Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 1, Lesson 11Sefer Even ShelemaPart 21Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0013:55Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Perek Alef, ot Yud Alef in0:06Even Shelema. It's a very, very important concept that he brings over here, they're all important.0:10Maybe we'll just do half; it's a big piece,0:13and it's connected a little bit also to what we read the last parashah that we read in the Torah,0:19Parashat Ha'azinu. We'll see how it fits.0:21Let's first read the Even Shelema, and here's the summary of the Gra's words.0:28ענין התורה לנפש דוגמת המטל לארץ. The relationship between Torah and the nefesh, which we explained by now,0:33the nefesh is the soul, the part of the soul where all the midot are,0:37that's like rain on earth. What does that mean?0:43When it rains on earth, what happens? Things grow.0:46He says,0:47שמצמיח מה שנזרע בה. But what grows? All the plants, what was planted there.0:53סם החיים או סם המוות. If a person was planting drugs, cannabis, which is what they use for weed, for weed,1:00excuse me, right, pot, so that's what's going to grow.1:02If a person was planting apple trees, that's what's going to grow.1:08כן בתורה, מצמיח מה שלבו. When a person learns Torah, whatever you have in your heart, it just makes it greater,1:13it makes it grow.1:15אם לבו טוב, תגלירה טוב. If you have a good heart, you have1:18yirat shamayim, the Torah that you learn will give you more1:22yirat shamayim. ואם בלבו שורש פורה ראש ולענה. If a person, however, in his heart has a root that's poisonous into the neshama,1:30to his1:33midot, יגדל הטינה בלבו, then it will make that bad trait even worse, even bigger.1:41כמו שכתוב, צדיקים ילכו בם, ופושעים יכשלו בם. As Chazal tell us from the famous pasuk in1:45Yeshayahu, the words of Hashem are straight.1:46The tzaddikim walk into them.1:48But the fosh'im, the people, the people who do1:53aveirot, they stumble upon them.1:54What's going on? Why this way, by that way?1:56Is it Torah? Is it not Torah?1:57The answer is, it all depends.2:00The Torah just makes you greater.2:01It all depends what you have inside of you.2:08U'kemo she'amru, l'meiminin bah sama d'chayei, l'misme'ilin bah sama d'mota. As the Gemara also brings another place,2:10in Masechet Shabbat says, it says,2:16Mimina osher v'chavod. What does it mean,2:19l'mimina? The Gemara says, l'meiminin, people who are right-wing in the Torah,2:21it'll be, right, it'll be sama d'chayei, it'll give life.2:27V'lemesme'ilin, people who are left,2:29you know, they're very2:30relaxed. Left usually represents the weak2:32hand. People are very relaxed about the Torah,2:34they couldn't care less about Torah.2:36If they learn it, that means they don't have yirat shamayim, really,2:38and they learn it, it becomes poison for them.2:41Why does it become poison for them?2:42It makes them greater, because it makes their evil greater.2:48That's why every day before a person comes to learn,2:51he has to clear out his heart,2:57v'harav me'arpus hamiddot, and he has to search inside of him any bad middot,2:59any bad way of thinking,3:01not thinking the right way also.3:02We've been speaking about middot a lot,3:04and we have to start adding the3:07da'ot. We find a lot of times, we find the word middot3:10and da'ot here, he's bringing both of them,3:12da'ot, middot. What's the difference between middot and the word3:16da'ot? Middot, we know, are character traits.3:19Da'ot is a person's philosophies,3:23a person's attitude towards things.3:25We need to have a da'at of what the Torah wants us to have,3:29not what we've been used to,3:31the way we grew up in society.3:33We grew up in a non-Jewish society,3:35especially most of us grew up with television3:37and today with the news,3:38so we get very, very influenced from the outside3:42non-Jewish philosophy or way of life.3:45Those are the3:48da'ot. Those are da'ot. We might have good middot,3:50but our da'ot might be based on them.3:53And what makes it even scarier is that sometimes3:55when we have Jewish middot and Jewish3:58da'ot that are somewhat similar to non-Jewish ones,4:01so it becomes very, very confusing4:02in how to make a difference.4:04But we have to always search,4:06what's our4:07da'ot? You know, sometimes when I learn something...4:10Let's, let's go back in4:11time. You ask, you know, most people,4:13you ask them certain halachot that they know,4:15why do you do it?4:16And they, you know, they can't trace back why they do it this way.4:19Ask people, why do you take three steps back?4:22Most people don't remember where they learned that from.4:24They don't have any4:25sefer. That's how we do. We take three steps back.4:28So how do you know you're taking it right?4:29I don't know. That's why I say everybody's doing.4:31So now, taking three steps back from the Amidah4:34is not so4:36chamur as much as it would be in halachot of Shabbat,4:38halachot berachot, where