Torah · MussarMussarSefer Even Shelema, Chapter 1, Lesson 10Sefer Even ShelemaPart 20Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0016:29Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum explains the teachings of the Vilna Gaon in Sefer Even Shelema in English.Transcript0:01Perek Alef, ot Yud.0:04The more we're learning from this book, the more I'm realizing how important this book is,0:10and a lot of such important things on not only just middot. Right now we're covering middot,0:15but a lot of things in life, how things are run, how things are supposed to be.0:19You get such an insight from this book. It's an amazing thing.0:22So I just wanted to point that out. Today it's the day after Yom Kippur.0:26It's a new season, and how important we have to take these words of the0:31Gra. It's not just another words. The words of the Gra are very, very, you know, selected,0:37very mekaven. He's not trying to give a pshat. The Gra is not trying, in his commentary, to give a nice chidush or divrei Torah.0:44And sometimes you hear some ideas that are brought down by other people that are trying to give a nice0:49chidush. The words of the Gra is telling you the way it works, the way this really happens.0:53So now, the Even Shelemah says,1:00יש מיני פחיתות באדם שניצל מהן על ידי עשיית המצוות. There are certain problems that a person could avoid, he gets saved from them by keeping1:10mitzvot. ויש שאינו ניצול מהם רק בתורה לבד. And then there's certain other areas of problems that could come in life1:14that mitzvot are not good enough to be able to help you, to protect you from them, but only through Torah.1:25ויש שאינו ניצול מהם רק אם רואה לאשר המידות על ידי תוכחות מוסר. And there's certain problems in life that people face, and there's certain situations,1:30and again, it could be many, many different types of problems,1:33that you could only be saved if a person accepts upon himself to work on his1:42middot and enhances his middot through words of1:47mussar, להפריש דרכיו הטובים מן הרעים, to separate his bad ways from the good ways,1:50which is the opposite, really, to separate his good ways from bad ways.1:54Good, let's see the source of all this. It'll make it a little bit clearer.1:58Now, the source is a bit long, and we're going to read it over here.2:01It comes from Mishlei, and he writes the following words.2:09ועניין הוא כמו שכתב במסכת סוטה. Famous Gemara, Masechet Sotah, Gemara says like this.2:12There's a pasuk, we know the pasuk, it says,2:16כי נר מצוה ותורה אור. So the Gemara says,2:19תלה הכתוב את המצוה בנר ואת התורה באור. The pasuk, Shlomo HaMelech is calling a mitzvah a candle,2:23and the Torah is calling it a light.2:25What's the difference? Doesn't a candle also give light?2:27But the difference is the light of here is the light of the sun.2:31The candle has a small little flame.2:33We all know the huge difference between all of them.2:36I'm sure you can list many differences, right?2:38So, Gemara explains2:41the mashal of the mitzvot and Talmud Torah,2:44of how Shlomo HaMelech said it. It2:46says the Gemara,2:48את המצוה בנר למה לך? Why was the mitzvah compared to a candle?2:51To teach you,2:55just like a candle, we know it has an expiration time,3:00right? You light a candle, we all know,3:02we all know the candles for Yom Kippur is a time3:04of shkiat hachamah. If you have a 24-hour, 48, but there's a time it's going to be3:09sharof. After mitzvah, אינה מגינה אלא לפי שעה. So too, the mitzvah that protects only protects temporarily.3:13That means whatever time that is, it has a limitation.3:16Now, the Gemara compares the Torah to or.3:19The pasuk, excuse me, because Torah, comes Gemara and says,3:24ותורה באור למה לך? מה אור מגין לעולם, אף תורה מגינה לעולם. The light is everlasting.3:26If you have light, if it's sunny,3:29true, the sun eventually sets, but the sun doesn't change.3:31The sun is there.3:33The sun is always on,3:34and the sun is always burning, you know, on just for different people in the world.3:38Likewise, the light... Protects forever.3:42And not only that, the Gemara, the pasuk never said sun.3:46The pasuk says, Or.3:48Or is existent forever,3:50right? There is light.3:52Different parts of the world may have different times of