Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 1, Lesson 14Sefer Even ShelemaPart 24Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:19Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:02Emen shalema, perek alef, today is a little bit shorter, and the next one is a little long.0:08The next one finishes the perek, so let's see how fast we get through this one.0:11Maybe we'll do Yudalet as well, but don't count on it. Let's begin.0:18Af al פי שאמרו, the Gemara Masechet Bava Batra says, and this is one halacha I brought down in Hilchot Lashon Hara, lo yechadedem bishvacho shel chaveiro, shemitoch shevacho ba lidei genuto. A person should not praise of his friend. Why?0:29Because once you start talking about his praise, you'll eventually come lidei genuto. You'll eventually come to put him down.0:35For example, if you start saying, Wow, what a great guy this guy is. Wow, he's so wonderful,0:40da da da, right? After a while, us as human beings, we, you know, can only handle so much,0:46so then we start all of a sudden saying, Yeah, but you know what?0:49He is great, but he's not so great in this area and this other area,0:53and then all of a sudden the genut comes out.0:58Makom makom, however, mi shemefursam b'midot tovot, says the Gra, a person who's mefursam, who is known to have exemplary midot, he's unbelievable,1:08he's great with his midot, ad רבה, ra'ui leshabecho. It's ra'ui to praise1:10him. What do you mean? The Gemara says not.1:13No,1:16ra'ui, shebazeh lo shayach shemitoch shevacho ba lidei genuto. Being that he has good midot, you won't come to see, you won't come to hear any bad about him.1:23Isn't that an amazing thing?1:24The guy who has good midot, very good midot, very hard to find something bad about him.1:30Why?1:31Shehakol meshabchin oto, v'af echad yomar alav devar genai lo imenuhu. And even if somebody opens his mouth, hey, but what are you talking about?1:36But see, over here, the problem is he has to have good middot everywhere.1:39Some people are very nice people1:41when it comes to business; they're business people.1:44So they're not the nicest people.1:46So a guy would say, What a nice host,1:49and a very nice guy. He's a great host.1:51But in business, we see how he is with his workers, right?1:54He yells at them.1:54It's very hard to really, because he doesn't have good middot all the way.1:57Good middot means in every area he has good middot, very hard to put him down.2:03So, and if somebody does put him down, it's very hard to be believed also.2:08So according to the Gra, it's a big chiddush, because he's coming to tell you that what?2:13We know that this is called avak2:15lashon hara. For those who remember the halachot of2:18lashon hara, avak lashon hara is when you say something that could cause other2:21people—not now, avak lashon hara is much bigger;2:23it's a whole perek on avak2:24lashon hara. One of the halachot is kind of like2:27derabanan: you're not allowed to say something that could put another person in the position to speak2:31lashon hara. Speaking good about somebody, praising somebody, or overpraising somebody,2:35it doesn't come out that somebody is going to knock him.2:37So the Gra is telling you, big2:40chiddush, not a problem.2:40You can say it.2:41If a person is known to have mefursam, known to have unbelievable middot,2:46you could say about him.2:48Very hard to find something bad about him.2:50Let's see the source of this.2:53It comes from the Kitav Yad,2:57the—what do you call3:00it?—the handwritten writings of the Gra, which means they were not published necessarily,3:04and says on the3:05Gemara—he writes it based on the3:07Gemara—he says,3:09Man deshapir shma'anei, shari lishabchuei. A person who has a good reputation,3:13you're allowed to praise him.3:14What is that talking about?3:18Says the Gra, hu bemiddot tovot shehakol meshabchin oto. That's talking about a person who has good middot.3:20Everybody praises a guy who has good middot,3:22like it says,3:27Ve'ahavta et Hashem Elokecha, and the Gemara explains in Yoma, sheyehei shem Shamayim mitahem al yadecha, that Shem Shamayim should become beloved through you.3:31How is that? What does that mean?3:33That means that when you have great3:37midot and people look at you3:38and you're a person representing Hashem,3:39wow,3:40they say,3:41This is a man of God,3:44you know, and they start praising you.3:45Vehi midat tiferet, and that's what we call tiferet,3:48as the Rabbi says, Rabbi Yehuda Nasi says in the beginning of Masechet Pirkei Avot, in the second perek,3:53he says like this:3:59איזהו מידרך ישרה שיבור לו האדם? כל שהיא תפארת לעושיה ותפארת לו מן האדם. It's something4:00that's—what's tiferet?4:01It's something that brings pride,4:03not pride,4:04gaavah, but people are proud.4:06Wow,4:07such