a person can make a4:41berachah levatalah. But, you know,4:43so if people are doing things on Shabbat4:44and you ask them, why do you do it?4:45That's a minhag. What makes it a minhag?4:47How do you know you're right? Right?4:49So when I started learning,4:51I tried to always think4:53whenever, especially when a question comes up,4:55to kind of picture the source4:57of where I saw something from.4:58That this way, one, if somebody asks me,5:01where did you get it from?5:02I know where it's from.5:02Number two, also more important,5:04that I know its source from somewhere.5:05It's not something just, you know, I'm doing5:07because everybody else is doing the same thing.5:09So the same thing also,5:11a person who's working on his5:13middot has to also trace back his middot5:16and his daot, where they're coming from.5:17What's the source of why I'm thinking this way?5:19Why I'm feeling this way?5:21Why I made myself feel this way or think this way?5:24Where is that sourced from?5:25Is it sourced from a Jewish source?5:27Is it sourced from the Torah?5:29Or is it sourced from,5:31because, you know, that's what's good in society.5:33In society, that's how you're supposed to do it.5:36ועת חטא ומעשים טובים. It has to be sourced5:39with5:40ועת חטא ומעשים טובים. He has another paragraph,5:42but I don't want to go into it yet.5:44Tomorrow will be the second part.5:45We'll continue on this paragraph.5:46Right now, I would like to go back5:48to the commentary of the Gra himself5:51and to read those words inside,5:52because we find a lot of times5:54he adds a lot of things inside.5:56I'm going to jump from the commentary.5:58So we said basically that6:00the Torah is like rain.6:02And rain makes things grow,6:04and the Torah will make things6:06in your heart grow even more.6:08So I'm going to jump to those6:10who do have the book, especially the ones here in class6:12live. I'm going to go down to the bottom.6:14You see, it has two columns. One is on6:16Mishlei. The other one is based,6:18it comes from the book of the6:20brother of the Gra called6:21Ba'alot HaTorah. Look on the6:22bottom, Beyakut Ha'azinu. You see that?6:26Od ita, he's bringing a Midrash6:30in Yalkut Shimoni, Parashat Ha'azinu. The pasuk says in6:37Parashat Ha'azinu, Ya'arof ka-matar likchi, tizal ka-tal imrati. Ya'arof ka-matar likchi. The Torah says,6:38my lekach, which is my lesson, should be like6:40rain.6:42Tizal ka-tal imrati, my words should drip down like dew.6:45So this is6:46now, we're quoting you a quote, a passage6:49from the words of6:50the book Ma'alot HaTorah, which is6:52written by the brother of the6:55Gra. So listen to his words.6:58Im talmid chacham hagun hu, tizal ka-tal. He gives a commentary. He says like this,7:00the simple meaning, he says, if a guy is a7:03talmid chacham, so Torah is pleasant7:05like the rain,7:06like the dew. The dew is pleasant, right?7:08It doesn't get you soaking and you have to put an umbrella.7:12V'im lav, or ifu ka-matar. But if not, then the Torah will7:14break him like the way7:17when heavy rain comes and it7:18ruins and it damages, that's how it's going to come.7:21That's how he explains7:22the Rav Zalman, the brother of the7:25Gra. Ve'amar achi hagaon, then he quotes his brother,7:30hagaon. And the taam shemidameh la-matar. Why is the Torah compared to rain?7:34Kemo sheha-matar yored u'mashkeh asavim ra'im ve'tovim, just like when the rain comes down7:37and waters7:38every type of grass, every type of plant,7:41good or bad.7:44U'vyoter mitgadlim asavim ra'im meha-matar. In fact, the ones that are,7:46like you see over here by us, over here,7:48you see this thing coming out, right?7:50When it rains, right,7:52plants, even the bad ones,7:54the weeds and all these bad7:56plants, they grow even more through rain.8:00Says the Gaon Mivilna, al yedei haTorah, mi she'eino hagun, metgadin techunot ra'ot b'libo. A person through Torah, a person who's not proper, a person who doesn't have good middot and doesn't have the right philosophy, doesn't have the right hashkafah in life, the Torah will create worse techunot in his heart. It will create worse, basically, traits in him.8:28V'gam haTorah nikreit or, al ha'olam hazeh nikra choshech also. We find that the Torah is called or, ki ner mitzvah v'Torah or. And we find that the world is called choshech, as pasuk says, Yashet choshech v'haila. This world is compared to the8:42choshech. V'chol zman she'ein hachoshech gadol kol kach, ein ha'stalek adam b'or sheb'adam mikol makom. As long as it's not so dark in the world, that a person who has a light, he could save him from any stumbling block.8:51Aval im hachoshech gadol hu me'od, but if it's very, very dark, choshech anan, v'afilu it's darkness, it's cloudy and heavy clouds, you know, when it starts the thunderstorms in the summer,9:02az al yedei ha'or sheb'adam mitbalbel min habocha yoter. The light makes it worse because the light kind of reflects against the clouds and it