when there's light,3:55or light can be created from something else,3:57but it didn't say what kind of light.3:58Any light. Light is always around.4:01So too, Torah protects forever.4:04Ve'omer, and the Gemara says there's a pasuk, B'ha'lecha tancheh otach, uvishchbecha tishmor alecha, v'hakitzota hi tesichecha. I'm going to translate the pasuk, then I'm going to tell you what the Gemara comes to explain. The pasuk4:15says, When you walk, it will guide you.4:19When you lie down, when you sleep, it will protect you.4:22And when you wake up, it will give you speech.4:26Comes the Gemara and says, B'ha'lecha tancheh otach, what does it mean, when you walk it will guide you?4:31Ze olam hazeh. That's referring to Torah in this world.4:34Learning Torah will guide you through this world.4:37Bvishchbecha, it says, when you lie down, it will protect you.4:39What is that referring to?4:40Zu mita. When a person dies, the Torah that he has will protect him.4:44V'hakitzota hi tesichecha, when you wake up, it will be your speech.4:47What is that referring to?4:48That's referring to a person,4:52l'atid lavo, b'techiyat hameitim. The ability to be able to speak, to get up from4:56techiyat hameitim, is the power of the Torah.4:58The fact that a person learns Torah4:59and have the ability to speak by getting up,5:03or get up by5:05techiyat hameitim. Says the Gemara, I will give you a mashal.5:07I'm not going to read the mashal over here inside.5:09I'm going to say it outside.5:11The mashal is, it says in Gemara, after this whole5:15explanation—this, by the way, there's no break in the Gemara.5:17There's all one Gemara. The Gemara didn't say anything yet.5:18The Gemara says, the mashal: the person walks in the darkness,5:23and when he's walking in the darkness, he's scared.5:26Maybe he's going to step on something,5:28right? It could be glass, it could be thorns,5:30it could be robbers, it could be snakes,5:32it could be—who knows? He can't see where he's going.5:34What happens? If he gets a flame or torch,5:38then he puts it on,5:40ah, he feels good, right?5:43But he only feels good because it's going to protect.5:45Now he can see where he's walking.5:46Now he knows, oh, oh, I shouldn't step over there.5:48There's a big puddle. He knows how to avoid that.5:50But he's still scared that maybe there's robbers.5:53Maybe there's others that will come in and see him,5:55right? It makes it even worse on that because they see flame.5:58All of a sudden, the sunlight comes out,6:01feels calm, right?6:02When the day is, it's morning, feel much safer and more protected.6:07The Gemara concludes, left for us to understand6:10that that's how the Torah is in comparison to Torah.6:14Comes the Gemara and says, Gemara says,6:16this is very strange, this whole thing, this Gemara.6:24The Gemara says,6:27Why was the Gemara specifically pointing out the problems6:30when the guy walks in the darkness?6:31It mentioned five problems.6:33What are they?6:34Said maybe he'll step in a puddle.6:37Maybe there's thorns.6:39Now that's number three is maybe wild animals.6:42Number four is robbers,6:44and number five is he's lost.6:46So we said the mashal outside,6:48you know, just a mashal,6:50but the Gemara is saying,6:51no, the Gemara picked those five examples.6:56The Gemara says, What?6:57Chazal couldn't think of other problems6:58when people walk in the dark,7:00right?7:01So why did they think of these five specifically?7:06The Gemara also started talking about7:08mitzvah compared to a7:10ner, a flame, one flame, a candle.7:12And the mashal that the Gemara gave7:14was a guy who had a torch.7:17Notice that, right?7:18When I said the mashal to you guys,7:19I tried to be as close as possible7:22to the Gemara.7:23Why did it switch?7:25And he brings many, many other questions.7:27So he says, I'm going to explain7:30to you about the meaning, the deeper meaning of the Gemara.7:34And the answer is that,7:35I'll give you a little introduction.7:37The yetzer hara comes to bother7:40and hurt a person in three areas.7:42What are they?7:43Pa'amim beguf. Sometimes by a person's body.7:48How? Shematio yismach al haguf, bichdei sheyevatel miTorah umitzvot. He makes him sick.7:49It makes them physically not well.7:52Why?7:53So