a good person,4:09right?4:10And that's the midah of having good4:13midot. When you have good4:14midot, everybody will praise you.4:16And the Gemara says,4:18according to the4:18Gra, I guess he's explaining like this:4:20if the Mishnah says that4:23there's4:25תפארת לו מן האדם, that people give him praise for it,4:27if you have4:29the derech yesharah, then he has, you know, tiferet,4:31he has good praise from it.4:32How can it be that people can praise him?4:33Isn't the Gemara saying that you're not allowed to praise him?4:35So it must be,4:36the Gra is explaining,4:37that it's talking about a guy who has good4:40midot, and then he's coming, and now he's coming,4:41and then that person,4:45you could come and give him a praise,4:47because when you give him a praise,4:49nobody will say something bad4:50and you won't fall into the pit of the Gemara.4:52Go to the bottom.4:54He has the notes over here on the bottom,4:57right?4:59He brings a little bit of a contradiction,5:01a little bit, from other places of the5:03Gra, because it says over here5:05that first he brings Rabbeinu Yonah5:07on Shaarei Teshuvah. What does Rabbeinu Yonah say in5:09Shaarei Teshuvah? He says that5:14שאל יספרו בשבחו, היינו בקהל עם. According to the Rabbeinu Yonah, one of the Rishonim,5:18when it says don't speak about the praise of another person,5:21it means b'kahal am.5:23It doesn't mean in private;5:24it means in public.5:28ומאושר רבי... שידע שאין שם שונאים, כנאה לאישו, until you know very well5:30that whoever you're speaking about...5:33In front of the whole group,5:34you know that everybody in that group,5:36nobody dislikes him.5:39Everybody is either part of him or likes him.5:48And if a person wants to praise somebody5:52who everybody knows he has a5:55chazakah that he is a person who is a adam kasher5:56and he has nothing bad about him,5:59then even in front of his enemy you could praise him,6:03כי לא יוכל לגנותו, because6:06you can't put him down.6:13... asher piv deber shav, ותהי לשונו מוקש לנפשו. Rabbeinu Yonah seems to say the same thing also6:15as the Gra.6:17Now over here he says,6:18in the bottom,6:21you see what it says?6:24וזה לשון רבינו יונה. The Gra, in his famous letter that he wrote6:26to his family,6:28which he told them, Live by this6:30letter and make sure you follow every thing, he says over there,6:37... The main thing you have to6:39keep in mind, when speaking about somebody else,6:40he's telling his family how to avoid lashon hara,6:42he tells them,6:43Don't speak about any person's praise,6:47... don't put anybody down.6:55... Person who speaks too much,6:57you're eventually going to come into a pit.6:59You're going to dig a hole.7:01And then what usually happens7:02when you praise7:04somebody, right, somebody's going to knock him down.7:05What happens when they knock him down?7:07You're going to try to defend.7:08Every time you try to defend, it gets worse.7:11They start to knock more and7:13more, right? It's kind of like that joke,7:16you know, the guy says,7:17I'm going to...7:23He says, I'm gonna, you know, the guy says, I'm gonna break this.7:25I'm so upset.7:26So his wife says,7:28Oh, please, no, no, no, don't get angry.7:31Come on, don't go break the vase7:32now. I'm gonna break the vase now. Oh no, come on, if you break the vase,7:34don't break the coffee table.7:36I'm gonna break the coffee table also.7:38Oh no, if you break the coffee table, you're not gonna rip the walls.7:40I'm gonna rip the walls also,7:42right? That's how, you know, that's what happens7:43when you start giving mussar to a person.7:46He's such a wonderful person.7:47No, he's not. He's a7:49ganav. No, he's not a ganav. You see how he gives7:51tzedakah? Yeah, of course. When he steals from everybody,7:53he gives a lot of7:56tzedakah. Oh no, he doesn't steal from everybody. Oh, come on.8:00Let me tell you about this guy. Every time he tries to defend, it becomes another, like, fuel, right, for the person to attack him.8:09You're just giving the guy ammunition to attack him even more.8:12So therefore, the Gra in his letter says, stay away from the shevah person.8:16If you're going to give shevach according to halacha, now that's the Gra's advice to his family.8:20It's not a halacha that he wrote down; that was his advice to his family.8:23But when it comes to halacha, Chafetz Chaim brings down there's two levels.8:27Number one is you're not allowed to overpraise somebody,8:32right? Number two is that when you come to praise someone, like the way over here,8:38Ben Yehoyada brings down, if you know one person over there that's not going to like him,8:42you're not allowed to say anything.8:43Now, if he's so mefursam, if he's so known, and you know that everything that you say about him will be taken,8:51everybody will—you talk about Mashiach