just, like, confuses you. It goes all over the place.9:13So too, a person who's so lost in olam hazeh, his whole life is about making money, it's about getting kavod and getting what the things that he needs, getting his ta'avot, and, you know, just he wants, just his whole mission is enjoy this world. That's his whole philosophy.9:34The Torah doesn't help him. The opposite. The Torah makes the person even more confused. Why? Because now he justifies everything that he has.9:44It's amazing how you see this. You know, people learn Torah, baruch Hashem, and you see a lot of people do change to the better when they learn Torah.9:50But a lot of times, when people don't work on their middot, the Torah becomes literally a poison for them,9:57because now they know so much and they just twist it to fit in their own10:02ta'avot. Oh, now we found a heter. Right? Now we could do, oh, why not? Why don't you say this, this and that, a seif katan, and make this and that,10:08and they come up with all different things using the Torah to justify their10:14ta'avot. That's the danger with a person who doesn't work on his middot.10:21One more thing from the Gra we'll read over here, which it goes on the pasuk in Mishlei. It says,10:34Hagos sigim l'kesef, vayetzei latzoref keli. Hagos sigim l'kesef, I think is bringing sigim, kesef, so silver is not 100% clean. You know, you have to clean out all the dirt from it.10:39So that's sigim. You're taking away sigim from silver,10:43vayetzei latzoref keli, and then the person who's working with the silver, it's called the tzoref, the person who works with metals, he has a keli.10:49What does that mean? He says, V'chen baTorah, the Gra says,10:51when it comes to Torah, first thing a person's got to do is take away all the dirt from his heart.11:01What is that dirt? Go away from all the evil.11:06Mechamat zeh yetzei imrat Hashem terufah. Stop doing the aveirot. You can't keep on doing aveirot and keep on learning Torah,11:09because one who does that eventually—so how could that be?11:13How could you learn, how could you learn Torah and you're still doing these11:19aveirot? What's the answer? The answer is that eventually you're justifying what you're doing11:25because of Torah. You say, oh, machloket, and there's a shitah this way and a shitah that way.11:29We all know how people are like that.11:31That's why you've got to stop the aveirah, and then you'll be able.11:34As pasuk says,11:37Niru lachem niru, al tizrau el kotzim. As the pasuk says, first clear the field and don't plant when there's thorns.11:42What does that mean?11:47When a person still has bad things in his heart,11:52that means bad philosophies and a bad attitude, you know, the non-Jewish way of living a life,11:57then the imrat Hashem becomes lo aleinu, if you switch lamed and resh around, becomes like a curse.12:08Because when he starts to learn Torah, he's going to start twisting the learning12:12to be able to get what he wants.12:15It's amazing, the Gra writes this, and we see this all the time,12:18how people literally twist the Torah to fit their lifestyle.12:23That's exactly what he says over there.12:25And that's—we're going to summarize one last thing, which we skipped already from12:30beforehand, where beforehand when he says that the Torah, you know, makes what a person grow,12:36makes him, you know, the good people go in it,12:37we find one of the people that12:40ein lo chelek l'olam haba was Doeg12:42HaEdomi. Doeg HaEdomi, the Gemara tells us12:45in Masechet Sanhedrin, Doeg knew the exact precise location of the Beit HaMikdash,12:49and he figured it out from his learning.12:51He was such a gadol in Torah.12:53The only other person who knew it was David HaMelech,12:56and only David only knew because Shmuel HaNavi told him exactly where it is.13:01But Doeg didn't need somebody to tell him; he figured it out.13:04Look how genius he was.13:05According to some opinions, why was he called Doeg13:07HaEdomi? Anybody who argued with him in learning13:10walked out red and embarrassed,13:11couldn't answer him.13:12Doeg was the rosh Sanhedrin, the head of the Sanhedrin,13:16and this person, the Torah says,13:20ein lo chelek l'olam haba. The Gemara says, Masechet Sanhedrin, ein lo chelek l'olam haba. Hakrivi? Ein lo chelek l'olam haba. Kol Yisrael yesh lahem chelek l'olam haba, Gemara says,13:24yeah, except for these guys.13:27Why?13:27He was such a13:29gadol. He knew so much Torah.13:31The answer is, but he had horrible, horrible middot.13:34He never worked on his middot,13:35and therefore the Torah just magnified his bad middot13:41and made it worse,13:42and eventually became sam ha-mavet, literally13:44for him, and destroyed him.13:46Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll continue tomorrow the second paragraph from this idea.13:50Right now we're out of time.13:52Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll finish it tomorrow. Baruch Adonai l'olam, amen v'amen.