shouldn't be able to do Torah mitzvot. People who...8:00You know, wake up, you know, not feeling well.8:03Today I'm skipping out class this morning.8:05I'm skipping out8:07Shacharit, right?8:08Or you mix a guy, you know, not feeling well8:11on purpose. Why?8:12So this way you come home very moody8:14and you start yelling and you start cursing,8:17you start doing all these different things,8:20and all very ... Good?8:21That's one area.8:23U'ba'amim hanefesh. And sometimes in the nefesh—what's the nefesh? A8:28middot, a machti'ah, right? Causes him to do sins.8:31U'ba neshama. And how could a8:32person—how can this affect you in the neshama?8:34He already told me he makes you sin.8:36And he says, no.8:42... The natural desire of a neshama8:45is to know, to want to get close to Hashem.8:50Chazal compare—the pasuk says,8:55Ner Hashem nishmat adam. The neshama of a person is like a8:57candle. We know the flame always, like, wants to go up,9:00right? You see the flame always trying to go up.9:02Neshama naturally wants to get closer to Hashem.9:05What happens?9:06The yetzer hara comes and he puts a block on that,9:08that the neshama should not want to have that desire.9:11Like it says in the pasuk,9:19Amalek ... ... This is what Chazal are telling us.9:27... What does that mean?9:29The Gra explains why did the mashal begin9:31when it's darkness of the night,9:32and the answer is that there's no light.9:36What does it mean there's no light?9:37We already told you,9:40the Torah or. There's no light.9:41We're talking about a person who has no Torah in his life.9:45Ve'ein lo Torah. Ve'afelah, it says darkness.9:47It says, in the dark9:49of the night,9:51... the dark of the night,9:52ve'afelah, and deep, deep darkness.9:55She'ein lo afilu ner. He doesn't even have a ner. He doesn't even have any10:01mitzvot. She'ein lo or v'lo ner, lo Torah v'lo mitzvot, v'lachen hu mityare. So you have a person who lives in this life,10:03he has no Torah and no10:04mitzvot. He's not connected to anything in Judaism,10:06right?10:06And obviously we're talking about a person who knows about it,10:09because otherwise he'd feel bad.10:10So this guy is scared now.10:12What is he?10:20... עניין הוא כי ... כל אחד ... ... Being that he's lacking these three areas,10:23so therefore each one of these areas10:25causes a person to do10:29more. That's why Hashem gave us three areas that we have to do10:33and keep our lives,10:34to protect us from these three areas.10:37And what are the three areas that we said?10:40That's a person who has no Torah,10:42no10:44mitzvot, right?10:44And that corresponds to the person's body,10:47the person's neshama,10:49the person's nefesh.10:49A person who has these three areas10:52doesn't have,10:53that means he's lacking his Torah,10:58mitzvot, and11:02midot. When you keep to these three things,11:04when you work on these three things,11:06they'll protect you.11:08And how does it work?11:09How does the protection work?11:10Listen to this line from the11:15Gra. Ki ha-mitzvot hem min ha'aretz, midvarim sheba'aretz. Most mitzvot are things that grow from the earth.11:18Look at them.11:22Think about every mitzvah that you do almost,11:24besides the ones that are just11:27b'machshava, right?11:28Every single mitzvah that we do is really physical,11:31right?11:35And they protect us.11:37They protect us in the same level11:40from physical things.11:41That's a physical harm to a person.11:44Physically, your body is protected from that.11:48VehaTorah shehi min haShamayim, the Torah comes from where?11:49From Hashem.11:50It comes from Shamayim.11:55Megina, ha'aptutah ba'a me'esh uve'avir. So it comes to protect us from11:57the areas that also are in the Shamayim,11:59that are not in the ground itself,12:01right?12:01From fire and air.12:07Vehamidot hem horot la'adam et haderech asher yelech bah. Middot is really the guidance.12:09It guides you in where to go.12:11It's interesting that12:13in every school,12:14the more professional schools,12:16like in public school, whatever,12:17they have a guidance team.12:19What's a guidance team?12:20That's a psychologist and a psychiatrist.12:23That's called the guidance team,12:25because really the12:27psychiatrists who deal with the middot of