:27Everybody is born differently,11:28and based on previous gilgulim or whatever it is,11:31and God judges you based on the actions,11:33how much effort you put in,11:35that's how much.11:36But you could change even the things that you're born with. Baruch... amen v'amen. Say not what your body could.