over here, you talk about the great tzaddik, then fine.8:54But it's very hard to find such a person, unfortunately. Not because such a person doesn't exist,9:00because in the world that we live in today, there's always some shmutz.9:04There's always people that are always making up stories. Whether it's true or not, we don't know.9:09And especially, unfortunately, most of the time it's not true.9:13People who are jealous, people who are, what's it called, can't stand even9:18tzaddikim will always find a pick on things and they'll knock him down.9:21Especially when our exposure to these tzaddikim is not limited to just Jewish exposure.9:27You have the news, whether it's Israeli news or even American news.9:33I'll give you just an example how they always twist things to make it look so bad.9:37A few years ago, us, for us who understand the value of Torah and understand that the whole world stands on Torah,9:44and we understand that the hatzlachah of the Jewish people is on Torah, and not only that,9:47the protection of the Jewish people throughout the whole world is on9:49Torah. So a few years ago, they, you know, they're still fighting this all the time,9:54they were coming out with, what's it called, in Israel, they were deciding to cancel the law.10:00Now, when a state was established— Ben Gurion met with the Chazon Ish.10:06The Chazon Ish was the gadol hador, and he was recognized as the gadol hador10:10and was not a safek. It was hands down, he was a gadol hador in10:16Eretz Yisrael. He was living in Bnei Brak, and Ben Gurion, who was establishing the state, came to the Chazon Ish.10:20He figured, you know, he'll get the charedim along with him.10:23So one thing that Chazon Ish told Ben Gurion, he says,10:27The success of the Jewish people throughout all these thousands of years was not because of the State of Israel.10:31Now you're trying to create it now. Most of our history, we lived outside of Israel.10:34The remaining Jews are left from all whatever is left over is because we had the Torah.10:40Make sure you don't take out yeshiva bachurim from the yeshivot.10:43Make sure they continue to learn Torah. And he agreed to it.10:46And that's why the law in Israel was that anybody who is in yeshiva is exempt from going to the army.10:54So a few years ago, they tried to, you know, they're still working on removing that law.10:58No, everybody must serve the army. As we all know, in Israel, everybody has to serve the army.11:02Now, happens to be a lot of secular people also figure out a way to get out of it, right?11:06But the law is in the Knesset is that if you're in yeshiva, you're patur from serving in the11:11army, okay? So they tried to, what's it called, do, what's it called, they tried to remove it.11:16So in America, so they made a Yom Tefillah.11:20They went to the city, they blocked off maybe I don't know how many streets,11:24they closed it off, and all the yeshiva guys from America over here, like in New York City,11:29Mir Yeshiva, all of us, we all went, and we went to say something Tehillim.11:34It was a public thing to say Tehillim.11:35One of the gedolim got up and he said Tehillim,11:39and everybody ran after that. Just Yom Tefillah. Good? Sounds very good and worthy cause.11:43What is a newspaper report?11:46Ultra-Orthodox, that's what they call us, right?11:49Ultra-Orthodox Jews gather in New York City to pray that other kids...11:56That the other people, that the other Jewish people's kids should die in the army, not theirs.12:03You like that headline?12:07They pray that their kids shouldn't die in the army, only other kids should die in the army.12:13Okay, so here's a person who12:15doesn't. So now, a guy who's parv, he's not, you know, he keeps Shabbat, but he likes to follow the news.12:22What does he read?12:25Disgusting.12:26This is horrible, right?12:27So because of that—now this is just one example12:30that I know. I was there, I was on the Yom Tov, and I saw the headline, right?12:35So, but what happens is, the reality is that's what happens,12:38that people are like that, and people hear the news from non-kosher sources.12:43So really, even about the greatest12:46tzaddik, there's always something that they're going to knock him with.12:49So to say the praise of anybody, really, you got to always be careful.12:52You got to check yourself a few times.12:54Say a good, you know, a very specific point that that's very clear, and move on.12:58But speak over shevach, even about the Gedolim, unfortunately,13:01not because they don't exist.13:03We have13:06great Gedolim. Not because they don't exist; they do exist.13:08But unfortunately, people hear the shekarim and the13:11chazakim and the twisted things about them, it's going to cause them to knock.13:14So you got to be careful when you speak.