a person12:29give you guidance,12:30and that's what he's telling you the same thing over here.12:32The middot is really a person12:33guides a person on how he walks12:35and how to go.12:36And you know,12:36I hear something very interesting.12:38After the fire, last12:40Hanukkah—you all know about the12:41fire—Hacham Yosef kept on speaking.12:42He's like,12:43a person who wants to be12:45protected should learn Torah.12:48The Gemara says,12:49and listen to the Gemara,12:50the Gemara says12:52every house that doesn't have Torah,12:53the voice of Torah,12:56esh ochalto. It's a scary line.12:57But now we understand why,13:00because the Torah comes13:01from Hashem,13:03from the13:04shamayim, and the esh,13:05like we said,13:06is part of that13:07in the four worlds,13:09afar, ruach, and things.13:11The esh comes also from the same place.13:13Esh comes also from the avir.13:15It comes from the same area of the Torah,13:17and that's why Torah is called,13:19Mimino esh dat lamo. We're going to read it in a few13:21weeks—not even a few weeks,13:22now,13:23Shabbat Torah is coming up.13:24Esh, the Torah is called esh.13:25So he says,13:26now we come back to the mashal,13:27you're going to understand13:28everything is going to make sense.13:32And this is now the mashal of the Gemara.13:36The Gemara says13:36the guy was walking13:38and he was scared of what?13:40Of thorns.13:42Those—what are usually thorns?13:43You step on it,13:44it's in the ground.13:45It can be something prickly13:46coming out from the dirt,13:49right? Hu hatzomeach, that's referring to the things that grow.13:54U'min hapechatim—and from the13:55pechatim. What's a13:57pechatim? Pechatim is,13:58what do you call it,13:59potholes13:59or like, you know, holes,14:01or maybe you can fall into a pit.14:03Hu hadomem, that's referring to the rocks,14:06right?14:06Things in this world that don't move.14:10U'mechayara, he was scared also of the wild animals.14:13We know that's also a14:14chai. We established this before, right?14:16There's14:17four—every creation in14:18the world is one of the four things.14:19It's either tzomeach,14:23domem, chai, umedaber, right? So now, u'min halistim hu haya medaber. Now,14:28הוא מפחיתות הבאה מאלו. He was scared from all these different things.14:30So what happened14:37is, זימן לו אבוקה של אור. What does14:38it mean? שמצווה, שנקראת נר, כמו שכתוב כי נר מצוה. That's—what's the abukah? All of a14:41sudden he gets a mitzvah. A mitzvah, when you get one14:42mitzvah, it's a flame.14:43It's one flame.14:44But when you get a torch,14:45it's many14:47mitzvot. So now14:48that he has what?14:49He has the flame,14:51the torch.14:52He's protected.14:53He knows where he's stepping.14:54So he's protected from what?14:56From the14:57domeh, from falling.14:59He's protected also from15:00the things that grow,15:03right? כיון שאור היום. But once the daylight comes,15:06אור תורה, but when he learns Torah,15:10... שהוא החיים ... המדבר, he's protected from wild animals15:12and from robbers,15:13people trying to harm him.15:16But then, ... אבל הוא still scared,15:18doesn't know where to go.15:21Even though it's daylight,15:22how many people get lost in the forest15:23in the middle of the day?15:24We get lost even with lights, right?15:26So he doesn't know.15:27He doesn't know direction.15:29כיון שלא הגיע עדיין לידי ... because he never reached15:31good middot,15:34כמו שכתוב, אין יראה אין חכמה. כיון שהגיע לפרשת דרכים, the Gemara says that person that—Mashal forgot to finish the mashal. Mashal says that once he gets to a15:38road and he sees where the road is leading, oh, now he knows the highway. He knows how to go home. And what is that road?15:48הן המידות, שהן דרך חיים תוכחות מוסר, as the15:49pasuk calls them,15:50כי דרך חיים תוכחות מוסר. The road of life is a person who learns.16:04ולפריש דרכים הטמאים מן הרעים, נצול מכולם, שדעה גם כן באיזה דרך מהלך. And now that he knows which way to go, now he can protect16:09him. That's the meaning of this Gemara.16:11One who has mitzvot, yes, he's protected from physical things.16:15One who has Torah, he's protected from higher things.16:18With good middot, he knows the direction he has to go in life,16:22he's protected from everything. Baruch ... לעולם, אמן ואמן.