Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 1, Lesson 2Sefer Even ShelemaPart 12Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:05Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01In perek alef, se'if bet in Eben Shelema,0:08today we're going to talk about how important it is for a person to work on his0:14midot. We're going to read the words of the Eben Shelema, the summary,0:17and then we'll see the Gra's peirush on Tehillim,0:21and also from his letter, and from Mishlei as well.0:26We'll see his peirush of how he speaks about how important it is for a person to work on0:31musar. Pay attention to the words:0:33'Ikar chayut ha'adam hu lechazek tamid0:38bishvirat hamidot.' The main purpose of a person's life is that he should always strengthen himself.0:45That means always work on himself to break0:49midot. 'Ve'im lo, and if he doesn't do this, if he is not working on himself to break the bad habits that he has,0:56'lama lo chayim?' What's the purpose of him having life?1:00Those are strong words.1:01Now let's see the actual words of the Gra and his commentary on1:08Mishlei. Mishlei, as we know, is a book that's written by1:11Shlomo HaMelech that's full of musar, full of words of how a person should work on himself,1:17of directs a person should go in his life.1:20On the pasuk that Shlomo HaMelech says,1:23'Hachazek bamusar'—these are the words not of the Gra; these are the words of1:31Shlomo HaMelech. It's a pasuk, 'Hachazek bamusar.' Hold on strongly to the musar,1:36'al teref'—don't let go.1:39'Nitzreha'—guard it, 'ki hi chayecha,' for it is your life.1:41This is the pasuk that Shlomo HaMelech tells us.1:43Comes the Gra, and he gives commentary.1:46He says, pay attention to the words1:47about that; this is powerful:1:48'Echozet hamusar'—hold on to musar.1:53'Shetachalta bo'—start working on yourself.1:58V’hitchazek et atzmecha b’musar, and strengthen yourself in musar.2:01Keep on working more and more on yourself in directing yourself.2:05Musar. Now, we want to define what musar is, because a lot of people don’t know.2:09There’s a study of musar.2:11We all know what that is.2:12It’s not Jewish philosophy.2:14Musar is actually the right way a person should direct himself.2:20Mitzvot, we know, is an action.2:22Musar is not just an action, but a lifestyle.2:26It’s the working on your character traits,2:29how one should behave and one should think,2:32and this is what musar teaches us.2:34So he’s telling you right now,2:37hold on to musar, don’t let go of it.2:42Afilu l’fisha achat, al tefet achazek b’musar. On the words of Shlomo HaMelech, it says2:44the Gra, even for one small time, even for a moment of time,2:48don’t let go of it.2:50Don’t let go from the study of musar.2:56Always add on fences,2:59always add more things upon yourself3:01for the sake of musar,3:02that you shouldn’t even come to let go of it even for a little bit.3:06Why?3:09Ki hu chayecha, the pasuk says, because it’s your life.3:11And now the Gra says his powerful words:3:17Ki ma sheha’adam chai hu kedei l’sbor mida shelo shava ad hena. Because the reason why a person is alive in this world,3:20Hashem gave him life in this world,3:21is in order to break the bad trait that he didn’t break till now.3:27And that’s why Shlomo HaMelech is telling you,3:29you got to hold on and you got to strengthen yourself with musar.3:33V’im lo yitchazek, and if one who doesn’t strengthen himself3:35in musar, lama lo chayim? What’s the purpose of having life at all?3:40So this is the famous words of the3:43Gra, and this is what we said3:47over here in Even Shelema: Ikar chayut ha’adam hu l’hitchazek tamid bishvil haTalmudot. The main purpose of a person’s life3:50is to always strengthen himself in breaking his3:52middot. V’im lav, lama lo chayim, and if not, why do you have life?3:54I want to read for you another... Statement from the3:58Gra. This comes from the letter of the4:00Gra, Iggeret HaGra. It would be quoted a lot.4:02Iggeret HaGra was a letter that the Gra wrote to his family,4:04kind of like a last will and testament.4:06So in there he writes the following:4:16The Gaon of Vilna is telling us something here, something amazing.4:19He says this is the whole purpose of a person's life,4:22from the time he's born until the time he dies,4:25that he must go through suffering.4:29But the suffering is not through fasting4:31or putting yourself in painful situations.4:34No, that's not how it works.4:36The suffering comes by sealing your mouth shut4:40and controlling your desire.4:41We all know that when we have something to say4:44and we want to say it back,4:45you know, somebody says something,4:47you know, sometimes people tell us off,4:49and they tell us like something4:50and they say,4:51Oh, you, you hypocrite.4:52Meanwhile, we know that they're hypocrites,4:54and we know how to answer back.4:56We know how to get them back.4:57And we could get them back,4:59and we'll put them in their place.5:01This is the time where a person is supposed to5:03know, is that the way Hashem wants me to act?5:06Now, there's no mitzvah directly,5:08but it's not proper to go down to the person's level.5:11I like to quote a friend of mine5:13in high school. He used to say,5:15Don't argue with a loser5:16because he'll bring you down to his level and beat you.5:18You know, when you argue with a person who has bad5:22midot, you're gonna have to go down to their level,5:25and even if you go down to their level,5:26they're gonna kill you5:27because they're horrible5:29in their midot, and then you could get so badly affected from it.5:33So there's no point of getting down to a person's level.5:35Keep that in mind.5:37Whenever you get into such a discussion with somebody5:40and you feel that they're gonna have to pull you down5:42because you want to show that you're right.5:45Keep in mind,5:46it's more important to do what Hashem thinks is right.5:49It's more important to work on your musar.5:51Not only more important, that's the whole purpose of life.5:53And even if they think you're wrong,5:55but that's where your test is in life.5:59That's one area,5:59and the other area is ta'avot and desires.6:02Imagine, right?6:03You get a food,6:04you pay for it,6:06you come to sit down6:07at the buffet to eat,6:08and then you realize that the food is not according to your kosher standard.6:12It's kosher, but it's not according to your6:13standard. You're starving,6:15right?6:15Controlling6:16that self-control is unbelievable there.6:18And this can apply in many areas of6:21ta'avot, and we'll discuss them more and more as we go on.6:23But that brings a lot of6:24suffering. You really want to.6:26It's kind of like you're at a wedding6:27or at a barbecue.6:28You forgot to eat beforehand,6:30and you go there6:30and you know that the meat is shady,6:33not something your rabbi recommends.6:35And now you sit there,6:37you're nervous,6:38should I eat, should I not?6:39And you know you're not going to eat,6:40but, like, it's so painful.6:42Everybody's enjoying,6:43and it really smells great,6:44but you're controlling yourself.6:46That kind of suffering,6:48that's the musar.6:49So the word musar over here6:50seems like from the6:51Gra; he's explaining from the word6:54yisurim. Yisurim, we know, means inflictions and pains.6:57V'zehu ha-teshuvah, says the6:59Gra. This is the7:01teshuvah. V'zeh kol peri ha'olam haba, and this is the whole benefits of7:05olam haba. That means, we all know that we're investing7:08in this world. We do a lot of things7:10that are difficult for us,7:12but it's an investment7:13because later on,7:15in olam haba, we will be able to7:18reap and eat the benefits from this world.7:21So he's telling you7:23the peri of olam haba is7:27this. You want to know what your reward is based on7:29from all these things.7:31Like it says in the pasuk,7:33Ki ne'eman me'od torah or. A mitzvah will give you a flame,7:37a candle,7:38will give you a light,7:39as powerful as a candle.7:41Torah will give you tremendous light,7:43but the pasuk continues and says,7:46V'derech chayim tocha'at musar. But the way of life,7:48which life?7:48The life of7:50Olam Haba, is tocha'at musar.7:54V'zehu yoter mikol hata'anitim v'sigufim ba'olam. And this is more valuable.8:00Valuable. This has so much more value than all the fasts and all the sufferings in the world.8:06It's an amazing statement.8:07We know we fast because we have to fast.8:09The things the Chazal are telling for us to fast, we must fast.8:13The kaporah is coming up,8:16that's min haTorah, some Gedolei Yisrael, miderabanan. We must fast during those days.8:18But a lot of people, when they, you know, they want to fast, they want to bring upon themselves suffering8:23because they feel it's going to atone for their8:24sins. The Gra is telling you, you know, if you're fasting but you're rude and getting angry,8:31and you're just letting your bad middot take over,8:33because especially when you fast you're much more moody and everything else,8:36so then it's not worth it.8:38It's much worse to do that.8:40It's more worth it: eat and control yourself.8:44Sit and learn and don't say a word.8:46Sit in tefillah and seal it, shut it.8:49Go to work and stick to your work.8:52Don't answer other people.8:54Don't comment back when your husband or wife tells you something.8:58That's9:00tochachat musar. That's musar. It brings suffering.9:02I can answer back,9:03but you're controlling yourself.9:04That kind of suffering is what will get you to9:08Olam Haba. One more statement I want to bring also from the9:11Gra, and he brings over here9:13a pasuk in9:15Mishlei, perek yud, pasuk yud-zayin. It says,9:17Orach lachayim shomer musar. The path for life is one who guards9:22musar, says the9:28Gra. The Gra says, I already explained to you9:30that musar means when a person inflicts himself with suffering.9:35What does that mean?9:36Like we said, not fasting,9:38but the suffering means from controlling yourself9:41not to go after your desires9:42or to just do whatever you want to do.9:46And a person is always careful to make sure9:50that yetzer tov overpowers9:58the yetzer hara, veshomer musar, hainu mi sheyir'eh leyaser et atzmo, veyargiz yetzer tov al yetzer hara, af al pi sheyesh lo yisurim mizeh. A person who guards10:01musar, that the pasuk says, right?10:03Shomer musar, you have to guard musar. Who's a person who guards10:06musar? He makes sure that the yetzer tov always wins the10:10yetzer hara. Even though he might suffer from it,10:13he knows that if I take this deal,10:17it'll be shady.10:19I might find some room in halacha, ta'ut goy and everything else,10:22but it's not the best way.10:24It's running after my desires.10:26I'm gonna not take it.10:28But then I'm gonna have to work harder in a different area.10:31That's a person who lets the yetzer hatov win over his10:35yetzer hara. And this way,10:37zehu sheyavo le'olam haba. In this way, it's gonna be for sure that he gets to the ways of life,10:42which is olam haba.10:51כי אור החיים אינו בא אלא על ידי יסורים. כמו שכתוב: ודרך חיים תוכחות מוסר, ומנו על זה שעולם הבא אינו בא אלא על ידי יסורים. Chazal tell us that three gifts Hashem gave to the Jewish people:10:55Eretz Yisrael, Torah, and olam haba.10:59And they only come through11:00yisurim. They only come through11:01yisurim. Simple translation is they only come through suffering.11:04The Gra is explaining to you that suffering,11:07yisurim, is the same word as11:09musar. In fact, the Maharal says the same thing in his introduction to his commentary on Pirkei Avot,11:14is that suffering doesn't have to be through suffering that Hashem sends upon a person,11:19like sicknesses, lo aleinu, or loss of money.11:22No.11:22Yisurim from the word11:24musar. He controls himself.11:26He directs himself in a certain way that, you know, it's painful.11:31Other people can't do it.11:32You know, they look at you and say,11:32How in the world could you do it?11:34But that's the way a person gets to olam haba.11:38That's the yisurim, according to the11:40Gra. That's the yisurim that the Gemara is talking about.11:42It's the self-infliction upon yourself11:45when you choose not to go on a certain path that everybody's running afterwards,11:48because you know the Torah doesn't let it.11:51Controlling your mouth,11:52controlling your desires,11:54controlling your anger,11:55controlling your speech,11:57all of these things are— Bring something to my person,12:00but they'll also bring life in Olam Haba to the person.